Riding without a helmet

In all the time I've been around horses, I've fallen off more times than I can remember, but I can count on the fingers of one hand the times I've been knocked over or kicked by a horse when I was on the ground

That seems to me to be an odd observation :confused: .
I know lots of people who, despite having numerous falls, have never actually banged their head upon imact with the ground.
But I think you'd agree that doesn't mean they never will ;) .

I've never fallen off when being without my hat, and by your logic, that should somehow mean I'm probably unlikely to :p .

It's your choice what you do anyhow :) , as is mine.
I don't think opinions from either side of the argument will be altered tonight.
 
No, opinions that are firmly entrenched with mind safely locked will not be changed by fact or figures.

I think, however, that the discussion is still valuable because there are still people lurking here that have not made up their minds on helmet use.

My hope is that those types of riders will look at the different posts and decide for themselves which side they believe is right for them.

Hopefully they will be using the 'left' side of their brain...;)
 
In all the time I've been around horses, I've fallen off more times than I can remember, but I can count on the fingers of one hand the times I've been knocked over or kicked by a horse when I was on the ground

That seems to me to be an odd observation :confused: .
I know lots of people who, despite having numerous falls, have never actually banged their head upon imact with the ground.
But I think you'd agree that doesn't mean they never will ;) .

I've never fallen off when being without my hat, and by your logic, that should somehow mean I'm probably unlikely to :p .

It's your choice what you do anyhow :) , as is mine.
I don't think opinions from either side of the argument will be altered tonight.




Why is it odd? It's a simple inductive argument - things that have happened before are likely to happen again. I've never hit my head falling off either - like Chev, I've been lucky enough never to have been hurt.


I was just saying that I'm more likely to fall off than to be hurt on the ground - which is why I wear a hat for riding but not usually for handling horses on the ground. But as to which part of you is likely to be hurt, that's a lot harder to predict: I've fallen on my bum, my back, my knee, my shoulder - it could easily be my head next time.
 
It's a simple inductive argument - things that have happened before are likely to happen again.

I didn't mean it offensively Linda :) .

But I do personally think it's an odd argument (mainly because I believe that you're just as likely to get your head injured from the ground than you are from falling from a horse hatless). And the fact that a non-hat wearer (not just you) is against riding hatless, but doesn't wear one on the ground is (I find) a little "pot-kettle-black."
Not just in relation to you Linda :) , I'm just saying in general - I find the "I wear a hat to ride in but not from the ground" debate a bit strange.

Yes your argument's sensible enough. And I agree with the sentiment ;) .
You choose not to wear a hat whilst handling your horse from the ground, and you choose to do this based on the fact that you've never been kicked, stamped, or barged in way which puts your head in danger. However, you also acknowledge that horrific accidents do happen under such circumstances.

But by that same argument, the fact that I've never fallen off when being without a hat suggests that I'm basically OK not to wear one.
However, like you (with your grooming etc) I accept head injuries do happen.

But that's just my opinion. And I respect yours ;) .
I think much of it is down to personal risk assessment. Some believe that getting on a horse at all is too dangerous, others don't.
 
I always wear my hat and BP when riding. I also wear them when lunging too. TBH they are so comfortable that I forget I'm wearing them anyway, and so easy and quick to put on that it isn't even an issue.

I think that if any BP 'caused' any injuries it was most probably down to it not fitting correctly. Someone mentioned their BP digging into them - this would not happen if it was well fitted. Also you should be able to roll in a BP, well you could do in mine anyway.

There are a lot of BP and hats on the market but they are not expensive pieces of equipment so really there is no excuse not to buy one.

The hat and BP I bought were quite expensive, not because I'm made of money - I'm not, but because I researched the models and felt that they were more than worth the money as they are comfortable as well as safe.

Properly fitted hats and BPs should be snug and comfortable fit. I thoroughly recommend the Racesafe BP as it is sooooooooooo comfortable and I just feel so much safer wearing it.

I went to visit a friend from a forum the other weekend and hadn't taken my hat with me as wasn't expecting to ride. But her hat fit me so I went for a little walk and trot. For some reason though the horse slipped and then went into a bronco-style thing and I fell off, hitting my head. Just imagine if I hadn't borrowed her hat and thought "oh, I'm only going to be walking and trotting so it doesn't matter"? My head hurt enough with the hat on so shudder to think of the alternative!

I would NEVER get on any horse without my hat. ALL are unpredictable, even the horse you have known for years. My horse is usually quite a gentle soul but even she can buck/rear and spook. If she gets scared or is having an off day and I fall off I need to be prepared.

Saying that it's OK to jump on without a hat because you're not going to canter is absolute ****. To add to my example above, the first time I fell off my mare was when trotting and she slipped on some leaves and went right down. The other time I fell off her was when I had just got on her - she was standing - and she bucked/reared and off I came.

Accidents don't just happen in eventing, showjumping, hacking or whatever. They can happen in the school or when you've just got on!

I completely agree with Harvey's posts.

I wouldn't try and force someone to change their mind about wearing a hat or BP but at the same time they aren't going to change my opinion that they are downright STUPID for not doing so :p
 
i would never ride a horse without a riding hat on:eek:

and anyone who does is a p---t, they don't just ruin their own lives when they finish up with brain damage, some poor sod has to look after them for the rest of their stupid life:(

I have to completely agree with Poohsmate. It is irresponsible and rather ignorant in this day and age. I bet the same people don't wear seat belts in their cars 'because it's too uncomfortable/been driving for years without one / I'm a good driver'. Well, what a pathetic excuse that is. Would you make your child sit in a car without a seat belt or ride a horse without a riding hat? If not then you have no excuse.

I really cannot abide such ignorance :mad:
 
I don't want to get involved the arguments - this thread has been interesting reading and I can see everyone's point of view (but that's one of my good points (or bad if you ask my OH because I can never make my mind up:D ).

Personally I always wear a hat on the ground and whilst riding and I was very glad I was wearing it a couple of weeks ago when I came off (still have a lump on my head too!). My OH would not let me ride if I didn't wear a hat - not because he wouldn't want to look after me if I had an accident but just because he wants me to minimise the danger if I do.

However I was very surprised having always ridden at UK riding schools ,where they insisted on hats for riding, that when I went on a trail ride in the US they didn't. I assumed that with the litigious culture out there that they would insist on every safety precaution but when I rode in Big Sur the helmets were optional and you just had to sign a form to say you wouldn't sue if you had an accident. I was the only Brit there and one of the ladies on my ride was a lawyer on holiday and she wore a hat (as I did) but the other 6 people on the ride didn't.
 
People at our yard have to sign a form saying they've read our safety rules and they agree to abide by them. That includes wearing a hat.

I can see the other points of view too, and I have my momens when I realise that I'm actually quite stupid when it comes to safety...
 
The thread about riding in trainers made me wonder how many of us are guilty of another horsey crime: riding without a hat or helmet.

I have to admit I've done this. In the southern part of the US very few people wear headgear when they ride. I could count on one hand the number of times I've seen my barn mates with helmets on. I used to wear one religiously, but since Sugar has gotten over her behavioral problems and has become such a sweetheart, I have been guilty of schooling her in the arena sometimes without a helmet. Not only that, but the other day I rode out on the trails and I forgot my helmet--and I didn't go back for it.

I know...I've been very bad. :o Will try hard to improve.

So...has anyone else done this?

It's not just a matter of getting over behavioural problems meaning you no longer need a hard hat. Anything can happen, your horse could take fright, a car could hit you, the horse could slip, anything.

In March I came off an apparently bomb-proof and well-behaved horse that I've owned for 7 years and known for ten, landing on my head on concrete. I was wearing the highest standard helmet available but still knocked myself out for about an hour and ended up in hospital for two days. If I hadn't been wearing it I would be dead. The helmet was split in two.

Please, it's better to feel like an idiot but be able to walk away from a fall than to be a dead fashion victim. Invest in a helmet and WEAR IT!!!!

It's advisable and insisted on by the British Horse Society to wear a hat when working on the ground with a horse as well.
 
Last edited:
Remember though - he was wearing the appropriate hat

Actually, I believe he was not wearing an approved helmet- an unfortunate thing that perhaps contributed to his injury.

I agree with you on the spine being a vulnerable part of the anatomy. When I had my accident, I had a concussion which was bad enough (no helmet that day), but also broke several bones in my back.

There are no fail-safe protections when riding with horses, but the wise ones do all they can to minimize the risk.
 
Remember though - he was wearing the appropriate hat and a body protector.

My doctor told me once to me much more worried about my spine than cracking my head on something. Although, knowing me I would find the one rock in the sand! So I always wear one, anyway.

Yes, but he broke his neck - a helmet and a body protector could not have prevented that. Heads are very fragile - wear a hat!

Incidentally, any impact, whether in a fall or by dropping the hat on a hard floor, can compromise the strength of the structure so after such an incident the hat should be replaced, EVEN IF IT DOESN'T APPEAR TO BE DAMAGED.
 
Last edited:
newrider.com