I thought things over last night.

BeachRiding

New Member
Aug 26, 2004
7,680
0
0
USA
I have decided not to sell Gitcha, Yet. I have given us 4 months and this schedule, do you think its even worth trying?


~Parelli groundwork for 3 months with Gitcha every day, he doesn't trust me, I don't trust him, and if I were him I wouldn't want me on his back either....:(

~English lessons 1x weekly for 4 months for me, I need to build my riding confidence up,and refresh my skills so that...

~ When I send Gitcha in for 1 month english training I will be able to match his skills.

~If things are working well I will continue lessons and send Gitcha in for another month of training a couple months after.

~If things don't work out, I'll sell him, and he will have some very nice training on him for someone who deserves him more than me.

Inspiration from Kalypso and Miss Mia!:) Made me realize that when I first bought Willie we struggled and didn't get along, eventually we had a great relationship, he tried his heart out for me.
 
I think that if you want to really try then you have to....you have to exhaust every route before you do sell.

Even though I love Bry I do still sometimes wish I had tried something else with Grady but then I did try alot.

Give yourself this time and make a list...everytime he does something good write it in the 'not to sell' side and when he does something not so good write it in the 'to sell' side. If after 4 months you aren't sure, consult the list.

Good luck, I hope it works out for you.
 
good luck! I hope you sort things out :D . It's true that you do have to exhaust every possible avenue. I nearly sold my ex-racer earlier this year after he bolted with me, but I have since spent a fortune getting his back, pelvis, tack and mouth checked out (plus a fortune on a calmer!) and he's a much much happier and better behaved little boy.
 
I've just gone back and re-read your previous thread. Sounds very familiar ;)

Take a look at mine

Nightmare Ride
Giving Up

Personally, having been through all that, I think that almost any problem can be worked on given enough time and patience (and in some cases, fairly deep pockets!). No, mine is still not perfect - I fell off in my lesson on Tuesday because we're just starting canter work again and he didn't want to stop :o , but we're working on it with a great riding instructor who also schools him for me occasionally, and I'm confident that eventually we'll get there. Even if it takes years, I think I can safely say that by the time I come to retire him, I will be able to canter him sensibly in the school without incident (given that he's not long since turned eight, we should have years to work on it! :D )

Good luck, and take care of yourself. And if you can get your hands on it, try some Rescue Remedy before you ride to help get over your own nerves. If you are nervous, it will only make Gitcha worse. Let us know how you get on!
 
yes - take care of yourself. That's the main thing. You won't do him any favours if you get yourself scared or hurt :(

Now you've gone back and forth a lot on Gitcha's future. Everyone's being very nice, and encouraging and quite rightly so. Just as a reality check bear in mind these 2 important pieces of information :

1) if you sell him - you have not 'failed' .. you have not 'admitted defeat'. It can take years and years to find your perfect horse. It is just NOT a big deal to move a horse on to a more suitable home. So don't let that be a guilt trip. You will be suprised - if you just start looking for his replacement - you will suprise youself when you find so many other horses out there that you also feel a 'special attachment'. Just because you meet several that are just 'yes,it's a horse, so what' <-- I'm like that with 80% of horses I see or ride ... but a good 20% are 'ow wow, I NEED to take her home right now'

The second thing is this - and it's a hard fact, don't read it if you're feeling down on yourself ...

2) The most sure way to ruin a young horse is for an owner to carry on and on and on ...when they are over-horsed and out of control. The longer that goes on, the more damage to the horse. Now Gitcha was a $2500 horse when you bought him... and you'd like to sell him for more ? Well, now realistically that's not likely. Carry on with him, use him as a 'project' for you to learn with .,... but think of it as an investment in yourself ! If it doesn't work out - then don't expect to have a $2500 horse left at the end of 6 months. You may put in all those hours ... and it may work out beautifully .. and you'll be a long way to becoming a 'horse trainer' ... but for your first one, put all thoughts of making a profit on this behind you. The risk of failure is high.

I hate to be a downer, because I do wish you luck, and with the right amount of time, study and commitment, I know you can do it. BUT I'd bet the statistics say otherwise. I'm quite sure that sale barns and nasty auctions are full of quite young horses that well meaning novices have tried to work on.

Go ahead, by all means, but be constantly alert to what progress you two are making, what the current issues are. Call in help from a professional trainer sooner rather than later (hint : my little mare was a week off going through the sale barn, and literally just one hour with a good NH handler showed me how far off base I was with her. The following week she was trail riding like she'd done it all her life - she had 2 hours under saddle at that time)
 
Oh, I don't mean to make a profit on him, highly unlikely with any horse. I am just saying if he has tons of training put on him and it still doesn't work out, I can get more money (still a loss as I would spend way more) for him with some finishing training.

He was actually a $4,000 dollar horse, I just got him for $2,500 because I am a friend of the original owner.
 
Yes WillieLove, I ditto EVERYTHING Katewooten said. Good for you for trying everything with Gitcha. You never know, he may just be your perfect horse in the end. Not every great relationship starts out wonderfully.

But you must remember that, when you tell someone your reason for selling, giving that you are being honest, you will have to tell them he has thrown you off on several occasions. Which is the reason you are selling him according to your other posts. (your "That's it, I'm done, he threw me" post, pretty much gives that away). No one is going to want to spend $4,000 on a horse that has thrown his previous owner, on numerous occasions. Furthermore, he is now your "project" horse, and you are a novice yourself are you not?

Not meaning to put you down or anything, as we all must start somewhere. But expecting to get "more money" for him, is not likely. Just trying to put things into perspective, but from your other posts it did sound like you quite wanted to make a profit off of him, despite the fact that he has thrown you and has not been the nicest of horses. Especially when you said you would not sell for under $2500. Nobody wants to lose money, especially on something you've dedicated so much time and effort to. Now although I think because of the area you live in you will at least make back the money you ORIGINALLY spent on him, ie. $2500, I do not think you will profit much more then that even with training, if you are an honest seller and tell the potential buyers YOUR reason for selling.


I hope all works out for, and that if you do not keep Gitcha, he does find a good home.
 
I AM NOT TRYING TO MAKE A PROFIT! Just trying not to LOSE to much money! Grr... think I have already tried to explain that enough, now I am just offended...

And I don't know what you mean by novice,or what defines it in your perspective, but I have been riding for 3-4 years and he is my second horse, I have helped train another horse,and I am very good at working with horses on the ground. So am I a novice?
 
WillieLove said:
I AM NOT TRYING TO MAKE A PROFIT! Just trying not to LOSE to much money! Grr... think I have already tried to explain that enough, now I am just offended...

Sorry for offending you, just going by what you sounded like on your other posts and threads. Take what I said as you'd like, but I just reread my post and it doesn't sound offensive to me in any way whatsoever, but if it offended you, It wasn't meant to.

WillieLove said:
And I don't know what you mean by novice,or what defines it in your perspective, but I have been riding for 3-4 years and he is my second horse, I have helped train another horse,and I am very good at working with horses on the ground. So am I a novice?

to put it bluntly: yes.


there are people who have been riding for 10+ years and still consider themselves Novices. Owning two horses does not dictate what level you are on. I know people who I would consider professional horsemen and experts, who have never owned a horse in their life. And others, who've owned over 6 and yet are still very much novices. Theres a quote on someone's profile here that says something along the lines of, " A man can say he has 20 years experience, but only 1 year repeated 20 times." I think it applies here, doesn't matter how long you've been riding, you can still be a novice.

Not having a go at you, don't take it offensively. Just answering your question with my opinion, and not sugar-coating it.
 
I'm still very much a novice, and actually still consider myself a beginner after 2 years of riding. Its just a way to be classified, and everyone classifies differently. Similar to what defines your level at any sport. You will get those who claim to be great, and in fact they know nothing, And those who claim to know nothing, and are in fact great.

Everyone is in fact a novice. Beezie Madden is an olympic showjumper, But has she got any idea what to do in the Hunter or Dressage Ring?

My YO is a GREAT horseman who has trained with Vets, and has been racing standardbreds for over 20 years. But he couldn't tell a sidepass from a piaffe!

Similar theory applies to everyone.
 
Because even with riding for 3 or 4 years, and being "good at working with horses on the ground" Gitcha will be your first horse for you to train, and that makes you a novice. Things can work out beautifully, or they can end up a mess. Gitcha is young, and as KateWooten said, "The most sure way to ruin a young horse is for an owner to carry on and on and on ...when they are over-horsed and out of control. The longer that goes on, the more damage to the horse."

Not saying your going to ruin Gitcha, just advising you to be on your toes, and the instant things start to turn towards the bad, get a professional out ASAP.

Good luck in everything.
 
Aww, I get it...stupid me. Well don't mean to be rude, but everyone should have asked specifically if I have ever trained a horse before, not are you a novice!
 
Sorry Willie Love, I agree with those guys. Continue with him if you wish, but I suspect at the end of it you'll still have problems.

Unfortunatly, yes, I'd still class you as a novice - just from what you've said in previous posts and threads - 3 or 4 years is nothing and most of that has been spend with a nice gentle, older horse (Willie).

Not everyone is a novice in general, but in specific disiplines, yes. I know next to nothing about western riding or racing but wouldn't be counted as a novice - I've been riding for more than 15yrs, ridden literaly hundreds of horses and schooled and competed many.

I think you've just over-horsed yourself, proabably in the beliefe you were more advanced than you thought you were. No shame in that - if you've not had the experience, you wouldn't know. It happens to a huge number of people.

If money is an issue (which it is, sadly to most people) and you don't want to loose money, then the only sure way is to send him for proffesional training and sell him right from there. But even then you're going to have to fork out a huge amount of money for the training and will still loose a huge amount in the end. Right now you WILL loose money on him (you'll not even get $2500 for a young and 'difficult' horse who's repeatedly thrown his rider) and unfortuantly I doubt you on your own will be able to sort the problem out - so professional training is the only way you can go but when he comes back - then what? Sadly I doubt his attitude to you will have changed and so, unless you can very quickly gain some extra skill and expereince or get in some (proabbaly expensive) help, you'll be back to square one.

I think sending him for schooling then selling him for probably not much more than you paid for him OR selling him right now for quite a lot less than you paid for him are your two best options. Then you can buy yourself a sensible horse who has the training already and you can enjoy.

Even money plays no part in it at all, I still don't think he nor you will be happy. He needs someone with much more experience and confidence (and sending him for schooling won't change that fact) and you need something a bit more experince and sensible and forgiving.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
God, that was harsh... He is not a difficult horse with anyone else, and he is worth way more than I paid! Maybe you haven't been following but I got a deal on him as I am a friend...

You know what, I am very offended by your post,and I think you were too harsh.
 
newrider.com