New Subs

Hmmm how about unlimited posting vs limiting free users to one post a day or something like that?

I don't think that would work too well. What if a new person comes to post a thread asking questions but then can only reply once (or a very limited number) a day until they pay up? I don't think that would encourage them to stick around, they'd go somewhere where they can have a good conversation about whatever they were looking to find out about. Maybe limit them to a certain number (say 3-5) of new threads a day instead so the board doesn't get flooded with junk.

I think perhaps if they had access to everywhere but the collecting ring area (that is cafe, sofa and members diaries isn't it?!) and maybe couldn't PM people on the board until they were a paid up member. That would still allow people to come on and ask about riding/horses/vet issues/saddles etc and easily reply and (hopefully) help them realise that we are a nice helpful bunch and maybe they'll want to pay to get a bit more out of the board. Although, in saying that, it might be quite nice if we had a "free" cafe area to encourage a bit of light-hearted chit-chat and introductions with new members rather than only fact/info based threads as found in the other sections.

I remember when NR went subs only there was mention of "experts" posting every month. I'd really enjoy something like that. Loads of companies now do live webchat type things with experts (vets/pro riders/nutritionists/trainers etc) and I think that would be something that would be nice for paid members. For example there was a post about horse agility recently and quite a few people were interested in that, wouldn't it be nice if we could get someone who is high up in horse agility who could answer our questions and give hints/tips advice etc for starting out. (I suppose it wouldn't need to be live as such but a good discussion about a "topic of the month" with an experts input would be good I think). We could maybe run a poll the month before and decide what the topic/what kind of expert we'd like the following month?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna
And what if we could do a board photo competition for paid members and the winner and runner up got a little rosette? I'm trying to think of things that members would enjoy that would encourage discussion and help entice new members.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna
Personally - I think it should go back to being free and am not sure why that all changed in the first place. Don't get me wrong, I am not that fussed about paying 99p or a tenner, but there are an awful lot of people who clearly are as we are now down to a very limited membership and I think that spells it out pretty obviously. Whatever carrot is dangled, there are loads of free and large horsey forums, so it is either going to be a tiny forum with a lot of big fish in a tiny pool, or a bigger forum with more average sized fish - I guess it is whatever the moderators choose.

Were it free, it would encourage a lot more people who are searching for info on certain items - NR used to be right up there with knowledgeable posts and info, but sadly isn't anymore.

I fear it has become a little too contained now, and that isn't healthy or viable - in my own opinion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rubic and Cortrasna
Why didn't we get the experts monthly postings? I had forgotten that.

Free or subs, you need people who actually use it to post though. It looks small currently because its the same people trying to keep it going, trying to think of discussions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rubic
I would guess because experts want paying. People who make their money out of horses aren't going to post out of the goodness of their hearts. We had two saddlers on here previously - Norm and sbloom. I know that Sbloom still posts on H&H but not on here any longer. I would guess it isn't worth her while because she doesn't get the volume of business on here.

It is very helpful to have professionals on forums and I think, at the risk of going on and on, herein lies the rub.

I personally will continue to pay to remain a member, whether it be 99p or a tenner. But I don't come on here daily anymore because I can catch up with everything weekly.

If it remains a subscription only forum, I will only need to come on here fortnightly and so it continues on a downhill spiral.
 
I see where you are coming from sjp. I suppose we do have the issue that there are people who would leave if the forum became free because they'd feel they'd lose privacy and they like the small community we have and the higher possibility of "trolls". I do fear it is rather quiet at times. I was a member of a forum once where you had to post a certain number of times before you got access to a more private part of the forum. I think the limit was around 50 posts and you were then approved by admins. So maybe if you had a limit before people had access to members diaries and the sofa. Again I don't know if that is feasible or if it would work well
 
We had someone from keratex about hooves and safe drive Steve.
No one posted questions for the experts.

Rubic, I agree maybe more than one post, I was writing that at work and just quickly typed 'one per day or something like that'. The point is that you entice folk on to want to post more.
And if I'm not mistaken, I've already seen a few new names in the mix. We just have to keep encouraging it and having lively debate. We will never rival hho. But there is a niche our friendly forum can fill, I just don't think we're maximising it's potential so I am trying to come up with suggestions.
I acknowledge some want it free for all. I'm totally on the fence. Maybe there should be a poll of existing members for consultation on the idea, maybe mike doesn't want to provide a free forum when he's invested in upgrading it. Maybe we need to survey folk who visit the site and ask them their opinions on why they don't stick around or what we could do better. Maybe I should just quit whining.
 
I joined NR only a few month before the subs came in.

So I am not sure what the issues were. But it was a cracking forum when I joined, sub free, so am not sure what the issues were to cause it to be paid only.
 
I joined NR only a few month before the subs came in.

So I am not sure what the issues were. But it was a cracking forum when I joined, sub free, so am not sure what the issues were to cause it to be paid only.

Edited to add - someone on keratex is only an expert on keratex. My farrier who deals with a lot of remedials is not keen keratex, unless you want the whole hoof ripped off when the horse loses a shoe. Keratex was the buzz word some years ago on hooves and all farriers recommended it, now, not so much. Hardening hooves is a double edged sword.

Experts to me, would be someone like Michael Peace etc. Someone who doesn't have an axe to grind or a product to sell, but deals with what is needed for whatever situation. But again, just my opinion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rubic
Hmmm how about unlimited posting vs limiting free users to one post a day or something like that?

IMO that would put people off - i know it would me. Perhaps there could be additional privileges available to paying members - such as a really "secret sub section" which is only viewable after the subs have been paid? I dont really know what would could be put in this area though as it would involve some work from mods/specially appointed bods ( ie for instance articles about horse events (all disciplines ) /classified adverts etc )
 
There are a few reason as to why i stopped posting -
1 - I have been uber busy most of the year with uni, trying to pass my driving test (keep failing although last time the examiner cancelled on me :mad:)
2 - I dont own a horse so dont feel i can offer any advice/an opinion to people as i think people would dismiss what i have posted.
3 - The forum is very cliquey - i am not in the clique and therefore feel like i dont belong. Its off putting to me as someone who was a regular poster until recently. If i was a newbie i would think twice about coming back.
 
The forum pre subs was a bullying and jump on any member that was "different/did things different" The same members got banned and rebanned.
People joined just for fun to join in the witch hunt. So subs came in, the trolls went, the troublesome went but so did a lot of good active members who wouldn't/didn't want to pay.

As for experts we do have Westgate who comes on, I feel for any expert as even after what happened to my cob people still are ignorant about worming.
I have been to vet talks/courses etc, the problem with a company is they promote their products.
You can read up on any expert, buy books etc, watch videos. So maybe the expert coming on that we were promised x years ago isn't going to attract interest?
Even the sales/swaps drifts inti the black hole. I use EBay, its quicker, no one replies to posts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers
Am off to bed shortly, but I think the long and short of it is, that the site was popular and growing pre subs and it is now stagnant post subs.

The answer isn't rocket science IMO.

Forums will always have differences of opinions, paid or unpaid. I would guess that is the Moderators job to shut down threads that become difficult and I would guess your trolls would go else where if they don't get the reaction they want?
 
3 - The forum is very cliquey - i am not in the clique and therefore feel like i dont belong. Its off putting to me as someone who was a regular poster until recently.

Candyflosspot I am stunned (truly) That you feel that way, I always think of you as one of the regular and long term members who is well thought off by all of us on here. That is an eye opener, if a long term and well known member can feel like that on here that what hope have we for attracting new members? :eek:

I don't actually think this is a cliquey forum at all, there aren't enough of us left to form any cliques!:p Talking of which, can anyone tell me where it is possible to find a members list on here, I tried yesterday without success to see who and how many members we actually still have?
 
3 - The forum is very cliquey - i am not in the clique and therefore feel like i dont belong. Its off putting to me as someone who was a regular poster until recently.

Candyflosspot I am stunned (truly) That you feel that way, I always think of you as one of the regular and long term members who is well thought off by all of us on here. That is an eye opener, if a long term and well known member can feel like that on here that what hope have we for attracting new members? :eek:

I don't actually think this is a cliquey forum at all, there aren't enough of us left to form any cliques!:p Talking of which, can anyone tell me where it is possible to find a members list on here, I tried yesterday without success to see who and how many members we actually still have?

Its definatley not as bad as it used to be as numbers have dwindled somewhat but there is a definate "group" who stick together on the forum.

Not sure about a members list - was there one available on the old version of the forum?
 
I didn't think it was cliquey at all. :confused: I understand there are some people who know each other better, possibly because they have met up IRL or had discussions off the forum, but I never would have said that they are cliquey. I can't even really think of any cliques. I do admit there are a few people who's threads I usually avoid replying to. Then there are others I feel I get on better with so will actively try to respond to their threads (however it doesn't always mean I agree with what they are saying!). I don't know, I felt there was an ok mix of people on here.

To find the members list: there is a "Members" tab at the top of the page. The members are sorted by post count to start with though and the list includes a lot of older members with high post counts who haven't been on for a while. You can then sort it by "likes"/"points" etc. Although I'm not sure any of the options give a good representation of currently active members.
 
If we are a clique I am not in it, or too blind to notice.

I have only met up with J@Z once in RL. I am in touch with people on here via the forum only. I may be located near to members, but we haven't met or spoken outside the forum.

It may look as if a group sticks together as they are the only ones who post.
Though I must say it doesn't feel like a forum anymore, I could handpick ten people and just email them to stay in touch.
 
There are a few reason as to why i stopped posting -
1 - I have been uber busy most of the year with uni, trying to pass my driving test (keep failing although last time the examiner cancelled on me :mad:)
2 - I dont own a horse so dont feel i can offer any advice/an opinion to people as i think people would dismiss what i have posted.
3 - The forum is very cliquey - i am not in the clique and therefore feel like i dont belong. Its off putting to me as someone who was a regular poster until recently. If i was a newbie i would think twice about coming back.

Really sorry you feel like that, candyflosspot - I never thought of this place as cliquey, and I never thought of you as being anything less that one or the regular posters. You don't have to own your own horse to offer comments or suggestions - anyone who rides at all has horsey experience to contribute... How's uni going?

PS wrote this before I read Cortrasna's post saying the same thing :D Cortrasna, we must be a clique!
 
newrider.com