"NH" and "Traditional" Methods

Yes but it could be argued that it is a difference only between two peoples approaches and not the methods that they use, ie another BHS or traditional minded person could well have other options that they would use to resolve the issue rather than get around it. :)

Sometimes I think it's as much a difference between peoples personalities as it is the method used. :)

(my bold and my italics)

A truer statement was never made.

In addition, I think that it is very sad that some people seem feel that they need to be told to look at things from the horse's POV. I was always under the impression that this would be one of the first actions of any thinking human who is, or who becomes, closely involved with a member of another species through their own volition.
 
Fair point, but I've been in the BHS world for long enough to know that the 'get the job done' approach is far from unusual. While the 'why is this happening, and how can I sort it out' approach is not really taught. At least not to me. I have another friend who is a BHSAI. I approach her for advice at times. Most recently when my colt was planting his feet on his way to the field. Her immediate response was to tell me to tie a lunge line round his back end. NOT to ask me any questions that might acertain WHY he has started planting feet. It just didn't seem to occur to her to wonder why. Or to regard the WHY question as relevant.

I agree, I have seen a lot of it too. When you are a complete novice owner like me it is really quite hard to see the wood for the trees at times, specially when you are surrounded by only this type of advice from people who have owned horses their whole lives, and with the best will in the World are trying to "help" you - I know this from experience! :)

If it were not for this forum and varied posts and advice I would still be listening to a lot of it because I didn't know any different. I am glad I have this forum, because from it I have learned so much and it has actually given me the confidence to question and ultimately ignore some of the advice that is thrown my way at every opportunity from others on the yard, and to learn to read the signs from my horse and make my own decisions about what to do with him and what is in his best interests.

I think the myth I disagree with the most about any NH approach is that people think you are "soft" when in reality a lot of the groundwork etc that I have done has now gained me the total respect of my horse, and I lead and he follows! :)
 
(my bold and my italics)

A truer statement was never made.

In addition, I think that it is very sad that some people seem feel that they need to be told to look at things from the horse's POV. I was always under the impression that this would be one of the first actions of any thinking human who is, or who becomes, closely involved with a member of another species through their own volition.

Thank you. It is sad, and it's what always niggled me and why I couldn't bring myself to follow some of the advice, I KNEW some of it wasn't right, but then I didn't have the knowledge to know what was. I am learning now though, and long may it continue!

A good example of the personality issue in the humans. My friends daughter has a pony, which can be a biter. He threatens to bite all the time, watching him it is through fear, he is just putting his point across first. My friend is rather "reactionary" so pony threatens, she shouts and then he threatens and tries for the bite, at which point she will hit him, throw water in his face or some such thing to punish him. When I handle this pony (which I started to do just as an experiment for myself), when he threatens me, I don't back down, but I don't shout either. I reassure him, his ears come forward and we are all friends, so much so he now very very rarely puts his ears back with me, but it is a daily occurence with my friend.

To me, that isn't the horses personality that is at fault, it's the people! :)
 
To me, that isn't the horses personality that is at fault, it's the people!
Although just like between people, you can get a horse personality and a human personality that just clash :) I'm pretty sure there are compatible people and horses, just like human partners... I suspect if I'd profiled me and my horse, we wouldn't have been compatible - but we are learning to live with each other's foibles!

For me, it's a case of working out how horses behave, and then testing what either NH or traditional thinking says about how to deal with things. If it agrees or seems to work with what I've learned about horse behaviour, I'll use it. If it doesn't, I won't.

A lot of the things described above work - so the lead rope around the nose etc. will work... but my other "inner voice" question is: do the ends justify the means? I would rather a less effective or less quick solution that worked with the horse's nature, rather than a quick or effective solution that left me with another problem to overcome. So the lead rope over the nose will overcome the problem quickly, but won't teach the horse what I want or that doing what I ask is a good thing :)
 
For Krissie I

1) teach him to respect my personal space and to lead on a loose lead rope

2) when he tried to drive me away from a field lick I stood my ground and drove him away instead with a lead rope and very aggressive body language. Kept him back away from me so he was circling me. When he backed down I relaxed my posture, then invited him in. He did not make any effort to eat until I let him. Since then we have had no food issues. I have continued working on aggresion around food by making him back away from me if I approach with food, grooming him while he's feeding and basically doing what I please with his food.

3) Neither

4) Both

5) teach him to stand.


But I agree, difference in personality not training.

Also I used to know someone who spent her whole time looking at it from the horses point of view. Evaluating why it had done this, why had it done that etc etc, how should she respond etc etc. I found myself saying to her your spending so much time wondering and evaluating that you don't enjoy your horse!! Also she could never react to a situation that needed an instant response. She had to stand back and question everything!! What did she do wrong? What did she say wrong? Why didn't the horse understand? The horse got away with naughty things and didnt get praise when it was actually needed. Like I said though, theres always the extremes.
 
I think that it is very sad that some people seem feel that they need to be told to look at things from the horse's POV. I was always under the impression that this would be one of the first actions of any thinking human who is, or who becomes, closely involved with a member of another species through their own volition.

You're right - it is sad. I often wonder why I needed this pointing out to me. I wish I had, at 8 or 10 or 12 or 16 or 20 thought 'hang on a minute, what does the horse make of all of this'. But I didn't. And no-one around me did either. And those people tasked with making a horse-woman out of me did not regard this as an important part of my education!

Your post somewhat misses my point though. My BHS friends DO understand horses. But frankly they just want to get the job done. They want to lead the horse to a field, or get it tacked up or get on one way or another. And saying 'that's to do with their personality' ignores the fact that this approach is the norm, at least in my experience. Very few owners (let alone non-horse owning riders totally dependent on riding schools) have a problem solving rather than a get the horse to do what I want mentality. Michael Peace makes the point that most owners lose patience with a horse who won't load after about 3 minutes. They just want their horse inside the bloomin trailer. Now!
 
Like others' have pointed out, under BHS/traditional etc you are not directed to look at things from the horses' point of view. I now think that is sad.

Sorry thats the sort of misinformation that really anoys me, for BHS thats probbaly true for most but if people really think that about traditional it shows how little they know about it, which is a huge shame as it cover 100's of years of scientific study of 1,000,000's of horses across europe.
 
Last edited:
I'd love to meet all these BHS/traditional people who go along totally ignoring their horses.

I do know plenty of people who treat their horses differently from how I treat mine, both NH and those who follow other schools.

It's not the school of thought that determines how you treat your horse it's how you are.
 
How did he train the horse for this stunt? :confused: I would love to hear some specifics on the methods and concepts used.:)

Keep on, keepin on

Jack

It was a while ago but as i remember it, it was based on trust and the relationship built up over years but in adition they practiced.

They marked out 12ft then practised galloping along and jumping 12ft.

Then they made up a jetty, and galloped along it and jumped of the end.

That was the prep for the jump, but they also did lots of normal stuff reinforcing the trust that allowed the rider to ask and the horse do it without question.

I've been trying to find the clip or anything about the stunt but without success so far :o but i do remmeber it was interesting :)
 
I KNOW that excellent horsemanship has existed since time immemorial, but most ordinary people don't have it! What they do have, however is the BHS. It's all very well saying Trad doesn't equal BHS, but unless you are lucky enough to know someone with traditional horsemanship skills who can teach you, you are stuck with the BHS, which does NOT imo, teach horsemanship.

I don’t think it’s unfair to say Traditional is not BHS any more than saying NH is not Parelli.

I don’t have access to PP, MR, Mark Rashid, Curt Pate etc, doesn’t mean my only option is BHS, a huge amount is available with the modern media if people choose to look or are aware of the options.

And that is one of the problems imo lack of awareness, for example the Classical Riding section of this forum is dead, occasionally some Dressage pretending to be Classical but that’s about it and there is so much in it the NH people would love, I’m not saying it’s perfect but there is defiantly a cross over of values and attitudes.
 
Using the example of light hands. I obviously don't want to be causing my horse any pain, but how do I cope with "light" and then "even lighter" in my situation.

As said a few posts back, he is very fussy with a bit and will not so much fidget but throw his head down to the ground. At the moment what I try to do is "block" that head throw every time he does it and then release. Is that wrong? How would I do this with a light and then even lighter contact?

Can’t comment if what your doing is right or wrong but I can try explain light hands as it was to me.

You have a light contact on the reins, then for some reason the horse drops his head or waves it around in shall we say resistance to what your doing\asking, you maintain the same pressure on the reins by moving your hands with the movement of the horse, once the horse stops moving his head and it is in the position you are asking for/had it you take a little pressure off (this may mean taking off all of the pressure in the beginning to be clear or because you contact is so light it’s the only place to go) as a signal/communication that’s where you want the horse to have it’s head.

You will then put the light pressure you have all the time back on because that is the place the reward/communication comes from.

That and the statement “Your horse has to trust your hands” helped me.

It’s not easy to explain and it’s even harder to do and that’s the reason you can find more NH in Traditional than NH imo, NH in it’s current form is mostly about amateurs with problems and the priority is to be effective (If it works and is not unkind to the horse that’s good enough for 99.9% of the people) and due to the modern pace of life get quick results.

If you look at some of the traditional stuff it’s not sport or work it’s an art and is a life time in it’s pursuit so if something takes longer it’s not a problem, that’s not for 99.9% of the people but that does not mean it does not exist or is not out there if you want it/can afford the time, if it’s for a person or not it’s still inspirational to watch.

Anyway time for me to shut up for a long time :)
 
Last edited:
You're right - it is sad. ...

Your post somewhat misses my point though. My BHS friends DO understand horses. But frankly they just want...

I don't believe that I stated or implied that any one school of thought or training 'understood' horse less or more than another. Indeed I would not, as a lack of thought and understanding - or at least a deficiency in the quality of thought, discussion and debate around practice - is all too common in equestrian practice today, be those practitioners old school or new age or a mixture of the two.

One thing to bear in mind, though, is that although the BHS may appear to promote itself as a venerable and traditional institution, it's no great shakes in reality. It's not even as old as I am!

The BHS had no part in the development of equestrian traditions, just a debatable one on maintaining and codifying a few of them in difficult post-WW2 conditions, when the majority of people thought the day of the horse was over for good, and there was no conception as to just how the leisure industries - and with them the horse - would develop and expand, encompassing all sectors of society.
 
India, I have the DVD with PP riding a horse into a moving trailer, and I thought it was awful, put me off straight away. He doesn't just ride it in, but grabs the roof of the trailer and hauls himself off the horse so it ends up on it's own. Seems like a lot of risk just to make himself look big. If you want the DVD (it's just a free one I sent off for from the website), I can always mail you it, don't need it anymore.

I'm a Monty Roberts girl myself ;)
 
Very few owners (let alone non-horse owning riders totally dependent on riding schools) have a problem solving rather than a get the horse to do what I want mentality.

I think that to a greater or lesser extent is the 'vs.' in a nutshell.
 
I don’t think it’s unfair to say Traditional is not BHS any more than saying NH is not Parelli.

And that is one of the problems imo lack of awarenesss.

Sorry Chilli. I didn't mean to imply it was unfair. It's a very very good point. I am forever saying PNH doesn't = nh which is the same sort of distinction. However my point (and yours?) is that the BHS is basically all that most people are aware of.... It is the leading organisation for horse riding in Britain, and most riding schools are BHS approved. Most instructors wanting a career in horses will go down the BHS stages route.

Of course other information is out there, but you need to go looking for it and there is no accreditation for 'alternative' practitioners, to help people who might want to look for another type of instruction or approach.

The OP was looking at trad vs nh. Maybe we need to be clearer in all these definitions: clearly separating out nh from PNH and trad from BHS. We need a new language!!

My experience on the ground remains: being human centric (how can I make my horse do.....) is far more common than being horse centred (why might my horse be doing...) and so however we choose to define the differences, these differences in perspective and approach are real.
 
there is so much in it the NH people would love, I’m not saying it’s perfect but there is defiantly a cross over of values and attitudes.

I'm sure you're right. Can you recommend a good introductory book?
 
Sorry Chilli. I didn't mean to imply it was unfair. It's a very very good point. I am forever saying PNH doesn't = nh which is the same sort of distinction. However my point (and yours?) is that the BHS is basically all that most people are aware of.... It is the leading organisation for horse riding in Britain, and most riding schools are BHS approved. Most instructors wanting a career in horses will go down the BHS stages route.

Of course other information is out there, but you need to go looking for it and there is no accreditation for 'alternative' practitioners, to help people who might want to look for another type of instruction or approach.

The OP was looking at trad vs nh. Maybe we need to be clearer in all these definitions: clearly separating out nh from PNH and trad from BHS. We need a new language!!

My experience on the ground remains: being human centric (how can I make my horse do.....) is far more common than being horse centred (why might my horse be doing...) and so however we choose to define the differences, these differences in perspective and approach are real.

I think this is quite true. A lot of people coming into riding and horse ownership for the first time come through the riding school system, which as you quite rightly point out means that they will more than likely have been trained by BHS instructors. I think it is also true that to even run a riding school the proprietors have to be BHS qualified? I'm sure there are alternative schools in some areas teaching different methods but they will be few and far between. This is exactly how I fell into horse ownership, with the only knowledge or anything alternative being the programmes on Sky on NH, ie Monty Roberts and Pirelli. Maybe that's why so many people think that NH = one of these methods. These programmes served their purpose in so much as they made me question certain methods and look for alternatives when things were not working.

I have gained most of my info though from NR - it's been very useful! :)

Possibly what is needed are more alternative type riding schools, BHS does seem to have a strangle hold on them at the moment!
 
newrider.com