Oh I was on stands donkey's years ago

In the days when they only had level 3+ students, instructors and Richard Marriot on them... You are absolutely right, I didn't pass level 2 + 3 - how could I when I worked with one horse after another and mostly they physically couldn't be ridden? Mind you, passing levels got less and less important to me the longer I was in the programme and now they are of no interest to me at all.
The horse I saw Pat working with was Teddy, a Blue Cross horse that had already been to level 3 with at least one student (Sue Gardner) and was close to that with his current student (Scott O'Malley). Pat wanted Teddy to jump towards him over some barrels on a 22ft line. Teddy was a bit reluctant, he had a history of abuse as a showjumper and could get very scared of jumps. Pat had to go to level 4 several times to keep Teddy focused on him and eventually get him over the jump. Obviously you PNH students know what level 4 looks like when applied with a 22ft line.
When Pat handles his own horses of course it looks soft and light and like dancing (most of the time). He only has to use the tiniest of phases to get them to respond, not a light phase 4 in my opinion, simply a phase half or quarter

Why is it like that? Because when he was training them Pat wasn't afraid to use an effective Phase 4. Surely that's obvious? Horses don't respond to the tip of your head or move of your eye unless you have previously given them a good reason to do so.
I don't know why people seem to think I have something against Parelli - I think it's great. It's a system that has given so many people access to a different way of being with their horses, and I think used correctly then it can be applied to every horse. Personally I am uncomfortable with phase 4 as applied in the Yo Yo game, but I can see it's use in other situations - like in a "driving game" situation if the horse threatens you. I think it's a shame that phase 4 of the Yo Yo game is taught at all, as there are alternatives that might not be so painful for the horse, but I won't argue that it doesn't work, because it does. I don't think any system is perfect, so however much I think of the instructor I'd always be ready to leave something of what they teach to one side.
I watched the lovely Alison Jones teaching earlier this year and when a pre-level 1 horse wouldn't back off in the Yo Yo game she quickly upped the phases to phase 4 and of course the bull clip smacked the horse around the face. Then the horse learnt to play that game.
I think that's all I've got to say on the exhaustive topic of the Yo Yo game now
