Being neurotic at heart, I always wear my hat to ride.
But I also think that we have to weigh up risks and accept that they cannot all be eliminated, in the horseworld.
By text books, we should also all wear hats to lead / handle / pick-out etc; I fall guilty of not doing this. Do others?
I am by NO means saying don't wear hats, but IMHO the risk / impact is to a degree "transferred" (can't think of a better word here) - if you have bad fall, your skull may be protected but your cervical spine may take the force. Even a body protector can't help all the way up. Hence Reeve's injuries for example. And from my nursing experience, I personally am not sure I'd want to stay alive in his state of extreme total paralysis; unable scratch your nose, breath independently, tube fed, urinary catheters, manual evacuation of bowels, pressure sores, chest infections / pneumonia, spasticity of muscles, etc. I'd rather be unconscious within seconds then goodbye folks.
Don't mean to sound gloomy, but I think we keep adding "safeguards" to such sports, then winge when people get different injuries. We have to accept the increased danger, or not do it.
An analogy - look at the difference air bags make to surving RTAs. Is it now irresponsible to drive old cars without airbags? Where do we draw the line? I think we're trying to shift into a society where all risk is controlled - not possible.
IMHO, take measures to reduce risk by all means, but accept that there's a limit and other risks still remain. (rant over, climbs off soapbox - sorry wasn't meant to be this long)