I always wear my hat and BP when riding. I also wear them when lunging too. TBH they are so comfortable that I forget I'm wearing them anyway, and so easy and quick to put on that it isn't even an issue.
I think that if any BP 'caused' any injuries it was most probably down to it not fitting correctly. Someone mentioned their BP digging into them - this would not happen if it was well fitted. Also you should be able to roll in a BP, well you could do in mine anyway.
There are a lot of BP and hats on the market but they are not expensive pieces of equipment so really there is no excuse not to buy one.
The hat and BP I bought were quite expensive, not because I'm made of money - I'm not, but because I researched the models and felt that they were more than worth the money as they are comfortable as well as safe.
Properly fitted hats and BPs should be snug and comfortable fit. I thoroughly recommend the Racesafe BP as it is sooooooooooo comfortable and I just feel so much safer wearing it.
I went to visit a friend from a forum the other weekend and hadn't taken my hat with me as wasn't expecting to ride. But her hat fit me so I went for a little walk and trot. For some reason though the horse slipped and then went into a bronco-style thing and I fell off, hitting my head. Just imagine if I hadn't borrowed her hat and thought "oh, I'm only going to be walking and trotting so it doesn't matter"? My head hurt enough with the hat on so shudder to think of the alternative!
I would NEVER get on any horse without my hat. ALL are unpredictable, even the horse you have known for years. My horse is usually quite a gentle soul but even she can buck/rear and spook. If she gets scared or is having an off day and I fall off I need to be prepared.
Saying that it's OK to jump on without a hat because you're not going to canter is absolute ****. To add to my example above, the first time I fell off my mare was when trotting and she slipped on some leaves and went right down. The other time I fell off her was when I had just got on her - she was standing - and she bucked/reared and off I came.
Accidents don't just happen in eventing, showjumping, hacking or whatever. They can happen in the school or when you've just got on!
I completely agree with Harvey's posts.
I wouldn't try and force someone to change their mind about wearing a hat or BP but at the same time they aren't going to change my opinion that they are downright STUPID for not doing so
