Parelli's yo-yo game

Jazzyy did better today. I found a different lead rope today that worked much better. Plus voice commands REALLY help with Jazzy. I don't know if Parelli uses voice commands, but I really like them. I do wonder though if she will always hold her head up high when she backs up now because she remembers getting whacked with the buckle a few times in the chin. :o
 
No, we don't use voice commands, I think because we are learning body language with the horse. The correct gear will go a long way to helping you with your signals, but try taking a deep breath and directing your belly button at the horse with your phase 1. It really makes them take notice.

The head UP thing will get better, as you learn to quit at the right time and your phases get lighter. Remember to reward the slightest try. ;)
 
Does parelli ever include voice commands later on? I think I'm going to continue w/ the voice commands so that my horse will have another way to understand if my body language is confusing her. It seems to really be helping and she's starting to take steps back. However she does take one or two steps back and then stop. When do I ask her to back all the way to the end of the line? I'm afraid that if I continue telling her to back she might think that means she's not doing it right.
 
Don't know how Parelli it is but one way to do it perhaps would be to ask and say get 2 steps back, then reward. Once that's established look for 3 steps, then reward, and so on until you're at the end of the rope.

Personally I make a lot of use of voice cues / commands in groundwork, and riding too. Unless you're planning to go the whole hog and be assessed etc with the Parelli there's nothing stopping you using your voice as well, it certainly won't spoil the training and might well make it easier for you and your horse. Lots of people (here) have used Parelli but tailored it to their individual needs and preferences, it doesn't need to be followed to the exact letter to be effective.
 
However she does take one or two steps back and then stop. When do I ask her to back all the way to the end of the line? I'm afraid that if I continue telling her to back she might think that means she's not doing it right.

If you want to ask for more than one step, ask her to take one step, then go back down to Phase 1, then increase your phases until she takes another step. Then give her extra Friendly Game and rest, so she knows that it's okay.
 
can you tell me where you can get a copy of the seven games on the internet from? I have looked everywhere and cant find them. Thank you.
 
Tiber said:
Start at phase one (wiggling finger), then phase 2 (wrist), then phase 3 (elbow) then phase 4 (swinging whole arm from the shoulder). Try and keep the rhythm the same through all the phases, and STAY AT PHASE 4 UNTIL SHE TRIES!

Yann said:
I've read rather too many posts about otherwise perfectly amenable horses rearing in official training sessions though, so some people clearly do. Your comment about the relationship being spoiled is spot on and why that type of training isn't for me. I don't want a horse that flinches when I make a gesture towards it. This approach will be entirely appropriate for some types of horse, but entirely wrong for others, one size doesn't fit all.

I've read through this thread a couple of times now and stopped myself from wading in. NOTHING that has been said (apart from thinking outside the box ie not strictly adhering to the principles) has convinced me that my thoughts and feelings about PNH are unjustified. I'm completely with Yann on this. I've seen how his horse, Rio, responds to the lightest of cues. I've seen how my horse, a completely different personality to Rio (bossy, stubborn, opinionated ;) ... Saff that is not Rio) reacts to similar methods that Yann uses and can honestly say that I cannot see how Phase 4 can ever result in a respectful, trusting relationship. If you tried that with her I know for a fact that I would have her front feet in my face.

How can *we* in all conscience bleat on to people about listening to your horse, understanding why they do things, trying a different method if they don't understand, not using force etc etc etc and then talk about Phase 4 as if it's acceptable! I cannot see how hitting the horse on the head or around the face with anything can ever be seen as an acceptable training method.

There's a very interesting thread going on the EE forums at the moment about the PNH approach to the seat/position etc. I won't repeat it here but it makes very interesting reading. I know which way I would prefer to follow ....

And with that I will bow out gracefully, raise the shields and retire to my room :)
 
Bay Mare said:
How can *we* in all conscience bleat on to people about listening to your horse, understanding why they do things, trying a different method if they don't understand, not using force etc etc etc and then talk about Phase 4 as if it's acceptable! I cannot see how hitting the horse on the head or around the face with anything can ever be seen as an acceptable training method.

There is no rule book.

Phase 4 is merely doing what it takes to get the desired response. No ifs, ands, buts about it from the horse. They do it and they do it now. The 'asking' element is no longer a privledge they're given at that point in time. Ideally, I like to think that with my PNH trained horse, my phase 4 is your phase 1.

Its the misconception that Phase 4 is about beating your horse that gives PNH a bad name. You do what you need to do and leave it at that. Phase 4 does not mean you immediately escalate to physical rampage against your horse.
 
I know exactly what you mean Tootsie - but how can you say Parelli phase 4 can be anything other than as Parelli themselves describe? To quote their own website "Start phase 1 by just wiggling your index finger at the horse. Phase 2, wiggle your wrist so it affects the rope only slightly. Phase 3, bend at the elbow and shake the rope using your lower arm. Phase 4, straighten your elbow and shake your whole arm and watch how much more the rope moves."
Phase 4 in the Yo Yo game is swinging your straight arm backwards and forwards until you get a yield (even a tiny one) from the horse. That is what it is, I have heard instructors describe it as such many, many times and I have also seen them use it. You straighten your arm, swing it back by your shoulder and then straight forward - sending huge "energy" straight down the rope with the result that the bull clip smacks your horse on the face. Used effectively it always works. Sometimes it doesn't work for students because they stick on their phases for too long, de-sensitise their horses and by the time they pluck up the courage to "find their phase 4" (as I have been told to do many times) their horse has braced themselves and takes the punishment.
It is great that you are able to help your horse to understand without using what Parelli call a phase 4 - but that doesn't change the Parelli system as they teach it.
Ever seen Pat use phase 4 with a 22ft line? His phase 4 isn't anyone's phase 1 for sure. When Pat goes up his phases they follow each other so quickly you hardly have time to blink. He is extremely effective in teaching the yields that are called the 7 Games.
 
I guess one of the problems with PNH students replying to answers in forums such as these is that much is left up to the interpretation of the written word and inflections. It's also that we are students and not instructors, and hence still learning the program. But people ask questions and so we try and explain as best we can.

One thing that I would really like to clarify for people who don't have a deeper understanding of the program is that it's not about doing the same thing for each horse. Ofcourse PNH recognises taht horses ARE different, you might play the games with each of them, but your body language phases etc are different for each one.

So to say it works for one horse and not another shows an absolute misunderstanding of the program. It's all about how the HUMAN is in order to get the desired outcome. It seems to be the hardest thing for people who are not dedicated to the program to understand. And it's probably one of the most challenging aspects of being a student. It's fine if you are not that committed to go down that path, but it's not really fair to put down something just because you don't understand it.
 
Naturally said:
It's fine if you are not that committed to go down that path, but it's not really fair to put down something just because you don't understand it.
I agree Naturally, but can I also add that while some folk do criticise PNH because they don't understand it, others do so merely to promote their own personal preference of NH training. ;)
 
My understanding of the PNH programme is so low that I was the only student who hadn't passed Level 2 to be invited to work on stands on Parelli tours. Equus, Horse events... I was there and possibly talking to some of you about the programme. They didn't used to let anyone below level 2 do this, but recognised my level of experience in this sort of work and the PNH system and I was an exception to the rule. The horses I was working with restricted my progress a bit (had physical problems or were too young to be ridden), but all 3 of my horses at the time had all of level 2 ground skills and some of level 3 in place (like some advanced liberty). I also worked at a Parelli centre for 6 months and rode every clinic I wanted to, and watched everything that went on.
Parelli isn't something that is supposed to be used in exactly the same way with every horse. Some horses won't need the same amount of phases to make them move, and I have always maintained here that the intelligent student can normally find other ways to "explain" to the horse what is wanted without escalating the phases. It appears to me that many here do, and I respect you for this. However, I don't see how that means that the PNH programme is re-written. The books and notes still say the same thing, the instructors still teach the same thing (I know, I still watch clinics and lessons). Phase 4 in Yo Yo is clearly explained again and again and it is what it is - as I quoted above. If it is no longer that then they should update their website. However I think that isn't the case, In the past I have attended a day clinic with Pat himself and he was quite clear about it then, I doubt he's changed that much.
If you look at what I have said I have been careful not to say that phase 4 of the Yo Yo Game is wrong. It is simply a fact that different clinicians teach horses to go backwards in different ways, they all work. It is up to us to decide which we want to adopt. This isn't a competition or a matter of one method being better than another. You can dismiss the comments as people promoting personal preferences if you wish, but to me this is just a discussion. I haven't promoted anything in this chat.
I will always recognise, respect and appreciate what I learnt during my time in PNH. I still use a lot of what I learnt now. The fact that I have studied wider and so use other ideas also is something that I think benefits myself and my horses. But that is my personal view and I wouldn't impose it on anyone. I have met a few people recently who aren't interested in going to see other clinicians because "I DO Parelli". They have watched videos of inspirational people like Phil Nye with me and waited and waited until they could see something to pick a hole in, almost it seems to justify why they need look no further than PNH. I think that is so sad. There is such wealth of learning out there and I think we should be encouraged to check it out, the good and the bad, and learn from them. I think that the mind, like an umbrella, is most useful when it is open :) In that respect I think it is sad that Parelli discourages this. Pat once told me "Until you've passed Level 3 you don't have the Savvy to evaluate another system". He was telling me not to go see Mark Rashid.
Keep having fun with your horses all!
 
It's fine if you are not that committed to go down that path, but it's not really fair to put down something just because you don't understand it.

Sorry, that's making a rather big assumption isn't it? So you're saying that if you aren't one of the dedicated 'chosen few' then you can't possibly be qualified to comment or hold an opinion?:D

others do so merely to promote their own personal preference of NH training.

Eh? Nobody has done that. I too try to keep an open mind and try to learn about as many different trainers and methods as I can, and I find that most have more in common than otherwise. What I don't like and always attempt to avoid is forcefulness or domination in training because that's not the way I aspire to deal with my horse. The yo yo game may only be a part of the foundation of the PNH method but it's an important one and symptomatic of the approach in general. And a method that is set down (and applied according to the letter as Crystal Fire points out) which actively discourages its followers from looking at or trying anything else is worthy of a little askance at the very least in my book.
 
How can *we* in all conscience bleat on to people about listening to your horse, understanding why they do things, trying a different method if they don't understand, not using force etc etc etc and then talk about Phase 4 as if it's acceptable! I cannot see how hitting the horse on the head or around the face with anything can ever be seen as an acceptable training method.

BayMare

Just curious about how much this is caused by the human interpretation of phase 4, where "phase 4" from another horse is "ok" ?? (Or do you not consider that to be ok ?? don't want to make an assumption....)

i.e. the "bad" phase 4 is when we make it a predator phase 4... ??

I watched a highland gelding (6) chase a highland filly yearling off her food bucket the other evening. he definately started with a lower phase and escalated. She's just arrived so is new to him and the other horses. There is a clear kick mark on her shoulder (no broken skin) where one of the horses appears to have used "phase 4" pressure on her. She learns quick, and there is only this one mark.

Same with my mare in Parelli - like Tootsie says with her horse, my horse has VERY light responses. She probably does have a phase 4 as Pat describes, but always puts her "try" in WAY before you get there ! She is mortified if you have to escalate. (Ok thats a human term, but thats what it looks like !).
 
It is a human interpretation I'm sure - just because horses are prepared to use overwhelming force on each other at times doesn't mean it's justified in our training with them. We are supposed to be the rational beings in the partnership, saying that because horses are prepared to use force and violence in their relations it's fine for us too is a very slippery road IMHO.
 
Yann said:
Sorry, that's making a rather big assumption isn't it? So you're saying that if you aren't one of the dedicated 'chosen few' then you can't possibly be qualified to comment or hold an opinion?:D

Nope, that's not what I said at all. :rolleyes:

Crystal Fires understanding of teachers all teaching in exactly the same way is interesting, but it has not been my experience at all with PNH. I have seen many instructors vary, according to the needs of the horse's sensitivity.

As an example I have seen, a horse would not yield at phase 4 on a back up or backwards part of a yo yo, so rythmic pressure was applied to make the phase 4 effective. It's not cruel and it's not crossing lines of being too harsh, it's just making it effective.

I've seen other instructors that have not had to demonstrate that, because the horse had yielded before the student reached phase 4.
 
newrider.com