all I know is what I've seen on the introductory video and read on here and in other places
Ok, therein lays the first probelm.

Sorry if this is harsh, but it is a detailed program of study, not copying.
because in this mare's book you don't work if you haven't got a headcollar on.
I assume you mean Halter by headcollar. We don't start our training at "liberty" (no halter) we start it with "online" (rope halter and leadrope), so wouldn't expect your horse to understand you straight up without any gear on.
With a headcollar on, held loosely, I can touch her all over, even the tickly bits, she will move backwards or sideways (shoulder or quarters) if I point at that bit, although I have to walk forward to get her to back. Then if I back, she'll walk forwards again.
All of this is good and shows that she is accepting of you as a leader, to some degree. Not sure when you say "point" as pointing is not part of PNH. We apply steady pressure in the porcupine game and rhythmic pressure in the driving game, which could be seen as pointing, but not really if you're doing it right (certainly not at pre level 1, which is where you'd be)
Not a particularly sensitive horse, but a dominant one, and very inclined to take over if she thinks there's danger.
Your first move to get into PNH for this was the correct one. For your own safety I would suggest you continue on with it.
The problem of the horse not moving at the wiggling of the rope is exactly the problem. He's unsure and so he's not moving. If he gets scared and unsure, he will land on top of you or run you over (but I think you know this). So what you need to do is to teach your horse that his comfort is found when he is OFF you, rather than ON you.... Hence the need for the games, as this is how we teach this.
I don't use a carrot stick, I just use hands and voice and body language.
Another pivotal point. You can't expect to get results with Parelli without using the tools adopting the principles. We communicate through body language, but not voice in the basic levels.
I'll just go back to one of your earlier points
If
I've got Parelli right, you reward the tiniest movement in the direction you want. But if you don't get any movement, and you still increase the pressure, that's when it looks as if you're bullying the horse.
You have the principle right, we reward the slightest try. Timing is crucial here, in knowing when to quit and allowing your horse enough time to digest the learning he has just done (licking of lips is a good sign) But if you are not comfortable with making contact with the horse to get effective, then no, Parelli is not for you. Your horse is looking for a strong leader and someone to respect. They are animals and this is they way nature has taught them. When you observe the phases that a horse gives another, there is nothing un-natural about giving them a tap on the HQ with a Carrot Stick, or a clunk with a snap of a rope. With a dominant horse (i have one too) and you want to train with parelli, this is going to have to happen, how much or for how long is up to how consistently assertive you can be.
Your horse, particularly a dominant one, will continually challenge your leadership. That is his natural tendency. Every time I think we're into a good groove, my horse challenges me up, and I have to meet the stakes. That doesn't mean I have to go beating him up, it might mean that I have to remind him that he receives comfort when he does as I asks, and discomfort when he doesn't. For example, if I go out there today and it's windy and he want's to be standing on top of me, I will back him up. When he backs up and stays out, he receives comfort. It's not safe for me otherwise. Mostly now, all I have to do is breathe in, raise my "life" and he says, "OK, I've got you and I'll pop back there like I know you want me to". The opposite end of that Yo-Yo is that when it is OK for him to come in, all I have to do is smile at him, drop my life a little and he can come in for a rub.
(Actually for KateFarmer if you're reading this, I would add here... this is where I am looking for positive reflexes. If he is back up, but with ears pinned, I know I haven't won the game, and certainly not if he is coming in with ears pinned. I would then "up the phase" until it is achieved with a positive response)
I hope that makes it clearer for you. If you've any other questions I'd like to have a go at answering them for you.
If any other PNH student has any further to add I'm sure it would be appreciated to solve LindaAD's confusions
