Following on from the Sharon Hunt thread .... training method differences?

  • Thread starter Thread starter CER1389
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Similarly AFAIK...



You haven't ridden a good selection of sharp horses have you :) there isn't always something you can do to prevent a situation .. :rolleyes: You sometimes can only perform damage limitation .. and in certain circs you simply have to deal with it "inappropriately" .. and sometimes you just don't achieve what you set out to achieve..

Obv dealing with something in such a way as to improve is everyone's objective but you know.. it's not always possible..

Regardless of whether or not I have ridden many sharp horses, which seems irrelevant to me :rolleyes: but unwanted behaviour can be minimised and made less likely. If a rider's actions make the behaviour less common, less likely, or less dramatic, then they have succeeded in taking those actions. :) You're right though, in that all you can do it try. There's no guarentee any method will work.

PS - What does AFAIK mean?

x
 
horses only do things for a reason no matter how quirky they maybe. that horse didnt want to do it for a reason. if he was this amazinly talented horse that loved his job then why did he choose miss is chance and get hit in the process???
 
Regardless of whether or not I have ridden many sharp horses, which seems irrelevant to me :rolleyes:
x

It makes all the difference IMO.. :) I wish you were nearer .. I have just the horse for you to prove your theories on.. (not Stanners.. he is faar to uncomplicated) .. If I could turn back time - TheG would have also been a great learning (and levelling) experience for you.. :)

AFAIK - As Far As I Know..
 
if he was this amazinly talented horse that loved his job then why did he choose miss is chance and get hit in the process???

By your reckoning horses don't understand things like chance.. :) .. he is an exceptionally talented horse.. or perhaps the Olympic selectors are all wrong ?

Anyway.. I digress.. horses don't just not do things because something for the 3 reasons you specify.. sometimes it's other factors that cause odd displays of behaviour.. nervous excitement, laziness and canniness.. some ring crafty horses will display behaviour at events that they would never show at home because they KNOW that they don't have to do something..

I have no idea what was going on in that horses' head.. do any of us ? I do think that at that level saddle fit, health(pain?) and will would have been carefully addressed..

Horses have been retired from the sport for less - I certainly wouldn't take a horse that I didn't think had his heart in it around a track like Badminton - nobody wants to die! The amount of riders that retired their horses half way (not even) around because of 1 refusal was testement to the fact that unwilling horses and big fences are a recipe for disaster .. best to retire..
 
It makes all the difference IMO.. :) I wish you were nearer .. I have just the horse for you to prove your theories on.. (not Stanners.. he is faar to uncomplicated) .. If I could turn back time - TheG would have also been a great learning (and levelling) experience for you.. :)

... Thus assuming a lot about me. I ride horses, that's good enough. I shouldn't have to value or justify my opinions based on how many difficult horses I have ridden. I don't expect you to, I just accept that this is what you believe and you have good reason to believe those things. Proving oneself is quite unnecessary, and impossible. :)

AFAIK - As Far As I Know..

Thanks :o I have a feeling that I really ought to know that, being a young adult and all ... ;)

x
 
Last edited:
It makes all the difference IMO.. :) I wish you were nearer .. I have just the horse for you to prove your theories on.. (not Stanners.. he is faar to uncomplicated) .. If I could turn back time - TheG would have also been a great learning (and levelling) experience for you.. :)

AFAIK - As Far As I Know..

I completly agree with you here...... some horses really ARE just quirky!

I've watched my boss/trainer with one horse ..... she just cannot do anything but hack and pop him over the odd jump at home, he just turns himself inside out.

Get him to an event he'll do dressage and jump a double clear and is EXTREAMLY talented ..... but due to the fact he cannot be trained at home he cannot progress and it's just not worth her while and he's being sold as a hunt horse after spending as season as a whipper in.

It's certainly not her training methods she has a yard full of the most wonderfully behaved and well mannored horses.

I infact now have her ex team horse, which she produced from a 3yr old when she was a young teenager and he wasn't the easiest when younger but is a complete gentleman.

Re.... hobby vs comp horses ....... well I have both now I have a retired top comp horse and I as CER and myself were discussing last night myself and others must remember his past.... he's not used to being handled and delt with like a 'hobby horse' ........ you stop for a chat during schooling...... to him he thinks he's finished for example.
 
... I just accept that this is what you believe and you have good reason to believe those things.
x

I'm curious to know what reasons/experience you have to believe what you do ? :)

I believe that you have to have walked a mile in someone's shoes to be able to comment on some issues.. I also believe through experience that theory and practice are sometimes miles apart..

I don't want you to prove yourself to be competant .. but would like to give you the chance to find out where the theories and realities part ways! It's all very easy to ride civilised horses, read about the ideal ways to deal with situations and pontificate about how things should be done.. but when you are sitting on 600kgs of lightening fast muscle that isn't giving you the time to do anything but "cope" it is very different..

I always want to test my theories :) .. how do I know if what I am thinking of is any good unless I do :)
 
Geoff Luckett is a SJer :) .. Weaving and cribbing isn't a ridden quirk that can mean it can be hugely difficult to get a horse to do a basic dressage test let alone go cross country safely!

Yeah i thought so, it was someone who i've heard of with a name similar anyway lol.

And when i was refering to the vices i ment he's going to have developed this for a reason in his past.
 
OK i haven't read the whole text because i've come home after doing exams and i'm too pooped to trawl though four pages :o:o - so i'll just say as i see. I think there is a difference TBH, in the event of something going wrong anyway, because there's so much more riding on professional riders performing well. If a horse has a paddy at a crisp packet out hacking, then yes there are elements of risk etc but at the end of the day if you can't get them to walk past the crisp packet or they tank for a hundred yards or so it isn't a huge problem usually, unless you have an accident on the way then you're usually both just a bit hot and bothered and you know that perhaps you need to to some desentitising work with crisp packets soon ;), but if you're at a major competition and your horse has a paddy on a XC course at a small child rustling a crisp packet as you come to a fence for example, and the horse puts in a stop and flat refuses to co operate further, then that could possibly be a lot of money, maybe Olympic selection, sponsorship deals and hours upon hours of training down the toilet, so it's more likely that a pro rider under the circumstances and that amount of pressure will just feel forced to 'get nasty' you could say. Which is one of the reasons i don't want to compete to a significant level ;). I would hate to feel so under pressure and have that much riding on a round that i felt i had to get nasty with a horse, because IMO it isn't fair on the horse. I know that it's so much down the drain if it all goes hideously wrong, but IMO it wouldn't be justification in my eyes because i'm too fluffy (there, i said the f word :p) - i know to most other people, all of those things will be more important than giving your horse a good few smacks and getting tough, but sorry i'm just too fluffy which is why i wouldn't want to compete at the top - as a leisure rider i wouldn't 'get nasty' with a horse unless i was quite literally at serious risk of being killed by a horse's actions (in which case i believe it would be a case of blind instinct taking over) and i wouldn't want to risk sacrificing my personal principles because of pressure. Just my view on it :).
 
Last edited:
which seems irrelevant to me

Me too. Our opinions are shaped by our personalities, experiences and inclinations. Who is to judge which is more valid? Somebody may have more experience of something than someone else, but it doesn't automatically make them right.
 
I'm curious to know what reasons/experience you have to believe what you do ? :)

I believe that you have to have walked a mile in someone's shoes to be able to comment on some issues.. I also believe through experience that theory and practice are sometimes miles apart..

I don't want you to prove yourself to be competant .. but would like to give you the chance to find out where the theories and realities part ways! It's all very easy to ride civilised horses, read about the ideal ways to deal with situations and pontificate about how things should be done.. but when you are sitting on 600kgs of lightening fast muscle that isn't giving you the time to do anything but "cope" it is very different..

I always want to test my theories :) .. how do I know if what I am thinking of is any good unless I do :)

I was initially taught more "traditional" (for want of a better word) methods and attitudes towards riding and training in general, by which I felt unsatisfied, incomplete and, to a degree, ineffective. Right from the start these methods and attitudes went against my instincts and so I began to broaden my horsey 'education' in various ways. I can honestly say that I have never ridden a 'well behaved' (or rather, non-quirky) horse as my opportunities have only involved rides that people didn't want, on which these "traditional" had been tried and failed on. I hasten to add that these specific "traditional" methods were particularly unfair, inconsiderate and corrupted the horses' wellbeing in many ways. Through looking in a fair amount of depth into & using other methods, attitudes, practitioners, trainers and other resources, I found pathways that satisfied me and complied with my instincts, took a more horse-centric rather than human-centric approach :) And so here I am. I wouldn't believe in, or use, ways that didn't work in some shape or form.
While I have not had the fortune to have been brought up around horses, many far older, wiser and experienced than I share similar opinions and perspectives, and so I see our views as being equally valid and helpful to find some sort of middle-point or equilibrium.

:)

x
 
Last edited:
Somebody may have more experience of something than someone else, but it doesn't automatically make them right.

Doesn't make them right.. but even scientists want the chance to prove their theories! Even better if they are proved right!

And quite frankly.. I think the type of riding a person does is hugely relevant.. I wouldn't expect someone who was the day to day driver of a family saloon to be a relevant source of information on how to handle a F1 car on a track..
 
Doesn't make them right.. but even scientists want the chance to prove their theories! Even better if they are proved right!

And quite frankly.. I think the type of riding a person does is hugely relevant.. I wouldn't expect someone who was the day to day driver of a family saloon to be a relevant source of information on how to handle a F1 car on a track..

Funnily enough used that analogy myself when talking about the differences with my mothership.
 
I was initially taught more "traditional" (for want of a better word) methods and attitudes towards riding and training in general, by which I felt unsatisfied, incomplete and, to a degree, ineffective. Right from the start these methods and attitudes went against my instincts and so I began to broaden my horsey 'education' in various ways. I can honestly say that I have never ridden a 'well behaved' (or rather, non-quirky) horse as my opportunities have only involved rides that people didn't want, on which these "traditional" had been tried and failed on. I hasten to add that these specific "traditional" methods were particularly unfair, inconsiderate and corrupted the horses' wellbeing in many ways. Through looking in a fair amount of depth into & using other methods, attitudes, practitioners, trainers and other resources, I found pathways that satisfied me and complied with my instincts, took a more horse-centric rather than human-centric approach :) And so here I am. I wouldn't believe in, or use, ways that didn't work in some wshape or form.

:)

x

That's very commendable.. but no idea about it's relevance to the above comments between us really.. :)

I don't care what methods people use tbh - it's not about the methods.. it's about experience .. new methods and approaches are what improves I have nothing against that!
 
I wouldn't expect someone who was the day to day driver of a family saloon to be a relevant source of information on how to handle a F1 car on a track..

In which case who on this thread is actually qualified to comment? There aren't any olympic riders contributing as far as I'm aware :D
 
Doesn't make them right.. but even scientists want the chance to prove their theories! Even better if they are proved right!

And quite frankly.. I think the type of riding a person does is hugely relevant.. I wouldn't expect someone who was the day to day driver of a family saloon to be a relevant source of information on how to handle a F1 car on a track..

Echo, agree, wotshesaid, repeat ad infinitum :)
 
In which case who on this thread is actually qualified to comment? There aren't any olympic riders contributing as far as I'm aware :D

No need to take it that far.. :rolleyes: it was an analogy.. :rolleyes:

I would consider DavidH, SFS and eml serious contenders to give advice.. DavidH in particular has been round big tracks and is out there doing it currently. Charlotte & Jill events at a decent level as does Rachel Event. All people I would consider qualified to comment.

As we don't have any Olympic riders on NR I would say - take advice from the most experienced that you do have! (or go and ask on HHO ;) )
 
No need to take it that far.. :rolleyes: it was an analogy.. :rolleyes:

I would consider DavidH, SFS and eml serious contenders to give advice.. DavidH in particular has been round big tracks and is out there doing it currently. Charlotte & Jill events at a decent level as does Rachel Event. All people I would consider qualified to comment.

As we don't have any Olympic riders on NR I would say - take advice from the most experienced that you do have! (or go and ask on HHO ;) )

Are we not all perfectly qualified to comment, since we all ride horses and that is all one needs to know. That in itself makes one perfectly entitled to perfectly right and valid comments. :D

x
 
In which case who on this thread is actually qualified to comment? There aren't any olympic riders contributing as far as I'm aware :D

Not 'bigging' myself up here in the SLIGHTEST!! :o

But as above stated I have been given an ex advanced horse he was shortlisted for athens (sadly didn't get to go due to injury). I've also ridden out my boss' 4* horse

I can tell you there is a GREAT difference, the subtlety I have to use within my riding is great.

Eg.... first time I asked canter trot transition i sat mearly half halted ....... and we HAD halted .......and I was up his neck ........... :o feeling and looking stupid :D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
newrider.com