Riding without a helmet

DeirdreBarlow said:
Incidently, I don't believe youre actually telling people anything they don't already know. By all means try to "get your message across" (as you put it), but to me, it's kind of like someone saying "horses have 4 legs" - I'm not quite sure how I'm expected to respond lol.

But we have a habit of putting our heads in the sand and trying to ignore what we should already know. And some truly never think of the consequences of their actions. Others think it'll "never happen to them". We often only change our ways once someone close to us has had a bad experience or we see it for ourselves. Are you in the UK? Remember the endless "wear a seatbelt" ads. More people started to wear a seatbelt once those adverts were shown because it made them think. And for those who needed a bit more encouragement, it was eventually made law ;)

I just wish you'd wear a hat............................................:o

Will get off soap box now and go back in my box (until next time........;) )

ETA: 4 legs......................really :eek: . You should see my horse.......... :p
 
I haven't read thru all this, but almost no one at my barn (Texas) who owns their own horse wears a hat. Everyone is lessons has to. It is so hot and humid here that I can sympathize with those who don't altho that is not the reason really- it's just the custom here. Same on trail rides at a different barn and it's been the same on the trail ride vacations I have taken- no helmets!! I always wear one.
 
Will get off soap box now and go back in my box (until next time........ )

I wouldn't dream of saying you're not fighting a worthy cause. In fact, I commend you on your attempts to promote the "equine safety" message. It's certainly a valuable lesson to be learned.
But using words like "foolish" and "selfish" (with regards to considering family) are bound to get people's backs up.

We often only change our ways once someone close to us has had a bad experience or we see it for ourselves.

Very true, but you're making an assumption here that the non-hat-wearers have never witnessed (or even experienced) such traumas.

Ah well, world would be a very dull place if we all agreed ;) .
 
Ill always wear a hat, :) .

The thought of me or anyone falling off with... horrendous head injuries just sickens me.:(
 
Always have and always will. I believe no hat = no horse.

My number one p**s off is seeing riders on the road with a hat on, but not done up ! :eek: What's the point in wearing it then ??? This is purely my opinion but I think you'd have to be a special kind of prat to ride on the road without a hat. Horses are unpredictable animals and even accidents happen with the most sane of them.
 
I'n afraid i'm goign to agree with Harvey on this one. I know this is going to get a lot of peoples backs up but riding and handling horses without proper care is incredibly selfish. By doing that you are saying to those that love you 'I don't care about your feelings enough to do the incredibly simple task of putting a helmet on'

My mum has a nursing home, once she had a resident with severe mental ncapacity caused by a horse riding fall because she wasn't wearing a helmet. She went from a perfectly normal working mother to practicaly a vegetable who had violent outbursts. I will always remember her reletives distress everytime they came to see her. They almost always left in tears, especially after she had been shouting obscenities at them.
It is really worth ruining your loved ones lives so you can 'excercise your rights'
 
Nope. Never. I'm a good girl ;) I think the naughtiest (or most painful :rolleyes: ) thing I've ever done is ride is Welly's. That was painful, and the forgetfulness never happened again :p
 
The first and only time I ever got on without a hat on, I fell off. I was about twelve or thirteen at the time and probably stupid enough to believe it wouldn't happen to me. I was mounting and didn't even get my right leg over the pony's back when something spooked him and he took off. I came off the side...... and whacked my head. I was very lucky that I wasn't dragged or kicked in the head and landed on soft ground. I was mildly dizzy and naueseous but alert enough to realise how lucky I was.

I'm going to Vegas on holiday in a week's time and planning to book a trail ride while I'm there. Having looked at one or two websites I was shocked to see pictures of entire groups going out with no helmets. One of the sites said that children had to wear hats and adults were "encouraged" but there was no information on the other ones. I find this amazing! Especially in such a touristy area where probably the majority of people on the rides will never have sat on a horse before! The girl I will be riding with is a nervous beginner and there is absolutely no way I will let her get on without one, no matter what the people at the place say. My hat is coming with me in my suitcase! :D

It's beyond my comprehension that someone would consider riding without one, unless they have a deathwish.....
 
None of the commercial barns around here require adults to wear a helmet on a trail ride...in fact I know of at least two which don't require kids to wear them either. Like I said before, safety just isn't the hot button issue in the USA that it is in the UK. Maybe this is because of the popularity of western riding over here? I know that in western pleasure classes I never see any of the competitors in helmets, just cowboy hats. Ditto barrel racing and pole bending...even in the high school rodeos I never see any of the riders in helmets, let alone body protectors.
 
I am wondering about other European countries - in France it is common to see people cantering through the woods on what look like quite spirited horses with no hats and wearing trainers. I have been told that some of the Icelandic old school never used to wear hats either.
For myself I do it because I always have and its automatic. Ditto my kids.
 
I find that at least here in California...many who ride English tend to ride with helmets...MOST Western riders gallop off without...I dont know if it largely depends on what type of riding, buteither way, I still beleive in safety! Cliche as it is SAFETY FIRST always is best when on horseback! ;)
 
I don't think any non-hat-wearers mind the hat-wearers holding the opinion that hats should be worn :) .
That opinion in itself isn't what gets people's backs up.
It's (for me at least) the using of words like "selfish" (and spoken as though it were hard fact rather than opinion) that I think is a bit out of line.
By using "selfish" (or similar), you're effectively making a personal attack on someone - baring in mind you know nothing about their non-horsey lives. "Selish" (with regards to not wearing a hat) implies (and I can think of no other meaning than this) that they're not considering others in their actions.
If that's your opinion then fair enough :o , but it is only an opinion and a fairly ill-informed one I think, given that you know nothing about the person ;) .
I take exception to being called selfish :( , and I just think it's a bit unnecessary (baring in mind I've made no such accusation of others who don't share my opinion).
Nobody's perfect, and I believe if you're going to make a statement which more-or-less says everyone who doesn't wear a hat is selfish, you better be able to say (hand on heart people! :D ) that you've never done ANYTHING remotely unsafety concious in your life (ie, worn unsensible shoes (we all love our heels ladies - myself included :rolleyes: ), or driven above the speed limit, or not looked properly when you're walking on uneven paving). Otherwise, that to me is just a tad pot-kettle-black :o .
We're never going to agree I suppose lol - but it has been an interesting thread :) .
 
Last edited:
I don't think people who make mistakes are selfish - not at all. Yes we all make mistakes; cross the road without looking etc. Even as said on this thread by a few people they don't wear a hat riding sometimes. However for most people it is either because they are uneducated, or don't think, or have a moment of stupidity (we all have those I'm sure).
However I do feel that if you make an "informed choice" not to wear a hat when you fully acknowledge the dangers and risks to your life by doing so, then yes I would describe that as selfish (i.e not considering others in their actions) as well as foolish. In the same way as someone who knowingly gets in their car and "chooses" to speed even though they know full well the dangers of doing so, is selfish.

Quote "There's no excuse really, but hey-ho, I'm an adult and all that." That does sound incredibly 'couldn't care less', so that is what I responded to, as well as to try and persuade you to wear a hat :)

Quote "Personally, I'm of the opinion that it's down to the individual's choice" .
Unfortunately I do disagree with this one. If we all chose to do what we wanted with no regard for others would we all be wearing no seatbelts, all be driving far too fast. Unfortunately we do need rules and regulations (such as the seatbelt laws and speed limits) in order to protect ourselves and others from our own actions. Because none of us are perfect......................

I don't want this to be a personal attack on anyone and I know I've used your quotes above Deirdre, but only because that is all I have to go on, to answer/justify my opinion. And because I think you've taken the question of hat-wearing out of context. To compare it with women wearing heels.......:confused: Well one might get a broken ankle I suppose. But that is nothing compared to a head injury I promise you. And just for arguments sake, if it was shown that wearing high heels increased your mortality, it was a well known fact, and a girlie thought to herself "I don't care what happens to me I'm going to wear these shoes, it's my choice" - again I would suggest that was being selfish. I think it's the perception here. I'm heavily anti-smoking, but I wouldn't tell someone I thought they were selfish for smoking. As with riding-hats, often it's a "it'll never happen to me" "I don't believe it's harmful" or even just plain ignorance etc etc (and addiction of course). However, if I was in conversation with someone who said to me "I know the risks, I know the dangers to myself and others, but it's my choice to smoke", then I would suggest to them that they consider those around them and that they are being selfish in their actions.

I think everyone who doesn't wear a riding hat should consider wearing one; if NOT for themselves, then for others at least. As Ilostmymarbles said - a head injury is an awful thing to witness a loved one with.

I'm not going to reply to this thread anymore, because I don't want it to get into an argument between us and because I don't want to upset anyone, and I think things are getting a little out of context here.

I meant no harm to anyone and I'm sorry if you felt it was a personal attack on you Dierdre.
Unfortunately it's a subject many people feel strongly about - but usually with the right motives i.e to stop unecessary injury or death.
 
OK Harvey - no worries.

I think it's the perception here. I'm heavily anti-smoking, but I wouldn't tell someone I thought they were selfish for smoking.
As with riding-hats, often it's a "it'll never happen to me"
Compared to most smokers who smoke whilst thinking . . .
"this gives me lung cancer this does. . . " ?????????????
I'm sorry - I completely miss your point with that particular argument.

But as you said yourself, it's a matter of perception I suppose (and as a smoker myself I'm pleased to hear you wouldn't tell someone I thought they were selfish for smoking. lol).
As for taking it out of context with the heels thing - I disagree, I obviously didn't mean that one as a full-on-serious-example :rolleyes: , but I still believe it was relevant. You disagree - cool, no problem.
Like I said before. . . "we're never going to agree. . ." I'm afraid I still stick by my own opinions, same as you stick by yours.
All's supposed to be fair in love and war etc lol ;) .

Can't really think of anymore to say on the matter.

But it's been interesting to read yours and everyone elses points of view.
Must get back to work now - if I get sacked for debating safety merits I'm blaming you and everyone else who disagrees with me :p ;) .
 
Last edited:
Afellpony said:
What is this cowboy thing anyway?

Good question. It is the "spirit of the west" that it took to get this country (USA) up and running- independance, courage, hard work, willingness to take chances, a strong streak of stubborness, and respect for others with the same attitude.

When it comes to helmets, it fits in as "I'll be d****ed if I am going to wear such a girlie thing!" Although the 'west was won' a long time ago, the attitude lingers in the pioneers descendants. There is a strong undercurrent of "this is the way it has always been done, and if it was good enough for grandpa, it's good enough for me!"

When we rode in the 4th of July parade, my children and I, along with one other rider, wore the only helmets. 4 out of 30 or so- and at least one of them an RI. We will be going on a competitive ride next week, and like last year, will be in the minority when it comes to helmets- only endurance riders seem to wear them regularly. Yes, we occasionally feel a little peculiar and out of place, and we have had more than one disparaging comment, but I feel we are being examples for those who have not made up their minds yet on the subject- and it also lets people know that helmets are available.

Contrary to what is here (NR) common knowledge, a lot of people in the west don't know that helmets exist for horseback riding. Bicycle, rapelling, motorcross, whitewater rafting, snowboarding all have helmets specific to their sport, but many people never think of riding as a dangerous sport (!). Neither of our local riding supply stores even carry helmets!! We have to get ours through catalogs.

We are doing our best to make a little dent into the attitudes of riders in this part of the world:)
 
Greentchr said:
We are doing our best to make a little dent into the attitudes of riders in this part of the world:)

Yes we are.:) Is one even allowed to wear a helmet into a western pleasure class? I don't know, never seen it happen.

How can anyone say riding without a helmet is selfish? We have several nationwide motorcycle rallies here each year, and SC has no helmet law. I can't tell you how great a benefit the bikers confer on all those poor people waiting for organ transplants - why just this year alone we've had over a dozen sets donated by those who no longer need them.:D
 
Ride Safely "Dare to be Different"

Equestrian Helmet Facts taken from the Fact Sheet link below
http://tarlton.law.utexas.edu/dawson/amea/feb00nws.htm#fact

Fact # 4. The most common reason among riders for admission to hospital and death are head injuries.
:eek: Fact # 5: A fall from two feet (60 cm) can cause permanent brain damage. A horse elevates a rider eight feet or more above ground.
:eek: Fact # 6: A human skull can be shattered by an impact of 4-6 mph (7-10 kph). Horses can gallop at 41 mph (65 kph).

My daughter has always worn a helmet when riding and will be riding on the Stock Seat Team in College this year and unfortunately the coach requires the riders to wear a cowboy hat during competitions. She has reluctantly purchased a cowboy hat, and i will keep my fingers crossed. I am sure she would perform better and be more comfortable in a helmet. I made her english helmet look western, (see how below) but she hasn't had the nerve to show it to the coach, for fear of being dropped from the team, or not being choosen next year.

I wish we could change the western riders minds, I challenge them "Dare to be Different" ride with a helmet, maybe it will only take a couple people to show up in the ring with a helmet at the same time. Sometimes winning isn't as important as making a statement.

Heres how I made her english ASTM/SEI approved riding helmet look like a cowboy hat.

I bought a black Malleable Brim Helmet Shade, and attached it to a black Troxel Sierra Helmet. I than covered the velcro area where it attaches to the helmet with a black band with silver accents to cover the area where the attaches with velcro to the helmet. It looks great.
 
Last edited:
newrider.com