What more can I do????

I've done 2 full clips on my grey boy already so I wouldn't worry about that. He is connemara X ID and gets super fluffy! Is there anyway you could do more hacking? Lots of hill work and interval training I find best to shift weight. I usually have the problem of keeping weight on when they are all hunting hard! You'll just have to go hunting twice a week lol. It is hard coz it sounds like you are doing all you can. Hope you find a solution to it all, ride twice a day maybe?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mary Poppins
I understand it is important to keep them at a healthy weight but I have to say I do wonder if some vets are getting a bit carried away with the whole weight thing. Some are evangelical about it and I do think a sensible vet would / should be able to see the overall picture. You are working Ben and trying to do everything you can to ensure he's a healthy size. I think a good vet should be able to differentiate between a horse that is overweight and at risk and one that is worked regularly, with the owner doing all they can to maintain a sensible weight. Surely Ben's breed dictates his shape to a certain degree? I really wonder about vets opinions on this at times. It isn't black and white - it can't be because of there being so many factors involved.
 
I really wonder about vets opinions on this at times. It isn't black and white - it can't be because of there being so many factors involved.

Yes, agree completely - also it is natural and desirable for the horse to gain weight over the summer and lose it again over the winter. It is now thought that maintaining a level weight throughout the year could be a contributory cause of the increasing incidence of insulin resistance which can lead to laminitis.

Scully is a 17 hh warmblood/TB/Shire cross and goes into Winter at about 700 kilos and by Spring is around 650 kilos.
 
I can empathise with your situation - we are/have been at the other end of the spectrum with the added complications of a long period of no exercise being available to us as an option - no matter what the size of the animal the breed is a big factor and your vet should have taken this into account when making any comment or recommendations - now unless you have a specialist equine vet with a good knowledge of breed definition then for me most vets have a one covers all attitude to weight.

Most peoples vision of a Shetland is Thelwell when infact most are obese- thank god that vision is changing.

I wouldn't even try to advise/comment on your situation as I am not familiar with the breed type, but have vast experience is general weight loss management on our own.

My farrier will also tells me if he thinks a problems brewing - suprising how the tiniest extra wieght shows in the trim.

We are lucky in that our Vets practice have a couple of equine vets and where ever possible and certainly if we are looking for specific advise we ask and get them.

I don't need to be told when they are overweight - I can see and feel it for myself - having had 2 with lammi and not due to weight the last thing I need is obesity in the mix but I get caught out now and again - take my eye off the ball or change in grass conditions ,we have battled with Nuts now for 2yrs + and gone from Hippo status 284kg for a 34" shetland to 170kg at the last weigh in she has been diagnosed with OA earlier this year - the extra weight and years as a brood mare took their toll together with an old injury and a more recent one this year - shes 20 now and has not been able to take proper exercise for 8 months - she is now in a position to start again but winter is not the best time, but we are were we want to be going into winter - we have restricted her grazing since April - she has a flap of hay now morning and night which she shares with Acorn - so prob one a day if shes lucky and a small maintenance feed of HH with her suppliments twice a day - she has this 365 days a year and is on 24/7 turnout - she has a rug on cold/wet and windy days even though she has a good coat to help withstiffness and it seems to be keeping it off - she will next month come off the hay and restricted and go onto the winter grazing with Tess who has been eating the best of it off - its rough hill grazing and is not fertilized, I full expect she may add a few kg at first but would expect this to be off again by spring when she will go into restricted again withe boys who have the same regime - Tess at 24 came out of winter heavier than she went in last year - unrugged, no exercise other than 24/7 turnout- a small maintenance feed for her suppliments twice a day - she has this during summer on restricted and maintains an acceptable weight - she went onto the winter grazing and the weight went on in 2 weeks we dropped the hard feed by a 1/3 and shes okay now as shes had the best grass - for us its the Grass/quality/quantity - they look at it and on goes the weight - its not rich grazing far from it but it does what theyexpect to do put weight on during the growing months to sustain over the winter months without the benefit of roaming miles in a day using some of that energy up finding the fuel.


On the last Vet visit he commented on weight loss and was more than pleased with all of them - he actually asked as for some tips - he has a porky shetland companion and needs to do something that works!


I suspect the lengthening of the growing period due to the milder climate conditions has a lot to do with it - last winter we had very few weeks where the grass stopped growing - so this year will be keeping an eye on the temps.

Lawns are still being cut weekly here - so sense tells us the grass is still growing.

I couldn't full clip and leave turned out over winter in all weathers and I find it difficult in any circumstances to understand why you would need to - on the other hand I wouldn't by choice (daughter has a different view) rug ours unless for health reasons even with a partial clip(not that they get one) - but I would like to think they have a full coat on their back - we turn away for winter so I can see a need for those who are lucky enough to have the facities and time to be able to ride all year round and need to clip and subsequently rug - , we don't so its not a factor in winter management.

For me every situation is individual to you - its finding what works and then managing it to the best you can - at the end of the day we can only do what we feel best and not everyone will agree with you all the time.
 
I haven't read all the replies but my thinking is its Autumn and its mild.
If his weight has levelled off then when it gets cold he will lose the remainder. You haven't said what he is and what you want/need him to be.
Mine has settled at 464kg with a high trace, she is out naked as her back and quarters have an unclipped untouched coat. If I reclip she would get a sheet, but that was if she gained weight-she is out on 15acres of winter grazing.

I wouldn't turn a clipped horse out with a rug, I haven't heard of freezing weight off, you clip because they sweat too much when worked. A cold horse eats more.

Can I just say that cob types are meant to have the apple bum, if your vet cares to look at the skeleton the tail is set low and the pelvis is wide. I get comments on my cobs bum but its pure muscle, no fat. The physio confirmed its muscle. They are designed to pull carts.
 
Thanks for all the comments, it's all food for thought. The vet warned me that many people may consider the 'freezing' it off option cruel, but in his opinion it is far crueller to allow a horse to become fat and risk the health consequences resulting from it. He says horses do not feel cold in the same way as humans. Ben will run round to keep warm and the grass in his field will act as an internal stove which creates warmth from the inside and his body will burn his excess fat to keep warm. He said to not think of him as a human because he is not human - he is a horse who has a completely different body than a human and it's far kinder for him to lose weight over winter than let him go into spring the same size as he is now.

He is an experienced equine vet with a fantastic reputation, but he is known for being strict on weight issues. He said that he sees many overweight horses and he is the one who deals with the consequences of it. In my heart of hearts I know that he is right. Ben is too carrying too much weight and if I want him to be at optimum health, the weight has to come off. He acknowledged that we have made significant process since he last saw us, but it's still not enough.

Many of you say that he will lose weight naturally over winter, but if I allow him to grow a full coat and/or rug him then I know he won't lose a pound. He will lose weight if I put him in a stable with no food but I think that is cruel and certainly not good for his digestive system.

Increased cardio exercise is the way forward, a few people have suggested that I take him hunting. If I wasn't such a wuss this is what I would do, but I would be terrified!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ruskii
I feel for you having a good doer myself. My vet said last month to keep going with the exercise and I know I have weight to lose. About 15kg.
What's helped us is trotting up hills. I trot up either of the last hills as they are a mile long.

Its 0 degrees here tonight, not sure about the rest of you.

I found this site re rainscald, yes its bacterial but its based on whether your horse is either a carrier or is exposed to a carrier (source of infection) The bacteria lives on the skin all time. Wet comes into it. On my yard we have one with skin problems he could easily be a carrier.

Eta-forgot the link

http://www.vevs.com.au/site/articles/56-uncategorised/229-rain-scald.html
 
Last edited:
Well you have nice big fields at your yard, I'd be doing lots of cantering around the fields up and down the hills and doing lots of schooling in extended canter back to shortened strides, lots and lots of transitions of cantering to trotting on the hills in those lovely fields, that will help shift the fat and make a nice muscled bum ! :)
 
Not easy, and I understand that you respect what your vet says and wish to concur.

What I would say is that some horses will always do better than others, and I personally think it is ridiculous to have a height and weight rule - thoroughbreds will always weight different to other horses.

I have an appaloosa. His background breeding, apart from appaloosa would be quarter horse bred in during recent decades - along with that TB and Arab - all of which I have picked up from researching his own particular breeding.

He has recently gone barefoot as he has had a tendon injury. He has a gutter down his backside BECAUSE of his breeding, and always has done, even when I could feel his ribs. Quarter horses are bred to be able to herd cattle. To do that they have to have short cannon bones, good shoulders and big back ends.

The barefoot trimming lady came last week to trim Tobes and tells me that he has good feet. No laminitic rings - a lot of other horses on our yard, who are shod, who are not built as stockily as Tobes, have laminitic rings, but they are shod and that would mask any lameness. Also good soles, and she believes he can go barefoot happily. I already feed as people who keep barefoot horses would.

He has put on weight since he hasn't been ridden due to his tendon injury. But when ridden, we would hack for miles, and he always lost more weight hacking than schooling. I know you are not keen on hacking, but I think hacking really loses weight easily and consistently. I think you also need to bear in mind that a 16hh shire cross for instance is ALWAYS going to weight heavier than a 16hh TB, and won't hurt for it.

I personally would NEVER clip a horse out and leave it naked. I think it is cruel and would far rather up the work or put it on less lush grazing than do that. But that is my opinion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: flump1967 and Lemme
Thanks for all the comments, it's all food for thought. The vet warned me that many people may consider the 'freezing' it off option cruel, but in his opinion it is far crueller to allow a horse to become fat and risk the health consequences resulting from it. He says horses do not feel cold in the same way as humans. Ben will run round to keep warm and the grass in his field will act as an internal stove which creates warmth from the inside and his body will burn his excess fat to keep warm. He said to not think of him as a human because he is not human - he is a horse who has a completely different body than a human and it's far kinder for him to lose weight over winter than let him go into spring the same size as he is now.

He is an experienced equine vet with a fantastic reputation, but he is known for being strict on weight issues. He said that he sees many overweight horses and he is the one who deals with the consequences of it. In my heart of hearts I know that he is right. Ben is too carrying too much weight and if I want him to be at optimum health, the weight has to come off. He acknowledged that we have made significant process since he last saw us, but it's still not enough.

Many of you say that he will lose weight naturally over winter, but if I allow him to grow a full coat and/or rug him then I know he won't lose a pound. He will lose weight if I put him in a stable with no food but I think that is cruel and certainly not good for his digestive system.

Increased cardio exercise is the way forward, a few people have suggested that I take him hunting. If I wasn't such a wuss this is what I would do, but I would be terrified!

I draw the line at clipping and leaving out.... from what i gather he’s bedded on straw? The only way you are really going to shift more lbs is to weigh out his entire intake for 24hours and get him off a straw bed so he cant top himself up.
 
Yes your vet is right about the inside furnace but I am horrified at a fully clipped horse turned out naked been seen as acceptable,he will have no external protection at all and I'm afraid that to me is cruel. I'm all for clipping and turning out without rugs if it's a suitable clip. But fully clipped?That is not natural by any stretch of the imagination. I think you do amazingly with Ben's weight and have come so far but I just cannot get my head around naked fully clipped.
 
He does have straw in his stable but he doesn't eat it. He often doesn't eat his hay either, when he comes in from the field he lies down in his bed and goes to sleep. It's not like he hovers up everything he sees. His weight issue is not something new to me, I have been dealing with it for years. He has lost 100kg from his heaviest and now we have reached a static level and I thought that he was doing well until the vet said otherwise.

I think that the clipping and naked issue isn't so black and white. Tonight it is going to be freezing so I have put a light rug on him and for the next few days it's going to be raining so he will have his rug on during the rain. Obviously when it's very cold and raining it wouldn't be right to leave him naked, but when it's 10 degrees and dry that is different. It also depends on how new the clip is. When the clip is new, he will need a rug more often, but when it is a few weeks old he will have more natural protection. He naturally grows a very, very thick coat which grows quickly and is why I have had to reclip him 3 times already this year.

I don't really see any other options. He is in a big field but the quality of grass isn't so great now they have been in it for a few months and there is not a huge amount of grass in there. I'm not prepared to stable him for longer and neither am I inclined to take him away from his friends and put him in a starvation paddock. I already ride him everyday and we already do fast rides over the fields, although I will do more of this.

My vet doesn't do a height/weight ratio - not sure where that idea came from? He assessed Ben, did the weight tape and said that he needed to lose 50kg, but also condition scored him and pointed out parts of him that were fat. Mainly his bum!
 
He does have straw in his stable but he doesn't eat it. He often doesn't eat his hay either, when he comes in from the field he lies down in his bed and goes to sleep. It's not like he hovers up everything he sees. His weight issue is not something new to me, I have been dealing with it for years. He has lost 100kg from his heaviest and now we have reached a static level and I thought that he was doing well until the vet said otherwise.

you’ve done a fab job!

do i understand he sometimes has hay left in the morning? He really sounds as if he is being given too much, sorry. There must be more in the field than you think as well if he isn’t coming in that hungry. He’s maybe just fine as he is but if you want to get more off him, he needs to not have access to so much and you need to be able to meticulously monitor it, you can’t know for sure he isn’t picking at straw over night but if has hay left then its unlikely, i agree. the idea would be to weigh his haynet and that is ALL he gets overnight and to prevent him topping up if he’s hungry he’d need to be off the straw. At least you know there IS more you can do if you decide you want/need to :)
 
Ben lives out overnight and spends at least 18 hours in the field. He only comes in from the field for a few hours everyday. This was mainly so that in the summer he could have break from his grazing muzzle, but I have kept the same routine in the winter because he likes to sleep. I know that he lies down and sleeps for a good 3 hours because the yard staff see him do it and everyone can hear him snoring. I leave a small soaked haynet in his stable for him to pick out if he wishes, but he prefers to sleep. I then ride him in the evening and turn him out again.

To stop him eating his bed I mix in wet bedding with the clean straw. He never touches it.
 
Ben lives out overnight and spends at least 18 hours in the field. He only comes in from the field for a few hours everyday. This was mainly so that in the summer he could have break from his grazing muzzle, but I have kept the same routine in the winter because he likes to sleep. I know that he lies down and sleeps for a good 3 hours because the yard staff see him do it and everyone can hear him snoring. I leave a small soaked haynet in his stable for him to pick out if he wishes, but he prefers to sleep. I then ride him in the evening and turn him out again.

To stop him eating his bed I mix in wet bedding with the clean straw. He never touches it.

ah i misunderstood, i thought he was in overnight, apologies. He must be getting more from the grass that you realise but if you don’t want to stable him longer or get him in a fatty paddock i don’t see any other options for you either.
 
The vet agreed that his field was the most suitable place for him. He wouldn't want to see Ben stabled overnight because he believes that horses will shift more weight moving around all night, and that it's better for his joints to be out.

The grazing muzzle has been a godsend but I removed it when I first clipped him. Perhaps I should have kept it on for longer, but this hasn't made much difference as he has only gained a tiny bit of weight since I removed it. He is happy out in herd and if it's a choice between keeping him cold to get the weight off, or making him miserable by keeping him on a small field on his own, I will opt for the cold option.

Thanks for all the comments - my mind is going round in circles so I'm off to bed now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CharliesAngel
As soon as the weather gets colder I think his weight will drop anyway. Do you hay in the field at winter?
 
As soon as the weather gets colder I think his weight will drop anyway. Do you hay in the field at winter?

I don't think that he will as he has never lost weight over winter before. Last year I blanket clipped him and turned him out naked all winter and he didn't drop a pound, that is why the vet has told me to fully clip and turn out naked this year. The grazing muzzle is the only thing that stops the weight piling on in the summer, but we have hit a brick wall with the weight loss and he just won't drop anymore. The vet seems to think that it is 'easy' to get that 50kg of him, but unless I take him off grass and basically stave him I can't see how I can do it. He needs to eat forage - he is a big horse and needs to have fibre going through his body and denying him of this will just cause problems in a different area.

No we don't hay the fields. I can't state enough that he doesn't have any extra food - just the grass in the field (which is starting to look sorry for itself) and a small soaked haynet for his stable which he doesn't eat anyway because he sleeps when he comes in. All his field mates are on 2 big hard feeds per day, all are rugged and have ad lib haylege in their stables. There is one other horse in his herd who could do with some weight off him, but his owner doesn't think he is fat.

We have made a start on the increased exercise front. I rode him for an hour in the school last night and only stopped for a few minutes walk (because I needed a rest) and the rest of the time we were trotting and cantering. He coped with this fine and wasn't even puffed out. I was knackard!
 
Sorry MP but if you really want to get the extra weight off you are going to have to restrict his grazing, I'm not saying leave him in a stable with no food but you either need to get that muzzle back on, get him on a fatty paddock or get him in for longer and give him soaked hay/straw.
He is obviously getting more than he needs in the field and believe me you would be amazed how much they can find to eat even when we think there isn't a stitch of grass in the field, if he's not eating his hay in the stable and he's overweight then he's eating more than he needs, just like humans, if we put in more than we use we get fat.
I think you have done really well to get the 100kg off him and I can see your predicament re not wanting him away from his friends but it's probably the only other option left if you really need to shift that bit of extra weight.
 
Last winter was very mild though! This winter if its colder may just do the trick! Can you see/feel ribs. Maybe get a second opinion also, he sounds very fit and on your controlled management I wouldn't of thought he would be too bad! Esp if your yo agrees that he isn't too bad
 
newrider.com