I think also, the person who has worked out healthy weights for heights has some answering to do - at 5ft 7ins - I look terminally ill anywhere near 10 stone yet around 11 stone is the top weight for that height :ninja:
I think also, the person who has worked out healthy weights for heights has some answering to do - at 5ft 7ins - I look terminally ill anywhere near 10 stone yet around 11 stone is the top weight for that height :ninja:
My BMI puts me in the 40+ category of obese. I am obese. I have no issue with what its telling me as its right. Ashamedly. What I do have issue with is the target 'normal' range for me being below 10 stone. Unrealistic for me. But someone will come along and say it is possible if I stop eating so much and exercise more. So I'll bow out now before I get annoyed at the potential replies that might not happen sorry!!!!:redface:
Good point Kite Rider. I can run six miles non stop. But I'm still fat.
This is interesting I am 5'5, a size 8, 9'2 with a bmi of 21.4 and not to boast but I am extremly fit and health I run at least 3 times a week 4-6 miles a time, Gym the other 2 days and ride my boys every night and I run between 7.33 - 8.20 minute miles.
I was reading an articule the other day about BMIs it stated that although it does not represent and work for every member of society the very fit strong rubgy types will even out with the very slim fit types so across the board it is meant to be a general guide not the bible of healthly living.
They are looking at a new way but it is not available to the general public as it requires your details to be input in to a machine.
Does there even need to be a general guide to health? I think so but like some have said it should not be used as a beating stick but but they are guidelines not rules.
My weight range is 7,10 to 10'7 I have been at both I looked to thin at the lower end and a little plump at the top.
Quite. Obviously, all BMI can tell you is whether you're at higher risk of weight-related illnesses such as type 2 diabetes etc. It's not an indicator of all-round good health or a diagnostic tool. My doctor has never looked at my BMI - not even when I was pregnant - and I don't imagine they do unless you actually go and see them about weight-related issues, so it's hardly a stick to beat people with, really.
But I think that relying on it does put barriers up. About 7 years ago I was told I didn't need help because I was an ok weight for my height according to the BMI scale. I'm glad things are changing now but for a while that was all doctors were relying on when it came to weight/health issues.
But I think that relying on it does put barriers up. About 7 years ago I was told I didn't need help because I was an ok weight for my height according to the BMI scale. I'm glad things are changing now but for a while that was all doctors were relying on when it came to weight/health issues.
That sounds like laziness on the part of your doctor, though. I've found that they often seem out of their depth if you go to them with a problem that's psychological, such as an eating disorder (I've not had one of those, I have had anxiety issues though.) They're happy to throw pills at the problem, but so long as you seem physically OK, that often seems to be job done as far as they're concerned.
Things are changing but they have to because the general population are getting fatter with more weight related issues.
If you removed this guide what are they meant to use? This guide used in conjunction with the waist measurement is the better option that and talking to the individual about their life style. but again this only works when someone approaches the Dr about a weight related issue be it to large or to small but as for those people that do not want to approach the DR they can look at the internet and get their BMI the result may be a shock but there are articules all over the internet about what the BMI means and puts it in to perceptive if you are above you BMI range then all it is saying is that you are at a greater risk to certain illness. It is a trigger a warning.
That sounds like laziness on the part of your doctor, though. I've found that they often seem out of their depth if you go to them with a problem that's psychological, such as an eating disorder (I've not had one of those, I have had anxiety issues though.) They're happy to throw pills at the problem, but so long as you seem physically OK, that often seems to be job done as far as they're concerned.
Yes not all gps are equal. Back in the 90's I was suffering from depression and OCD to the point where the OCD controlled me. My gp tested my thyroid then sent me away with a flea in my ear and told me to lose weight! No help at all for the real reasons behind my appointment.