New Subs

Hmm it's difficult. Personally I like NR because I like the feeling of a small forum, I like the fact that I can look at the New Posts list and recognise every username, I like that feeling of familiarity and recognition. In real life I am nervous with strangers and in big groups but much more open and chatty when there's less people around, and I suppose that carries over into forums too - I would be less keen to go into detail about certain things if I knew there were 200 strangers reading about it. But I do agree with SJP that we need to actively encourage new members or this forum will just go down the drain! I like it small but not THIS small and would love it to be a bit busier.

I didn't think it was cliquey either and I am normally the type who would pick up on that :confused: I wouldn't say there are enough active members for there to be an "in crowd", IMO either you are an active poster or you're not, and it's quite obvious that people who post more will become more chummy with each other - because we "know" each other better. Of course if people only post occasionally then they are bound to miss out on things and feel isolated - but I would have hoped that that was incentive for them to post MORE often, not less? Also I hear there is a lot of discussion on the NR Facebook group (I wouldn't know, I'm not in it) so maybe someone off this thread could post in there and try to encourage people to share more on the forum. I think it's a shame people are posting a lot on there but not in here. I also think it's a shame the Facebook group is private and invite-only, if that isn't isolating people then I don't know what is...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rubic
I don't go on fb so don't know about the NR group there. Perhaps as well cos if its invite only and I didn't get asked I would sulk!:p
Just kidding... I do have a life really....
 
I an one or two others have tried posting on the facebook group to encourage people to come back on the forum, but with little success unfortunately. I am not sure that the facebook group is invite only though? Darkstorm would know more than me as I believe she actually started the group on there. I think you only have to request to be added, I think the fact it is private is why people DO use it on Facebook. It seems to work for that particular media being private, but not for forums as far as I can see.

I think the suggestion of this being a cliquey forum is probably a result of a few of us attempting to post more to gee the forum up and get more activity on here. It would seem that idea has failed miserably, if it has inadvertently made us appear cliquey in some way!:rolleyes:

I actually give up now, it will sink or it will swim, my overall opinion is probably that being non subscription would revive it all but that could well change the feel and style too much for some members.

Just off to try and delete anything too private I might have posted in Sofa over the years!:p
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rubic
I agree that the forum is cliquey and recently I haven't put threads up or responded to posts in the way that I used to. It's sad in a way because I always felt very loyal to New Rider, but I now feel that I could quite happily leave the forum altogether. One problem is that when the forum is so small it is difficult for any individual comments on threads to be taken in isolation and therefore if someone isn't aware of other threads/background it can make newer members feel left out. Everyone seems to remember every single comment that every user has ever made and this makes for tiresome reading because the same things are repeated over and over again. Threads can get blurred because so often they don't stay on the topic in question, they merge into more personal discussions between members who know each other well. For the 'outsiders' this is very off putting. While us old time members may wish ourselves to be viewed as the 'New Rider Family' it does nothing to attract new members and it's inevitable that the forum will die out.

My vote is that we test the water and go subscription free for a period of say 3 months. After that 3 months we can revisit to see how it's going and if this is the way that we wish to continue. We would need an increase in moderators and some new 'forum guidelines' but I think that it's worth a try. If members are concerned about privacy, how about giving everyone 2 weeks or so to delete any threads they don't want to be made public (although I'm not sure that users can actually delete threads?). If this doesn't work, just re-introduce the subscription charge.
 
I have so far managed to delete any thread that might identify me IRL from the sofa area (good job its raining!) tomorrow I shall set to work on the other areas that I have threads that are too private for general public viewing....just in case.;)

I really am still genuinely bewildered that some regular members feel the place is cliquey? I just don't see it is a big enough forum to have that issue - surely by the smallness of the community we are just one isolated clique under the banner of NR members? I feel that we will probably find far more cliques and pockets of smaller groups forming who know each other better, in a larger community? But TBh that doesn't really concern me, it is just a reflection of real life isnt it? Within any large group there will be a splinter of people with common ground and differing views? To my mind that will actually make this forum more interesting and enjoyable to participate in.:)
 
  • Like
Reactions: joosie
I like this forum, I don't find it cliquey as such but as it's so small I can perhaps see it may look like that from an outside perspective. There are the same people posting all the time,I don't think that they are cliquey just the only active members.
Truthfully 'trolls' could come anyway for 99p and new members are going to be strangers so in effect you still won't know who is reading old threads anyway whether they have payed or not. I have seen debate on here even as a small forum, people won't always agree that's life imo. I think it's at least worth a try to give it a boost as that seems to be what most people want.
 
Given the choice, would you opt to post in the Facebook group that is free, or here where you pay.
For some the answer is obvious, that group started as everyone appeared to be on fb and wanting something free.
You could argue that split the forum up, but it just solved a problem.

Correct me if I am wrong, but we have been subs four years and have only just got an upgrade. I realise this takes time and money, but with our subs and advertising for some four years was too long a wait.
People found uploading photos a problem, they left. Now we have lost tapatalk.

As its called New Rider, it was originally aimed at beginners, novice, new riders. Maybe none of us belong here then. I really can't get my head around the cliques. If you dont post or join in how can say we are in groups?

Eta-it says we have 15 thousand members, that's obviously not true. The main page is about starting out, riding schools, tips, guides etc. Seriously I do wonder if we should be moving on?
 
Last edited:
I like the idea of a sub section or free cafe, I'm surprised to learn the collecting ring is the sub only bit at the moment (maybe I got that wrong) I thought the chatty cafe would be free and people wanting to get into the more structured and informative conversations would be paying, just assumes I guess.

I don't think a tenner is either here nor there, but when I google 'horse forum' NR is a good way down the page, and honestly as an experienced rider, if I've got a horsey query I wouldn't go to a forum called new rider, I know we cater to new riders but it's good to have a mix of skills and experience to learn from right?
Eta newforest think we are on the same thought there, or perhaps the site needs to reassess the target audience
 
I think the attraction of the facebook group is the very fact that it IS private. Sometimes there are things both horse related and everyday things
that you don't want your family or real life friends knowing you are concerned about. In my case if my family knew some of the horse stuff I either do or stress about, they would be worrying about me and I don't want that. (Plus the pressure would be on to give up riding!:eek:)

If we go public I shall probably save the more personal stuff for the privacy of the group and all the other horse stuff for here.

It would be helpful if Mike could tell us his thoughts about the possibility of going subscription free.
 
So a rebranding exercise may be required then?! New rider becomes something else?
Going back to the topic of this thread (not that I'm fussed it went a bit ot - the discussion developed!) but could we be more mindful of our thread titles especially in the public part of the forum as it will aid google searches I imagine. As jessy makes a very good point that we're not that popular by google standards and that's how I came across this forum to start with.
I also think (and please Candyflosspot, don't take offence) that the reason you feel this is slightly cliquey is down to your perception of being inferior because you don't have a horse. I think there's a good few plonkers out there (and in here) that do have horses, so dinnae be letting them intimidate you, you're a hell of a lot smarter for not running out and acquiring a stray without thinking through the consequences!
Although I acknowledge quite a few of my threads are 'does your horse do this' which can't help, sorry!
I'm glad we're talking about this issue and overall I think the theme is that we want the forum to develop and stay. How we do that is the concern and I too would appreciate mike's input on this - I'm not sure what costs are involved and why he set it up in the first place as to if it could be rebranded or made free again. As for sitting and removing all my posts I don't want anyone to see, cortrasna could you go through mine aswell hehe - I am so lazy, that sounds like hard work!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna
Well so far it has been tedious and boring, but so were most of the posts I have deleted so no loss to anyone, including myself. And today has been very wet and miserable.;)
 
I have never viewed 'New Rider' as being for new riders. I always thought that the title reflected people who wanted to develop their riding and learn from each other - hence you become a 'New' rider through learning and discussing with other people.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
I think the attraction of the facebook group is the very fact that it IS private.

I disagree. I think that New Rider is much more anonymous than Facebook. On facebook everyone knows your name, who your real life friends are, and if you discuss any event/incident/person everyone knows who you are referring to. On NR you can choose the level of disclosure. I never use real names, never post photos, never identify exactly where I have been. I have met up with a few NR people face to face but on the whole I think that it would be pretty difficult to identify who I am from this forum. The picture in my avatar isn't even of my current horse!
 
Well I am not looking to take my privacy to quite that level MP! I wouldn't even come on the internet if I felt unable to post a picture of my own horse or something as innocuous as that. I am not interested in hiding, just in protecting those I care about from worrying abut me worrying about certain things etc.;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers
I have been very public on here some years ago (I used my real name, put up photos etc.) and it came back to haunt me. I said something on here about my old share horse which a friend of the owner read. This resulted in all her friends joining and turning what started as an innocent thread into a right old ding dong, I actually had to give up the share horse in the end. It taught me a very valuable lesson so since then yes I have 'hidden' my true identity, but I don't think that there is anything wrong with that. I do sometimes worry about the level of detail that some users go into about their lives. I actually met someone at my riding club who used to be on this forum, and as they introduced themselves I realised that I knew their name, where they work, what their horse was called, the state of their relationship and their views on NH. It was really strange knowing all this about a perfect stranger.

I have been around friends houses when the wine has been flowing and have witnessed some real in-depth internet searches to try and find 'dirt' on people. While I haven't got anything to hide as such, I just rather that if someone else from my yard were to join this forum they wouldn't know who I am. Apart from anything else, I would be mortified for real life people to read all my gushy Ben posts. They would think that I was insane and I would find it all pretty embarrassing!!!
 
I have had a wee nosey at other places to chat and we are not the quietest. One has only had one new post all day today and only three posts all week.
Another has a section with one or two replies-maybe people have moved away from forums?
 
I am not interested in hiding, just in protecting those I care about from worrying abut me worrying about certain things etc.;)

I know where you live, boo ;)
Seriously though I dont trust fb, so I left. My horse is on tripadvisor, my yard has its own website. I dont post things I need to go back and remove, I am not that interesting. But, I wouldnt post anything that would affect reputations etc.

My cob looks very much like other cobs, the world IS a big place.
 
I hadn't thought it was cliquey either. And although I joined pre subs, even then when there were obviously trouble makers I hadn't realised were there, I thought everyone was just enchanting and really helpful.

But, I suppose it is something we should take on board. I don't get offended if the whole forum don't reply to one of my threads, because it is either because they don't know, or it doesn't interest them, which is fair enough - I am the same.

But maybe we should endeavour to answer posts whether we have a useful contribution or not?
 
Must really read all threads before I reply, had forgotten about page 3, possibly because my computer is very old and very slow!!

MP, I would have thought you were one of the most popular members on here - why would you think it is cliquey??

However, I do think that I must delete my diary. Previously, prior to subs, the members were pretty stable, now everything is changing, I am not sure I want hundreds of unknown people reading it!
 
I still feel diaries should stay private. The diary is really for my progress, people follow if they like.
I like to look at photos.
If it goes public I would want mine deleting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
newrider.com