Parelli's yo-yo game

LindaAd And me said:
Seems your horse is doing everything you want, so why do you want to change?

But to answer some of your query. PNH is much more than just 4 phases and I won't do it justice answering it here.

The games are set out in order. I found out to my cost that you should not progress to the next game before having the current game in good shape. The is a lot of worry here about the 4 phases. They are as set out but also it is about raising your personal energy so that the horse knows you are asking something. I found that initially very hard to do.

P4 can be strong or soft - it depends on the horse. Sometimes that is not the answer and you have to think out of the box to get around a situation. It's maybe that your horse will be hit a few times, but it will never be temper, never without due warning, never be unjust, and the horse will know it is just. They have been using this language for thousands of years and know it well. You have to convince them that you can speak their language as well.

I live near an eventing course and see hundreds of riders kicking their horses on, whipping them to jump, jabbing them in the mouth with the bit when they jump or want to stop. If they can't stop then put a bigger harsher bit in.

They get far harsher treatment than my horse will ever know about.

I do think PNH is difficult to learn from a book. The pack helps if you read it properly, but for me it only made real sense when I had a lesson and I needed several to get me through my problems. The right equipment I think is essential to get the right feel. There are many third party suppliers, but if funds are short you can always get some rope from a yacht chandler and there are several sites on the 'net showing how to make them. I think even Parelli has some diagrams.
 
Jacquie said:
Sorry, I'm a little confused by this statement. If your horse already does as you ask why would you want to ask her to do it differently?? :rolleyes:


Well, I don't Jacquie. But if I wanted to work through the Parelli games, I think I'd have to. Because, unless I've misunderstood (and of course that's always possible), in the porcupine game you ask the horse to go back by pointing and moving forward, and in the yo-yo game you ask her to go back by standing still and wiggling the lead-rope.

Linda
 
cvb said:
LindaAd

Just thought I'd share this thought from Mark Rashid, on what we use in terms of "escalation" (reinforcement).

Just to set the scene first, when we use a cue, and the horse doesn't respond, under parelli you would escalate a form of the same cue up the levels of pressure. As soon as you see them make a "try" you release the cue, to indicate that they found the right 'answer'.

Mark comments that when he was at school, if he didn't do the right thing the "reinforcement" was praying. He doesn't pray much these days.....

He asks the question why we use the same cue (but bigger) as the reinforcement ? And in a lot of his work he doesn't seem to use any form of escalation at all. This has made me challenge the whole idea of phases of pressure.

As you say, one possibility is that the horse didn't understand what I was asking. So do I repeat it - like when you speak to someone who doesn't speak your language and you just say the same thing LOUDER and s..l...o..w..e...r - or do I try and find a way to make it easier for the horse to know what I want ?

Thanks for the reply cvb. What you say there - or what Mark Rashid says - makes perfect sense to me. That's definitely the way I'd go. But how does that fit in with the Parelli stuff?

Linda
 
David80 said:
Seems your horse is doing everything you want, so why do you want to change?

But to answer some of your query. PNH is much more than just 4 phases and I won't do it justice answering it here.

The games are set out in order. I found out to my cost that you should not progress to the next game before having the current game in good shape. The is a lot of worry here about the 4 phases. They are as set out but also it is about raising your personal energy so that the horse knows you are asking something. I found that initially very hard to do.

<snip>

I do think PNH is difficult to learn from a book. The pack helps if you read it properly, but for me it only made real sense when I had a lesson and I needed several to get me through my problems. The right equipment I think is essential to get the right feel. There are many third party suppliers, but if funds are short you can always get some rope from a yacht chandler and there are several sites on the 'net showing how to make them. I think even Parelli has some diagrams.

Thanks for the reply and the explanation, David. Why do I want the horse to change? Well, I wanted to do some groundwork with her, and the Parelli games seemed a good idea, and fun. And I bought a rope headcollar, and I adopted the principle of using pressure/release, and made a huge amount of progress with both horses. But this mare has read a different book (the one that says you should always pick out the feet in the same order, and should always tack up from the same side and that if you haven't got any tack on you don't need to work), so although we could go some way towards the first three games, we had to stop when it came to the yo-yo.

In general, as I said somewhere else in this thread, she knows if I'm asking something, and she will do it, because that's what horses do in her book. But if she doesn't understand, she gets very stressed.

Linda
 
LindaAd said:
But this mare has read a different book (the one that says you should always pick out the feet in the same order, and should always tack up from the same side and that if you haven't got any tack on you don't need to work), so although we could go some way towards the first three games, we had to stop when it came to the yo-yo.

Linda

Can you tell me at what phase is she moving in each of games 2 and 3, and how solid is your friendly game? Sometimes with a sensitive horse you need to get these first three games really really solid before moving on. If not already, aim for response at phase 1 or 2 in the porc. and driv. games.

Do you have any friends who are doing Parelli that are higher level? or are you able to get to a lesson, even to watch? It might help.

Also, in PNH we do need to make the horse "uncomfortable" in the teaching phase, because they learn when they receive the "comfort". But if you can't get effective with your phase 4 (for whatever reason) it is quite acceptable to add a little rhythmic pressure with your carrot stick, or say, marching on the spot, for the horse to get what your asking.

A friend of mines horse used to pick up the clowns at the Rodeo, nothing phases him and we went through this with him. He now responds very lightly at P1 or P2.

My only other advice is that PNH is about much more than the 7 games. It helps to be a member of the Savvy Club and to get to clinics. It is very very hard to go it completely alone.

Good luck
 
It's maybe that your horse will be hit a few times,

Well maybe that's my fundamental problem with the system, I don't think hitting a horse or smacking it in the face with a heavy metal clip have any part in training a horse, whether used in temper or otherwise. As for thinking outside the box and not going to phase 4 with a horse that doesn't understand the request it's clear from many posts on this board and elsewhere that whilst you might, official trainers don't, they follow the system to the letter and horses get roughed up.


cvb said:
p.s.and Yann, after at least two years of reading your well informed and well observed posts, I find it seems you no nothing ... how dare you mislead me all this time !! Posing as a knowledgeable and caring horse owner - what were you thinking of !!

LOL @ cvb :) :) :)

LindaAd said:
Thanks for the reply cvb. What you say there - or what Mark Rashid says - makes perfect sense to me. That's definitely the way I'd go. But how does that fit in with the Parelli stuff?

It doesn't, it's at the other end of the spectrum. Have you read any of his books? I'd thoroughly recommend them, they're fantastic:)
 
LindaAd said:
Thanks for the reply cvb. What you say there - or what Mark Rashid says - makes perfect sense to me. That's definitely the way I'd go. But how does that fit in with the Parelli stuff?

Linda

Linda - well thats the dilemma, as it doesn't really fit with what the packs etc ask you to do.

I'm also not 100% clear I have understood Mark - let me explain whyt. He uses a scale quite a lot of 1 to 10, where 1 is just about nothing, and 10 is way more than you'd want to use. He commented that if a person never goes beyond 3 on the scale, then the horse may learn that and take them to "3" every time to get the release.

So it is slightly more subtle than "never escalate". Its more about how you escalate (not necessarily with more pressure).

(just to explain the "going to 3" thing. Mark comments that whenever we are with our horses, leading them, grooming them etc etc we are "training" them. We train them that the behaviour we accept is ok. We also train them that what they do to get the release is what we want. So if we always "release" when they up the pressure to "3", we're teaching them that is what we want :eek: I have something in my head to rationalise this - that there is a difference between the pressure WE put on THEM (e.g. through a cue) and the pressure THEY put in US (in resistance to a cue). Its not fully formed yet, but I thought I'd better mention it....)
 
Also, in PNH we do need to make the horse "uncomfortable" in the teaching phase, because they learn when they receive the "comfort". But if you can't get effective with your phase 4 (for whatever reason) it is quite acceptable to add a little rhythmic pressure with your carrot stick, or say, marching on the spot, for the horse to get what your asking

This is true in my experience also. I have seen instructors do this on horses, I have also seen them take a lot longer on phase 1 and 2 and 3before reaching phase 4 in order to make it clear to the horse that it has had the 4 phases.
 
Thanks for the questions, Naturally.

I'll have a go at answering.

"Can you tell me at what phase is she moving in each of games 2 and 3, and how solid is your friendly game? Sometimes with a sensitive horse you need to get these first three games really really solid before moving on. "

Well, in Parelli terms, I don't think we're anywhere ... because in this mare's book you don't work if you haven't got a headcollar on. With a headcollar on, held loosely, I can touch her all over, even the tickly bits, she will move backwards or sideways (shoulder or quarters) if I point at that bit, although I have to walk forward to get her to back. Then if I back, she'll walk forwards again. All this with the very lightest of suggestion from me. But if I wiggle the leadrope at her, either in front or at the back, she doesn't understand and doesn't move away: just looks worried.

Not a particularly sensitive horse, but a dominant one, and very inclined to take over if she thinks there's danger. She used to treat me with no respect at all (which is why I started all this stuff in the first place), would even barge me over if she felt like it...

"But if you can't get effective with your phase 4 (for whatever reason) it is quite acceptable to add a little rhythmic pressure with your carrot stick, or say, marching on the spot, for the horse to get what your asking."

I don't use a carrot stick, I just use hands and voice and body language. With this horse, if she doesn't understand what you're asking, you can up the pressure as much as you like, she'll just get more and more stressed, and end up rearing or running away. Not that I ever do put that much pressure on her, but I've seen her in other situations. ...

No, no friends doing Parelli at all, all I know is what I've seen on the introductory video and read on here and in other places.

Linda



Naturally said:
Can you tell me at what phase is she moving in each of games 2 and 3, and how solid is your friendly game? Sometimes with a sensitive horse you need to get these first three games really really solid before moving on. If not already, aim for response at phase 1 or 2 in the porc. and driv. games.

Do you have any friends who are doing Parelli that are higher level? or are you able to get to a lesson, even to watch? It might help.

Also, in PNH we do need to make the horse "uncomfortable" in the teaching phase, because they learn when they receive the "comfort". But if you can't get effective with your phase 4 (for whatever reason) it is quite acceptable to add a little rhythmic pressure with your carrot stick, or say, marching on the spot, for the horse to get what your asking.

A friend of mines horse used to pick up the clowns at the Rodeo, nothing phases him and we went through this with him. He now responds very lightly at P1 or P2.

My only other advice is that PNH is about much more than the 7 games. It helps to be a member of the Savvy Club and to get to clinics. It is very very hard to go it completely alone.

Good luck
 
all I know is what I've seen on the introductory video and read on here and in other places

Ok, therein lays the first probelm. :( Sorry if this is harsh, but it is a detailed program of study, not copying.


because in this mare's book you don't work if you haven't got a headcollar on.

I assume you mean Halter by headcollar. We don't start our training at "liberty" (no halter) we start it with "online" (rope halter and leadrope), so wouldn't expect your horse to understand you straight up without any gear on.


With a headcollar on, held loosely, I can touch her all over, even the tickly bits, she will move backwards or sideways (shoulder or quarters) if I point at that bit, although I have to walk forward to get her to back. Then if I back, she'll walk forwards again.

All of this is good and shows that she is accepting of you as a leader, to some degree. Not sure when you say "point" as pointing is not part of PNH. We apply steady pressure in the porcupine game and rhythmic pressure in the driving game, which could be seen as pointing, but not really if you're doing it right (certainly not at pre level 1, which is where you'd be)

Not a particularly sensitive horse, but a dominant one, and very inclined to take over if she thinks there's danger.

Your first move to get into PNH for this was the correct one. For your own safety I would suggest you continue on with it.

The problem of the horse not moving at the wiggling of the rope is exactly the problem. He's unsure and so he's not moving. If he gets scared and unsure, he will land on top of you or run you over (but I think you know this). So what you need to do is to teach your horse that his comfort is found when he is OFF you, rather than ON you.... Hence the need for the games, as this is how we teach this.


I don't use a carrot stick, I just use hands and voice and body language.

Another pivotal point. You can't expect to get results with Parelli without using the tools adopting the principles. We communicate through body language, but not voice in the basic levels.


I'll just go back to one of your earlier points

If
I've got Parelli right, you reward the tiniest movement in the direction you want. But if you don't get any movement, and you still increase the pressure, that's when it looks as if you're bullying the horse.

You have the principle right, we reward the slightest try. Timing is crucial here, in knowing when to quit and allowing your horse enough time to digest the learning he has just done (licking of lips is a good sign) But if you are not comfortable with making contact with the horse to get effective, then no, Parelli is not for you. Your horse is looking for a strong leader and someone to respect. They are animals and this is they way nature has taught them. When you observe the phases that a horse gives another, there is nothing un-natural about giving them a tap on the HQ with a Carrot Stick, or a clunk with a snap of a rope. With a dominant horse (i have one too) and you want to train with parelli, this is going to have to happen, how much or for how long is up to how consistently assertive you can be.

Your horse, particularly a dominant one, will continually challenge your leadership. That is his natural tendency. Every time I think we're into a good groove, my horse challenges me up, and I have to meet the stakes. That doesn't mean I have to go beating him up, it might mean that I have to remind him that he receives comfort when he does as I asks, and discomfort when he doesn't. For example, if I go out there today and it's windy and he want's to be standing on top of me, I will back him up. When he backs up and stays out, he receives comfort. It's not safe for me otherwise. Mostly now, all I have to do is breathe in, raise my "life" and he says, "OK, I've got you and I'll pop back there like I know you want me to". The opposite end of that Yo-Yo is that when it is OK for him to come in, all I have to do is smile at him, drop my life a little and he can come in for a rub.

(Actually for KateFarmer if you're reading this, I would add here... this is where I am looking for positive reflexes. If he is back up, but with ears pinned, I know I haven't won the game, and certainly not if he is coming in with ears pinned. I would then "up the phase" until it is achieved with a positive response)

I hope that makes it clearer for you. If you've any other questions I'd like to have a go at answering them for you.

If any other PNH student has any further to add I'm sure it would be appreciated to solve LindaAD's confusions :D
 
Last edited:
More to back up what has been said. The first games are sooo important. I was watching a Peggy Cummings clinic and was pleasantly surprised to see her effectively do "friendly" with the whip before she then asked for anything else.

In this case we are talking a normal dressage style whip being used for in hand work (NOT for punishment, for direction and refinement).

When I ride Fi, if I don't "friendly" with the whip she seems to not know where it is and jumps when it touches her - so these days I always do a little whip-friendly first.

So then when I went to try some long reining, and some fancy stuff such as shoulder-fore etc, the only "whip" I had to hand the first time was my carrot stick. Again I did a little "friendly" first and she was time. Tried to rush it the next time - NOT a good idea - she felt the stick and nearly jumped out of her skin :eek:

The carrot stick is quite heavy to use this way - but I find that I can use e.g. a dealer's whip instead - as long as we do friendly first...
 
Thank you for you careful answers, Naturally. I've commented on them below.

I take your point about the correct equipment, and cvb's, but I don't really see the point about introducing a new stick when this horse is well used to sticks or all kinds (riding stick, lunge whip ...); she's quite happy to accept that they give her instructions, she's not afraid of them.

And I'm still not clear about the answer to my first question: what do you do if the horse doesn't understand what you want? OK, you reward the first sign of a try, but what if you don't get any signs?

Linda


Quote:
Q. all I know is what I've seen on the introductory video and read on here and in other places
A. Ok, therein lays the first probelm. Sorry if this is harsh, but it is a detailed program of study, not copying.

So probably not for someone like me, who likes to learn, understand, digest first ...



Q. because in this mare's book you don't work if you haven't got a headcollar on.
A. I assume you mean Halter by headcollar. We don't start our training at "liberty" (no halter) we start it with "online" (rope halter and leadrope), so wouldn't expect your horse to understand you straight up without any gear on.

Yes, I do, sorry. Yes, rope halter and leadrope.


Quote:
Q.If I've got Parelli right, you reward the tiniest movement in the direction you want. But if you don't get any movement, and you still increase the pressure, that's when it looks as if you're bullying the horse.
A. You have the principle right, we reward the slightest try. Timing is crucial here, in knowing when to quit and allowing your horse enough time to digest the learning he has just done (licking of lips is a good sign)

But this is the problem: what if the horse doesn't understand and you don't get the slightest try? I understand about pressure and release, that's how we've got this far ...



A. But if you are not comfortable with making contact with the horse to get effective, then no, Parelli is not for you. Your horse is looking for a strong leader and someone to respect. They are animals and this is they way nature has taught them.

I'm not sure what you mean by this. I taught her to move in the direction I wanted by pushing her. She understood that, no problem. Then I could make the push lighter and lighter until just pointing was enough.
 
I may have slightly different answers to below from Naturally - as I said I have a bit of a mix of styles to contribute and take the best of what I see..

LindaAd said:
I take your point about the correct equipment, and cvb's, but I don't really see the point about introducing a new stick when this horse is well used to sticks or all kinds (riding stick, lunge whip ...); she's quite happy to accept that they give her instructions, she's not afraid of them.

Yes - I should clarify here that I use the carrot stick for Parelli work - it is used for direction and emphasis at the level I am on. I only use a different whip for long reining and riding cos of what I am doing and using it for - a different purpose (and to stop my arm falling off !)

And I'm still not clear about the answer to my first question: what do you do if the horse doesn't understand what you want? OK, you reward the first sign of a try, but what if you don't get any signs?

and this is where we get into the debate about escalation. But to park that for a moment...

Q. all I know is what I've seen on the introductory video and read on here and in other places
A. Ok, therein lays the first probelm. Sorry if this is harsh, but it is a detailed program of study, not copying.

So probably not for someone like me, who likes to learn, understand, digest first ...

The problem is that the material you are learning, digesting etc is not giving you all the information you need. Thats why the study packs were designed in the first place. I had Natural Horse.Man.Ship (the book) as my first resource and didn't get very far. I actually work in the Education sector so can appreciate the learning design that has been put into the packs - they are lightyears ahead (in terms of a learning resource) of the book.

Q.If I've got Parelli right, you reward the tiniest movement in the direction you want. But if you don't get any movement, and you still increase the pressure, that's when it looks as if you're bullying the horse.
A. You have the principle right, we reward the slightest try. Timing is crucial here, in knowing when to quit and allowing your horse enough time to digest the learning he has just done (licking of lips is a good sign)

But this is the problem: what if the horse doesn't understand and you don't get the slightest try? I understand about pressure and release, that's how we've got this far ...

right - let's unpark that debate ;)

As has been previously commented - it could be that you are not asking as clearly as you think. I also had problem with the "tapping the rope" approach so asked at a session with an instructor. If you are a bit half-hearted about the tapping, you actually put pressure on the rope towards you, so the horse naturally walks forward. This is where notes and the introductory video will not give you enough info. I was also doing all yooooo and no "-yo", and got that sorted out with some feedback from an instructor as well. So in these cases the lack of try, or the wrong response, was actually down to the "ask" being "wrong".

Now - the other option. My mum's Fell pony simply doesn't get waggling the rope. he just stands. Thats his reaction to something he doesn't get - "do nothing" (as opposed to some horses who will remove themselves from what they don't understand). Escalating up phases would not have improved his understanding. And there was no try. What I needed to do was go back a step and work on the basics again. The principle of moving his feet, and other yields which gave me back-up.

This is where I am probably a bit of a hybrid, as I won't just escalate, I will repose the question. Naturally may be able to comment here on a purer "parelli" response to this issue.

So if I don't see any try at all, I will think why that is and try to "create" a try that I can reward. (Mark Rashid talks about this - about giving the horse something that they can do rather than saying "don't do that" to them. Not saying this is "non-parelli" - but mark says it more clearly in my view).

I'm not sure what you mean by this. I taught her to move in the direction I wanted by pushing her. She understood that, no problem. Then I could make the push lighter and lighter until just pointing was enough.

The point is that you don't want to train your horse so that if you walk towards them, they walk away cos you've put "pressure" on them. (This is one of my concerns about methods that "send away" the horse). You need a toolkit with more than one tool in it, as different circumstances need different solutions. There is nothing wrong with what you have - but why not also be able to do it - with contact, at liberty etc etc
 
cvb
Cucumber


L: And I'm still not clear about the answer to my first question: what do you do if the horse doesn't understand what you want? OK, you reward the first sign of a try, but what if you don't get any signs?

cvb:and this is where we get into the debate about escalation. But to park that for a moment...

Yes! That's the point where the debate starts ...

<snip>

L: So probably not for someone like me, who likes to learn, understand, digest first ...

cvb: The problem is that the material you are learning, digesting etc is not giving you all the information you need. Thats why the study packs were designed in the first place. I had Natural Horse.Man.Ship (the book) as my first resource and didn't get very far. I actually work in the Education sector so can appreciate the learning design that has been put into the packs - they are lightyears ahead (in terms of a learning resource) of the book.

L: But this is the problem: what if the horse doesn't understand and you don't get the slightest try? I understand about pressure and release, that's how we've got this far ...

cvb: right - let's unpark that debate
As has been previously commented - it could be that you are not asking as clearly as you think. I also had problem with the "tapping the rope" approach so asked at a session with an instructor. If you are a bit half-hearted about the tapping, you actually put pressure on the rope towards you, so the horse naturally walks forward. This is where notes and the introductory video will not give you enough info. I was also doing all yooooo and no "-yo", and got that sorted out with some feedback from an instructor as well. So in these cases the lack of try, or the wrong response, was actually down to the "ask" being "wrong".


Well, I'd say I'm asking in the wrong language! This horse, like your mum's Fell pony, doesn't understand robe-wiggling at all - it you wiggle it near her bum, she'll just stand and look at it.



CVB: Now - the other option. My mum's Fell pony simply doesn't get waggling the rope. he just stands. Thats his reaction to something he doesn't get - "do nothing" (as opposed to some horses who will remove themselves from what they don't understand). Escalating up phases would not have improved his understanding. And there was no try. What I needed to do was go back a step and work on the basics again. The principle of moving his feet, and other yields which gave me back-up.

Yes, I understand this. Moving feet, she'll do, no problem. Front feet, back feet, she'll even cross them, moving sideways, if asked.



cvb: This is where I am probably a bit of a hybrid, as I won't just escalate, I will repose the question. Naturally may be able to comment here on a purer "parelli" response to this issue.

Now this is where I don't understand Parelli; this is the question I keep asking.



cvb: So if I don't see any try at all, I will think why that is and try to "create" a try that I can reward. (Mark Rashid talks about this - about giving the horse something that they can do rather than saying "don't do that" to them. Not saying this is "non-parelli" - but mark says it more clearly in my view).

I understand this, very well (I'm a teacher too, by the way, so I know about giving kids something to do rather than saying Don't do that!)

Thanks for your careful answer, cvb. I've tried to reply, and to keep the discussion fairly clear ...

cvb: The point is that you don't want to train your horse so that if you walk towards them, they walk away cos you've put "pressure" on them. (This is one of my concerns about methods that "send away" the horse). You need a toolkit with more than one tool in it, as different circumstances need different solutions. There is nothing wrong with what you have - but why not also be able to do it - with contact, at liberty etc etc

No, she knows the difference between being asked to back (a hard stare and I walk towards her from the front), and being asked to stand still so I can approach her (I look down, and walk towards her shoulder). And then there's voice too - if it's backing, I say "back", and if it's approaching I just talk, in a totally different voice.

Linda
__________________
 
Second go lucky - slightly shortened from last time as I've practiced it already ! ;)

This horse, like your mum's Fell pony, doesn't understand robe-wiggling at all - it you wiggle it near her bum, she'll just stand and look at it.

Are you really wiggling ? Cos if so the "ask" is still to her chin, not her bum...

If you are actually "swinging", then the swing becomes "rhythmic pressure" when it gets close to their bum. And they have learnt this before so should respond. You can make the link between the previous "tapping the ground with the stick" version by "tapping" the ground with the rope....

I also commented on something Mark Rashid says about swinging the rope - that there is a difference between an overhand rotation and an underhand rotation (e.g. in Circle game, "lunging"). He uses an underhand swing to start the horse moving - the energy is up and forward. The overhand swing comes into use, for example, to disengage the hindquarters. The energy is "down" into the ground... It may be that parelli makes this distinction in a higher level.... but I don't recall seeing it used anywhere (perhaps I wasn't looking for it ?)
 
Naturally said:
this is where I am looking for positive reflexes. If he is back up, but with ears pinned, I know I haven't won the game, and certainly not if he is coming in with ears pinned. I would then "up the phase" until it is achieved with a positive response

Does that work? If the horse is reluctant to back but is doing it, albeit not with good grace, does making the request to back up more forceful really make them more willing?

And doesn't it go against the principle of rewarding any steps towards the action that you want? :confused: I'm confused!
 
And doesn't it go against the principle of rewarding any steps towards the action that you want?

ah - but you are "shaping" the behaviour. So for example, you may start being happy with a shift of weight, then with one step, then more steps...

Rewarding the "try" is how you create the link between the cue and the requied behaviour, but you are after more than a try..

If the horse is reluctant to back but is doing it, albeit not with good grace, does making the request to back up more forceful really make them more willing?

Well this may take us into our next area of discussion - leadership: "alpha" or passive leader ?

In some methods, you are aiming to be the "alpha" in the partnership. Smplistically what the alpha says goes. In a herd, the alpha is the one who deals with crises and survival.

Passive leadership is less easy to find a dictionary definition for - I know, I've looked ;) But the passive leader tends to be the one who knows where the good grass is, so if you have any sense you stick close ;)
 
Zingy I think CVB has pretty well answered your questions, but I would like to add that it's not about being more forceful (in the whole dominance debate) it's about being a stronger/better/less emotional leader. Sometimes this can be achieved by the slightest of changes in our own behaviour and body language.

As an example.

If I go out to a horse that I just KNOW is not going to back up, cause I've tried and tried and nope, my horse just wont move..... I jiggle the rope, I'm looking frustrated and damn it, it just wont happen.

or
B

If I go out to a horse and I think, what can I do to help this horse understand what I'm asking. I draw a deep breath, I square my shoulders, I look way beyond his rump to the fence and hills beyond and I start at phase 1. Before I've even got to phase 1, the horse is listening to me.

It's about so many things, but focus, feel and timing are the keys for me. But that doesn't come from learning it from friends or reading about it on a forum. It comes for a couple of years of hard work (would have been much shorter if I had more horse time) Attending clinics, play days, watching higher level friends and reading and absorbing as much as I can.

LindaAD, I'm really lost on your post and what you may or may not need answered any longer. If you have any other questions I'd be happy to help.
 
LindaAd said:
But this is the problem: what if the horse doesn't understand and you don't get the slightest try?

I'll have a poke at answering this question by talking through how I would approach it.

We are talking about the yo-yo game here, which is an extension of the driving game. (yo-yo game assumes you have got the driving game working pretty well). In both of these we use rhythmic pressure to communicate an intention to the horse.

We start by standing still just out in front of the horse making sure our intention for the horse to back is clear in our body language (belly button pointing up, shoulders squared, eyes firm) and we give a phase one finger wiggle.

The horse doesn't respond we more to phase two which is swinging the rope from our wrist, and increasing the intention of our body language. No response we more to phase three which is swinging the rope from our elbow, and again INCREASING THE INTENTION of our body language.

No response again and we move to phase four which is swinging the rope side to side with our whole arm and making sure you intention is still focused in your body language. By this stage the whole rope and headcollar should be moving, and this should be uncomfortable for the horse.

For Yann's sake and others I will make a point here of saying that if you have suitable rope control, stage four while being uncomforatable for the horse does not have to be harsh or painful, if you control your movement you can avoid hitting your horse with the snap.

The horse does not respond again, so what do you do? You be passively persistent in the proper position, which means not getting angry or frustrated about it, not giving up and not giving in your intention for the horse to move backward.

If you are doing a full phase four the horse SHOULD eventually move. In fact if you are willing to wait long enough you can probably get a try from phase one, two or three, but it might take a week! The point is that you must be patient. There are very few horses that are prepared to put up with phase four for very long.

If you are in a real hurry you can probably speed up the process by adding some more intention into your phase four by say star jumping towards your horse as you swing the rope or stomping your feet, this will reinforce the intention for your horse to move backward.

Then the second you get a try (any sort of movement) you quit - but not before.

This would be my approach based on Parelli and my own experience, I don't know what hard-core Parelli people will think of it, but never-the-less.

Linda, I don't know your mare, so perhaps a bomb could drop and should would refuse to go back, but in my experience a phase four will eventually get some result (it doesn't have to be very forceful), you just have to persist.

Perhaps you have already stood in the paddock for an hour waving the rope about, or perhaps you don't have this kind of time or patience, in which case if I were you I would try other routes, like I said, do whatever it takes to get the message through.

I would also reiterate that the yo-yo game is just the driving game in disguise, can you get your mare to back using the driving game, i.e. flicking the air in front of her to get a backward yeild? If not you might want to start there.

Alternatively Parelli might not be your cup of tea in which case forget about it, move on, there are plenty of fish in the sea and some of them are tastier than others :p!

 
newrider.com