Hmm it's difficult. Personally I like NR because I like the feeling of a small forum, I like the fact that I can look at the New Posts list and recognise every username, I like that feeling of familiarity and recognition. In real life I am nervous with strangers and in big groups but much more open and chatty when there's less people around, and I suppose that carries over into forums too - I would be less keen to go into detail about certain things if I knew there were 200 strangers reading about it. But I do agree with SJP that we need to actively encourage new members or this forum will just go down the drain! I like it small but not THIS small and would love it to be a bit busier.
I didn't think it was cliquey either and I am normally the type who would pick up on that
I wouldn't say there are enough active members for there to be an "in crowd", IMO either you are an active poster or you're not, and it's quite obvious that people who post more will become more chummy with each other - because we "know" each other better. Of course if people only post occasionally then they are bound to miss out on things and feel isolated - but I would have hoped that that was incentive for them to post MORE often, not less? Also I hear there is a lot of discussion on the NR Facebook group (I wouldn't know, I'm not in it) so maybe someone off this thread could post in there and try to encourage people to share more on the forum. I think it's a shame people are posting a lot on there but not in here. I also think it's a shame the Facebook group is private and invite-only, if that isn't isolating people then I don't know what is...
I didn't think it was cliquey either and I am normally the type who would pick up on that