"NH" and "Traditional" Methods

...Sometimes a horseman like Parelli may be trying to teach us something when they do these seemingly outlandish demo's such as loading onto a moving trailer. Though it's not something I would try, it offers a wonderful example of one NH concept worth exploring a bit.

"How would you teach a horse to load into a moving trailer?"
(Not why, HOW?)


Keep on, keepin on

Jack

The only information I could find on the internet where links to a couple of threads discussing PP galloping a horse, bareback onto a moving trailer.

Not sure how true it is, but if that's the case.....

I don't think any horse that loads confidently onto a stationery trailer would have a problem being ridden on (infact, when I was a kid, I always loaded my cob in that way because he'd bomb off otherwise). So, I guess riding onto a moving trailer would be an extension of that procedure....with the trailer initially moving at a snails pace.

But what would be the purpose behind the principle of galloping a horse, bareback onto a moving trailer...as far as I can see, there doesn't appear to be a justifiable reason.:confused:
 
There was a French stuntman who galloped a horse flat out along a jetty and at the end jumped over12ft into a smallish rowing boat which had left the jetty (Remember this was a stunt for a film and the boat was full of a soft landing for the horse).

It was done for a period film, it was amazing to see how he set it up and trained the horse for it over a period of weeks.

That traditional horsemanship it seems can get some pretty amazing results.
 
I believe this was at the start of an old Parelli video called 'Loading your Horse the Natural way' (or something similar).
I've not seen that one, but I've got the PNH "Trouble Free Trailer Loading" DVD and it's not on that.

Now that is an excellent DVD.:)
 
Now why would you actually need to teach a horse to get into a moving trailer? Is it practicing incase it misses the bus?

This was one of the places where I lost my faith in the Parelli training. Getting horses to do tricks that are extreemly dangerous. All it would need to do it mis-step, and you potentially end up with a horse witha broken leg. Here's a pic of him using the Driving Game to make a 3 month old foal jump a piece a tree stump. Why would a foal need to be jumping this? They don't need that strain on their legs!
13170697.png
 
Interesting you use the word make rather than ask.
Its not a thing the foals are asked to do over and over again just something they are asked to do occasionally so there no worries later.Its something foals do out in the field when they play in their process of learning skills to be a horse.:)
 
This is a general post, not directed at anyone in particular.

I like to think I use whatever methods work the best for me and my ponies, I don't use only NH methods, and I don't use only traditional methods. Just because I use NH training does not mean I am paying through the nose for equipment and dvd's and packs etc, I would like to make it clear once and for all that NH does NOT only equal Parelli!

I turned to NH training as traditional methods had failed in helping me with Phantom. Not just me, but other experienced people too who had tried to work with him. However, I am always open to different approaches and will use what I feel is suitable. I very much think of my riding style as classical, I use a treeless saddle because Cassie feels more comfortable in it, and it fits Phantom when he's carrying extra weight. When he's fit again I intend to get a well fitting Saddle Company saddle for him. I use a bit with him, and I sometimes carry a schooling whip.

Just because people use some NH methods does not make them preachy, soft, idiots, or lacking in common sense. I dislike close-mindedness and fail to see where this benefits the horse. To close your mind to every single NH method or approach without reading about it/trying it/observing it is foolish. If you don't need to use it, then leave it alone, simple as that.

Personally using some NH methods has changed my life but I am still an average horsewoman who dabbles in everything! And the only different equipment I own is a rope halter and 12ft rope :)

p.s I am not liking that photo one bit :(
 
This is a goood thread, im very intreaged (sp?) :)
Could the point of parelli making the horse to go onto the moving trailer, not to catch the bus if running late ;) (made me giggle ;D) maybe to make the horse think?
I wouldnt see it to be about trailer at all, its a challenge for both rider + horse? :)
 
cant it think about normal (dare i say natural :p) stuff like grass and carrots?

im sure its not too fussed by leaping onto moving trailers unless its a bit of an adrenaline junkie ;)

i would personally see it more as a death wish, but each to their own, cant say i would risk ours leaping onto a moving wagon.

its all (expensive) circus tricks, to earn him more publicity and money.
 
I'm liking this thread too, mainly because everyone posting is accepting of the fact that there is always more than one way to achieve the same thing! :)

I, like a lot of others posting, have dabbled in some of the so called NH principles because I had a problem, and it has really helped me. Like Laura and Phantom, I didn't spend loads of money or buy any special equipment! It's worked and I think I am quite open minded about what I can try with my horse and almost instantly know whether something will work for him or not.

I can understand why people often comment on "circus tricks" when you hear the comments about loading onto a moving trailer. Yes it can be done, but why it would be done, who knows! Perhaps is just another selling point for their methods, ie if you can train a horse to jump into a moving trailer imagine what else you could train them to do!
 
I think we train horses to do a lot of wierd things, but some of them we've been training them to do for so long they no longer seem wierd. :D
Of course that's why Pat P trains his horses to do extreme things - to show that he can. It doesn't mean that all trainers of similar ilk, or the students, have any ambitions to do the same things.
 
I've heard NH-ers say it's not natural to ride with a bit or saddle. The horse should be barefoot and living out, unrugged. If you really want to nit-pick, then you could go all out and say it's not natural to be on horseback in the first place. You could say they shouldn't be ridden, stabled or fed any sort of concentrate, since, naturally, they wouldn't find that in the wild.

With regards to the PP thing, I think at one stage, he was one the right track, but not it seems alot about knocking the traditional disciplines and way of riding (Linda Parelli has said that sitting upright with your shoulders back impairs the horse's movement and riding with your heels down puts you in a vulnerable position), and selling their own goods.
 
I've heard NH-ers say it's not natural to ride with a bit or saddle. The horse should be barefoot and living out, unrugged. If you really want to nit-pick, then you could go all out and say it's not natural to be on horseback in the first place. You could say they shouldn't be ridden, stabled or fed any sort of concentrate, since, naturally, they wouldn't find that in the wild.

With regards to the PP thing, I think at one stage, he was one the right track, but not it seems alot about knocking the traditional disciplines and way of riding (Linda Parelli has said that sitting upright with your shoulders back impairs the horse's movement and riding with your heels down puts you in a vulnerable position), and selling their own goods.

I've heard these comments too about saddles and bits, but only second hand, never from an individual first hand.
 
Up until a few years ago i would have said i was very much traditional despite the fact that I had very little formal training.
Then one of my pupils made a statement that shocked me for a moment. She said....."You take a very holistic view of horses dont you"

Juno's owner also commented about the amount of time and effort I put in to making her as comfortable, relaxed, confident and happy as possible and that the riding element is a very small part of my overall approach.
I explained to her that I expect the horse to give me 100% when I compete her but with that expectation comes a responsibility to make sure she is 100% capable physically and mentally of fulfilling my requirements. Its a two way street. :D

My aim when riding and handling a horse is to be able to use as light and quiet a cue as possible (NH ethos?) but I will not have my requests questioned (Trad view point?). I want the horse to work for me willingly and will give it every chance (through training) to do so but equally it HAS to do as asked even if it is unsure, doesn't feel like it or is just being arsy.

If I dont get the response I expected I will always question whether I am asking in a way the horse can understand and will consider a different approach if any doubt before becomming insistant or upping the pressure.

So now I guess I dont follow NH or Trad. I just use DH ethos as developed over 44 years of trial and error.:eek:
 
Last edited:
Up until a few years ago i would have said i was very much traditional despite the fact that I had very little formal training.
Then one of my pupils made a statement that shocked me for a moment. She said....."You take a very holistic view of horses dont you"

Juno's owner also commented about the amount of time and effort I put in to making her as comfortable, relaxed, confident and happy as possible and that the riding element is a very small part of my overall approach.
I explained to her that I expect the horse to give me 100% when I compete her but with that expectation comes a responsibility to make sure she is 100% capable physically and mentally of fulfilling my requirements. Its a two way street. :D

My aim when riding and handling a horse is to be able to use as light and quiet a cue as possible (NH ethos?) but I will not have my requests questioned (Trad view point?). I want the horse to work for me willingly and will give it every chance (through training) to do so but equally it HAS to do as asked even if it is unsure, doesn't feel like it or is just being arsy.

If I dont get the response I expected I will always question whether I am asking in a way the horse can understand and will consider a different approach if any doubt before becomming insistant or upping the pressure.

So now I guess I dont follow NH or Trad. I just use DH ethos as developed over 44 years of trial and error.:eek:

The "Pick & Mix" approach, excellent - I am a fan of this myself, you can be guaranteed to get exactly what you want! :D
 
Then maybe some of us who are rather embroiled in NH-style training set a few myths to rest.
(I keep saying "NH-style" or "NH" because you need to realise that many trainers who use that sort of approach shun the NH label, and I'm in that camp as well now, mainly because of Parelli).
Xandos, to me rugless, bitless, shoeless has nothing to do with NH. Why? Because the foremost practioners in this school do not promote those views, and if you can't take any notice of the leaders in the training, who can you take notice of? In fact, I would go further than that, most of the high-profile trainers we are aware of in this country are positively anti-treeless saddles. You won't catch Pat P or Mark Rashid in a treeless saddle, or my friend Steve Halfpenny. They will all rug and shoe if needed. I know some here were present at a Mark Rashid clinic a couple of years back where he was visibly distressed about a horse that had been taken barefoot when it was patently a bad idea (at least in the way it had been done). Also bitless - these people promote riding bitless as a short stage in the training of horse and rider. They all believe that it is beneficial to progress to a bit when the time is right, and some will go as far as a curb bit. As said somewhere else, if your horse has been taught to yield softly and lightly to pressure from a rope halter, and their rider is ready, they will be able to use a curb bit without discomfort or distress.
Unfortunately, a host of people who are fanatical about keeping their horses in what they think is a natural way have adopted the label Natural Horsemanship. If they follow the work of the prominent trainers, they are totally out of step with the beliefs of those people, and personally I don't think they are putting the horse first. Get that clear and you'll feel much better next time someone tries to impose those views on you, ask them to convert Mr Parelli first. :D
DavidH, you say
My aim when riding and handling a horse is to be able to use as light and quiet a cue as possible (NH ethos?) but I will not have my requests questioned (Trad view point?). I want the horse to work for me willingly and will give it every chance (through training) to do so but equally it HAS to do as asked even if it is unsure, doesn't feel like it or is just being arsy.
That is 100% what all of these "NH" trainers teach. Some of their students don't have the determination and skill to carry that through. However they don't understand things like how "soft hands create heavy horses", or that if you are clear and consistent in what you ask of your horse, and prepared to back it up, your horse will then benefit from always being able to respond to the lightest aid. They may be students of NH, but they're missing some vital principles about lightness, and even safety. No pulling, "firm contact" or constant leg contact for an NH horse...
There is no mix and match here, this is about horsemanship. I think one of the limitations of Parelli is that they only deal with people who are working through their programme. Other trainers don't do that, they can deal with anyone, regardless of backgrounda and previous training. That is why the clinic I run work in half-day sessions. One half-day group will be people who have been working with that trainer for some time, so understand his principles. Anyone who has something they want to work on, or who just wants an insight into what it's all about, can work in the other session.
I'm spending a lot of time on the threads running at the moment, trying to set some misunderstandings to rest and generally help two sides to understand each other better. I'm hoping as a result of the efforts of myself and others that the people who post on this board might be able to move on and start talking about what is important - horsemanship. For me personally, it's getting rather boring that we keep running back round the same old loops every time someone tries to discuss something about their horse. I just hope that the people on this thread who have been fed such a load of cr*p by so-called NH students will feel able to believe what they are being told here, and leave the garbage at the door when they join in discussions in the future. :)
 
Last edited:
Excellent post CF :)

It is an excellent post, and is what I believe I think I have been trying to say, but not so eloquently!

Good horsemanship is good horsmanship and I really don't see why there should be a distinction, hence my asking the question in the first place, wondering why so many people see one! :)
 
:D
On another forum where I post we manage to discuss aspects of life with our horses, and our training, without getting hung up in NH/IH/BHS or whatever. We might refer to the trainer that has given us the idea, but every time someone is talking about something from an "NH" viewpoint the discussion doesn't deteriorate into "Parelli is sooo commercial" or "Why don't you NH people just get on with it". All the input is just discussed on it's own merit, each idea is viewed as a possible option. We've got very traditional people chatting away with the more NH'y sort of people on an equal footing without niggles. (In fact, if anyone starts to just dig at people and it's off-topic we delete their post and pm them - not the whole thread).
I really hope this little board can sort of grow up a bit, and progress in that sort of way, if that hope doesn't offend anyone. :)
 
Crystal Fire - When you say "light hands make heavy horses" - what do you mean by that?

Just curious, I have a youngster who is fussy with a bit, so we do have bitless option but I am trying to get him to go with a bit too. He does seem to balk at anything but the lightest contact and I have to give him his head to get him forward (ie when schooling - hacking is not a problem he is forward enough then!!!).
 
newrider.com