"NH" and "Traditional" Methods

India, I have the DVD with PP riding a horse into a moving trailer, and I thought it was awful, put me off straight away. He doesn't just ride it in, but grabs the roof of the trailer and hauls himself off the horse so it ends up on it's own. Seems like a lot of risk just to make himself look big. If you want the DVD (it's just a free one I sent off for from the website), I can always mail you it, don't need it anymore.
Thanks for the offer abisheridee, but to be honest, I'm not interested in watching stunts or circus tricks and IMO, riding a horse into a moving trailer is nothing short of either.

PNH worked for me and my one horse, but maybe that's because I concentrated purely on the re-educating and training methods of the programme and didn't get sucked into all the razzamatazz that goes with it.

I'm a Monty Roberts girl myself ;)

Each to their own.:)
 
I just love this thread and would (for once!) rather "listen" quitly. GREAT posts chaps, very thought provoking! I'd just like to add that I strngly have the mentality of being "horse-centred" but my RS's have all promoted "human-centration" which meant that, in my irst 3 years of riding, while I felt great compassion for horses I shamefully admit that I used more forceful methods than I would ever do now, because I didn't know any better, even though these methods went against my gut instincts. Thank goodness I found NH and NR is all I can say, as the "horse-centred" part of me has overcome the "human-centred" mentality that I briefly fostered! :D

I feel like many people immediately jump to forceful methods, or use greater pressure/physical strength to get the horse to do what they want, and because so many peple do it, it is seen as being the normal, acceptable and expected methods/mentality to use.

However why would you yell or slap someone to do make them something for you when you can ask nicely and fairly, and have them leap up to do it?

This debate reminds me of the science VS religion debate - you should be able to take bits from each and use those beliefs, rather than feel that you have to chose one over the other. Also, they don't have to oppose each other at all; they can work together harmoniously, just like traditional and NH methods, if you let them.

x
 
Last edited:
It has been a great thread, and a really encouraging one I feel with lots of understanding from all posting, I'm glad I started it!

The dentist visited my horse a couple of weeks back, and he himself apparently is NH trained (did work with Monty Roberts in the US) and he was asking me questions etc about Ranger as he handled him. He asked me if we did groundwork and if he would "back up" to which I said "yes". So he started waving the leadrop in front of him and he just stood and looked at him a bit puzzled. I said "all you have to do is put a finger on his nose and say the word "back" and he will do it", which he did! :)

It's just another example of all the different ways of doing things, in a lot of cases there is no right or wrong, just different! :)
 
Well said! :)
There are so many individual differences to take into account, such as the personality, beliefs, education and attitude of both the horse and rider which makes for so many different ways of doing things.

x
 
I don’t think it’s unfair to say Traditional is not BHS any more than saying NH is not Parelli.

I don’t have access to PP, MR, Mark Rashid, Curt Pate etc, doesn’t mean my only option is BHS, a huge amount is available with the modern media if people choose to look or are aware of the options.

And that is one of the problems imo lack of awareness ....

Oh yes oh yes!

But it's not just 'modern media' - my daughter's INNER-CITY branch library has the Michael Peace books, Karen Pryor, Linda Telllington-Jones, among others, as well as Alois Podhjsky.

Not bad for a branch where the only horses to be seen on the streets are police horses, and where the deprivation index is something off the scale. It only takes a moment of looking or asking to broaden one's equestrian education far, far beyond bog-standard riding school fare (with apologies to all those NON-bog-standard riding schools out there!).
 
In addition, I think that it is very sad that some people seem feel that they need to be told to look at things from the horse's POV. I was always under the impression that this would be one of the first actions of any thinking human who is, or who becomes, closely involved with a member of another species through their own volition.

Grab a copy of this months' YH mag.... there is a very interesting, long (lots of pics) article on Traditional and NH 'starting' horses.
I know which method clearly takes the horses POV into consideration and which doesnt (and the 'doesnt' is how an extremely good, talented Olympic dressage rider/trainer and breeder does it)........
 
Great selection of horse writers, OW. However many such writers (Roberts, Peace, Rashid, Moffett to name a few) start their books with an account of how they were raised within one school of thought - without really questioning it- then realised how inadequate this was and developed different ways of doing things.....

Of course there is good info out there, but it strikes me as odd that it is quite so hard to get at it. As well as being into horses I am also a triathlete and endurance runner. While different coaches have differing styles, you don't get a situation where coach after coach says "well I did my British Triathlon Coaching Qualifications, and then learnt that......."
 
Of course there is good info out there, but it strikes me as odd that it is quite so hard to get at it.

Now this is where I am stumped. WHAT is so hard about reading a darned book? The library provision in the UK is - despite cuts and ecomomies - simply excellent and you don't even need electricity to read a book! Put it in a sturdy plastic bag and take it out to the field with you to read and practice with ...

As a teenager at school in the 1950s, to this day I can remember a speaker we had at assembly. He was from an organisation which supplied books and supported library services in what is now known as the third world. He painted a vivid picture of a poor man or woman struggling to learn to read and then, desperate for books, the charity supplied them with basic texts about things such as repairing water pumps, rearing goats, family hygiene, child nutrition and women's health which could and often did bring massive improvements to a family and to the wider community.

We are so, so fortunate not to have this struggle, The sheer amount of information out there, free for the taking and easy of access, is simply astounding.

If people claim that the information available is in too great a quantity to sort through, or that it is hard to know which information to rely on, then I could sympathise. If people live in a country without a free-at-point-of-use (or almost free) library service, then I would agree that buying a range of books (new) could well be prohibitively expensive.

But come on -
it strikes me as odd that it is quite so hard to get at it.

I am afraid that it strikes ME as odd that anyone would believe it to be hard to get at!
 
I encourage someone who's a bit hard up but keen every year to get to see the clinics that I run. I give them a free spectator place in return for help with running the clinic, it might mean going to collect lunches, making sure everyone who arrives knows where to put their horse and gets settled in. Little groups of us meet up from time to time to discuss or watch each other work with a horse, we have Alexander lessons as well. There's a lot of encouragement out there once you start to get your feet wet.
And yes, the libraries are much better at getting the books you want to read than people realise. :)
 
I don't think you are comparing like for like, on the whole you are attempting to resolve what you see as issues while she is just working round them.

But what if the answer you get isn't one you can work with?

If the reason your horse wont do something is because it has never been taught properly, then teach it.

What if it knows exactly what is required of it? (e.g. does it instantly if it knows there is a chance of a food reward?)

I think the 'why' approach is all very well in principle, as long as you can get an answer that means you can do something....
 
But what if the answer you get isn't one you can work with?

If the reason your horse wont do something is because it has never been taught properly, then teach it.

What if it knows exactly what is required of it? (e.g. does it instantly if it knows there is a chance of a food reward?)

I think the 'why' approach is all very well in principle, as long as you can get an answer that means you can do something....

Focussing on 'why' doesn't mean let the horse do what it wants. If you understand the 'why' you've got a much better chance of 'persuading' the horse to do what YOU want.
There are 3 major reasons for horse behaviours which I reckon account for most horse responses to human requests:

1: Horse doesn't understand request/command
2: Horse can't comply with request/command
3: Horse doesn't want to comply with request/command

IMO, many people jump straight to 3 and pay little attention to 1 or 2.

I totally agree with you - if he doesn;t understand, teach him. If he's scared, desensitise him. If he can't be arsed, get after him!
So if you are confident that the horse knows what you want then you can confidently use incentives or pressure.

Understanding the why might give you a tricky answer - in which case you need to out-think the horse. So WHY for not being caught could be 'Thanks but I'd prefer to munch grass'. So the solutiuon to this 'why' is make staying in the field VERY hard work.

Sorry if I've misunderstood your post.
 
Ditto Krissie - as the saying goes "if your horse isn't doing what you want it to do then you are either asking the wrong question, or asking the question wrong".

x
 
Ditto Krissie - as the saying goes "if your horse isn't doing what you want it to do then you are either asking the wrong question, or asking the question wrong".

x

I would argue that in many instances the question is neither wrong in itself, nor being asked wrongly - rather that you shouldn't even be asking the question at all at that stage.
 
I would argue that in many instances the question is neither wrong in itself, nor being asked wrongly - rather that you shouldn't even be asking the question at all at that stage.

Can you give a concrete example - I'm not sure I understand what you mean. In what instances should you not be seeking to understand the 'why' of horse behaviour?
 
Asking a horse to do anything which is beyond its 'ken' or its understanding is, in my opinion, a question which should not have been asked at all.

That is not to say that a horse should not learn new things! Of course it should - the more it learns, the easier it will find learning to be.

It is not a case of 'not understanding' horse behaviour - it is case of understanding horse behaviour to the point that you KNOW there is no point or purpose in asking a particular question, as the horse in question has no mental background with which to offer you a positive, or even possible, answer. This is where I believe clicker training can be so very valuable - it teaches the horse to think not just to react.

Sometimes, of course, you will ask a question with the best will in the world, believing wholeheartedly that the horse will understand your request. If it doesn't, then that is a lesson for YOU - and lessons for you are more valuable by far than lessons for your horse.

Concrete examples - this is a bit more difficult as it is more a philosphy than something where one can use concrete examples. Here's one, though. Trailer/box loading. If your horse doesn't (a) trust humans and (b) understand the 'go forward' cue, all the fancy-mancy 'questions' in the world may well result in his refusing to load. There is nothing inherently wrong with the question itself, nor with the way it is being asked - except that it should not have been asked in the first place! if it is not an emergency situation, then you need to - MUST! - work on (a) and (b). Of course some horses are inherently more trusting than others, and some have learned to ***trust. Unlearning something is always harder work than learning something, for us or for horses.
 
I was not suggesting one should always be asking THE HORSE questions - just that the 'why' question should always be in one's own mind. This was in response to a post saying 'but what if the horse gives you an answer you can't do anything with?' My view is that understanding the why is always helpful.

I agree that sometimes knowing what not to ask of your horse - or when to recognise you are asking too much and backing off is important.
 
what about the ones that when you aks the question , nicely, but they are P taking

its debatable

in my experience not every horse is honest...........so what when they arnt

youve done the work, the horse is ready

but its a pig headed horse.I mean some just do ignore

so I think its keeping all the knowlage you have and balancing it to suit each horse no??

like somethimes akwardness isnt any fault of the rider.....its the horse

some just arnt honest in these cases I think you have just be firm but fair

thats my thougths on it :)

mix it all up use all the knowlage , dont seperate it out and be a follower of one genre of horsemanship

you can loose a lot of valuble tools at your fingertips

keep an open mind

dont follow

make breakthroughs and share :D
 
what about the ones that when you aks the question , nicely, but they are P taking

its debatable

in my experience not every horse is honest...........so what when they arnt

youve done the work, the horse is ready

but its a pig headed horse.I mean some just do ignore

so I think its keeping all the knowlage you have and balancing it to suit each horse no??

like somethimes akwardness isnt any fault of the rider.....its the horse

some just arnt honest in these cases I think you have just be firm but fair

YOU'VE done the work and YOU think the horse 'should' be ready ...
DID YOU ASK THE HORSE AND GET A RESOUNDING 'YES'?

No, of course you didn't - you can't!

I don't believe that horses have the intellectual ability to be 'honest' or 'dishonest'. These concepts are far beyond the understanding of horses.

The concept that they ARE very quick at learning and differentiating is 'it will profit me/it will profit me not'.

It is we humans who teach 'mixed messages' to horses and thus trigger confused reactions which we humans, in our wisdom, choose to describe as 'stubborness' or 'dishonesty'. Now then, please do not think that I am talking about 'poor confused horses, diddums'. Far from it - when danger arises, sometimes drastic means are necessary for our own safety.

BTW I think that being firm but fair is an essential attribute for ANY horse-owner, trainer or rider, not just the one with the 'awkward' horse.
 
newrider.com