"NH" and "Traditional" Methods

Zani, their mouths are so precious, I'd like someone to see what happens and then give you some advice :) However, if you think about it, if you give with your hands every time your horse fidgets with the bit you are rewarding the fidget. Same if they lean. So you make your hands soft and you can teach them that what they are doing is right. Different trainers have slightly different ways of dealing with this, but it all tends to come back to us riders getting consistent and quite firm, but rewarding the soft feel instantly. Might be a good topic for a whole new thread. :)
 
The problem is pretty much everything attributed to an NH ethos is actually from traditional horsemanship and the reason why there should be no friction between the two camps.

Elements of horsemanship have been taken, packaged and marketed as NH, if you really think about it there is no such thing as NH other than as a collection of like minded individuals.

In traditional horsemanship you can find areas that make NH look like it cares little about the horse and uses little of it’s instinct and nature.

It’s also important I think to realise traditional is not BHS, we have ridden horses for thousands of years and the BHS has only been in existence 50,60? Years, when I bough my house it had derelict stables that predated the BHS by 150 years.

NH if you ignore the North American variety is actually much older that the BHS.

Lets not also forget that you may be qualified to teach with you BHS qualifications in the UK but they are not good enough for you to in France, does not say much for the way the French think of the quality of the BHS training at the lower levels (Unless things have changed). Traditional does not = BHS.

if you think about it, if you give with your hands every time your horse fidgets with the bit you are rewarding the fidget. Same if they lean. So you make your hands soft and you can teach them that what they are doing is right.

I think this a good example of NH taking something from traditional and not getting the whole picture, which is why you can find (If you look in the right places) better NH in traditional the NH

Light hands are maintained all the time but even lighter hands are used as the reward for doing the right thing in this context.

This is taken by many in NH as using firm/strong signal to the horse when it’s doing the wrong thing and lighter as the reward, the difference my not seem important but it always amazes me how big a difference the small things make.
 
Last edited:
Using the example of light hands. I obviously don't want to be causing my horse any pain, but how do I cope with "light" and then "even lighter" in my situation.

As said a few posts back, he is very fussy with a bit and will not so much fidget but throw his head down to the ground. At the moment what I try to do is "block" that head throw every time he does it and then release. Is that wrong? How would I do this with a light and then even lighter contact?
 
"Stroke the horse while holding the whip in the hand that is making contact with him. Then stroke him with part of the whip. Start off at the shoulder area and gradually work over his body. Little by little use more of the whip so that the horse eventually accepts being touched all over with it. Before you attempt any in-hand work he must be totally relaxed with the whip - if he isn't or is anxious you will not progress effectively".
Different tools and equipment but in my opinion, the concept is exactly the same

That's the type of statement I find in many of the outdated horsemanship ideas. "Stroke the horse while holding the whip in the hand blah, blah,". Does it mention what one should do when the horse goes nuts and stands on it's hind legs at the sight of a whip? Good horsemen provide the whole story, and the methods to deal with it. Others might not.:rolleyes:


There was a French stuntman who galloped a horse flat out along a jetty and at the end jumped over12ft into a smallish rowing boat which had left the jetty (Remember this was a stunt for a film and the boat was full of a soft landing for the horse).

It was done for a period film, it was amazing to see how he set it up and trained the horse for it over a period of weeks.

That traditional horsemanship it seems can get some pretty amazing results.

How did he train the horse for this stunt? :confused: I would love to hear some specifics on the methods and concepts used.:)

I believe that Parelli's methods with the moving trailer were pretty "natural" for a horse to understand. I suspect he wanted people to think about the concepts that needed to be understood to accomplish the task. I recently saw Dennis Reis accomplish much the same thing with a camel. It's one of those areas that I believe are being explored and refined more and more.


Keep on, keepin on

Keep on, keepin on

Jack
 
"Stroke the horse while holding the whip in the hand that is making contact with him. Then stroke him with part of the whip. Start off at the shoulder area and gradually work over his body. Little by little use more of the whip so that the horse eventually accepts being touched all over with it. Before you attempt any in-hand work he must be totally relaxed with the whip - if he isn't or is anxious you will not progress effectively".
Different tools and equipment but in my opinion, the concept is exactly the same

That's the type of statement I find in many of the outdated horsemanship ideas. "Stroke the horse while holding the whip in the hand blah, blah,". Does it mention what one should do when the horse goes nuts and stands on it's hind legs at the sight of a whip? Good horsemen provide the whole story, and the methods to deal with it. Others might not.:rolleyes:


There was a French stuntman who galloped a horse flat out along a jetty and at the end jumped over12ft into a smallish rowing boat which had left the jetty (Remember this was a stunt for a film and the boat was full of a soft landing for the horse).

It was done for a period film, it was amazing to see how he set it up and trained the horse for it over a period of weeks.

That traditional horsemanship it seems can get some pretty amazing results.

How did he train the horse for this stunt? :confused: I would love to hear some specifics on the methods and concepts used.:)

I believe that Parelli's methods with the moving trailer were pretty "natural" for a horse to understand. I suspect Parelli wanted people to think about the concepts that needed to be understood to accomplish the task. I recently saw Dennis Reis accomplish much the same thing with a camel. It's one of those areas that I believe are being explored and refined more and more. :)




Keep on, keepin on

Jack
 
I read posts on 'commonsense' and it all seems very reasonable.
From what I read there is no need for anyone to question traditional approaches. It's all very straight forward yada yada yada.

And then I go onto the yard, or to a show, or to my friend's yard who provides stabling for multi-day trail riders, or to one of several local riding schools, and I see terrible horsemanship. Horses that can't load, or be caught. Riders being encouraged to 'kick him' or 'pull his bloody teeth out'. Horses who stamp being whacked on the chest or yelled at to 'pack it in'. I've lost track of the number of times I want to tell someone that I don;t think their horse speaks English. Ridiculous attributions being made: "He knows EXACTLY what to do, he's just being a sod'. On another forum I asked the question: "can horses take the mickey - ie deliberately deceive their owners by, for example, feigning fear?" The answer was a unanimous YES from every respondent.

In 30+ years of riding lessons, I was never encouraged to view things from the horses point of view. And call me thick, but it took reading Mark Rashid's Considering the Horse to make me think 'omg, everything I do with horses is from a human-centred not a horse-centred point of view.'

I KNOW that excellent horsemanship has existed since time immemorial, but most ordinary people don't have it! What they do have, however is the BHS. It's all very well saying Trad doesn't equal BHS, but unless you are lucky enough to know someone with traditional horsemanship skills who can teach you, you are stuck with the BHS, which does NOT imo, teach horsemanship. It justb teaches how to get the job done. The stage 1 handbook has 1 page on horse psychology - one paragraph of which is wrong (the one saying stable 'vices' are caused by imitation). The manual gives more space to recipes for linseed jelly than to horse perception or herd behaviour or anything else that helps people understand the WHY of horse behaviour.

Solutions to problems are likely to be things like gadgets rather than training - eg side reins to create an 'outline', a dropped nose band to prevent bit evasion, sheer force to bridle a headshy horse.

Now before non-nh people say 'I don't do that' - the point of this post is to say that in the 'normal' world of 'normal' riders (not the horse obsessed people like us who spend their life on internet forums and at demos and reading the world's horsey literature!) the BHS is their only realistic avenue into horses, and what the BHS teaches is not the same as what I have subsequently learnt from people like Rashid or Michael Peace.

I am deeply grateful to nh (as a broad term referring to the way in which horses are viewed, not as a method) for pointing me in a different direction and I definately see a clear dividing line between nh and bhs/trad:

In my experience the BHS primary focus has been: How can I get my horse to.....???
From nh I have learnt to have as my primary focus: Why does my horse.....???
 
This is a really interesting thread and Im plsd to see there are more like minded people out there!! I do what I do... if it works great... if it doesnt i change what im doing.

Hope the following doesnt make me sound to bad!!!!:o:o

Most probably class me as traditional. Ive never looked into NH/PP or anything else. I do have an interest in understanding the basic theory behind all types of horsmanship but wouldn't practice it myself.

While working with any horse I change my aproach and depending on the horses responses.

I will shout/growl/smack, I use a treed saddle and Bits, varying from snaffles to gags. I use a whip to back up leg aids and I have used spurs. My cob goes in a chiffney is she being a cow and I will not tolerate bad manners from her, she knows better. I have bitten and kicked a horse in the past in retaliation to being bitten and kicked by said horse, Im afraid if they can do it to me they can take it back, besides its what would happen naturally?!?! I have an will continue to use some gadgets, however like all thing they have a place and must be used correctly. Side reins to give a contact and help my cob balance evenly on the lunge, not to create an outline, A chiffney which without no matter of training would not stop my single minded cob wanting to go munch that piece of grass over there when Im not feeling to swish. A gag, which when used with 2 reins can create a much happier mouthed horse rather than having to get heavy handed with a snaffle. And some horses are just palin simply happier with strong bits...it doesnt make it wrong??

On the other hand all horses I work with are "spoilt rotten" they are lavished in hugs, cuddles, treats and any other reward that suits horse and moment. I have never beating a horse and would never wish it harm, I always work towards a happy and comfortable horse and if I think either of these is in question I will not stop till I've solved the problem. It has been comment on many occasions that I am quick to reward, over the top in my praise and a big softy. I have many comment I need to give my horse to someone who can "sort it out" and I know they mean grab it by the mouth kick it in the ribs and force it to do it. This would distroy my horse who is of a particulalry nervous nature and get frightened easily. I dont understand how on earth people think by frightening her even more will give me a long term solution to any problems that may arise???

So which am I? Mean and hard? Or soft and let my horse walk all over me? Neither Id like to think:D:D

I have nothing against any other form of training and alot of people have commented what I am doing is some form of "New" horsemanship, I explain its not, its just part of that horsemanship aswell. So many of the technics flow from one to another but are just practiced differently.

Im afraid however I have come across far to many people who practice "New" horsemanship and tell me I should do it their way as its better/kinder?:eek: I find this very offensive:mad: Im afraid just as they would if I said the same to them. I do not feel any method is kinder, the stress (I don't mean bad stress) that a horse can go threw in join up is alot(please dont jump on me) and then in PP (or what I've seen) you may ASK the horse to do something but when it doesnt u put the horse into an uncomfortable position to "encourage" it. Surely then you are MAKING it as its avoiding the uncomfortable? In all "New" methods there are still methods of repremanding unwanted behaviour, there just different it doesnt mean there kinder or better??

Please correct me if Im wrong?!?!

I dont feel "new" horseman are softer. The top trainers couldnt get the results they do if the were to soft?!?! I don't feel traditional are to hard, it is easily noticable if a horse is doing something out of fear and I rarely see this is horses on a day to day basis. However there are always extremists in everything and unfortunatly it those that ruin it for the rest of us.;)

(Added)

I have taken some BHS stages and would like to continue with them, I dont agree with everything in the exams. Some of what is taught is cringe worthy and seriously needs up dating. But again its one of those "commonsense" things!!
 
Last edited:
I read posts on 'commonsense' and it all seems very reasonable.
From what I read there is no need for anyone to question traditional approaches. It's all very straight forward yada yada yada.

And then I go onto the yard, or to a show, or to my friend's yard who provides stabling for multi-day trail riders, or to one of several local riding schools, and I see terrible horsemanship. Horses that can't load, or be caught. Riders being encouraged to 'kick him' or 'pull his bloody teeth out'. Horses who stamp being whacked on the chest or yelled at to 'pack it in'. I've lost track of the number of times I want to tell someone that I don;t think their horse speaks English. Ridiculous attributions being made: "He knows EXACTLY what to do, he's just being a sod'. On another forum I asked the question: "can horses take the mickey - ie deliberately deceive their owners by, for example, feigning fear?" The answer was a unanimous YES from every respondent.

In 30+ years of riding lessons, I was never encouraged to view things from the horses point of view. And call me thick, but it took reading Mark Rashid's Considering the Horse to make me think 'omg, everything I do with horses is from a human-centred not a horse-centred point of view.'

I KNOW that excellent horsemanship has existed since time immemorial, but most ordinary people don't have it! What they do have, however is the BHS. It's all very well saying Trad doesn't equal BHS, but unless you are lucky enough to know someone with traditional horsemanship skills who can teach you, you are stuck with the BHS, which does NOT imo, teach horsemanship. It justb teaches how to get the job done. The stage 1 handbook has 1 page on horse psychology - one paragraph of which is wrong (the one saying stable 'vices' are caused by imitation). The manual gives more space to recipes for linseed jelly than to horse perception or herd behaviour or anything else that helps people understand the WHY of horse behaviour.

Solutions to problems are likely to be things like gadgets rather than training - eg side reins to create an 'outline', a dropped nose band to prevent bit evasion, sheer force to bridle a headshy horse.

Now before non-nh people say 'I don't do that' - the point of this post is to say that in the 'normal' world of 'normal' riders (not the horse obsessed people like us who spend their life on internet forums and at demos and reading the world's horsey literature!) the BHS is their only realistic avenue into horses, and what the BHS teaches is not the same as what I have subsequently learnt from people like Rashid or Michael Peace.

I am deeply grateful to nh (as a broad term referring to the way in which horses are viewed, not as a method) for pointing me in a different direction and I definately see a clear dividing line between nh and bhs/trad:

In my experience the BHS primary focus has been: How can I get my horse to.....???
From nh I have learnt to have as my primary focus: Why does my horse.....???

Great post! :) I do believe that the majority of people on this forum do have their horses best interests at heart and so quite rightly defend the "traditional" methods as they would never display the behaviours or use the methods you have described above.

I think the key point for me in your post is looking at things from the horses point of view, which is understanding, and for me that is where some advice from "NH" orientated people really opened my eyes and made me look at my horse in a different way to try and understand him better.

I think I was at a point where I knew what I couldn't do with him (ie take a friend on the yards advice and get a "decent" rider on him who would give him a "damn good crack" if he was naughty - I knew that wouldn't work for him). But at the opposite end of the scale I wasn't sure what I should do! :confused:

I think the best thing about some of the things I have discovered is that I know my horse so much better and what makes him tick, not by following any prescribed methods, but just by spending time and trying different things.

He is not an outwardly spooky horse, but I can tell if something is worrying him by that slight tense of his muscles, or the quickening of his breath on my hand, and I can deal with it and reassure from there before it becomes an issue.

Damn I can waffle when I try hard! :o
 
Great Post too Madaz Maddy! :) You are one of those great "common sense" people that we all aspire to be!


I looked into NH methods because I wasn't sure where else to go and the only other voice talking to me was the "give it a crack" woman.

I have a few issues with the join up process, for me horse at any rate. He was very scared and wary of human contact when I got him but we have a fantastic bond now. He is well mannered, attentive and a very quickly learner, and he loves to be given little tasks to do, because the he gets praise and he just goes overboard on it! :) I have had to rein in my use of the phrase "good boy" though as when we lunge he takes it as a signal to come straight in and get his ears scratched :o. I don't think doing the whole join up process with him would bring any benefits, though I could see the benefits of doing it with a new horse perhaps, who was balshy and dominant.
 
I deliberately tried to refrain from going into any detail about "soft hands" etc because I think it's too open to misinterpretation unless accompanied by some video, or hands-on help. Most people interpret being soft with their hands as a lack of contact, but it's better felt than trying to teach by writing. So when they let their hands go soft they do in fact release in the wrong place. So Chill, I think you'd find that on the ground, my interpretation of how the hands should be used would be the same as yours. As is often the case. :)
 
That's the type of statement I find in many of the outdated horsemanship ideas. "Stroke the horse while holding the whip in the hand blah, blah,". Does it mention what one should do when the horse goes nuts and stands on it's hind legs at the sight of a whip? Good horsemen provide the whole story, and the methods to deal with it. Others might not.:rolleyes:

In all fairness Jack, the book that snippet was taken from only gives the very basic methods of groundwork training..both NH and traditional. It's just a taster to give the reader an idea of the different methods available....it's not intended to be read as a training manual.;)
 
I'd be interested in how people would see the following scenarios:

I have a young horse on loan. I come at things from an nh perspective, but the horse's owner also owns the rs where he lives, and is a BHSI.

I took him on as a 3yo in November 08 and we have had various issues to resolve along the way. With each new issue, the differences in approach became clearer: I'm not saying which is 'right' or 'wrong' but they ARE different...

1) He was bargy and difficult to handle: YO solution: wrap rope around head to provide poll pressure. My solution: groundwork - teach him to respect my personal space and to lead on a loose lead rope.

2) He was aggressive around food: YP solution: put his feed in his stable before he goes in, so he can't chase me out. My solution: when he tried to drive me away from a field lick I stood my ground and drove him away instead with a lead rope and very aggressive body language. Kept him back away from me so he was circling me. When he backed down I relaxed my posture, then invited him in. He did not make any effort to eat until I let him. Since then we have had no food issues. I have continued working on aggresion around food by making him back away from me if I approach with food, grooming him while he's feeding and basically doing what I please with his food.

3) Head shy when bridling. YO solution: 'he's taking the **** - hold nose and bridle in right hand, hold on HARD to prevent him lifting his head, and open mouth with other hand. My solution: clicker and pressure/release. Her approach worked a lot quicker! She could get him tacked up in 45 seconds flat. Still takes me a while - but my aim is for him to drop his head for the bridle.

4) Getting him working correctly. YO solution: lunging in side reins. My solution, hind/fore quarter yields on the ground, pole work, transitions, circles, work at liberty to free him up and no lunging at all. He's now going quite well in both walk and trot.

5) Not standing for mounting: YO solution: get someone to hold him , or get on when he;s stuck in a corner. My approach: teach him to stand.

I totally respect this woman's skill. And she loves her horses and treats them very well. She's a former olympic showjumper. But we do things VERY differently.... It simply isn't true to say that there are no differences ime.
 
I'd be interested in how people would see the following scenarios:

I have a young horse on loan. I come at things from an nh perspective, but the horse's owner also owns the rs where he lives, and is a BHSI.

I took him on as a 3yo in November 08 and we have had various issues to resolve along the way. With each new issue, the differences in approach became clearer: I'm not saying which is 'right' or 'wrong' but they ARE different...

1) He was bargy and difficult to handle: YO solution: wrap rope around head to provide poll pressure. My solution: groundwork - teach him to respect my personal space and to lead on a loose lead rope.

2) He was aggressive around food: YP solution: put his feed in his stable before he goes in, so he can't chase me out. My solution: when he tried to drive me away from a field lick I stood my ground and drove him away instead with a lead rope and very aggressive body language. Kept him back away from me so he was circling me. When he backed down I relaxed my posture, then invited him in. He did not make any effort to eat until I let him. Since then we have had no food issues. I have continued working on aggresion around food by making him back away from me if I approach with food, grooming him while he's feeding and basically doing what I please with his food.

3) Head shy when bridling. YO solution: 'he's taking the **** - hold nose and bridle in right hand, hold on HARD to prevent him lifting his head, and open mouth with other hand. My solution: clicker and pressure/release. Her approach worked a lot quicker! She could get him tacked up in 45 seconds flat. Still takes me a while - but my aim is for him to drop his head for the bridle.

4) Getting him working correctly. YO solution: lunging in side reins. My solution, hind/fore quarter yields on the ground, pole work, transitions, circles, work at liberty to free him up and no lunging at all. He's now going quite well in both walk and trot.

5) Not standing for mounting: YO solution: get someone to hold him , or get on when he;s stuck in a corner. My approach: teach him to stand.

I totally respect this woman's skill. And she loves her horses and treats them very well. She's a former olympic showjumper. But we do things VERY differently.... It simply isn't true to say that there are no differences ime.

I don't think you are comparing like for like, on the whole you are attempting to resolve what you see as issues while she is just working round them.

I'll respond to other comments later as i find them interesting :)
 
i don't think you are comparing like for like, on the whole you are attempting to resolve what you see as issues while she is just working round them.

I'll respond to other comments later as i find them interesting :)

EXACTLY!!!!!!! That;s what I am perceiving as the main difference!
 
EXACTLY!!!!!!! That;s what I am perceiving as the main difference!

Yes but it could be argued that it is a difference only between two peoples approaches and not the methods that they use, ie another BHS or traditional minded person could well have other options that they would use to resolve the issue rather than get around it. :)

Sometimes I think it's as much a difference between peoples personalities as it is the method used. :)
 
great posts Krissie....

re your 'comparison' one - I was BHS taught for far too long!!! "get the job done" / "the horse needs to show you respect"/- very direct line approach.

Sure, I used what I'd been taught for 20 odd years. No body ever suggested to think about the horses' feelings! And to be fair, I've had alot of horses and ones to train/break etc. None ever gave me any real probs with the approach I'd been taught - until the fella I have now. He retaliates, BIG style.
I battled on for 6 months on a seriously losing battle (never mind will to live!)

I turned to NH cos I'd nothing left in my 'armoury'. Bingo. I have learnt so much more. Why my horse does X etc etc and most importantly how to read him properly and understand him. He's not, underneath, a naughty, aggressive hooligan. He is a sensitive, unconfident (was) soul. I needed to learn how to help him not force him.

Like others' have pointed out, under BHS/traditional etc you are not directed to look at things from the horses' point of view. I now think that is sad.

I never thought I'd be "converted" but I look back on so many situations and regret I didnt know what I know now so I could have handled them differently - with more empathy - and probably got a better, longer lasting result with a happier horse.
 
Yes but it could be argued that it is a difference only between two peoples approaches and not the methods that they use

Fair point, but I've been in the BHS world for long enough to know that the 'get the job done' approach is far from unusual. While the 'why is this happening, and how can I sort it out' approach is not really taught. At least not to me. I have another friend who is a BHSAI. I approach her for advice at times. Most recently when my colt was planting his feet on his way to the field. Her immediate response was to tell me to tie a lunge line round his back end. NOT to ask me any questions that might acertain WHY he has started planting feet. It just didn't seem to occur to her to wonder why. Or to regard the WHY question as relevant.
 
newrider.com