Parelli's yo-yo game

Have you watched Ray Hunt or Buck Brannaman work with a new horse? NH trainers all tend to teach a horse to yield in roughly the same order. Who did Pat learn from? Chickens and eggs... :D
I have seen a natural horsewoman doing a demo and still using word like "squeeze" and "yo yo" - which I think is a bit suss. But I don't think you could claim to be the first to invent sideways? :D :D
I think if someone comes up with what is clearly 7 stages to teaching a horse basic groundwork, and they were an ex-Parelli person AND it was the same yields in the same order you might say they were copying. None of the NH trainers I'm working with now do that. Starting a youngster they tend to make sure the horse is happy with high energy stuff (like friendly game, but beyond level 1), make sure it will move in all directions, make sure it's soft and relaxed and get on. Pat himself says that "it's so old it's new" - maybe he'd acknowledge himself that other natural horsemen might work in a similar way. There's a guy up the road from me who rides and trains western. He's never seen Monty Roberts or a Parelli person, but he uses "Hook Up" in a round pen, a stick with a bag or a string on the end, and he teaches... what looks remarkably like the 7 games. He's been doing it all his adult life, he's about 60 I think.
This is the problem when people start to think NH = Parelli. It doesn't. NH training is as old as history, passed down from father to son (or daughter), trainer to student. Phil Nye,for example,learnt his horsemanship from his grandad on the sheep farm in Tasmania. Steve Halfpenny (as you know he is my friend) was a western trainer who was SA reining champion for several years. Pat P was the clever bloke who realised that there were a lot of people out there who could benefit from learning these methods as well.
 
Last edited:
Yann said:
Surely after a horse has been through level 1 and 2 it knows full well that any reluctance on its part to carry out a task is going to get it uncomfortable very quickly, so it will learn to be switched on to any clue as to what the handler is going to ask of it?
.

That's not true and shows how little you know Yann.

Parelli didn't invent yielding exercises, and although there might be variations between what different trainers do they usually boil down to the same sorts of things. Teaching your horse to back, come forward, move sideways and yield the shoulders and hindquarters are the starting point whatever style of training you choose to employ.

Have you watched Ray Hunt or Buck Brannaman work with a new horse? NH trainers all tend to teach a horse to yield in roughly the same order. Who did Pat learn from? Chickens and eggs...
I have seen a natural horsewoman doing a demo and still using word like "squeeze" and "yo yo" - which I think is a bit suss. But I don't think you could claim to be the first to invent sideways?

No he didn't and he never claims to either. Ray Hunt, Ronny Willis, Tom Dorrance, Bill Dorrance are/were all Pat's mentors and he acknowledges them regularly. Surely you have never seen anything of Parelli if you don't know this.

How often does PP talk about not getting rid of the curiosity ??! And thats what worries me about the reports of switched off horses, cos its sounds like they lost their mojo and their curiosity

The switched off horses are usually the ones that have just started in Level 1. This would mean that they have come into the program that way, so where do you suppose they switched off and brown down??? Traditional homes would be a fair bet if they have just started NH.


Pat P was the clever bloke who realised that there were a lot of people out there who could benefit from learning these methods as well.

Yes he was clever. Packaged it up and took it to the masses. I for one thank him for it, as do thousands and thousands of others. Including the people like Phil Nye, Steve Halfpenny, Mark Rashid, Monty Roberts, etc etc etc. Because without Pat's brilliant ability to get his message across to the masses, the masses would have stayed doing what they were doing and none of the rest of them would have any where near the exposure that they do now.

I may play games with Fi, but she also plays games with me and everyone else she interacts with. I do NOT want train that out - she's a horse, she plays .... full stop. I don't see playing as being "bad", lacking respect etc etc. She's simply being a horse

I'm not sure what your are implying CVB, but PNH does not advocate training that out at all. We encourage it and we revell in it. The horse continually ups the ante and it's up to the student to meet the challenge. It's all a game and that's why we like it. But I may have misunderstood what you meant.

You know so many of these comments really show how little some of you understand PNH. I don't know why you insist on trying to rip it to shreds when you clearly do NOT understand what it is about. I guess its just good sport for you or something.
 
Crystal Fire said:
This is the problem when people start to think NH = Parelli.
In all honesty, I don't think there are many (if any) that do actually think along those lines Crystal Fire but if there is, they must be very narrow minded folk. :)

Pat Parelli often mentions how he's been influenced over the years and owes his success to a number of great horsemen such as Troy Henry, Tom Dorrance, Robbie Willis and Ray Hunt to name but a few.

The majority of 'natural' horse trainers do share similarities in their techniques and training methods (the same as a 'normal' horse trainers do). However, the difference being... many ex PNH instructors seem to also produce a very similar teaching programme to the Parelli system.

Just an afterthought....I wonder why these folk didn't attempt to set up their own programmes before becoming PNH endorsed instructors? :rolleyes: :)
 
I think Naturally needs to re-read my post. We agree with each other! I'm agreeing that Pat P recognises his roots for goodness sake :)
Answer to your question Jacqui may well be that at the time they joined Parelli they didn't think a programme was needed at all - certainly Pat didn't. I'd been studying Parelli a couple of years before it evolved beyond a few random vids and some task lists. I think most trainers who teach regularly and in different countries recognise the need to offer some sort of support to students when they're not there.
The good trainers acknowledge their roots and the people who have helped them. Pat does, Monty Roberts does (although some of the trainers say they've never taught him!), certainly Steve H does - he says Pat is the best horseman he's ever worked with when it comes to problem horses.
There isn't a great conflict between these people, the "x vs y" stuff comes from the students. Of course you will see similarities - how many times can I agree with that? But you will also see differences and that is what attracts us as individuals to learn from different people.
p.s. Phil Nye doesn't have a programme - I don't think he is that interested in teaching, just gets forced to twice every 2 years.
 
Crystal Fire said:
p.s. Phil Nye doesn't have a programme.
I don't think I've ever suggested he did have I? :rolleyes:
QUOTE
Answer to your question Jacqui may well be that at the time they joined Parelli they didn't think a programme was needed at all.

Mmm, maybe.....but I have other opinons as to why they developed their NH programmes after becoming endorsed instructors - best leave this discussion at that I think. ;)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
We've meandered a long way from bashing horses round the face with clips in the yo yo game haven't we? :D
I think it's terrible Pat deciding to produce a distance learning programme - fancy copying the Open University... ;)
The first person who invented a book had a good idea and others copied it - but it doesn't mean the contents were the same.
These trainers - they're all different in some way, so they all have something different that we can learn from them. That's what I intend doing anyway. My main mentor Steve encourages me to go to as many horsepeople as possible and learn as widely as I can.
I was thinking - If people simply copied PNH's programme then the PNH students wouldn't buy the "copies" would they? But they do, so they must see some variations. :D (I normally lend them mine before they buy).
La la, whatever :)
 
Crystal Fire said:
ROFLMAO!
I know, I get tired sometimes, specially when I'm in the middle of "clinic season". I hope I bump into you one day Jacqui, you seem a nice person to chat to :)
Ahh, thanks Crysal Fire, but now you've made me all embarassed. :o :D
 
Originally posted by Naturally I'm not sure what your are implying CVB, but PNH does not advocate training that out at all. We encourage it and we revell in it. The horse continually ups the ante and it's up to the student to meet the challenge. It's all a game and that's why we like it. But I may have misunderstood what you meant.

Gosh - you think you might have misunderstood me ?? No... after all you seem to have assumed I am NOT a Parelli student (which I am). That I was saying Parelli trained the games out (when I was NOT)

As you would see elsewhere in the same post where I say

"How often does PP talk about not getting rid of the curiosity ??! "

Before making assumptions and jumping down my throat, you might just like to "hurry up and slow down" (as the man himself has been heard to say).
 
Before making assumptions and jumping down my throat, you might just like to "hurry up and slow down" (as the man himself has been heard to say).

CVB, I'm sorry you are upset, but you are the one making an assumption. I thought that you WERE a PNH student, which is WHY I didn't understand your statement, and to which I clearly said

But I may have misunderstood what you meant.

So please go redirect your anger somewhere else.
 
Naturally said:
CVB, I'm sorry you are upset, but you are the one making an assumption. I thought that you WERE a PNH student, which is WHY I didn't understand your statement, and to which I clearly said



So please go redirect your anger somewhere else.

and right below the response to me you write

You know so many of these comments really show how little some of you understand PNH. I don't know why you insist on trying to rip it to shreds when you clearly do NOT understand what it is about. I guess its just good sport for you or something.

but of course its ME who is making assumptions, responding aggressive etc. Does it not occur to you that you seem to have reacted to a number of us as if we were attacking you/parelli when you weren't ? Could this not possibly indicate a pattern ??

One of the main reasons I continue to post on this board is because of the open debate and discussion which is possibly. But its not possible if there is this kind of reaction ...

To quote another poster
La la, whatever
 
That's not true and shows how little you know Yann.

Hmmm... seeing as how almost all horse training is carried out using pressure and release can you explain how it does work then?:rolleyes: However with Parelli there's an automatic escalation of that pressure to unacceptably (in some people's book) high levels on a regular basis if any resistance is encountered from the horse.

The comment was written in response to the assertion that you don't have to use phase 4 with a level 3 horse, that's all.

As to dead eyed automaton comments, I've usually heard them in relation to demo horses, not level one.

Your tone is a bit aggressive Naturally, is everyone who disagrees with your opinion stupid and uninformed?:)
 
Yann said:
Hmmm... seeing as how almost all horse training is carried out using pressure and release can you explain how it does work then?:rolleyes: However with Parelli there's an automatic escalation of that pressure to unacceptably (in some people's book) high levels on a regular basis if any resistance is encountered from the horse.

The comment was written in response to the assertion that you don't have to use phase 4 with a level 3 horse, that's all.

As to dead eyed automaton comments, I've usually heard them in relation to demo horses, not level one.

Your tone is a bit aggressive Naturally, is everyone who disagrees with your opinion stupid and uninformed?:)


I have been following this and other threads on PNH and it seems that you do not have an understanding of the principles. Don't know what your experience of it is or is it just heresay.

It would be useful to know what you do with your horse and how you use him, what you achieve with him and how you think your methods are better?
 
David80 said:
I have been following this and other threads on PNH and it seems that you do not have an understanding of the principles. Don't know what your experience of it is or is it just heresay.

It would be useful to know what you do with your horse and how you use him, what you achieve with him and how you think your methods are better?


I'm a total outsider here; I've read a bit about Parelli and all sorts of other things, and I've used some of their ideas with success.

But the idea I get about Parelli is that there are four levels of pressure: you try the first, then if the horse doesn't respond, you try 2, then 3, then 4. Is this right?

Now it seems to me that there are two reasons why a horse doesn't do what you ask for. One is "Do I really have to?" It understands, but for some reason, because it's hard, or it's scarey or whatever, it refuses. So you up the pressure, and the horse says "Oh, well, if I really have to ..." and does it.

But the other is if the horse doesn't understand what you mean. My Ginny will back very sweetly if I just point to her chest (like the porcupine game, no?), but if I wiggle the leadrope she just gets puzzled, bored, cross ... And in that case, upping the pressure just makes her crosser because she doesn't understand.

If I've got Parelli right, you reward the tiniest movement in the direction you want. But if you don't get any movement, and you still increase the pressure, that's when it looks as if you're bullying the horse. And it seems to me that at this point the Parelli people start saying Oh no, you don't understand. No, I don't - so perhaps someone will be kind enough to explain?

And me, that's when I give up on Parelli, because as long as the horse does what I ask, I don't care if she doesn't do it if I ask differently. She's learnt to stand still around wiggly things, leadropes, hoses, whatever, and I don't particularly want her to move away from them. But that's me and my horse, and that's one of the reasons why I don't do Parelli.

Linda
 
Going back a few dozen posts to the original problem ;) as this is the first time I've read this, could part of the problem be discomfort in backing up rather than lack of understanding? Seems to me that reinback isn't a comfortable pace for some horses, whether this is caused by conformation or mental dislike (is this really a natural pace anyway - wouldn't a horse in the wild just spin and go forward?). If that is the case, then to get that pace you have to put the level of discomfort of not doing it above the level of discomfort of doing it - surely not much of a release when they achieve what you want?
 
Naturally said:
Well that paragraph wasn't directed at you, so I'm sorry if you've interpreted it that way.

<slaps forehead> gosh I'm so stooopid. I should have known that a general comment in an email that quoted me didn't apply to me !

Apology accepted.

p.s.and Yann, after at least two years of reading your well informed and well observed posts, I find it seems you no nothing ... how dare you mislead me all this time !! Posing as a knowledgeable and caring horse owner - what were you thinking of !!
 
LindaAd said:
because as long as the horse does what I ask, I don't care if she doesn't do it if I ask differently.
Sorry, I'm a little confused by this statement. If your horse already does as you ask why would you want to ask her to do it differently?? :rolleyes:
 
Escalation

LindaAd

Just thought I'd share this thought from Mark Rashid, on what we use in terms of "escalation" (reinforcement).

Just to set the scene first, when we use a cue, and the horse doesn't respond, under parelli you would escalate a form of the same cue up the levels of pressure. As soon as you see them make a "try" you release the cue, to indicate that they found the right 'answer'.

Mark comments that when he was at school, if he didn't do the right thing the "reinforcement" was praying. He doesn't pray much these days.....

He asks the question why we use the same cue (but bigger) as the reinforcement ? And in a lot of his work he doesn't seem to use any form of escalation at all. This has made me challenge the whole idea of phases of pressure.

As you say, one possibility is that the horse didn't understand what I was asking. So do I repeat it - like when you speak to someone who doesn't speak your language and you just say the same thing LOUDER and s..l...o..w..e...r - or do I try and find a way to make it easier for the horse to know what I want ?
 
newrider.com