However she does take one or two steps back and then stop. When do I ask her to back all the way to the end of the line? I'm afraid that if I continue telling her to back she might think that means she's not doing it right.
joop said:can you tell me where you can get a copy of the seven games on the internet from? I have looked everywhere and cant find them. Thank you.
Tiber said:Start at phase one (wiggling finger), then phase 2 (wrist), then phase 3 (elbow) then phase 4 (swinging whole arm from the shoulder). Try and keep the rhythm the same through all the phases, and STAY AT PHASE 4 UNTIL SHE TRIES!
Yann said:I've read rather too many posts about otherwise perfectly amenable horses rearing in official training sessions though, so some people clearly do. Your comment about the relationship being spoiled is spot on and why that type of training isn't for me. I don't want a horse that flinches when I make a gesture towards it. This approach will be entirely appropriate for some types of horse, but entirely wrong for others, one size doesn't fit all.
Bay Mare said:How can *we* in all conscience bleat on to people about listening to your horse, understanding why they do things, trying a different method if they don't understand, not using force etc etc etc and then talk about Phase 4 as if it's acceptable! I cannot see how hitting the horse on the head or around the face with anything can ever be seen as an acceptable training method.
I agree Naturally, but can I also add that while some folk do criticise PNH because they don't understand it, others do so merely to promote their own personal preference of NH training.Naturally said:It's fine if you are not that committed to go down that path, but it's not really fair to put down something just because you don't understand it.
It's fine if you are not that committed to go down that path, but it's not really fair to put down something just because you don't understand it.
others do so merely to promote their own personal preference of NH training.
How can *we* in all conscience bleat on to people about listening to your horse, understanding why they do things, trying a different method if they don't understand, not using force etc etc etc and then talk about Phase 4 as if it's acceptable! I cannot see how hitting the horse on the head or around the face with anything can ever be seen as an acceptable training method.
Yann said:Sorry, that's making a rather big assumption isn't it? So you're saying that if you aren't one of the dedicated 'chosen few' then you can't possibly be qualified to comment or hold an opinion?
Nope, that's not what I said at all.![]()
Crystal Fires understanding of teachers all teaching in exactly the same way is interesting, but it has not been my experience at all with PNH. I have seen many instructors vary, according to the needs of the horse's sensitivity.
As an example I have seen, a horse would not yield at phase 4 on a back up or backwards part of a yo yo, so rythmic pressure was applied to make the phase 4 effective. It's not cruel and it's not crossing lines of being too harsh, it's just making it effective.
I've seen other instructors that have not had to demonstrate that, because the horse had yielded before the student reached phase 4.