Should and ahouldn't

@Ale do you want to start a thread on training methods? I have to say I sometimes get a bit confused by what falls into what category, but it seems to be a popular area with a lot of people and it would be nice to get some discussion type threads going in a neutral way so that people don't feel they're being criticised or picked on. I'm reluctant to start one on training methods though because of the said confusion!
 
Hmmmm what gets in the way of horse training?? I’d say the attitude/ego of the trainer or so called trainer. I don’t believe everyone is cut out to train horses, some people are only cut out to ride them and even then I use that term loosely. Words well that’s a dictionary 🤣🤣

Anyone can learn, anyone can improve if they wish to however some don’t wish to to the detriment of their horses and some don’t wish to as their horse knows what they need it to know for them and don’t want to teach anything else.

On the other hand some can’t stick to a method of training and ends up with very confused horses and some are blinkered and won’t see past any other method than the one they have chosen, even if it doesn’t suit the horse.

I think If you aren’t willing to accept the consequences your habits have on your horse then that’s the most negative thing. Accepting what’s wrong and trying to fix it in an appropriate way to me is a positive way of doing things, so is accepting that maybe you aren’t the right person and having the humility to get the help 😃
 
  • Like
Reactions: carthorse
No haha I've done that before and it just confused people more. Sorry my replies went a bit off track from this topic.

The main thing for me that hinders training can be the attitude that they are not living things and should be perfect.
 
  • Like
Reactions: carthorse
@newforest the problem I was seeing was the owner was shrieking "bad girl, you shouldn't do that" but doing nothing to correct the behaviour let alone show her what she wanted. So to take your approaching the jump example, she'd still be going into the fence with no leg or support but wailing "you should be going forward" - I did feel like asking her if she'd shown the horse the videos she's working from!
i once grabbed a pony at show being beaten up by a brat and gave her and her mum a right rollicking that it wasn't the pony's fault that the kid couldn't ride for toffee and the pony was being extremely tolerant and had every right to dump her pronto
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huggy and Trewsers
No haha I've done that before and it just confused people more. Sorry my replies went a bit off track from this topic.

The main thing for me that hinders training can be the attitude that they are not living things and should be perfect.

Well if you change your mind, or think of anything else that's a discussion type topic, then feel free! I was probably one of those people who ended up confused before, but that doesn't make it a bad subject 😄
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers
I hate it when people say 'you need to show him who's boss!' To me it implies that you need to give the horse a good beating if it isn't doing what you want. Maybe they don't actually mean that and I'm just being over sensitive.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers and MrA
I hate it when people say 'you need to show him who's boss!' To me it implies that you need to give the horse a good beating if it isn't doing what you want. Maybe they don't actually mean that and I'm just being over sensitive.

I feel the same. I also wonder about the sanity of the person saying it because in many cases if a person is stupid enough to openly challenge a horse it isn't going to end well for the person - we're too small, too slow, and too fragile. Hopefully people with that attitude only deal with placid horses! But certainly that attitude is a huge block to good and effective training, though it's a useful way of identifying people I won't have near any horse of mine.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bodshi
Along those lines I also don't agree with the well horses do it to each other so it's okay for us to do it principal of training.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bodshi
Along those lines I also don't agree with the well horses do it to each other so it's okay for us to do it principal of training.
But that's down to the particular types of training methods that someone might be interested in. It may not get in the way of their training, but they will probably get in the way of the horse.

I could say I don't like the term barefoot because she's unshod. She's trimmed by my farrier. So please do not reinvent the wheel. It irks my trainer if I say barefoot by mistake, that's an alien world.
Her hoof "shouldnt" resemble that of a wild horse, because she is been ridden and living a totally different life. It should be balanced to her.
 
I hate it when people say 'you need to show him who's boss!' To me it implies that you need to give the horse a good beating if it isn't doing what you want. Maybe they don't actually mean that and I'm just being over sensitive.
I had someone say she needs taking in hand, it didn't tell me anything else apart from they were probably going to show her who is boss, which implies aggression, force etc.
I am not the boss, its a partnership, we are in it together.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bodshi
But that's down to the particular types of training methods that someone might be interested in. It may not get in the way of their training, but they will probably get in the way of the horse.
Can you elaborate more to what you mean here as isn't this all about training methods?
 
It used to annoy me when I took Ben to pole/ mini jumping clinics that I was often told that a horse his size should have a longer canter stride and therefore be able to make the distances that other horses could in gymnastic style grids. Both Ben and I preferred life in the slow Lane. Ben responded to me. He knew I wanted him to be steady and produced exactly the canter stride I felt comfortable with. I therefore wanted the instructors (I had this discussion several times) to reduce the distance so he could jump it. This often caused conflict because they said he ‘should be able to extend his stride’. Perhaps if someone else was riding him they could have ‘made him’ do it, but a good instructor needs to work with the horse and rider combination they have in-front of them. One instructor said to me that I needed to put my reins in one hand, give him several hard smacks because he was bone idol and needed waking up. She didn’t understand that we were a partnership and all I wanted to do was to have some fun popping over 50cm jumps at our own pace. I had no desire to go faster or to win anything, I just wanted to enjoy my horse and have fun, even if it was at a snails pace.
 
But that's down to the particular types of training methods that someone might be interested in. It may not get in the way of their training, but they will probably get in the way of the horse.

I could say I don't like the term barefoot because she's unshod. She's trimmed by my farrier. So please do not reinvent the wheel. It irks my trainer if I say barefoot by mistake, that's an alien world.
Her hoof "shouldnt" resemble that of a wild horse, because she is been ridden and living a totally different life. It should be balanced to her.

See, I don't like or use the word un-shod as to me it implies horses natural state is shod and they popped out of the womb with shoes on 🤣 I always say barefoot and I have a barefoot trimmer not an un-shod trimmer, although I now I want to drop unshod trimmer in on their next visit just to see their reaction!

It's fascinating how differently we all intepret things :)
 
Trying to answer the original question, I think anytime 'Is this a fair ethical question to the horse?' with the horse's reaction monitored (physical and emotional) at the forefront of training can never be effective as the horse will never feel heard. I'd love to see heart rate monitors used routinely in training as a way of monitoring stress.

I don't think any method is as important as the horse feeling they are at the heart of any conversation. Subsequently there are +R trainers I wouldn't let near my horse and there are traditional trainers I'd jump at the chance to train with.

The rest is individual preference a lot of the time - I prefer French classical training over the German for example as I really value the emphasises on lightness, but I dont think the German classical is necessarily wrong and there's a lot I use from it. I use a mix of some +R, some natural horsemanship, some traditional methods and I haven't found it confusing for the horse if the horse feels heard.

There are plenty of things I 'should' do but don't or can't, so I don't expect the same impossible standards from my horse. He's perfectly capable of more advanced dressage more often but it doesn't float his boat but he comes alive cantering up the Downs and loves long rides so thats what we focus on ;)
 
Can you elaborate more to what you mean here as isn't this all about training methods?
If you start another thread on training methods then we can chat about them.
But this thread is asking about what words gets in the way of training, not the actual training methods itself 🙂
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrA and carthorse
See, I don't like or use the word un-shod as to me it implies horses natural state is shod and they popped out of the womb with shoes on 🤣 I always say barefoot and I have a barefoot trimmer not an un-shod trimmer, although I now I want to drop unshod trimmer in on their next visit just to see their reaction!

It's fascinating how differently we all intepret things :)
I get where you are coming from, but none of our horses are living in their natural state. We can though get as close to what we think that is.
(The trim is different depending on who they trained under, that's why the name is different, but that's another thread) 🙂

Using the op post as an example about wondering what book the rider was reading, all the research that's been done to date has likely been put into a books for others to study from. It's someone's viewpoint, opinion, first hand experience. It's their interpretation of what they think they are seeing.

We all learn in different ways, the same as the horse. J loved all the obstacles, loved messing around, loved exploring, loved not knowing what we could be doing today.
The cob isn't like that.
I as a person will learn in different ways to you. I am a bookworm, I can actually learn things from them.
I learnt to trot before I even sat on a horse that the instructor said are you sure this is your second ride!

Back to the should post.
The cob needs your voice dressage will penalize its because the horse should listen to other aids.
To throw a spanner in, let's say dressage decided that we couldn't use our leg because the horse should listen to your voice and seat. How many people would struggle with that and how many horses won't pick up the voice.
 
I would just say without shoes. Lol. I can't remember the last time I talked to anyone in person about shoes and their feet. I can't remember what term I used. I do know OH told someone ours weren't shod. That was a non-horse person he was talking to.
 
I would just say without shoes. Lol. I can't remember the last time I talked to anyone in person about shoes and their feet. I can't remember what term I used. I do know OH told someone ours weren't shod. That was a non-horse person he was talking to.
Non horse people tend to query why she hasn't got shoes.
They see that horses should/would have shoes to be ridden on the roads.
My original reason for keeping metal off the hoof was because she kicked!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jane&Ziggy
If you start another thread on training methods then we can chat about them.
But this thread is asking about what words gets in the way of training, not the actual training methods itself 🙂
Makes sense now thanks
 
newrider.com