Following on from the Sharon Hunt thread .... training method differences?

  • Thread starter Thread starter CER1389
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
That's very commendable.. but no idea about it's relevance to the above comments between us really.. :)

I don't care what methods people use tbh - it's not about the methods.. it's about experience .. new methods and approaches are what improves I have nothing against that!

I thought the whole point of the thread was about the methods :o. I think what puzzles was saying was how she doesn't believe there needs to be a difference as she's ridden plenty of difficult horses who have responded very well to less traditional methods and without the less 'fluffy' (for want of a better word) methods like the one that sparked this thread :). Could be totally wrong but that's just how i read it :).
 
Last edited:
Not 'bigging' myself up here in the SLIGHTEST!! :o

But as above stated I have been given an ex advanced horse he was shortlisted for athens (sadly didn't get to go due to injury). I've also ridden out my boss' 4* horse

I can tell you there is a GREAT difference, the subtlety I have to use within my riding is great.

Eg.... first time I asked canter trot transition i sat mearly half halted ....... and we HAD halted .......and I was up his neck ........... :o feeling and looking stupid :D

... I don't really see the relevance of this to the quirkiness of horses ridden in competition. :o

x
 
Last edited:
Are we not all perfectly qualified to comment, since we all ride horses and that is all one needs to know. That in itself makes one perfectly entitled to perfectly right and valid comments. :D

x


Everyone can comment yes.. to be considered qualified to comment on how a situation, like as in question, is handled - no.

I drive a small Peugeot every single day.. I am not qualified to judge Lewis Hamiltons performance.. I might have an opinion on his performance but I'm in no way qualified to make weighty points about it :)
 
... I don't really see the relevance of this to the quirkiness of horses ridden in competition. :o

x

If the horse is as C&J described at home.. can you imagine the adrenalised competition version ? And that would appear to be a not quirky horse..
 
Everyone can comment yes.. to be considered qualified to comment on how a situation, like as in question, is handled - no.

I drive a small Peugeot every single day.. I am not qualified to judge Lewis Hamiltons performance.. I might have an opinion on his performance but I'm in no way qualified to make weighty points about it :)

Forgetting cars for a moment, what's your experience?
 
Why ever not? You can only make comments on what you know, and as you say, you may well know a thing or two about Lewis Hamilton's performance ... which brings us to this thread ... I assume that most people on here have, at some point in their lives, ridden a 'quirky' horse (which in itself is, of course, a subjective judgement and varies in degrees of severity). A quirky horse is a quirky horse, regardless of what level it may be competed at, or how many quirky horses it's rider has ridden in the past. :) So in that sense, we are all on the same level. Is this a democracy in which we are living? ;)

x
 
If the horse is as C&J described at home.. can you imagine the adrenalised competition version ? And that would appear to be a not quirky horse..

A friend has lovely footage from the weekend of my mum TRYING (trying being the opterative word in the sentance here!!) to do an elementary test on him at the weekend

I think was quite an achievement getting a 2 in an elementary on an advanced horse ........ who thought flying changes and throwing paddys where wholey exceptable in an otherwise boring test!!! :D

Editted to add : this horse knows it's job (gettings in 30s in dressage at high level) but hadn't done a test on grass in sometime and just 'thought' he knew what was going on ........
 
Last edited:
Enough.. :) Anyone who actually knows me (Rips, Lacetti, Welsh_Girl, Toffee Monster) will know vouch for me..

Oooh.. I forgot Wibble.. :)
 
Last edited:
Why ever not? You can only make comments on what you know, and as you say, you may well know a thing or two about Lewis Hamilton's performance ... which brings us to this thread ... I assume that most people on here have, at some point in their lives, ridden a 'quirky' horse (which in itself is, of course, a subjective judgement and varies in degrees of severity). A quirky horse is a quirky horse, regardless of what level it may be competed at, or how many quirky horses it's rider has ridden in the past. :) So in that sense, we are all on the same level. Is this a democracy in which we are living? ;)

x

I don't know a thing about racing cars.. (that' KC's specialist subject ;)) I did say I might comment about his performance but tbh my comments would be worth feck all! :D

Everyone can comment on anything - I don't recall ever saying anything to the contrary.. I simply said it was relevant to have ridden horses of a similar type..

Personally I would never consider myself to be of the same or even approaching a similar level of Sharon Hunt, DavidH etc in any way ..
 
If I had a tenth of the talent and courage of anyone riding at 4* then I would feel fit to comment.

I really don't think this thread is going anywhere useful and is becoming rather a dispute between two or three parties so I am closing it now.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
newrider.com