Thanks for all the comments, it's all food for thought. The vet warned me that many people may consider the 'freezing' it off option cruel, but in his opinion it is far crueller to allow a horse to become fat and risk the health consequences resulting from it. He says horses do not feel cold in the same way as humans. Ben will run round to keep warm and the grass in his field will act as an internal stove which creates warmth from the inside and his body will burn his excess fat to keep warm. He said to not think of him as a human because he is not human - he is a horse who has a completely different body than a human and it's far kinder for him to lose weight over winter than let him go into spring the same size as he is now.
He is an experienced equine vet with a fantastic reputation, but he is known for being strict on weight issues. He said that he sees many overweight horses and he is the one who deals with the consequences of it. In my heart of hearts I know that he is right. Ben is too carrying too much weight and if I want him to be at optimum health, the weight has to come off. He acknowledged that we have made significant process since he last saw us, but it's still not enough.
Many of you say that he will lose weight naturally over winter, but if I allow him to grow a full coat and/or rug him then I know he won't lose a pound. He will lose weight if I put him in a stable with no food but I think that is cruel and certainly not good for his digestive system.
Increased cardio exercise is the way forward, a few people have suggested that I take him hunting. If I wasn't such a wuss this is what I would do, but I would be terrified!