What is your BMI?

Sunshine-x

Well-Known Member
Jul 31, 2008
2,703
90
48
Bit of a nosey question! :yellowcarded: Was chatting to someone on fb about BMI and how you look/feel and thought it would be interesting to get a wide range. My BMI is currently 20.6 according to the NHS calculator. It tells me my ideal weight for my height has 3 stone of variation from the lowest to the highest. Now I reckon personally I would be overweight if I were at the higher end of my ideal weight and cannot picture someone of that weight and height being considered an ideal healthy weight. So if you are considered in the ideal BMI range how do you feel about that range of weight for your height, do you think it is about right, or not enough/too much variation? I know there are obvious exceptions for rugby players and the like but for the majority of people do you think BMI is a good indicator of ideal weight? Feel free to ignore me if you think its too nosey but it is an area I am considering going into re work as a follow up from my degree and would find the info useful. :smile:
 
Mine is 20.7. That's OK I suppose. I could get away with another half a stone, any more than that and I feel flabby.
 
My BMI puts me in the 40+ category of obese. I am obese. I have no issue with what its telling me as its right. Ashamedly. What I do have issue with is the target 'normal' range for me being below 10 stone. Unrealistic for me. But someone will come along and say it is possible if I stop eating so much and exercise more. So I'll bow out now before I get annoyed at the potential replies that might not happen sorry!!!!:redface:
 
I think as a basic rule of thumb BMI is ok, however, that doesn't take into account someone's fitness.
I mean you can be thin as a lath but still be unfit, or you could be on the heavier end of your BMI healthy range and be really fit and healthy.

I'm not sure what mine is but I know I'm in the healthy weight range for my height, according to the chart I should be somewhere between 8 stone and 11 stone, I know for a fact that much less than I am now (9 stone) and I start to look too thin, but if I got up to 10 stone I would look fat so yeah I see what you are saying.

Oh I've just done the nhs BMI thingy and I'm 20.3
 
Last edited:
I haven't a clue what mine is- but I shall just go and check on the NHS thingy!

Done it - 24 - is that good? It doesnt ask for age or anything just height and weight, doesnt age or activity level come into it then?:unsure:
 
Some of the top athletes of this country are obese according to the BMI scale - its a big table of shit as far as I am concerned - and not a great way to judge if you are overweight/healthy or not. #justsaying

There are many other ways to judge what weight you should be or your height.
 
I haven't a clue what mine is- but I shall just go and check on the NHS thingy!

Done it - 24 - is that good? It doesnt ask for age or anything just height and weight, doesnt age or activity level come into it then?:unsure:

The NHS one asked me for age, does it come up differently for you? Here is a link to the NHS one I used.
http://www.nhs.uk/Tools/Pages/Healthyweightcalculator.aspx

Ideal range is between 18.5 and 25 apparently.
 
Some of the top athletes of this country are obese according to the BMI scale - its a big table of shit as far as I am concerned - and not a great way to judge if you are overweight/healthy or not. #justsaying

There are many other ways to judge what weight you should be or your height.

Was hoping someone would say this! How would you find a good way to judge weight, by clothes size/measurements or another way?
 
Some of the top athletes of this country are obese according to the BMI scale - its a big table of shit as far as I am concerned - and not a great way to judge if you are overweight/healthy or not. #justsaying

There are many other ways to judge what weight you should be or your height.

I dunno. If you're a rugby player or weight lifter, you might come up as obese, but very few non-athletes would have that kind of muscle density. It would just be fat. I think the BMI range is quite broad, really. It's not a tool for diagnosing how healthy you are, but pretty good at what it does in telling you if you're bigger than you should be!
 
Was hoping someone would say this! How would you find a good way to judge weight, by clothes size/measurements or another way?

One of the other ways is your measurements, for example, having a waist over 37 inches is supposed to be unhealthy and so, have attached a link

http://www.thecalculatorsite.com/articles/health/alternatives-to-bmi.php

BMI just does not take any other factors like ethinicity (sp) into account, where as it is important.

Any muscle density changes the factor not just big athlete muscle.

If you look at people outside of the normal range, that are classed as obese, like some 5 year old children, its obvious its wrong.
 
One of the other ways is your measurements, for example, having a waist over 37 inches is supposed to be unhealthy and so, have attached a link

http://www.thecalculatorsite.com/articles/health/alternatives-to-bmi.php

BMI just does not take any other factors like ethinicity (sp) into account, where as it is important.

Any muscle density changes the factor not just big athlete muscle.

If you look at people outside of the normal range, that are classed as obese, like some 5 year old children, its obvious its wrong.

Although there's some margin for error, the majority of people with high BMIs are obese. Criticising the way of determining who is and who isn't seems to be shooting the messenger, rather. As a society, we're fatter and unhealthier than ever before, although paradoxically, living longer. Luckily, our lives don't demand that we go out and hunt wildebeest any more though, so in a sense it's not really a problem, apart from the strain on the NHS.
 
no idea, I don't own any scales :frown: last time they weighed me at the GP it was bang in the middle of the scale in the green. it's probably not quite as 'average' post pregnancy any more, ahem. To be honest, I don't think a BMI is needed to figure out if someone is too big?
 
I do not doubt for one minute we are all fatter blah blah, however the way it is measured within the BMI tables, IMO, is flawed especially for children.

It should not be used as a stick to beat people with. It is not shooting the messenger its simply saying it is flawed. If the way we class people is flawed, of course its right to review it.

Alternatives are less flawed IMO.
 
I do not doubt for one minute we are all fatter blah blah, however the way it is measured within the BMI tables, IMO, is flawed especially for children.

It should not be used as a stick to beat people with. It is not shooting the messenger its simply saying it is flawed. If the way we class people is flawed, of course its right to review it.

Alternatives are less flawed IMO.

I think you're right about kids - they are still growing and people don't necessarily do that on some kind of neat, perfect curve.

For fully grown adults, I think it's a crude but fairly effective tool for working out if someone is too heavy for their height. But as others have said, you generally don't need to do a calculation for that.
 
newrider.com