Following on from the Sharon Hunt thread .... training method differences?

  • Thread starter Thread starter CER1389
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
That's a rather sweeping statement?
.

Like yours :) .. I can't find the thread sadly :(

Not ALL police horses can ALWAYS cope with their situation (hence the horse in the referred-to thread getting a smacking when it stepped backwards away from a rowdy crowd) like ALL competition horses don't ALWAYS cope with what they are faced with..

They are ANIMALS not machines. Apart from your horses Yann and Chilli, who are clearly total paragons that never err from their training in any situation.
 
..

They are ANIMALS not machines. Apart from your horses Yann and Chilli, who are clearly total paragons that never err from their training in any situation.

Whooooooo never said that, and your right they are not machines and can never be 100% but training in what ever form it takes is responsible for increasing the percentage.

That imo is really trust in the rider which is gained through training that increases the percentage
 
Last edited:
Apart from your horses Yann and Chilli, who are clearly total paragons that never err from their training in any situation.

Why do you feel the need to descend into sarcasm? That sort of comment is exactly why threads like these end up getting locked.
 
Why do you feel the need to descend into sarcasm? That sort of comment is exactly why threads like these end up getting locked.

No sarcasm Yann.. if you read it that way then I apologise for the tone that you may have felt was aimed at you ..

From your posts it would appear from my POV (I neither know you or your horses) that once you have trained your horse to do something and trust you - it would never do any different no matter what the external circumstances .. That, to me makes you an exceptional trainer.. and Yogi Breisner needs the sack!
 
The comparison to police horses is a complete red herring.
Police horses undergo a very strict selection process before they ever get in to training. One of the major criteria is temprament. Once in training not all will go on to be active police horses. If all issues could be delt with by training then 100% would go in to active service
Comp horses are also slected for certain traits but these are almost completely the opposite to the requirements of police horses. I seriously doubt you would get a police horse to jump around badminton no matter how much you trained it. Likewise, I seriously doubt any badminton horse could do what is required of a police horse no matter what its training.
 
From your posts it would appear from my POV (I neither know you or your horses) that once you have trained your horse to do something and trust you - it would never do any different no matter what the external circumstances .. That, to me makes you an exceptional trainer.. and Yogi Breisner needs the sack!

It'd be possible to construe that reply as sarcasm too if I was so inclined ;) :D

Nowhere have I suggested what you are saying is the case. My assertion was that you can make problems less likely by preparing as thoroughly as possible for them. The more water a horse has jumped into, surrounded by quads and photographers, the more likely it is that it will be fine with it next time. So long as the experience was a relatively positive one of course.

That principle applies whether you're Pippa going into the water at Burghley or Rio crossing the River Moss.
 
Whooooooo never said that, and your right they are not machines and can never be 100% but training in what ever form it takes is responsible for increasing the percentage.

That imo is really trust in the rider which is gained through training that increases the percentage

I agree with you about the trust vs increase in percentage.. but it's no guarantee.. :)

Apologies.. I did totally misread your comment! You did never say that your horse was infallible!! Ooops.. :o I'm very sorry.
 
No sarcasm Yann.. if you read it that way then I apologise for the tone that you may have felt was aimed at you ..

From your posts it would appear from my POV (I neither know you or your horses) that once you have trained your horse to do something and trust you - it would never do any different no matter what the external circumstances .. That, to me makes you an exceptional trainer.. and Yogi Breisner needs the sack!

Hmm, I took it to mean that when problems arise, she deals with them differently and places emphasis on prevention to minimise extreme 'cure' methods. I may be wrong ... :o

x
 
It'd be possible to construe that reply as sarcasm too if I was so inclined ;) :D

Nowhere have I suggested what you are saying is the case. My assertion was that you can make problems less likely by preparing as thoroughly as possible for them. The more water a horse has jumped into, surrounded by quads and photographers, the more likely it is that it will be fine with it next time. So long as the experience was a relatively positive one of course.

That principle applies whether you're Pippa going into the water at Burghley or Rio crossing the River Moss.

We'll have to agree to disagree so.. :)

I simplfy it like this - I ride my sane young horse on the same stretch of road all the time.. and have done for a year - he's been trained to walk past the scary plastic, barking dogs and noisy dairy without batting an eyelid.. one day the barking dog had had a haircut and was shorthaired.. Stan had done a 180 and legged it before I knew what was happening.. he saw the same dog the day before.. slight difference to the situation can cause all manner of behaviour. There is no guarantee..

Having been out there and jumped around big tracks on an advanced horse.. I feel absolutely sure that no matter how many times you've had a positive experience all it sometimes takes is a dodgy shadow thrown on a fence to make it all go wrong..

IMO no amount of preparation can prepare you for you or your horse for seeing something you have seen a hundred times in a different way.. just at that moment .. on that day... it's the unknown variable that can't be prepared for that makes it all so difficult (and fun!).. otherwise we'd all be jumping clear with never a fault between us all!
 
I don't think we actually disagree ;) Chances are your horse would have been a lot worse if he'd never met a dog at all :D

You aren't going to get a horse 100% ever, it's not realistic or even desirable (buy a moped instead!), all I'm saying is that you can often get to 95% instead of 80% :)
 
You aren't going to get a horse 100% ever, it's not realistic or even desirable (buy a moped instead!), all I'm saying is that you can often get to 95% instead of 80% :)

The horse in question that started all this has made 99 starts at events. I believe this is the 3rd time he has done this so already at 97%. Therefor not a training issue and S should be congratulated on her exemplary ability as a trainer ;)
 
The horse in question that started all this has made 99 starts at events. I believe this is the 3rd time he has done this so already at 97%. Therefor not a training issue and S should be congratulated on her exemplary ability as a trainer ;)

Well, it depends on so many things. If the 3 stops were recent then it could still be a training, or other unerlying issue and not without good reason. Whatever the reason, lack of training or preparation is a common cause/factor for problems out competing so it's only natural to look to that first.

x
 
I don't think we actually disagree ;) Chances are your horse would have been a lot worse if he'd never met a dog at all :D

But we were discussing the fact that no matter how great your training is - it can mean sod all :) Not that there was no training :)

As per this comment..

How come my happy hacking horse will go into water she's never seen before without much of a look then?


The horse in question that started all this has made 99 starts at events. I believe this is the 3rd time he has done this so already at 97%. Therefor not a training issue and S should be congratulated on her exemplary ability as a trainer ;)

:D
 
Well, it depends on so many things. If the 3 stops were recent then it could still be a training, or other unerlying issue and not without good reason. Whatever the reason, lack of training or preparation is a common cause/factor for problems out competing so it's only natural to look to that first.

x

I think that at Olympic level.. with so much at stake.. they would have looked long and hard at the reasons.. sometimes it's simply the way of that horse and nothing a human can or has done is to blame.

The horse in question has always been a difficult character.
 
Therefor not a training issue and S should be congratulated on her exemplary ability as a trainer

If it's not a training issue what is it? 'Just one of those things'?

Maybe so, but if it happens next time will it still be 'just one of those things'?
 
I think that at Olympic level.. with so much at stake.. they would have looked long and hard at the reasons.. sometimes it's simply the way of that horse and nothing a human can or has done is to blame.

The horse in question has always been a difficult character.

That may well be true. :) I suppose it's in how you deal with such an issue that causes the greatest stir, and raises the question of 'how do you ride a horse that is challenging by nature?' Many people would feel that they are 'giving in' to ride and train to suit the horse's temperament, but changing riding methods slightly, or attitude/'tactics' may be preferable to putting up a battle of wills. There is always something the rider can do/could have done to either prevent such an aversion in the horse, or deal with it appropriately to encourage a better performance next time. How did Sharon deal with the horse in question the previous 2 times?

x
 
i do not feel that profesional riders should be "allowed to get away with" or be excused for firmer treatment of horses just because it is their job.

the horse is not aware of how important the event is. he has no concept of money etc. and so to say yes the horse should be made to go because after all he is at the top level and a lot of money etc. has been spent on him and her reputation will be spoiled etc. the horse doesnt understand this.

IMO there are only three reasons why a horse may nap/refuse to go in the way Tankers Town did.

1, he is in physical pain
2, he is over challenged and really doesnt want to do the work
3, he has been allowed to get away with it in the past. this might start off from the horse feeling possibility two.

the majority of horses i see at events are desperate to get running. at worst they just stand, not showing much enthusiasm but not refusing to go.

Tankers Town is 15 (i think) maybe he just doesnt really enjoy it and so i think his feeling should be taken into consideration. i do not feel this horse feels like he wants to try his hardest even if he does start and so maybe she should think about working on other horses to replace him.

i was in the main arena when this went on. there wasnt a terrible beating but it shouldnt have happened and it didnt look good.
 
How did Sharon deal with the horse in question the previous 2 times?

x

Similarly AFAIK...

There is always something the rider can do/could have done to either prevent such an aversion in the horse, or deal with it appropriately to encourage a better performance next time.

You haven't ridden a good selection of sharp horses have you :) there isn't always something you can do to prevent a situation .. :rolleyes: You sometimes can only perform damage limitation .. and in certain circs you simply have to deal with it "inappropriately" .. and sometimes you just don't achieve what you set out to achieve..

Obv dealing with something in such a way as to improve is everyone's objective but you know.. it's not always possible..
 
the horse is not aware of how important the event is. he has no concept of money etc. and so to say yes the horse should be made to go because after all he is at the top level and a lot of money etc. has been spent on him and her reputation will be spoiled etc. the horse doesnt understand this.

No but I bet Sharon's bank manager does.. and her creditors and employees that need to be paid..

IMO there are only three reasons why a horse may nap/refuse to go in the way Tankers Town did.

1, he is in physical pain
2, he is over challenged and really doesnt want to do the work
3, he has been allowed to get away with it in the past. this might start off from the horse feeling possibility two.

You've never had a properly quirky horse have you ? :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
newrider.com