Parelli's yo-yo game

Crystal Fire said:
My understanding of the PNH programme is so low that I was the only student who hadn't passed Level 2 to be invited to work on stands on Parelli tours. Equus, Horse events... I was there and possibly talking to some of you about the programme.
Just out of curiosity Crystal Fire, how long ago was this? As far as I'm aware you only have to have an official L1 pass. I'm a L2/L3 student and I (along with many other L2 students) have also been asked to volunteer to work on the stands at the Parelli tours/demo's. :)
 


I don't even know where to begin to respond to this thread.

Tootsie and cvb have said pretty much what I am thinking.

I think it's a matter of perspective. People adopt methods for different reasons, and their beliefs are their own.

I personally practice and support many of Parelli's methods. I used to be a very big sceptic until I actually tried it and now I am very humbled by my success, yet I do not shy from other methods, nor take everything in his program as gospel.

To me the use of phase 4 pressure makes sense to me, even if it results in discomfort for the horse. When I find something that makes more sense to me then I will use it.

Finally a question for Bay Mare - If phase 4 pressure is unacceptable then what is acceptable? Perhaps you can give us a useful lesson in horsemanship?
 
Nope, that's not what I said at all.

So what did you say then? :)

I do not shy from other methods, nor take everything in his program as gospel.

That's fair enough, and a sensible approach to any training, but not one that is not always taken by other PNH adherents if some of the posts you read are anything to go by. I'm afraid I end up thinking 'cult' quite a lot :p
 
What I was saying Yann is that IF you don't understand the principles, then it's not fair to put down the program. That was all.
 
Crystal Fire said:
I know exactly what you mean Tootsie - but how can you say Parelli phase 4 can be anything other than as Parelli themselves describe? To quote their own website "Start phase 1 by just wiggling your index finger at the horse. Phase 2, wiggle your wrist so it affects the rope only slightly. Phase 3, bend at the elbow and shake the rope using your lower arm. Phase 4, straighten your elbow and shake your whole arm and watch how much more the rope moves."

It is great that you are able to help your horse to understand without using what Parelli call a phase 4 - but that doesn't change the Parelli system as they teach it.

Ever seen Pat use phase 4 with a 22ft line? His phase 4 isn't anyone's phase 1 for sure.

Sorry, had to quote alot there :D

With your example, he has layed it out in very specific terms because he is trying to teach a mass audience. It is the *average* requirements. But every horse is different and some you may never need to get to the 'straight arm swinging the line' bit. In that essense, whatever Phase you used to get the response becomes your Phase 4. This is where "deeper understanding" of the process comes in. The phases aren't specific. You may have been instructed to use the shaking finger as Phase 1 but you may not even need that much of a cue to get your horse to yo yo.

I have seen Pat use Phase 4's and I completely agree that it isnt always a pretty sight. But, when you see him use that Phase 4, what sort of horse is he training? Ever see him work with one of his own horses, a PNH trained horse? To the average eye, you dont SEE ANY Phases, or at least very mute ones. Its a dance. His Phase 1 with that horse may be subtle eye movements, his phase 2 a shift of his weight, his phase 3 actually stepping in a certain direction... phase 4, raising his arm to make it more obvious. Those aren't written out anywhere in his training packs but they've been tailored to the individual. Phase 4 isnt always force - its only doing what is necessary to get a response.
 
Oh I was on stands donkey's years ago :) In the days when they only had level 3+ students, instructors and Richard Marriot on them... You are absolutely right, I didn't pass level 2 + 3 - how could I when I worked with one horse after another and mostly they physically couldn't be ridden? Mind you, passing levels got less and less important to me the longer I was in the programme and now they are of no interest to me at all.
The horse I saw Pat working with was Teddy, a Blue Cross horse that had already been to level 3 with at least one student (Sue Gardner) and was close to that with his current student (Scott O'Malley). Pat wanted Teddy to jump towards him over some barrels on a 22ft line. Teddy was a bit reluctant, he had a history of abuse as a showjumper and could get very scared of jumps. Pat had to go to level 4 several times to keep Teddy focused on him and eventually get him over the jump. Obviously you PNH students know what level 4 looks like when applied with a 22ft line.
When Pat handles his own horses of course it looks soft and light and like dancing (most of the time). He only has to use the tiniest of phases to get them to respond, not a light phase 4 in my opinion, simply a phase half or quarter :) Why is it like that? Because when he was training them Pat wasn't afraid to use an effective Phase 4. Surely that's obvious? Horses don't respond to the tip of your head or move of your eye unless you have previously given them a good reason to do so.
I don't know why people seem to think I have something against Parelli - I think it's great. It's a system that has given so many people access to a different way of being with their horses, and I think used correctly then it can be applied to every horse. Personally I am uncomfortable with phase 4 as applied in the Yo Yo game, but I can see it's use in other situations - like in a "driving game" situation if the horse threatens you. I think it's a shame that phase 4 of the Yo Yo game is taught at all, as there are alternatives that might not be so painful for the horse, but I won't argue that it doesn't work, because it does. I don't think any system is perfect, so however much I think of the instructor I'd always be ready to leave something of what they teach to one side.
I watched the lovely Alison Jones teaching earlier this year and when a pre-level 1 horse wouldn't back off in the Yo Yo game she quickly upped the phases to phase 4 and of course the bull clip smacked the horse around the face. Then the horse learnt to play that game.
I think that's all I've got to say on the exhaustive topic of the Yo Yo game now :D
 
Crystal Fire said:
...when a pre-level 1 horse wouldn't back off in the Yo Yo game she quickly upped the phases to phase 4 and of course the bull clip smacked the horse around the face. Then the horse learnt to play that game.

I dont own Parelli equipment, I have homemade stuff that works just as well. But I don't recall Parelli using bull snaps on the ends of his halters or lines... ? (maybe he does, I dunno... I dont) So in your example, was it Parelli that caused the mess up, or improper equipment?
 
The older Parelli ropes have a big clip on that my PNH instructor always called a bull clip. The current ropes have a clip that is a sort of safety clip, the middle spins round to close it, if that makes sense... quite a big clip anyroad. I expect there are pictures on their website.
Wrong equipment can always make things worse I guess. If the halter is too loose at the bottom, as you often see, then of course the clip swings further and makes contact higher up the jawbone.
I don't think any PHN instructor would teach with improper equipment, as they regard the equipment as integral to their system, which it could well be. Certainly this was a Parelli halter and line in the example I'm mentioning.
I am not saying Alison did anything wrong. I am saying she demonstrated the 4 phases of the Yo Yo game and warned the owner that they were being too slow going through the phases and that was why she wasn't being effective.
 
There's a very interesting thread going on the EE forums at the moment about the PNH approach to the seat/position etc. I won't repeat it here but it makes very interesting reading. I know which way I would prefer to follow ....

Where is this?? Could you give me a link? I would like to read it.

As for the other things going on, I am too tired right now to give my opinion(I just ran 5.5 miles). Maybe some other time... ;)
 
Crystal Fire said:
I watched the lovely Alison Jones teaching earlier this year and when a pre-level 1 horse wouldn't back off in the Yo Yo game she quickly upped the phases to phase 4 and of course the bull clip smacked the horse around the face. Then the horse learnt to play that game.
:D

That is the correct way to apply phase 4 of the yo-yo game. The horse does SOMETIMES get a little knock with the snap, but you rarely have to go there more than once or twice with a particular horse. It's not cruel, it's effective. If it was going to have to be harder than that, every instructor I have seen would "go outside the square" and apply some rhythmic pressure, or start again and get any or all of the first three games better.


I am not saying Alison did anything wrong. I am saying she demonstrated the 4 phases of the Yo Yo game and warned the owner that they were being too slow going through the phases and that was why she wasn't being effective
.

If you don't think it's wrong, why did you use it as an example for your argument against the yoyo game at phase4 ?
 
I'm not saying Alison did anything wrong, I think I'm saying that she was teaching the game correctly as she'd been taught to do, she was doing something right.
I'm not sure I am "arguing against the yo yo game at phase 4". I really joined this discussion to say that in my opinion the 4 phases of the yo yo game are very clearly described by Pat P in his learning materials and regularly used in that way by instructors and students. For my personal preference I wouldn't do it. I certainly have in the past for sure, but am more relaxed with different ways of teaching a horse to yield backwards. I know that you rarely need to hit the horse round the face with a clip more than once or twice, but I have decided that I'd rather not do it at all. I now know that you can be effective without causing that much discomfort, so I suppose in that respect I personally feel it is unfair to cause the horse pain when you don't need to.
I feel that people who say that they have a "soft phase 4" are kind of fitting the system to suit themselves, because if you are soft then you are getting things done at a low phase - say phase 1 - aren't you?
What you want to do is up to you. I learnt not to bother trying to impose my ways of doing things on others a long time ago :) (Probably in the early days when I thought PNH was the be-all and end-all of NH and everyone should try it :D ).
You seem quite attacking towards me, but maybe I'm mis-reading it. All I'm giving you is my first-hand experience. Yours is obviously different... Mine made me look outside of PNH, others here are obviously happy sticking with it. No worries :)
 
Ok, well I actually thought you were attacking me, so now we're even.. :D :D :D :D

I tried to say this earlier, but I think it's really interesting that the experiences vary so much, especially from country to country, (considering we "share" instructors).

I have many friends who joined the program here in Australia in the days when P himself was teaching here and touring regularly. They often refer to how things "used" to be and how much things have changed. Personally I find it a good thing that the organisation pushes it's own boundaries. They dump the occasional instructor, change the levels to reflect more strongly the necessary outcomes for each stage etc etc. I find it a really dynamic organisation and I'm sure it's changed tremendously since the days when you were active in the program (though I realise you still attend clinics etc).


I understand that I may reach the same point as you one day, but to be honest, I hope I get through L3 first. :o
 
Crystal Fire said:
You are absolutely right, I didn't pass level 2 + 3 - how could I when I worked with one horse after another and mostly they physically couldn't be ridden? Mind you, passing levels got less and less important to me the longer I was in the programme and now they are of no interest to me at all.
Crystal Fire, I don't think there's a need to justify why you didn't pass L2, if you re-read my post you'll notice it wasn't about the PNH level of achievement you attained - it doesn't really interest me (no offence).
I see passing the levels as a personal goal, I think it's up to the individual how far they want to go. I don't aim to become a PNH professional or set up another NH programme by using the PNH techniques as a basis. :)
 
Phew, glad we're all friends then :D
I have never been a target-driven person, not competetive in shows or anything. When I first got into PNH I wanted to be an instructor, but as I learnt more about what that involved (in terms of cost) I went right off the idea and so the levels just lost all importance.
I can understand the phases being taught completely, because Pat has to have some way of getting this stuff over to people, and it is the way he trains horse. I guess I'd be more comfortable if the clips came off the ropes completely to avoid the possibility of abuse - which we all know happens.
Working with horses now the idea of phases never enters my head. I have found that I don't have to keep on doing something but harder to get the horse to understand, but it is an option isn't it? :) I try to come from the standpoint that all of these great horsemen have something to teach us, they do things differently but it doesn't make it wrong. Something like not liking the use of clips is a personal thing, and we have to decide for ourselves if we want to do it or not.
I'm riding with Phil Nye in Australia next spring and can't wait. His approach these days is so interesting, not a hint of a "phase" and so "it's not personal horse". That's a bit hard to explain, but I find some other trainers very direct them vs the horse, more personal in trying to establish themselves as some sort of Alpha.
Just a quick thought - some people are accused of setting up NH systems using Parelli as a basis haven't actually done that. If you look at their history pre-Parelli you realise that they were horsemen in their own right before they were invited (yes, invited in the old days!) to join the PNH programme. Phil Nye is one, and there are others. It was easier for them to be part of PNH in the days when they just had a list of tasks to video, so got them done their way. It was in more recent times when the style of teaching had to become more standardised that these people had to go their own way. Things were so different. My friend Irena qualified as a PNH instructor and she only ever attended one lesson with Pat in her life - that wouldn't happen now!
 
Last edited:
Crystal Fire said:
Just a quick thought - some people are accused of setting up NH systems using Parelli as a basis haven't actually done that. If you look at their history pre-Parelli you realise that they were horsemen in their own right before they were invited (yes, invited in the old days!) to join the PNH programme.
I agree Crystal Fire, they where all horsemen in their own right, I wouldn't argue that fact at all. ;)
However, there are a few of the ex PNH instructors who have tailored the method of teaching slightly (to avoid a law suit being issued), but still use the Parelli seven games as a basis to their NH teaching programme - don't you agree? :)
 
There are plenty of instructors here that are ex Parelli instructors that still teach Pat's methods, even though are no longer endorsed instructors.

Crystal Fire: I know a couple of current PNH instructors who teach without the strong phases, but I have also found that that approach comes more in the refinement (Level 3), and also therefore no longer needed when say, a L3 graduate goes onto to start a young horse, or begin with a new horse. Having said that, I also think the way L1 is being taught now is very different to when I did it 3 years ago.

I know, after taking a few horses through L1 and L2, that I rarely find I have to use a strong phase 4 anymore, I think it's (the process) the science of learning. It is at the horses expense, but so is everything we do with horses, and it certainly beats the daylights out of the way I've seen many people training horses.. :eek: . (that statement applies to thumping, kicking, pulling, yanking, etc...unless you do that, please don't take offence).
 
Surely after a horse has been through level 1 and 2 it knows full well that any reluctance on its part to carry out a task is going to get it uncomfortable very quickly, so it will learn to be switched on to any clue as to what the handler is going to ask of it?

Of course that evetually results in a horse that falls over itself to do what the handler wants with very light cues and suggestions, but not always a particularly happy one.

but still use the Parelli seven games as a basis to their NH teaching programme

Parelli didn't invent yielding exercises, and although there might be variations between what different trainers do they usually boil down to the same sorts of things. Teaching your horse to back, come forward, move sideways and yield the shoulders and hindquarters are the starting point whatever style of training you choose to employ.
 
Yann said:
Surely after a horse has been through level 1 and 2 it knows full well that any reluctance on its part to carry out a task is going to get it uncomfortable very quickly, so it will learn to be switched on to any clue as to what the handler is going to ask of it?

Of course that evetually results in a horse that falls over itself to do what the handler wants with very light cues and suggestions, but not always a particularly happy one.

Well in theory if they didn't want to do it you WOULD get the signs of resistance and opposition, and the person would fail the assessment. In practice of course we are going to submit the parts where they don't show resistance. So the fact that the person is listening enough and asking the right way on an assessment does not necessarily mean they are going to do the same thing day in day out. They're human and no doubt have bad days like the rest of us ! The problem is that they are doing it in public, where they are setting an example and providing "leadership".

This is also (in my mind) a dialogue not a monologue. So the fact that we/they ask the horse to do something does not mean the horse will automatically just go off and do it, without expressing its own opinion. How often does PP talk about not getting rid of the curiosity ??! And thats what worries me about the reports of switched off horses, cos its sounds like they lost their mojo and their curiosity :(

I may play games with Fi, but she also plays games with me and everyone else she interacts with. I do NOT want train that out - she's a horse, she plays .... full stop. I don't see playing as being "bad", lacking respect etc etc. She's simply being a horse.

But I am amazed how often I hear comments which imply someone expects to "have" their horse all the time. It may simply be the words they are using, as I want the horse to be aware of me and listening (and safe), but the way I've heard it said sounds like they will end up with an automaton :( Then they should go buy a motorbike and ride that instead !

I know its a fine line - but thats why it takes skill....
 
Yann said:
Parelli didn't invent yielding exercises, and although there might be variations between what different trainers do they usually boil down to the same sorts of things. Teaching your horse to back, come forward, move sideways and yield the shoulders and hindquarters are the starting point whatever style of training you choose to employ.
Call them what you will, the fact remains it's the seven games that most ex PNH instructors base their methods on. They even tend to teach them in the same sequence. :rolleyes:
 
newrider.com