Should and ahouldn't

It's quite hard to talk about words used and attitude without mentioning training methods or is that just me 🤣
 
I think you can separate them, maybe think about the purpose of training and the mindset of the trainer rather than how it's actually done.
 
Now there is a thought provoking few words.

Thank you :)

I think it's the first stumbling block in a lot of cases, people are training but ask them why and what they intend to achieve and they don't really know. I get something vague like "him not to be rude", ask them to define that and get blank looks or another meaningless phrase. I think to train anything - horse, dog, husband (is that possible?) - you first need to have a very clear picture of what you want, and for me the emphasis is on want as opposed to not want. The next step is to look at the current position, the nature of the horse I'm working with and then have a think about where to go from there. Yes I could refer to a book etc about how to get that behaviour, and if dealing with a problem I wouldn't rule that out, but I won't take what the book tells me as gospel because the writer isn't writing about this individual horse and the horse certainly hasn't read the book.

For me training is very specific, and it also isn't something done only in a certain environment.
 
The words and the methods are linked because horse training has for years borrowed the terminology urrent in human psychology. Often with a delay. Behaviourism (reward and withholding of reward) was modified by a situation where the horse had a mind of its own and allowed some part in decision making?
Then the idea that horses do not look on food as a reward led to some trainers avoiding treats. I cant cite the various opposing experts as I am rebuked for name dropping.
But ot has been suggested that communication with horses was drastically altered when women began to own and train horses. That women communicate on many levels and men are more likely to exert phsycial strength and speed.
 
I think to train anything - horse, dog, husband (is that possible?) - you first need to have a very clear picture of what you want, and for me the emphasis is on want as opposed to not want.
Lol yes you can train some husbands................(some are more receptive than others!)🤣😆😆
 
@Skib if you read my original post it's clear I'm not talking about terminology linked to methods. The example I used was someone who was so hung up on verbally telling the horse it should do something in a certain way that she never actually gave it the training/instruction to do so.

The question, clearly asked at the end, was "What words or attitudes do you think get in the way of effective training and horsemanship?". For me putting too much emphasis on the horse being the responsible partner to the extent of the trainer not training/giving instructions is a big problem, and nowadays seems far too common.
 
@Skib if you read my original post it's clear I'm not talking about terminology linked to methods. The example I used was someone who was so hung up on verbally telling the horse it should do something in a certain way that she never actually gave it the training/instruction to do so.

The question, clearly asked at the end, was "What words or attitudes do you think get in the way of effective training and horsemanship?". For me putting too much emphasis on the horse being the responsible partner to the extent of the trainer not training/giving instructions is a big problem, and nowadays seems far too common.
The two words that started the thread.
Should and shouldn't, because it suggests the trainer/rider is not able to think independently.
 
The words and the methods are linked because horse training has for years borrowed the terminology urrent in human psychology. Often with a delay. Behaviourism (reward and withholding of reward) was modified by a situation where the horse had a mind of its own and allowed some part in decision making?
Then the idea that horses do not look on food as a reward led to some trainers avoiding treats. I cant cite the various opposing experts as I am rebuked for name dropping.
But ot has been suggested that communication with horses was drastically altered when women began to own and train horses. That women communicate on many levels and men are more likely to exert phsycial strength and speed.
I find the different approaches that men and women take towards training horses very interesting. I had a male instructor for a few years and he often told me what I ‘should’ be doing. His ideas about my level of riding and mine were poles apart, but I did listen to him and in those years he had me riding XC, showjumping and galloping over fields. I was terrified most of the time but I did it. No female instructor has ever been like he was.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrC
I find the different approaches that men and women take towards training horses very interesting. I had a male instructor for a few years and he often told me what I ‘should’ be doing. His ideas about my level of riding and mine were poles apart, but I did listen to him and in those years he had me riding XC, showjumping and galloping over fields. I was terrified most of the time but I did it. No female instructor has ever been like he was.
I think its also what words people say that may or may not register with us, and what energy they bring with it.
I wouldn't want to be terrified because I wouldn't be unlikely to repeat what I was doing. Outside the comfort zone yes.
 
I'm an "I will" not an "I'll give it a try" person. Jim in particular taught me that if I went into something with a try mindset then it almost always wouldn't work because I was allowing for error. I also have turned round to instructors in the past and said no because I've not been confident/positive about doing something, or I've known it was the wrong approach for us. Conversely there were times with Jim when I said to instructors to look the other way while we had a little "discussion" about something! I have lessons to learn. I don't learn when I'm tense or stressed - it was my third lesson on Luka when the teacher turned round and said I could actually really ride as opposed to push buttons and be correct, basically once I'd relaxed riding in front of him! I would have liked to carry on lessons with him but once I moved Luka the cost of transport plus lesson became crazy, I had no means to practice between lessons, and also I came to the conclusion that for now at least Luka was better with one job. He's an incredible rider though, very much works with the horse he's on rather than expecting the horses to fit a method, and so quiet and calm. He also completely got my doing not trying mindset and I don't think I ever heard him sat words or phrases like try, give it a go, see if you can, or he should.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrC
The most common attitude I see getting in the way of training is a prideful one, not admitting when they’re over horsed, under skilled, lacking confidence, lacking understanding/being cocky, all because their pride won’t let them admit the truth, then they spend years stuck in a rut, or doing alternative training or not doing anything and not achieving their potential.

I don’t really give a crap what words people use, actions are what counts. I think perception/intended meaning of words varies so much, when I say I’ll try that doesn’t mean I’m expecting failure, it’s just not being cocky and saying I can/will do that. When I say my horse is a plonker it’s not me belittling him, or somehow making him less, as some believe, it’s a term of endearment and I am fond of that side of his silly behaviour (mostly), but it can be taken either way without seeing actions with it.

I don’t think you can never try something, training horses is progressive, you never get a new movement/skill perfect on the first go, you have to try until you perfect it, nibbling away at it bit by bit until you get perfect, once it’s established then you can get to I will. If you could just do everything first time why do you need lessons?
 
  • Like
Reactions: PePo and Trewsers
newrider.com