I thought things over last night.

I'm going to try and keep this short and sweet, for if I posted all of my true feelings, I'd be banned for sure :rolleyes:

No one is trying to offend you, none of them have said anything that hasn't been said before.
Go back to your other threads, they are just repeating what they've said before in your other threads. Who wouldn't be a little frustrated when they've repeated the same things over and over again to either be ignored or have someone come back with dramatic childish responses. "Oh, everyone is too mean, I'll never post again." :rolleyes:

Good for you for trying to make it work with Gitcha. But be sure you're not doing it because of some fantasy in your head. Look at your situation clearly and be realistic.
You must also accept that if it doesn't work(clashing personalities can't be fixed, if that's what it is), that you stand a high risk of losing money(potential does NOT mean anything), which could possibly affect you not being able to purchase another quality horse.

Honestly, I don't think you two being trained separately is going to work. You'll gain confidence with other horses, which doesn't always carry over to the horse you have confidence issues with. He'll learn valuable stuff, but he'll only learn it with the trainer, and will still see you in the same light he always has.
I'd take as many lessons a week with him as you can, which could be a lot cheaper than sending him to a trainer. You can then practise what you learned in the lessons at home.

And please, whatever you do, if it doesn't work, don't post a thread asking for sympathy. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Actually (and I'm not trying to argue here anymore :o ) but me and Mia were 'trained' separately for a time. I was riding the school horses and other peoples' horses because I was scared to ride her and needed to build my confidence, while I had my other, more confident friends, riding Mia to teach her that she would NOT get away with the crap she was trying on with me. After we'd re-established my confidence, and Mia's manners, I got back on her and used her in lessons (and still did a lot of groundwork) and it worked fantastically.

I do agree that maybe some lessons for both WL and gitcha together would be good, too, but not when she's too nervous to ride him. She needs to get her confidence back first. I know, I've been there :)
 
Sorry, forgot to say different situations warrant different techniques. WL knows her situation, just throwing in another idea.
I do think training separately can work(i.e. those that get their horses backed elsewhere), I guess I've just seen the way I suggested been used more. :)
I've also never had confidence issues, so I don't have experience with that perspective. I can understand how nerves would interfere though. :)
 
Last edited:
Yes WillieLove, please know that I was NOT trying to offend you or put you down in anyway. Just giving you the advice you asked for, it might not have been what you wanted to hear, but it was my opinion.

Yes you do well in getting professional help for Gitcha and for yourself but what I was trying to say was for you to please keep in mind that things may not work out the best, and your project horse may result in a loss of money (most likely), a loss of confidance (probable, and already happening), as well as a possible "problem horse" who throws his riders. Now we all hope for the best, and I know about working through issues to form a great bond. Taz and I for instance did not get on the first time i rode him, but he NEVER threw me or lost all respect for me. But please don't be afraid to throw in the towel and sell Gitcha before things go to far for both him and yourself. You DO NOT want to give him a negative outlook on people and the ridden life.

This has all been said before, but multiple threads on the same subject, particularly the selling, not selling, selling, not selling, threads do tend to get exhausted, and then when advice is given, the kind of advice you didn't particularly want, (my original post saying you were a novice), it ended up in you sending me on a "goodbye newrider" guilttrip.

But the best of luck to you, and keep us posted on whatever you decide. I'd like to know how you and Gitcha are both getting on, as I'm sure whatever you decide will be the right choice for the both of you, afterall nobody knows your horse more then you do.
 
Okay, here's the thing, I am NOT trying to make a profit, I don't CARE if I lose money,and I AM getting LOTS of help,read my first post, I am not doing this on my own! GOD!

Why can't this work? With all the help? It's like why sell him, if I take lessons and I am going to be a good enough rider for him next year? why he gets lots of training, we work on our trust on the ground,i.e Parelli. Why keep saying it won't work? Why not have a little faith. If I listened to all the comments I got to sell Willie at first,and no he was not a gentle horse!Grr. Then I would still be a very crappy rider,and have no horses at all.

I take it very rudely when you guys are saying,if I posted my true feelings I would get banned. How do you think that makes me feel?!

Oh,and I can post whatever I want,cvr. But I am not going to be posting a bunch of sympathy crud.Grr...

Really guys, have some faith!

Kirstie and Amba went back and forth, but now they are doing very well so far, why can't it be that way with me? She got support from everyone...

I don't even know why I bother posting, no one seems to listen.I don't have to do it YOUR way, I can do it MY way. Just because you say sell, you don't own the horse, you don't have the right. Think of how if you wanted to do something and everyone was saying your going to fail,fail,fail, then how would you get anywhere in life?

Grr...why do I bother...
 
WilliLove what you are forgetting is that some people are just perfect, they never have any issues or problems with their horses because they do things right the first time every time and those of us who don't know straight away instinctively the exact way to tackle every problem we come across with our horses should just give up now before we ruin them for life. Much better you don't bother putting any time or effort into helping overcome his problems and just give up now and sell him on as a problem horse to someone perfect. Or why not send him to auction, he could fall into any hands of course but I mean anythings got to be better than him staying with you hasn't it! ;)
 
Hi WillieLove

I think your plan sounds good. Don't give up !!!!

I'm going through the same battles as you are .....

Its about having a horse that you love and can't bear to part with.
Its about doing whatever you can to try and make it work for you.

Just because you have fallen off a few times doesn't make the horse bad, or you bad.

My horse tries to test me out, yet behaves perfectly for my instructor. We are now working on getting my assertiveness and confidence happening so we can overcome the problem. Who says that another horse would make this problem go away anyway? The problem is with me and my lack of skill. I'm not one to give up when the going gets tough.

Its one hell of a learning curve, and its really difficult (sometimes I drive home from a lesson in tears) but I've given it another 6 months before I re-evaluate the situation.

Yes, I'll make a profit if I sell her (very sought after breed and hard to get), but I don't want to sell her, so its irrelevant. My instructor assures me that I'm not 'wrecking' my horse, and as she is riding/training my horse twice a week (and will start competing soon) her value will go up anyway.

Feel free to PM me if you want some support or just someone to talk to.....
 
respect is due to those who give it a go in my humble opinion.

it's always been my mind set. keep going at a problem like a dog with a bone.
if that makes me bone headed then fine i don't care.
i do just a little bit at a time, like knitting a jumper.
sometimes you're down because it's one step forward, two steps back, sometimes you're on top of the world because it's gone well.


good luck, i hope you'll post on the progress you and Gitcha make

eta teehee angelfben :D i love your reply
 
not sure if i am brave enough to contribute to this but here goes. please no one bite my head off as I have a headache already

i am 50 and have ridden since i was 5. i was lucky enough when younger to be a trainers rider so i got a lot of experience, then i gave up riding for 10 years, coming back to it when i was 30. got my first horse when i was 40 (had 2 on loan which did not work out, had accidents with them which totally battered my confidence). bought a horse who was a disaster but i still have her 12 years later as she is unsellable and ill, and quite frankly a pts job if i can't keep her.

got rosie, aged 14, 3 years ago, a truculent cob with a history of being a brat. despite my years of experience with lots of horses, good bad angels etc, i had to call in the cavalry as rosie was dangerous and i was getting no where with her. she was a big strong girl used to throwing her weight around and she was a total cow. i was lucky in that my instructor saw what was needed and we were able to fix her in about 6 weeks - she still reverts to Ms Piggy by instinct but i now have a lovely quirky mare who i love but is still not anyone's cup of tea. she would die for me - well she would want advance warning and the chance to say no but she is a very good mare now.

the point of my post - the two horses i had on loan and failed with i had for 8 months and 18 months respectively and did try an awful lot with them. I had a fall on the road with one, not the horse's fault, but it dented my confidence and i could not ride him the way he needed to ridden. so i sent him home as i was going to make him worse. the one i had for 18 months was a nutty tb mare who had had more homes than hot dinners and hospitalised me! i eventually decided that bravery wasn't enough and that there was more to life than having a pain in the ass horse who was a professional missbehaver - her next home worked out and she is still there, aged 26!

so i have succeeded and failed with horses. in between times, i have had two yearlings who i have kept till they were ready to be started and sent them off for starting as nice, calm, well mannered fillies ready to start work - they are still in the same homes which perhaps says something about how they turned out.

i hope that your training with and without Gitcha works out and that that is the end of it. but there are some horses that you personally don't gell with and you can go on and on and on and all you do is drive each other into more dangerous and worse situations. i have ridden for many years, but i would not now consider for a moment bringing on a youngster myself as i am too stiff, not quite as brave as I was etc. although i could have schooled the two babies i had, i sent them away to be professionally backed, having them ready to go in terms of handling and manners.

you can spend years on a horse and have to admit defeat, so all i can say to you is to make rational assessments month by month as to whether you feel there is any progress, as you could spend all this money training a horse you get on with rather than one you don't.

there are so many folks on NR who have struggled with horses and lost their confidence and made the horses worse as part of the process - i am not saying this is the case with you, and I wish you all the luck in the world, but from my own personal experience, there are times when it just doesn't work ok.

i have seen quite a lot of horses over the years and ridden in races, hunted, point to pointed and competed in one day events. so while i am now just a fat old happy hacker, i have had a wide range of experience with all sorts and in that time, there are at least 5 horses that i just eventually said to myself or whoever i was riding for, i am not getting back on that one! One racehorse came over backwards on me and flattened me - fortunately i don't remember much about it, and in fact at the time i didn't even remember which horse i had been riding, but going through the yard, i picked out the one i thought it would be and i was right. I never rode her again simple as that.

there is a major problem with horses worldwide in that there is no protection for them at all - anyone can buy them. there are so many of us who have, despite the best of intentions and taking all reasonable precautions, have ended up with an unsuitable horse, and then have the huge problem of what to do about it. many are sold on with lies told and the problem simply goes to the next person. we have had horrible cases on here where a very dangerous horse was sold to a 'permanent home' then a couple of weeks later was advertised at a much higher price and suitable for a novice. i enquired about him and was told that he was perfect for a mature novice rider, when he had only recently hospitalised someone.

i hope all goes well with your training - all i can say is keep it in perspective and don't tough it out too long if it doesn't go as you wish.
 
Thanks for that post! I am not stupid, if things get worse or dangerous,I am not going to keep on. I think things can and will work out. I had a lovely join-up session with Gitcha on the ground yesterday. And the original owner,who has showed in all the top jumping shows in america, is going to help me tuesday. I think I have some very knowledgable people who will help.
 
If I had given up on my girl (who is not the easiest of mares to say the least), she would have gone 11 years ago.

If you have the support, then persevere if thats what you want - only you in your heart know what you want so make a decision and go with it.

Best of luck whatever you decide and dont take what is said on here too seriously, it's too many opinions that cause the problems in the first place.

Hugs x
 
WillieLove said:
I don't even know why I bother posting, no one seems to listen.I don't have to do it YOUR way, I can do it MY way. Just because you say sell, you don't own the horse, you don't have the right. Think of how if you wanted to do something and everyone was saying your going to fail,fail,fail, then how would you get anywhere in life?

Grr...why do I bother...

why do you bother? because input of anykind on your problem helps you to see it from more than one perspective :D I think people are just trying to look out for you and help but if you are already feeling a little less than positive it can be read 2 ways?

You can do it and you are doing all the right things, getting help, going back to basics and groundwork, stay positive and keep that enthusiasm. both you and Gitcha can learn so much from each other.
but all I ask is be carefull, I am sure its only cause we care what happens to you :D
 
but even if you do have to admit defeat in the end, you get such a valuable education along the way.
one that an easier horse just wouldn't give you.
also, you never have to ask yourself the question "well what if I'd tried this and that...." because you'll know.
 
Tots n Dots- Thanks gret post, yes I know it is for my safety, but if you worry so much about safety you wouldn't walk out of your house. or turn on the stove, god forbid drive a car! How do I learn if I only work with easy horses?
 
WillieLove said:
Tots n Dots- Thanks gret post, yes I know it is for my safety, but if you worry so much about safety you wouldn't walk out of your house. or turn on the stove, god forbid drive a car! How do I learn if I only work with easy horses?
:D :D
exactly! but do you cross the road without looking to see if a car is coming? :p would you light a match if you could smell gas? its just risk assesment, I know you are not daft, but I am in my 30's and its not till someone states the obvious sometmes that I think OMG they are so right, you need to know the full extent of the risk before you can assess it :D
 
WL, you asked for advice you got it! Trust me after years of NR I haven't always had posts where people have gone **** ME Becky you are AMAZING!!

You can't expect to come on a worldwide message board and expect everyone to feel the same, I'm sure you wearn't expecting that, but no one has been rude to you, nore has anyone purposely offended you if you want to keep Gitcha then good luck with it, but if you arn't open for a bit of critisism then you may aswell Sell him right this instance!!!

Trust me I have done it my first horse after a year and a bit of my safe share Cob, thought i was amazing, wouldn't say experienced but i'd say intermediate rider. Oh i could jump 3ft tracks, ready for the world, I went out and bought my big ol' Showjumping boy to take me round these 3ft tracks. I got a hell of a horse, he could jump 5ft tracks!!!

The ONLY way I skimmed through still intact and a love for horses was becasue I kept him and college and i have got the help and support and the fact my horse is the most forgiving, willing to wait about for mum horse ever! but trust me I have had him for 6 months and 4 months of them EVERYONE turned round and went SH*T good luck mate!!! Get rid of it silly girl, look what you've bought, and it hurts!!!

BUT it either makes you stronger and in 4 months time you can come back to NR if you are really going to stop posting :rolleyes: and give all the poeple that told you there views the V's or you can sit crying over quite an easy decision!

Trust me I have given everyone the V's with Roo, its been a long haul and i have fallen off more times than you can imagine haha but F*C* it. You love him, you want to learn to ride, you want to do this horse justice well get of your bloody arse, stop your moaning, and GET ON WITH IT!!!!

Good luck Chick x x x
 
Just going to add my tuppence worth
I got Ben as 15 month old colt, I hadnt 'trained' a youngster but what I did is took advise from others who had, went to a yard who was an expert, this so called expert basically broke my spirit and destroyed any confidence that had built up and I nearly sold my boy. Thank god I moved to another yard and for the past year my horse has come on leaps and bounds and so have I, in fact the more I have learned I realised that 'expert' knew jack - he came on my new yard a few months ago and started to dictate what I could do with my horse! . he is a clydesdale so got a good temperament to start with but I know I have done a good job with him (altho its an ongoing job!) the man who sold him to me said on wednesday what a great job had done with him and he has had clydesdales for nearly 40 years.
Willie love, I know you love Gitcha and will do your best for him and you.
Both of you get some extra training and take it from there, then when thats finished you are in a better place for both of you to make a decision whether to keep him or sell him and know you will have done your best for him and you. Sometimes its whats written that can be taken the wrong way especially when already upset about the predicament the person is in
I am not saying always answer with kid gloves but maybe a little consideration for other peoples feeling would be nice:)
 
angelfben said:
WilliLove what you are forgetting is that some people are just perfect, they never have any issues or problems with their horses because they do things right the first time every time and those of us who don't know straight away instinctively the exact way to tackle every problem we come across with our horses should just give up now before we ruin them for life.
LOL :D

Willielove, I can see exactly why you thought those posts were rude, I would have to. You posted looking for a bit of support and got exactly the opposite.
Pinks Lady, yes there is giving your opinion and then there is forcing it down someones throat. Things arent always as black and white as you make out.
I dont normally comment when things get a little b*tchy but I am sick of seeing well meaning people being shot down just because they arent as experienced as others. WL will have help from a trainer and she has tonnes of determination. There are tonnes of people on this board, Kalypso and Angelfben included who have been though similar things with their horses and they have come through it, what makes WL so different?

Willielove I wish you all the luck in the world hun. If you believe you can get through this then have a go, there is nothing worse than feeling like you gave up too soon.
 
newrider.com