Riding without a helmet

Wow. Reading through those posts on the gaited horse message board gives a person the willys. There are a lot of ways to die from horse/head injuries...

I think I shall get me a brand new Troxel for Christmas:) .

I liked that quote for people who make fun of us for wearing a helmet "Thanks- I do value my brain power!" or "Just making the world a safer place, one brain at a time"

I spent way too long looking for that OSHA Trail Horse comic Anyone know of a link for it- sounds hilarious.
 
Well we have to here... its a law if you're a minor.
But even when I'm 'of age', I will still wear my helmet all the time. It doesn't really bug me.
However on the occasional super-hot day... I may take it off when I'm cooling the horse off.
 
I have to agree with Diedre as I am an adult then its my choice whether I wear my hat or not. I wear it if I am out on the roads hacking round the village and such and if there are (which there usually isn't) any children at the farm. But for bringing horses in, working in the school and lungeing then I won't. I rarely do the chin strap up either. There is a reason for this. Once when I was riding out (on a 17.2 ex racer) I had stopped to take hat off and wipe sweaty forehead, put hat back on, and then he took off as a rabbit scurried out of the hedge at his feet and scared him, we took off down the track like bats from hell! Roubnd once of the corners there was a tree branch (quite a large one as well) and my hat got caught in the branch, if I had done the chin strap up I would have been off and strangled possibley or at least a crushed windpipe, as it was the hat came off and lodged in the tree, my boss was half expecting the worst when she saw that! However we managed to stop, trot back calmly and retrieve hat! As for a BP I've never had one and never will, they really can be dangerous. One of MMs friends came off her horse, was wearing a BP and she punctured her lung thanks in part to her BP shattering. So I'm sorry if I appear 'selfish' and 'inconsiderate' but as I am an adult I can make an informed decision about whether I wear my hat or not. My family all are aware that if I suffer some horrendous injury I have made a decision to have any life support machine turned off, and they have been absolved from taking this responsibilty by me making my wishes known to my GP who has it on my medical records. If (and its a big IF) I suffer from such injuried that would mean I am literally going to be a 'vegetable' then the machine will be switched off . My mother is a retired nurse who has worled both A&E and in theatre and wholeheartedly supports the decison I made some 35 years ago wne I first started my competitive riding. As I was 3 day eventing at the time and a fall then (as now) could kill you I made my choice then and still have that today.

I'm not being selfish or irresponsible, please don't think I am, its my choice and sometimes preaching to the 'unconverted' don't work.
 
My family all are aware that if I suffer some horrendous injury I have made a decision to have any life support machine turned off, and they have been absolved from taking this responsibilty by me making my wishes known to my GP who has it on my medical records. If (and its a big IF) I suffer from such injuried that would mean I am literally going to be a 'vegetable' then the machine will be switched off .

Unfortunately not all vegetative states mean you are on life support. Plenty of people survive well enough to breathe independantly but cannot feed, dress, bath themselves. In those cases switching the machine off is not an option; but you do need 24 hour care for the rest of your natural life. :(

I do agree it's an individual's choice. My feeling is that I would not ride without; I know enough people who would have been killed without a hat on (and OH's son, who *was* killed at ten years old when a hat would have saved his life) to mean that I choose to wear one. Not that long ago I rode a horse for a friend who threw a bronking fit as soon as I mounted; I ended up on the ground. The back of my head hit teh floor first and had I not been wearing a hat I am sure (looking at the state of my hat) that I would have been sporting a failry serious head injury without it. The horse had never done that before; nobody can work out why he did it that time. Horses are unpredictable; I like to load the odds in my favour where I can!

My kids wear hats; and will do until they're 18, if they want to ride at all. After that they have to make their own choice; I hope they choose to wear one.

I also refuse to hack out with anyone who doesn't wear a hat; it's their choice not to wear it, and my choice not to ride with them. I had to sit with a girl who came off and split her head open on a hack once. She was lucky in that she came away with stitches and concussion - but it's not an experience I'd want to repeat. I have the right to make that choice; I do not have the right to denounce hatless riders as stupid or selfish. I can be just as stupid and selfish - wearing a hat doesn't change that!

I really don't like the way some people start flinging insults at those who choose not to wear a hat. It is a choice; and nobody has the right to insult anyone else who makes a choice different to their own.

I always wear gloves when working with horses; had enough nasty rope burns to make me want to prevent any more! For me, it's a sensible precaution. Doesn't make someone who chooses not to wear them any less sensible though!
 
I do not have the right to denounce hatless riders as stupid or selfish. I can be just as stupid and selfish - wearing a hat doesn't change that!
I really don't like the way some people start flinging insults at those who choose not to wear a hat. It is a choice; and nobody has the right to insult anyone else who makes a choice different to their own.

Well said :) .
 
I was alarmed to read recently that in some workplaces, you're only allowed sick pay once for injuries sustained in a dangerous sport, including riding. So if, say, you fell off and were concussed, you'd get sick pay while you recovered. If you fell off and broke your arm after that, you'd be on your own financially.

I was outraged at the time, because I don't consider what I do when riding (mostly pottering!) as dangerous. You'd be more likely to be injured doing DIY or crossing the road, in my opinion. But of course to some employers riding is dangerous, and they would consider it selfish of me to spend my weekends pootling about "at risk" of crashing to the ground, expecting them to continue to pay me while I recovered from such a fall. People have different ideas of acceptable risk, and to some people, riding AT ALL could be considered unacceptably dangerous.

I'm the only rider in my immediate family, so I can't say how I'd feel if a family member was seriously injured because they didn't put on a hat. I can imagine they'd be pretty annoyed with me if I was injured under those circumstances. But because they're my family, I feel they'd be entitled to be annoyed, because they'd be personally affected. I don't really understand feelings of annoyance against strangers who are taking what you might consider to be unacceptable risks with their safety. When I see riders without hats, especially on the roads, I get a little twinge of alarm in the back of my throat -- but I don't feel angry. It's more a feeling of "Accident waiting to happen -- I can't bear to look!"

I don't really understand why people don't wear hats. I didn't always when I was younger, but since then I have fallen off and landed on my head, so now I always wear one. But equally, I don't understand why some people get so worked up about non-hat-wearing in the abstract, by people they don't know and will never meet.
 
I'm the only rider in my immediate family, so I can't say how I'd feel if a family member was seriously injured because they didn't put on a hat. I can imagine they'd be pretty annoyed with me if I was injured under those circumstances. But because they're my family, I feel they'd be entitled to be annoyed, because they'd be personally affected. I don't really understand feelings of annoyance against strangers who are taking what you might consider to be unacceptable risks with their safety. When I see riders without hats, especially on the roads, I get a little twinge of alarm in the back of my throat -- but I don't feel angry. It's more a feeling of "Accident waiting to happen -- I can't bear to look!"
.


That's it exactly. Sorry, but if I wanted to go without a helmet (not that I do) then I'm answerable only to myself and my family, who would really kick my butt in. I personally couldn't care less if someone else goes without a helmet except as a little "Gee, that's an accident waiting to happen. Hope they don't get hurt"-and really, seeing as how almost everyone who is in western disciplines DOES go without helmets, on the roads as well, its not as if I'm not used to seeing it.

Sorry if that's harsh, but it is their choice. Personally, I find smoking a heck of a lot worse-because not only are you damanging your own body (and there is no "maybe I'll be ok") but you're also damaging the bodies of those around you with second hand smoke.

So in the long run, wear a helmet, don't wear a helmet. It's your life to live. And you're the one who will have to live with the consequences.
 
Last edited:
It's up to each adult to decide whether they need to wear a hat or not. However, if they decide not to wear a hat and have a nasty accident, then it's the poor old NHS (which I'm paying into) that has to pick up the pieces.
If peeps wanna play look at me I dont need to wear a hat, I'm so cool about it - well that's up to them, please dont expect Joe Public to pay for your treatment!!!! Pay privately for your treatment when you come off and your head gets bashed on the road or wherever, then yes, you have every right to ride hatless.
 
it's the poor old NHS (which I'm paying into) that has to pick up the pieces.
Pay privately for your treatment when you come off and your head gets bashed


I assume then that you always wear a hat when handling your horse from the ground?
I can think of numerous people who think riding is in itself too big a risk to take. Never mind risk-management, they believe choosing to hop onto a horse is risk enough.
Very few "hat-wearers" are so evenagelical about wearing a helmet whilst grooming, catching, leading and feeding their horse. But a well placed kick, or a sudden spook is easily enough to trample a person's head.

And personally, I sometimes get a bit fed up of my taxes helping those who. . . smoke/ drink excessively/ don't eat five fruit and veg a day/ wear very high heels (thus breaking their ankle and taking up valuable casualty time and resources)/ are obese/ are underweight/ get themselves involved with drugs and solvents . . . the list could go on and on really :cool: .

But that's life and it's their right to live as they choose :) . I'm not perfect - no doubt I do things the NHS could do without helping me with (such as riding in general) - so I don't feel I'm in a position to say "pay for your treatment privately!"
 
I am by NO means saying don't wear hats, but IMHO the risk / impact is to a degree "transferred" (can't think of a better word here) - if you have bad fall, your skull may be protected but your cervical spine may take the force. Even a body protector can't help all the way up. Hence Reeve's injuries for example. And from my nursing experience, I personally am not sure I'd want to stay alive in his state of extreme total paralysis; unable scratch your nose, breath independently, tube fed, urinary catheters, manual evacuation of bowels, pressure sores, chest infections / pneumonia, spasticity of muscles, etc. I'd rather be unconscious within seconds then goodbye folks.
)

Unfortunately, we don't get the choice. It would be nice if we could tick the boxes - OK for instant death, not OK for paralysis - but it doesn't work like that, does it.



Because it's your job, and you get paid for it, so stop the holier than thou attitude. Dierdre is an adult, and as an adult can make informed decisions.....

Well yes. But If my children or my husband decided to ride without a hat I'd be very upset indeed. To me, an informed decision means weighing up the risks and coming to a decision. If Dierdre or anyone else decides she's not likely to fall of her horse, and the horse isn't likely to spook or stumble, well that's her decision. It's up to her and the people who care about her.


None of the commercial barns around here require adults to wear a helmet on a trail ride...in fact I know of at least two which don't require kids to wear them either. Like I said before, safety just isn't the hot button issue in the USA that it is in the UK. Maybe this is because of the popularity of western riding over here? I know that in western pleasure classes I never see any of the competitors in helmets, just cowboy hats. Ditto barrel racing and pole bending...even in the high school rodeos I never see any of the riders in helmets, let alone body protectors.


There's obviously a huge cultural difference between the UK and the US about hats, like there is about guns. But stables where they do Western riding here generally provide hats that look like cowboy hats, but are actually built round riding hats.
 
Yes, I do always wear a hat when handling Falcon from the ground. I'm one of those NHS workers just trying to keep themselves out of hospital (although I work in one)! Anyway, the above is a clause in my insurance policy so really I'm obliged to wear a hat while handling my ponyo!
 
Very few "hat-wearers" are so evenagelical about wearing a helmet whilst grooming, catching, leading and feeding their horse. But a well placed kick, or a sudden spook is easily enough to trample a person's head.

I have to admit I don't think of that most of the time. And just to prove how inconsistent and hypocritical I am, I do, however, insist that my kids are hatted any time they come down and handle the ponies.

They have their lessons with a girl who is 9 or 10; 3 years ago this girl was in a coma in hospital and not expected to survive, let alone make a full recovery, after their ponies spooked in the field and trampled her.

Guess why my kids handle with hats on!!

(And why on earth don't I? Can't answer that one.)
 
I'm one of those NHS workers just trying to keep themselves out of hospital (although I work in one)!

I don't think anyone's going to be converted one way or another here :D .

I can only refer back to my previous statement in answer to that. . .

personally, I sometimes get a bit fed up of my taxes helping those who. . . smoke/ drink excessively/ don't eat five fruit and veg a day/ wear very high heels (thus breaking their ankle and taking up valuable casualty time and resources)/ are obese/ are underweight/ get themselves involved with drugs and solvents . . . the list could go on and on really .

But that's life and it's their right to live as they choose . I'm not perfect - no doubt I do things the NHS could do without helping me with (such as riding in general) - so I don't feel I'm in a position to say "pay for your treatment privately!"


But it's interesting to hear all the different takes on the subject ;) .
 
I couldn't imagine riding without a hat, its second nature to me to put one on my head before I get on. Every riding establishment I have ever been at has insisted on their clients wearing a hat while riding, and I have seen one of the liveries at my yard getting an utter bollocking from our YO because she got on her horse in the outdoor school without a hat on.

I would never, under any circumstances, ride without a hat. No matter how well behaved a horse is, it can still slip and fall, or spook, and you just have to fall the wrong way once for it be the last time you get to ride. It's just not worth it in my opinon.
 
Yes it is interesting. Each one has their different views and it's interesting reading them. I guess it's each to their own I suppose!

Quite :) .
 
Guess why my kids handle with hats on!!

(And why on earth don't I? Can't answer that one.)


Could it be because we're a bit more experienced than the kids, and know to keep an eye on the horse and keep out of the way of a possible kick? :rolleyes:



I have been knocked down a few times by spooked or bargy horses, but fortunately not hurt, and now I'm careful never to be between them a horse and the rest of the herd, even though we don't have barging and knocking-over any more (touch wood!).
 
I assume then that you always wear a hat when handling your horse from the ground?
I can think of numerous people who think riding is in itself too big a risk to take. Never mind risk-management, they believe choosing to hop onto a horse is risk enough.
Very few "hat-wearers" are so evenagelical about wearing a helmet whilst grooming, catching, leading and feeding their horse. But a well placed kick, or a sudden spook is easily enough to trample a person's head.


In all the time I've been around horses, I've fallen off more times than I can remember, but I can count on the fingers of one hand the times I've been knocked over or kicked by a horse when I was on the ground. So riding is a lot more risky than handling a horse on the ground.

I do wear gloves and a hat for lunging, though, if it's likely to get exciting.


Linda
 
Could it be because we're a bit more experienced than the kids, and know to keep an eye on the horse and keep out of the way of a possible kick? :rolleyes:


Doesn't alter the fact that they are, still, unpredictable however much we think we can see things coming.

I had a gelding run past me in the field one day; lashed out (in play, at another horse, nothing malicious) with both hind legs and missed my head by inches. One hind foot caught my shoulder, knocked me flat on my back in front of the horse he was playing with; who luckily for me jumped clear over me.

I've never had a *serious* injury around horses; not even a broken bone, which is probably fairly miraculous in 25 years of being around them. But I've had more near misses than I can count. Maybe it's more complacency with me than anything. :rolleyes: :o
 
Well... At our yard, everyone has to wear a hat to ride or catch. However, I do break this rule, and I'm not the only one. I wear one to ride nearly all the time, and most of the occasions I haven't have been accidents, like when I left my hat on the yard gate. If I forget/loose my hat, I usually borrow one of the kids hats to ride in, its quite easy to find one to fit. Anything can happen while I'm on a horse/pony, I always wear one on a horse I don't trust 100%. I have got on horses and thought 'oh f*** the hat!' before, but now I know it's only a matter of time before something does happen, so it's not something I do a lot, that would be tempting fate!

With the handling, it's a different story... I never wear one in the stable, unless I'm pulling mane/tail of or clipping a horse I don't know, or one that's unpredictable. Others on the yard wear them to groom and tack up, even to carry water buckets. We're supposed to wear them to leadrein, but the older ones are usually excepted from this, so I don't. We're also supposed to wear them to catch, but if I can't find mine, its not my priority, unless again I don't trust the horse, and I do trust most of ours. Only yesterday I was catching/turning out without one. Stupid I know...

Don't wear my body protector for anything other than xc and hacking, unless its compulsory at a show (or my mums in worry mode). Don't like them, again, it's stupid but its my choice...
 
newrider.com