"NH" and "Traditional" Methods

I understand what your saying Zani, but that sort of "sell" isn't just restricted to the horse world, it can be found on most bill boards and television adverts advertising anything from pet food to cars.

It's a case of deciding if the product is suitable and right for the job... and then just ignoring all the guff that goes hand in hand with it.:)

I agree it does.

It must just be the love of horses that gets people so wound up about it all!
 
lol - I brushed Ranger with a yard broom, now does that count as traditional or NH I wonder!

It's all a nonsense really, common sense is whats needed, that's all!

Exactly.

I have to say one of the reasons i don't 'follow' NH as it were is because of the attitude of how it's promoted. Like your post a bit ago about the ad for those saddles, so what there saying is i don't care for my horse because i have tree'd saddle? Or like this about game5 - the circling game.

This game is not lunging. Do not bore you horse by asking him to do too many circles.

Why bother saying the bore bit?

This is pretty much the reason i'm so defensive and negative about anything NH (unless it's Monty Roberts!) it's not because i think what they're doing is wrong it's because of how it comes across. The way i see it it's like "if you don't do it this way your cruwl and don't care about your horse".

*That's not to say everyone who does NH is like that before you all jump on me :D*
 
the reason i 'dislike' NH is because it is sold as new and the nicer way, and anything else is old (meaning outdated) and cruel.

some (deffo not all) of the people who practise "NH" know this is BS but its the ones who preach otherwise that leave a bad taste in my mouth (either the pros who dream it up or the followers, both can be as bad)

NH is relatively new (the form its packaged as now anyway) so obviously decended from the traditional horsemen but this isnt explained, it is marketed as new and only just thought up by this guru which is simply wrong.

some of the methods i use already cos they arent new :rolleyes: and some are a complete waste of space and of no benefit to a normal horse person *unless you like circus tricks*

i wouldnt mind if it was just there and was open, but its like a special club of all these new age preachers and they go recruiting "vulnerable" people (must admit its mostly those that have come into horses late or young people who want to give their horse cuddles and call it cute (never met a cute horse :confused:)) who feel like they should spend hundreds of pounds to learn stuff thats taught for free/considerably less.
 
Now, i use my lunge whip with the loose bit strapped straight and touch Lantern all over as he has a bit of a fear of anything other than my hands touching his legs. Now does this mean i'm practicing NH, IMO no it doesn't. But in my book of "groundwork training for your horse" it under "Natural horsemanship - Pat Parelli".
That book covers quite a few different NH and non-nh trainers and their groundwork exercises. What I found interesting is that nearly all of them have the same basic concept. For example in the non-NH section Groundwork in Practice (page 138) under "Whip-Wise"

"Stroke the horse while holding the whip in the hand that is making contact with him. Then stroke him with part of the whip. Start off at the shoulder area and gradually work over his body. Little by little use more of the whip so that the horse eventually accepts being touched all over with it. Before you attempt any in-hand work he must be totally relaxed with the whip - if he isn't or is anxious you will not progress effectively".

Different tools and equipment but in my opinion, the concept is exactly the same.:)
 
I use common sense- has served me well ;)

However, if someone made me choose I would say traditional. I really cannot stand NH and the concept of it. Packaging new things up into something wonderful to make money- sickens me. All equipment very expensive- need special packs and ridiculous DVDs, do not like or agree with the various practitioners, different levels- WTF?! I abhor the whole thing to be honest and probably have used a load of NH methods because they are traditional common sense that has been repackaged into something magical to create a new bandwagon to be jumped upon.

Ultimately, as long as the horse is happy I'm sure it doesn't matter but it's all a load of piffle to me!
 
I use common sense- has served me well ;)

However, if someone made me choose I would say traditional. I really cannot stand NH and the concept of it. Packaging new things up into something wonderful to make money- sickens me. All equipment very expensive- need special packs and ridiculous DVDs, do not like or agree with the various practitioners, different levels- WTF?! I abhor the whole thing to be honest and probably have used a load of NH methods because they are traditional common sense that has been repackaged into something magical to create a new bandwagon to be jumped upon.

Ultimately, as long as the horse is happy I'm sure it doesn't matter but it's all a load of piffle to me!

I think that's what gets my goat to be honest, the packaging and hard sell of it all.
 
I do also accept though that some of the prescribed methods on offer do help a lot of people in so much as it possibly gives them a framework to work to and if it helps them and how they interact and handle their horses then it's been worth the money.

I think I just don't like to be pigeon holed into a box!
 
NH is relatively new (the form its packaged as now anyway) so obviously decended from the traditional horsemen but this isnt explained, it is marketed as new and only just thought up by this guru which is simply wrong.
Think you might be mistaken there.....even Pat Parelli admits NH is so old it's new again.;)
 
It’s kind of a non question, Traditional covers beating a horse into submission to methods that make “NH” look like it uses nothing of the horses natural instinct/behaviour and cares little for it’s welfare.

“NH” also covers a lot of variations.

If I was pushed to describe what I try to do it would be a fusion of traditional NH (Not the modern stuff) and a variation of French/Portuguese Classical.

What I actually achieve is another thing but I try.

I think if anyone is rigidly against one or the other and won't even consider it, at best they are missing out on opetunites to learn and at worst don't know what they are talking about, then again maybe they know everything already.
 
Last edited:
I was originally taught the traditional way with horses and Daisy ex-owner is a very traditional owner/rider. After I bought Daze, I had a friend who was heavily in Parelli and it sounded great. I tried the games with Daisy and she was not impressed! Being kept and worked with traditionally for the past 20-odd years means she's used to being a traditional horse. So I gave up on the Parelli stuff and now, years later, while I do agree with some of his training, I have seem things in it that I don't agree with, so I take what I can and leave the rest.

Daze's ex-owner also said she must be stabled at night and heavily rugged due to old age. I've found that keeping her more natural, without a stable, works better for her and she enoys it.

So I think it's a case of taking what you need and want from each training method, be it the various traditional training methods and/or the NH methods and do what works for you and your horse as a team. It's not a "one size fits all" thing as there is no method that works 100% for every horse. Like people, they are individuals and their training and keeping needs to be tailored to their needs.
 
the reason i 'dislike' NH is because it is sold as new and the nicer way, and anything else is old (meaning outdated) and cruel.

some (deffo not all) of the people who practise "NH" know this is BS but its the ones who preach otherwise that leave a bad taste in my mouth (either the pros who dream it up or the followers, both can be as bad)

NH is relatively new (the form its packaged as now anyway) so obviously decended from the traditional horsemen but this isnt explained, it is marketed as new and only just thought up by this guru which is simply wrong.

some of the methods i use already cos they arent new :rolleyes: and some are a complete waste of space and of no benefit to a normal horse person *unless you like circus tricks*

i wouldnt mind if it was just there and was open, but its like a special club of all these new age preachers and they go recruiting "vulnerable" people (must admit its mostly those that have come into horses late or young people who want to give their horse cuddles and call it cute (never met a cute horse :confused:)) who feel like they should spend hundreds of pounds to learn stuff thats taught for free/considerably less.

Yeah this is exactly what i think tbh, it is always marketed as the kinder better way for your horse and that's defiantely what puts me off it.

The only trainer i have the least bit of respect for is Monty Roberts, as well first off he doesn't call himself NH anyway. For example he'll join-up with a horse to then break it to be ridden in tack. And actually after seeing him a few times what he does isn't anything like traditional methods, because let's be honest who joins up with their horse?

And i've never felt he's marketed it in the same way as say Parelli, because what does he do... isn't make a horse get on a moving trailer or something like that?
 
And i've never felt he's marketed it in the same way as say Parelli, because what does he do... isn't make a horse get on a moving trailer or something like that?
Does Pat Parelli demonstrate and teach that now, because he hadn't used to???:confused:
 
There was a thread on here a while ago where someone had seen Parelli advertised and they were getting the horse to jump into a moving trailer... i'll see if i can find it.

If you can find any information, that would be great..thanks.:)
 
The way i see it it's like "if you don't do it this way your cruwl and don't care about your horse".

i wouldnt mind if it was just there and was open, but its like a special club of all these new age preachers and they go recruiting "vulnerable" people

I referred to comments like this on another thread, the perception is often rather different to the reality. There's always this 'someone' saying something about you and your horse and it often seems that people feel the need to justify themselves strongly and use terms like 'common sense' a lot when faced with some of this stuff. Sure, there's hard sell, and some of the products are eyewateringly expensive for what they are (not singling out PNH here either), but nobody is forcing you to buy them.

Common sense is great, and if you have a straightforward horse and are gifted with a bit of intuition and empathy then there's no need to concern yourself about it because you and your horse are probably absolutely fine. People tend to take an interest in this 'stuff' when they have a problem and 'traditional', whatever that is, and good old 'common sense' has failed them. For me it was fixing an uncatchable share horse, and a bad loader that convinced me there was something worthwhile in looking further. I now in a very small and minor way sometimes help friends and fellow liveries with problems if they ask me to, stuff like catching, clipping and loading. I find it deeply satisfying and interesting, and I learn something new every time. I hasten to add that I'm very much aware of my limits, and wouldn't go beyond them.

Like most people I don't actually consider myself to be one thing or another, some people might consider me traditional, and others a radical horse hippy depending on where they're coming from. And like everyone else I do my best for my horses with the knowledge at my disposal at the time, and constantly review and reconsider anything new in the light of our experiences with it.

never met a cute horse

That's sad. I own one, she has a rather endearing personality:D
 
i wouldnt mind if it was just there and was open, but its like a special club of all these new age preachers and they go recruiting "vulnerable" people (must admit its mostly those that have come into horses late or young people who want to give their horse cuddles and call it cute (never met a cute horse :confused:)) who feel like they should spend hundreds of pounds to learn stuff thats taught for free/considerably less.

Whats the difference between having a group of people who hold this type of knowledge and charge others to share it, and your typical Riding Instructor?

Teaching a different thing maybe, but it is still knowledge and it still has a price tag...

Some people might be naturally more intuitive riders/handlers, or more knowledgable through experience when younger- but nobody seems to have an issue with instantly suggesting a person who comes into horses late should get a riding instructor to teach them a particular way.

We live in a consumer culture. Get over it!


Oh and my horse is cute!! (When he isn't being a monster :) )
 
And actually after seeing him a few times what he does isn't anything like traditional methods, because let's be honest who joins up with their horse?

And i've never felt he's marketed it in the same way as say Parelli, because what does he do... isn't make a horse get on a moving trailer or something like that?

All good horsemen keep their horses "hooked on" to themselves. I always want a horses attention. I expect every horse to "go with me" if I ask them too. Monty certainly doesn't hold any "patents" on join up, or the many methods of achieving it.

Sometimes a horseman like Parelli may be trying to teach us something when they do these seemingly outlandish demo's such as loading onto a moving trailer. Though it's not something I would try, it offers a wonderful example of one NH concept worth exploring a bit.

"How would you teach a horse to load into a moving trailer?"
(Not why, HOW?)


Keep on, keepin on

Jack
 
"How would you teach a horse to load into a moving trailer?"
(Not why, HOW?)

Unless I'm missing a trick that would in principle be quite simple wouldn't it? Start with a well trained and willing loader and get it trotting loose into the trailer (not that hard). Then add a very small amount of forward movement into the equation, repeat gradually increasing the amount of forward movement and hey presto, you have a rather hazardous trick :)
 
newrider.com