"NH" and "Traditional" Methods

Zani

New Member
Jan 15, 2008
1,706
0
0
North Yorkshire
This is purely for a debate, and I know how lots of us like a good one of those!

Following on from a few different posts recently there seems to be an amount of angst between so called "traditionalists" and "NHers" (not sure what to call them :o).

I would like to think that all the members here have their horses best interests at heart, even though we all do things in different ways.

Do you view yourselves as a traditionalist or an NHer? I don't think I would put myself in either camp, I would say I like to learn and find out about all different kinds of methods for achieving the same thing and then applying what seems best for me and my horse.

Thoughts please! :)
 
Do you view yourselves as a traditionalist or an NHer? I don't think I would put myself in either camp, I would say I like to learn and find out about all different kinds of methods for achieving the same thing and then applying what seems best for me and my horse.

Not sure anyone would actually put themselves in a specific "camp":confused: I go along with your practice and take what works best for my horse and me. If thats NH then great, if its tradionalist methods then thats great too - I am open minded to anything that works.
 
Neither. I use some 'traditional' methods, some that suddenly seem to have morphed into 'NH', some that NH has brought to my attention. I don't follow any one practitioner in particular and cannot understand the war that seems to be breaking out between the two camps.

But it's not just trad v NH either any more. There's aggro between various different NH methods as well. It seems like everyone suddenly seems to want to be some sort of guru - the 'my way is the only way' kind of thing.

I had a traditional upbringing with horses. It wasn't the evil some seem to believe - it wasn't a case of hitting it til it does what you want at all. Yes, we used treed saddles, shod our horses and rode in bits (unless you had a hackamore, which is not really NH anyway) but that didn't mean we didn't work with the horse to better understand it.

I wish people would just forget about labeling and just get on with using a bit of horse sense.
 
Neither. I use some 'traditional' methods, some that suddenly seem to have morphed into 'NH', some that NH has brought to my attention. I don't follow any one practitioner in particular and cannot understand the war that seems to be breaking out between the two camps.

But it's not just trad v NH either any more. There's aggro between various different NH methods as well. It seems like everyone suddenly seems to want to be some sort of guru - the 'my way is the only way' kind of thing.

I had a traditional upbringing with horses. It wasn't the evil some seem to believe - it wasn't a case of hitting it til it does what you want at all. Yes, we used treed saddles, shod our horses and rode in bits (unless you had a hackamore, which is not really NH anyway) but that didn't mean we didn't work with the horse to better understand it.

I wish people would just forget about labeling and just get on with using a bit of horse sense.

I get were your coming from Chev,
I would say i use NH methods cos thats wat ive bin taught + it works for me + my horse, but im openminded unlike some people who just block different suggestions out, if someones got a better way of doing something then its best to learn, take notes not take offence because by using dif methods of training you become a better horseman/women. :D
Every horse + owner/rider is different + some methods dont suit wereas others do.

I wish people would just forget about labeling and just get on with using a bit of horse sense.

Exactly, :)
 
I'm neither or, probably more specifically, a mix of everything ;)

I was brought up BHS traditional, though my RI was more classically orientated looking back on it, the way the BHS should be. I dabbled with IH but then went onto clicker and looking at/learning about learning theory which is what I'm more comfortable with and which my horse has responded best to. Riding wise I'm following a more classical path now which, again, works for us. I don't say that I'm 'NH' because there are some NH methods that I wouldn't ever want to be associated with and I don't really see clicker as NH anyway.
 
It's a shame that many people view this as an either or situation, which from the replies so far it clearly isn't.
One thing that gets to me is the fact that 'traditional' has in some peoples eyes become to mean bad as far as horsemanship is concerned.

There is I believe a common theme with good horsemanship and that is 'finding effective ways to help horses understand what we are asking them to do' . This doesn't include violence. It also doesn't include being too much of a walkover either :D
 
I have to agree with you Chev, the whole labelling business makes for unpleasant stereotyping.

It is almost like a war! Those strictly NH think Traditional horsemen are cruel or below them in some sort of way. And those strictly Traditional believe NH horsemen are soft and let their horses walk all over them.

I'm not in either camp, and I don't think I ever will be. There is nothing wrong with tampering with either methods; it is all about what suits you and your horse best. That is not to say I believe in some cases that people should be strictly for or against both NH and traditional, because that is wrong. It is wrong to be so closed-minded when it comes to your horses welfare.
 
Because of the stereotypes for each, I personally strongly avoid ever suggesting i subscribe to one or the other.

I've used some NH stuff which wasnt shown to me as NH, so i don't call it that (even if most of has been 'promoted' by one practitioner or another).

If anything i guess i have a more traditional attitude to handling than a NH attitude, but my horse is barefoot (cos its cheaper and he is happy), has a treeless (as it fitted) and can go bitless (wouldnt move at all with a bit in his mouth when we first got him).

If it works for you...

I think some people feel really got at by people who really emphasise their success with such a method, and encourage its application by others- like an evangilist of any form (be it religion, or about private vs state schooling, or whip use)...
 
I'm fed up with this "either or" stuff, and the conflict between what some people regard as "sides". It's all horsemanship. Why can't people just say "Oh, that's interesting, I'd do it this way, what do you think?". We all know that there is always more than one way to get the job done.
Bloomin' paralysis by analysis if you ask me. :rolleyes:
 
It is almost like a war! Those strictly NH think Traditional horsemen are cruel or below them in some sort of way. And those strictly Traditional believe NH horsemen are soft and let their horses walk all over them.


Im sorry but i dont aggre with this statement, :eek:
I do not think im higher or anyway better than a 'traditional horseman'.
Also how is NH soft? Please elaborate :)
 
Im sorry but i dont aggre with this statement, :eek:
I do not think im higher or anyway better than a 'traditional horseman'.
Also how is NH soft? Please elaborate :)

I was meaning generally, sorry, should've made that clearer. There are a lot of NH folk who look down on traditionalists, I've seen it on this board before, so please don't be offended. There are always exceptions to the rule. :)

I don't think NH is soft, however, a lot of traditional horsemen look at it that way.
 
I was meaning generally, sorry, should've made that clearer. There are a lot of NH folk who look down on traditionalists, I've seen it on this board before, so please don't be offended. There are always exceptions to the rule. :)

I don't think NH is soft, however, a lot of traditional horsemen look at it that way.

Ahhh gotcha, TY for your reply :)
 
Neither.


When I work with horses, be it my own, or those i've had for re-hab work, I use my own methods which have evolved over a lot of time spent just watching & learning & asking what id do if i was the horse. I use some trad methods, some NH, some TT, some based on Pirrelli.


So im not one or tother, im a morph.
 
Thanks for your replies, it's all interesting reading. :)

I also don't like the stereotyping that seems to go on with all these arguments, everyone responding here though seems to be of the opinion that a little bit of what works is what counts, and I would agree with that too!

Seems there must just be a few "radicals" (as in all things in life) that will always be battling their causes and refuse to see that there is never just a single way to do things.
 
Does it really matter who's "NH" and who's "traditional" as long as the horse is being treated fairly and with respect??????

I rode and competed my one horse the "traditional" way, and it worked well for both of us. My other horse was re-started with the help of an NH instructor and later went through the PNH levels. Both where, and still are individuals with different needs and requirements and while my "traditional" horse was later introduced to a knotted halter and (dare I say it) carrot stick, it was just a formality as he'd already been taught the equivalent of the seven games by "traditional" schooling.

The horse doesn't know or care what label he's being taught under.....so why should we?????

In my opinion, to much emphasis is being put on something that has very little bearing on true horsemanship.
 
Does it really matter who's "NH" and who's "traditional" as long as the horse is being treated fairly and with respect??????

I rode and competed my one horse the "traditional" way, and it worked well for both of us. My other horse was re-started with the help of an NH instructor and later went through the PNH levels. Both where, and still are individuals with different needs and requirements and while my "traditional" horse was later introduced to a knotted halter and (dare I say it) carrot stick, it was just a formality as he'd already been taught the equivalent of the seven games by "traditional" schooling.

The horse doesn't know or care what label he's being taught under.....so why should we?????

In my opinion, to much emphasis is being put on something that has very little bearing on true horsemanship.

The labels matter not a jot to me I have to say! I look to learn new things all the time and will pick and choose what I do with my horse as I know what will work for him and what wont.

I have to say though, and this in no way is meant to disrespect anybody who follows a certain method, but I do think that sometimes some of the trainers, practitioners and retailers of NH/IS methods, training and products have fuelled the flames on a lot of this. For example I ride in a Barefoot Cherokee saddle because it's comfy for me and my horse is young and constantly changing shape. Said saddle has a pad on it that says "Barefoot, for Riders who care" or something along those lines. That irks me somewhat because I wouldn't want anyone to think that I have any objections to treed saddles! :o
 
I do things Kc's way :D
What i don't like is when people call things they're not... for example -

Pat Parelli, Game one - The Friendly Game

*some of this is missed out as it's irelivant and long lol*

It's purpose is to establish you as the horses friend. During the game you touch the horse all over with your hands, then a rope, then a carrot stick. This helps to build trust and desensitizes the horse to contact, helping him *or she ofcourse lol* to become more confident.

Now, i use my lunge whip with the loose bit strapped straight and touch Lantern all over as he has a bit of a fear of anything other than my hands touching his legs. Now does this mean i'm practicing NH, IMO no it doesn't. But in my book of "groundwork training for your horse" it under "Natural horsemanship - Pat Parelli".
 
I understand what your saying Zani, but that sort of "sell" isn't just restricted to the horse world, it can be found on most bill boards and television adverts advertising anything from pet food to cars.

It's a case of deciding if the product is suitable and right for the job... and then just ignoring all the guff that goes hand in hand with it.:)
 
I do things Kc's way :D
What i don't like is when people call things they're not... for example -



Now, i use my lunge whip with the loose bit strapped straight and touch Lantern all over as he has a bit of a fear of anything other than my hands touching his legs. Now does this mean i'm practicing NH, IMO no it doesn't. But in my book of "groundwork training for your horse" it under "Natural horsemanship - Pat Parelli".

lol - I brushed Ranger with a yard broom, now does that count as traditional or NH I wonder!

It's all a nonsense really, common sense is whats needed, that's all!
 
newrider.com