Riding without a helmet

raingodz said:
Is there not legal/insurance pressures to wear a riding hat in the USA in riding schools? In the UK the riding schools would probably be closed down if the let people ride with out riding hats.

Cross-posted, sorry.:) Insurance? Schools have insurance where you live?;)

We have equine liability immunity laws - schools can't be sued except in very limited circumstances.
 
Yes, and in the USA motorcyclists are not required by law to wear helmets if they are over the age of 18 but they must wear eye protection (goggles or sunglasses) ! Yes, those Oakley's are definitely going to save you when you wipe out at 60 mph.... I think we Americans tend to have an "it won't happen to me" attitude, which I heard also contributed to Christopher Reeve's accident....
 
Goes and stands with Appy in the naughty corner! Actually the one time I was wearing a hat ,with the chin strap undone, it saved my life! My horse bolted as we were taking a breather, and my hat became stuck in a tree branch. If I had done my chin strap back up I would have been choked or had my neck broken, as it was it came off easily and I stayed on horse, luckily no damage done to either of us that day. But I shudder to think I could have been injured.
 
I always ride with my hat on. I've not worn it once in my whole life! It felt really weird having the wind in my hair while on a horse :D

I don't think I've ever come close to damaging my head either on, off, or falling off a horse - but it only takes that one time to stove your head in. I don't think my family would ever let me ride without one anyway - my dad's cousin died in a fall whilst showjumping, and so his side of the family think riding is super-dangerous and would have kittens if they thought I rode without a hat.
 
Peace said:
Cross-posted, sorry.:) Insurance? Schools have insurance where you live?;)

We have equine liability immunity laws - schools can't be sued except in very limited circumstances.


Oh, but in the US people file lawsuits all the time and believe me a school can be sued even if there are liability laws. It's like flinging a bucket of mud - toss it out and see where it sticks... some may escape but usually there's one or two people standing with mud on them and the lawyers start circling (and racking up fees).
 
Hanamoon said:
Yes, and in the USA motorcyclists are not required by law to wear helmets if they are over the age of 18 but they must wear eye protection (goggles or sunglasses) ! Yes, those Oakley's are definitely going to save you when you wipe out at 60 mph.... I think we Americans tend to have an "it won't happen to me" attitude, which I heard also contributed to Christopher Reeve's accident....

Motorcycle laws vary from state to state.:) You don't need either a helmet or eye protection here. Wonder if that has anything to do with all the bikers who get killed every year at our motorcycle rallies at the beach?:rolleyes:

But as I understand it, Christopher Reeve was just eventing. Of course, that may be considered kind of suicidal by some.:D His horse put in a dirty stop and he was thrown, landing on the back of his neck.
 
Hanamoon said:
Oh, but in the US people file lawsuits all the time and believe me a school can be sued even if there are liability laws. It's like flinging a bucket of mud - toss it out and see where it sticks... some may escape but usually there's one or two people standing with mud on them and the lawyers start circling (and racking up fees).

Ok, I should have said "can't be held liable." But that amounts to the same thing, really. Personal injury lawyers don't generally get fees if they don't win - and with an equine immunity statute few are willing to take on a lawsuit against a riding school. Too much of a slam-dunk for the defense - it would never get to trial, unless there'd been demonstrable and specific gross negligence.
 
raingodz said:
This sounds the wrong way round to me, surly the school should be in a postition or responsibility to promote safty?

I understand your point. You should see what some of our riding schools get away with!:eek:

But our legislature has declared a policy of promoting and protecting the equine industry and believe leaving riding schools, or any equine activity sponsor, open to suit would have a deleterious effect on the industry.
 
Peace - South Carolina sounds more like the Wild, Wild West than Texas!
No helmets, no goggles, no lawsuits? you all must believe in personal responsibility!!
It's practically un-American!
;)
 
Hanamoon said:
Peace - South Carolina sounds more like the Wild, Wild West than Texas!

LOL - hence the reason for my signature line. Although the guy who said it was talking about our departure from the United States, I've always felt that comment pretty much summed up the mindset around here.:D
 
Last edited:
I always ride with one, but am guilty of driving without one.

But had a salutory lesson yesterday with driving two younger horses. Maybe when driving youngsters I shall always wear my hat.
 
Okay, one more post and then I stop... Peace, I just saw that you are an attorney - please don't think I have anything against the law profession. My husband used to practice personal injury law (but I married him anyway!) :D
 
Being neurotic at heart, I always wear my hat to ride.

But I also think that we have to weigh up risks and accept that they cannot all be eliminated, in the horseworld.

By text books, we should also all wear hats to lead / handle / pick-out etc; I fall guilty of not doing this. Do others?

I am by NO means saying don't wear hats, but IMHO the risk / impact is to a degree "transferred" (can't think of a better word here) - if you have bad fall, your skull may be protected but your cervical spine may take the force. Even a body protector can't help all the way up. Hence Reeve's injuries for example. And from my nursing experience, I personally am not sure I'd want to stay alive in his state of extreme total paralysis; unable scratch your nose, breath independently, tube fed, urinary catheters, manual evacuation of bowels, pressure sores, chest infections / pneumonia, spasticity of muscles, etc. I'd rather be unconscious within seconds then goodbye folks.

Don't mean to sound gloomy, but I think we keep adding "safeguards" to such sports, then winge when people get different injuries. We have to accept the increased danger, or not do it.

An analogy - look at the difference air bags make to surving RTAs. Is it now irresponsible to drive old cars without airbags? Where do we draw the line? I think we're trying to shift into a society where all risk is controlled - not possible.

IMHO, take measures to reduce risk by all means, but accept that there's a limit and other risks still remain. (rant over, climbs off soapbox - sorry wasn't meant to be this long)
 
Peace said:
Cross-posted, sorry.:) Insurance? Schools have insurance where you live?;)

We have equine liability immunity laws - schools can't be sued except in very limited circumstances.

Exactly. At my yard my YO actually took two ten-year-old boys out on a hack and none of them wore helmets. :eek: The boys' dad was along and he didn't wear a helmet either; it's just not taken into consideration much here for some reason. Before taking lessons or going on a commercial hack you have to sign a release form--parents sign for their kids--which basically states that you take a risk by riding and you cannot sue the horse owner for any injuries you might receive.

Honestly, I do try to remember my helmet. I started riding as an adult and was always extremely careful about it--especially when I first got Sugar and she was going through her issues. But I've started backsliding. Part of it is probably because I trust my horse so much that it no longer makes me feel unsafe to be without a helmet (yes, I know that's no excuse!) and part of it is just picking up the habits of those around me. :o

I'm not encouraging anyone to go without a helmet don't get me wrong! I know it's unsafe. I was just wondering who else besides me does it. :rolleyes:
 
Amazing, isn't it? My YO insists all children wear helmets, but I think that's because it's a hunter/jumper barn and they're going to have to show in them anyway. But I know loads of barns, especially western ones (which is what most lesson barns here are) with no helmet requirements at all.
 
Sadly most of the people I know don't wear helmets when they ride. Of course a helmet won't protect from every possible type of injury, but it is a simple thing to do, and the statistics do show significant reductions in traumatic brain injuries. It's like wearing a seat belt in a car--won't always save your life, but it does offer significant protection. In recent years, motorcycle helmet laws in a number of states have been repealed due to voter pressure, resulting in demonstrable increases in deaths and serious brain injuries.

Anyway, AFAIK, in California, helmets are legally required for under 18's when biking or riding scooters or skateboards, but not for riding. The riding schools I've been to require them for under 18's, but not for adults. I'm not sure if this is an insurance requirement, or just what the schools feel they can do.

In 10 years of riding I've only had two falls (knock on wood!). Both times I wrecked helmets. The second one I hit hard enough to crack the helmet in half, and I still had concussion. Would have had a skull fracture for sure. Otherwise I was uninjured except for a few bruises (and I didn't land on my head, I rolled, and it snapped back). So, I wear mine...
 
newrider.com