Should and ahouldn't

carthorse

Super Moderator
Jan 6, 2006
13,791
8,540
113
Two words that really get in the way of effective training in my opinion.

I was watching someone today and these words were used a lot, and took the place of actually doing anything that might have worked towards the wanted behaviour. The book or the preferred trainers videos may say this is what should happen, but the horse doesn't know that and so without clear guidance it isn't going to happen and there's no point in getting cross with the horse over it. Whatever happened to working with the horse that's in front of you? I sometimes think the modern horse world would be a lot better off without a lot of the books, YouTube etc, if a hefty dose of common sense could be handed out then so much the better! As an example, yes Luka should stand like a rock at the mounting block but for some reason he has an issue with this, however he'll stand politely at my steps so why bother insisting he stand at the proper mounting block because he should? He shouldn't be led on a loose rope, but he's quiet that way so why insist on a short one held with tension in it?

If I wanted something that complied with a manual then I'd buy a motorbike!

What words or attitudes do you think get in the way of effective training and horsemanship?
 
I agree with working with the horse and rider on front of you.

Some horses and or novice beginner riders/owners however need to be given clear boundaries with the basics. The should/shouldn't might step in as a guidance.
Your horse should be going forward with impulsion before jumping. Someone new to jumping will need to be told that?

Who said the horse shouldn't be on a loose rope?
Mine is on a loose rope and walks slightly behind me, (possibly why the little minx pinches grass 😂)
That's her preferred place to be, why is she right or wrong? Why is about who is doing it wrong?

What about changing the word shouldn't to no and it's the same thing isn't it?
If the cob steps into me while she is tied up, she "shouldn't" do that, sheet she didn't, she just has, so I ask gently to step back, no.
It's not really a major issue.

The attitudes that get in the way, is not being open to alternative ways, if you come across a horse that really doesn't understand what is being asked.
Nobody was willing to teach me and my previous chap, I only got you should get rid of him. He was quirky. So it needed me to think outside the box.

I am a self confessed book worm, but, I will cherry pick from it and put things into practice. Someone might just say say something that makes me think.
Mine hasnt read any books, but I am pretty sure she's written one!
 
@newforest the problem I was seeing was the owner was shrieking "bad girl, you shouldn't do that" but doing nothing to correct the behaviour let alone show her what she wanted. So to take your approaching the jump example, she'd still be going into the fence with no leg or support but wailing "you should be going forward" - I did feel like asking her if she'd shown the horse the videos she's working from!
 
@Skib in his case people think that because he tends to dance, and even his normal walk is steppy and up - a friend rather accurately described it as he thinks the ground is lava 😂. But he steps and dances at my speed so if he wants to waste energy that's up to him imo.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huggy
If I tighten the grip and shorten the lead rope on Hogan, he sees it as an invitation to argue. Everything with Hogan is contrary to how I did things with Ramsey - different strokes - different horses- rule book out the window :confused:. Necessity is the mother of invention - as far as I'm concerned, I do what is necessary to get the best out of the horse in front of me.
 
I can lead Belle on a loose lead, tighter lead or no lead at all, but she’s gentle and kind and will follow me anyway.
The one other livery however, I swear she would kill you if you hold her tight, loose lead or it’s a huge fight with her.
But yes, common sense would be wonderful, just a shame it’s not common at all anymore.
 
Does anyone else's horse do that weird head thing before walking on when you lead them?
If I go catch her to put her back in the paddock she does the head and neck is coming but my legs aren't.
She is coming and she does walk on, it's just this weird thing she did first.
😂
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Trewsers
Hogan throws his head up as though he's bracing to pull a cart when he starts to lead out.
 
Two words that really get in the way of effective training in my opinion.

I was watching someone today and these words were used a lot, and took the place of actually doing anything that might have worked towards the wanted behaviour. The book or the preferred trainers videos may say this is what should happen, but the horse doesn't know that and so without clear guidance it isn't going to happen and there's no point in getting cross with the horse over it. Whatever happened to working with the horse that's in front of you? I sometimes think the modern horse world would be a lot better off without a lot of the books, YouTube etc, if a hefty dose of common sense could be handed out then so much the better! As an example, yes Luka should stand like a rock at the mounting block but for some reason he has an issue with this, however he'll stand politely at my steps so why bother insisting he stand at the proper mounting block because he should? He shouldn't be led on a loose rope, but he's quiet that way so why insist on a short one held with tension in it?

If I wanted something that complied with a manual then I'd buy a motorbike!

What words or attitudes do you think get in the way of effective training and horsemanship?
Negative ones.
It's almost setting up the horse and rider to fail before you even start.
Using my example from another thread, mine has been called various things, obstinate, strong mindset, difficult and stubborn. Those are all negative and actually only tell you what she's like if she isn't working with you.
When she's working with you she's a fairly forward willing, quiet, calm and content little cob.
 
@newforest the problem I was seeing was the owner was shrieking "bad girl, you shouldn't do that" but doing nothing to correct the behaviour let alone show her what she wanted. So to take your approaching the jump example, she'd still be going into the fence with no leg or support but wailing "you should be going forward" - I did feel like asking her if she'd shown the horse the videos she's working from!
This is just completely incompetent horsemanship. They generally have no clue how to work with the horse to show it what is wanted, they just expect it to do it because they bought one that was already trained, then blame the seller for misselling to them when it regresses into a difficult horse (ie one that takes advantage of their incompetence)
 
  • Like
Reactions: carthorse and Huggy
I found an example 😂
Stubborn. She just HAS to do the neck first sometimes twisting it left and right, then moves.

I’m afraid this would drive me potty, they haven’t been taught that leading starts with a back foot moving and have been dragged instead.
@Skib in his case people think that because he tends to dance, and even his normal walk is steppy and up - a friend rather accurately described it as he thinks the ground is lava 😂. But he steps and dances at my speed so if he wants to waste energy that's up to him imo.
I see it as the horses job to keep slack in the rope while my job is to set speed and direction. If you don’t ever expect them to take a little responsibility for themselves they will always need you to micro manage them.
Luka high stepping bouncing next to you is a perfect example of a horse doing his job and managing himself, he needs to bounce and strut, but he’s doing it at the speed you’ve set and not pulling.
 
Then of course there's the Ramseys of this world, no lead rope, walk at your shoulder, straight into their box.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Trewsers
I’m afraid this would drive me potty, they haven’t been taught that leading starts with a back foot moving and have been dragged instead.

I see it as the horses job to keep slack in the rope while my job is to set speed and direction. If you don’t ever expect them to take a little responsibility for themselves they will always need you to micro manage them.
Luka high stepping bouncing next to you is a perfect example of a horse doing his job and managing himself, he needs to bounce and strut, but he’s doing it at the speed you’ve set and not pulling.
Frustrating yes and something I could look into again.
It comes back to the horse should walk when you walk, stop when you do.

Before she came she was tanking off when led so she was allowed to follow mum for 18 months.
I can unstick her feet where she sticks, it's the same three places.
 
@newforest that photo would be better titled "how to end up with massive chiro bills for your horse"! Not to mention that she looks to have the rope wrapped round her hand or wrist which is an accident waiting to happen. I hope it's a joke photo.

@Jessey he's a naturally very polite horse but in the past his natural exuberance combined with a late cut presence has been misinterpreted by people who have then scared him by being aggressive - he didn't fit into their box of how a horse should behave and they didn't have the sense/skill to look at what he is. How to wreck a good horse, and it happens too often :(. @Huggy we don't have the set up to let him do that, but when my back was bad and I was up early before others were about I would often throw the rope over his neck so that if I lost my footing I didn't pull on him. If I was really slow he'd walk circles around me 😂
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huggy
I hope so to, mine isn't actually that bad!

Well I decided to spend a session working on this "can't be arsed to come with you, yeah whatever attitude.

I approach her with the lunging whip tucked under my arm, she lifts her head instantly. Good girl with a stroke as it goes on.
Then I focus on where I am leading her, verbally voice a authority walk on with a slight feel in the rope, and blow me she walks on straight away.
So I turn her out.
No reason to repeat she's got it.

Thank you @carthorse for starting the thread and to @Jessey for saying it would drive her potty.
I have realised that actually I have let her become sloppy. All I needed to do was focus and tell her to walk on. 👍😁
 
You can train without clear guidance it just depends what you are trying to achieve. If I wanted to train ale to stand near a block I could just put it near him, he would almost certainly go straight over to it and I could shape it from there. If I wanted to train him to jump through a hoop that would not work at all 😂 some people want their horse to obey everything they ask and some don't, but it's up to them I guess.
 
You can train without clear guidance it just depends what you are trying to achieve. If I wanted to train ale to stand near a block I could just put it near him, he would almost certainly go straight over to it and I could shape it from there. If I wanted to train him to jump through a hoop that would not work at all 😂 some people want their horse to obey everything they ask and some don't, but it's up to them I guess.
I did/do have a photo of mine jumping through a hoop, she was not thrilled about it. 😂
I love Trec and obstacles but she's not into that, so I have had to find other things we can enjoy.

There are certain things I need to her to listen to from a safety point of view. She will bump into you or walk over you if she's not reminded about that.
I don't expect perfection, but something polite would be nice.
 
There's a video of a para rider I love, her horse is over the yard and just one signal and it comes and lines up beautifully at the mounting block, all taught through positive reinforcement I believe. Most of us don't need that kind of behaviour and I can't imagine the amount of work that went in to teaching it, but for her it's essential to allow her to even get on
 
newrider.com