I thought things over last night.

Pinkslady... He was for sale at $4,000 with interested buyers, but I was given him for $2,500 as I am a friend and help a lot with the seller. He is a one in a million horse, very nicely bred with lots o potential compared to others selling for way more around here!
 
Sorry you don't agree but I'm saying exactly what I think. I could have very easily said, yes, you're wonderful, he's wonderful and everything will turn out beautifully. But that ins't going to help anyone.

I don't know what horse prices are like over there, but over here you'd get £1500 for him, if you're lucky. That's if you sell him yourself because, as you said yourself, he's badly behaved for you. If someone else sold him for you (i.e the professional trainer) you'd get more, possible £2500. Still not a lot of money. Potential means nothing is he's not demonstrating it at present.

He is not a difficult horse with anyone else,

I think that just about sums it up. Something about either you or him don't mess. You can out a huge amount of effort (time and moeny) in and it might come right (depends on what the problem is, which I suspect is you're lack of experience, not his) but unless you address the right problem, it'll just be down hill from here.

Which is why I think selling him now whilst he's still sellable is the best bet and find something you will enjoy.
 
Yes but now he has thrown a rider, numerous times. You haven't fallen of of him at your own fault, he has thrown you, as you stated. That decreases his value, as he is young, and not educated enough.

So he's worth 4000 because he has potential? Every horse has potential, its the rider's responsibility to bring out the best of it. I hate seeing horses rediculously priced, because of their "potential." And who's to say he has potential, and potential for what? Not having a go at Gitcha, just generalizing.

ETA: hehe Pink's Lady we cross-posted.
 
Yes, he WAS $4000. That was before his behaviour deteriorated and he started to chuck his rider off. Now he's not worth anything near that.
 
Its all about the market! And it is ridiculous here! It's either a greenbroke horse for $4,000 or a 22 year old for $2500.... If you want something decent.

Supertania- I have fallen off twice. weeks apart.

Pinkslady-It's not that I don't agree, I know I am not experienced enough, its just you could have been nicer, the tone of the post was rude.

I LOVE this horse, I can't sell him.
 
right and both those times you've been thrown according to your posts.

I don't understand you. Your plan was to work with him, and possibly get him sold for 4000. Now you can't sell him?

I understand you become attached, but you aren't doing him or yourself any favors by staying with each other even if you don't click.
 
Oh,and just wanted to say, I think the first time I fell wasn't his fault, he spooked,bolted, turned, I fell. Ever since then things have deteriorated, he doesn't TRUST me, I don't think he really wants to hurt me. When I first bought him we were great,a great match, I galloped him, he responded well to seat aids I was riding him in a halter! I was a good enough leader then, why not now!? Sorry upsetting myself. I don't want to argue on here, but I know something happened, when I fell off that day. What? *cries*
 
SupaTania said:
right and both those times you've been thrown according to your posts.

I don't understand you. Your plan was to work with him, and possibly get him sold for 4000. Now you can't sell him?

I understand you become attached, but you aren't doing him or yourself any favors by staying with each other even if you don't click.
I said I would sell him if it DIDN'T work. read the first post! I am relying on it to work. I don't want to make money, I want things to work!
 
Rude - really? It's a hell of a lot more diplomatic than what I was going to say.

Maybe you will get more for him if you sold him - the horse buying market can be stupid and what you get it not always what they're worth.

It is difficult if you're very attatched to him but maybe you have to be brave and make the right desicion for him. I don't think you're right for him, not him for you. It's mostly about confidence and it's a fragile thig - once it's been broken it's virtually impossible to mend back to as it was before.
 
Okay I am done.Obviously I have no support, and that's what i am on newrider for, helpful posts and support. So goodbye newrider. I am going to do everything on my own now.
 
Willie thats a shame, where all we're giving is out support and advice. We're trying to help you stay safe, and Gitcha not end up as an unruly and "problem" horse.

But if you want to proceed on your own, I'm not going to beg you to stay, or fall into a guilt trip. GoodLuck with everything you do, and I hope Gitcha turns out well.
 
Thank you, and if you think I am tyring to make you feel guilty I am NOT! I just can't handle this, it's not helpful. And very downing.
 
Just wanted to add, I will still be on, but I am not going to be writing any of my own threads. I have made to many friends here.
 
Oh, honestly :rolleyes: I'm not going to be at all sympathetic - you got an amswer you don't like - you're just going to have be adult about it and deal with it.

You wanted helpful advise - I gave mine (weither you like it nor not) - you've not really got the experience to deal with this young horse (who's obviously not as straight forwards as some) and I think you should sell him and get something more suitbale, before you hurt yourself or him and destroy your confidence beyond repair.

I'm sorry you don't like it, but that's tough.
 
Why does everyone automatically assume, right off the bat, that she is going to fail and 'ruin' gitcha? I don't understand it. She's said she's going to send him for training. She's said she's going to have an instructor train HER and that she's going to do a lot of groundwork with him.

Honestly, it seems to me that people think that just because she isn't doing it the way YOU would do it, it's the wrong way. I'm REALLY glad I didn't have 'friends' who told ME I wasn't suitable for Mia and that I needed something different because we didn't get on. Instead, I had those who were behind me whatever decision I made. yes, they were horsey friends, all of them, who KNEW me and Mia, who had seen everything I was going through.

I DON'T think she's going to end up ruining Gitcha. She has the heart, and the love for the horse. She has a trainer, and a trainer for the horse. It isn't as if she has said she's going to do everything on her own.

So, maybe I'm wrong, and they are unsuitable. I don't know her or Gitcha. But neither do any of you. If she feels like she can give it a go, then why be so harsh? Again, I reiterate, she NEVER said she was going to go and do it all on her own. Even I would balk at that.

She's only had him for four months. What harm is there in a little more time and work, on both their parts? She NEVER said, in any of her posts, that she wanted to make a profit on him. She did say that she wanted to price him higher to have bargaining room to get the price she wanted. I don't see anything wrong with that.

Maybe I'm just really lucky, but I've had two such horses and both of them have come through being lovely, well-trained animals. They just took some work. I had a wonderful instructor and friends both times who helped me, and it sounds to me as if WL has the same types of people to go to. If I thought she was planning on going in on her own, no help, because she thought she was better than she is, and was going to end up harming gitcha or herself, I'd be right with you guys in telling her off!

And, I just wanted to add, before I get my head bitten off, that I'm not having a go at anyone. I realize we all have different views on things, it's not goig to change, and it's nice to have both sides of an argument. I like the fact that people speak their own minds. But it does seem as if everyone is being very pushy to make WL have things their way. that's not right, is it? :confused: Let her make her own decision. There are times I come on here and think "wow, that person is being really stupid and deserves every single bit of 'harsh' criticism he/she is getting" -- but this just isn't one of those times.
 
Pink's lady said:
Oh, honestly :rolleyes: I'm not going to be at all sympathetic - you got an amswer you don't like - you're just going to have be adult about it and deal with it.

You wanted helpful advise - I gave mine (weither you like it nor not) - you've not really got the experience to deal with this young horse (who's obviously not as straight forwards as some) and I think you should sell him and get something more suitbale, before you hurt yourself or him and destroy your confidence beyond repair.

I'm sorry you don't like it, but that's tough.
I like to see how you'd feel if you got such heavy critizism! I feel sick to my stomach. I have been made to feel useless.I've got common sense, I am not going to hurt myself or him!
 
you know, the majority of you guys dont seem to listen, yes you give advice, sound advice for the most part, but it seems that Will love is doing everything she can think of, quite sensibly too and now youre all getting rather harsh because shes not doing things how YOU want them to be done, the difference here is to give ADVICE, not to dictate;)
 
WillieLove... I'm going to PM you my email address as I don't get on here very much these days (juggling a full time job, 3 horses, dogs, cats and some resemblance of a social life :D ) but if you want any support, advice or just someone to talk at through the next 4 months feel free to get in touch.

I've had my boy for 18 months but it is only just now that I feel we are really starting to bond and get somewhere, of course I always loved him to bits but to say we've been through the mill is a huge understatement! But we are getting there and none the worse off for the trials and errors we've been through together. I think that what you are doing is extremely sensible, responsible and highly commendable.. you are prepared to put in the time, money and effort and even more importantly you are seeking help for both you and Gitcha. How many people would try and struggle on on there own? Or write it off as the horse having the problem? Those are the people who ruin horses and cause them problems.

I think you have made a very considered and sensible decision in your plan for you both and I wish you all the best.

Like I said, drop me a line if you ever want to chat :) xx
 
newrider.com