Vetting

If the vet finds any sign of lameness at the vetting this goes on the report and will result in insurance exclusions. That is one reason why I walked away from Baby Pony because all 4 feet would have been instantly excluded. My vet says many people have the horse vetted, vet says it’s lame and they buy the horse anyway and then blame the vet for seeing lameness! I was so upset to walk away from the sale, but I know it was the right thing for me and now I have Harry to ride. I do wonder what happened to him though, I wonder if he is still lame?
I had one vetted after i had tried him, rode like a dream. Pulled out of stable hobbling, vet said just get out of here as he had clearly been buted up when i rode him. she said he had long term issues and just walk.
 
This seems very open to subjectivity, I had no clue! I've been reading more about it and it's no longer a pass or fail its purely based on if the horse is suitable for intended use.

I guess no matter what you could change in the sales process those horses would still be lame, so if they had no chance of being sold what would happen to them.
It is still a pass or fail if the horse is lame. A lame horse is a lame horse regardless. However, it means the buyer can decide to walk away or retest depending on what showed up and the intended use.

I think you are getting confused because you are assuming a vetting is just about finding out if the horse is sound, it's a lot more involved than that.

And answering the op question no I don't think a vet certificate done by the owner is a good idea, because it's already out of date once it's done.
 
Just pondering. With all these lame horses being advertised for sale. What are peoples thoughts on making the seller have the horse vetted at the time of adverising.
Should they be made to have a 2 stage vet minimum. Which would cover young stock. Not in work.
Could such a system even work.
I have just thought of something.

If the seller gets their vet to do a pie purchase two stage and there is an issue. That issue will likely go on my vet records. This could mean my insurance may exclude things I didn't know I had a problem with.
The buyer may not vet for whatever reason, so I have found things out for them they weren't concerned to check for themselves.

I always think full disclosure is the way to go. I was able to chat to the cobs vet, nothing was hidden.
 
I think you are getting confused because you are assuming a vetting is just about finding out if the horse is sound, it's a lot more involved than that.
I misread that the vetting process was different depending on the expected use. When actually it's just the conclusions drawn that are different, the process is the same (apart from unbroken etc) I was also under the impression, maybe again from misreading, that lame horses passed vettings if the intended use was lower level.

If lameness occurance is increasing in horses for sale then I think something should be done to try and establish why. Before they get to the for sale point. Welfare audits, even just owner based ones could be useful. This would have been a great dissertation topic!
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
I misread that the vetting process was different depending on the expected use. When actually it's just the conclusions drawn that are different, the process is the same (apart from unbroken etc) I was also under the impression, maybe again from misreading, that lame horses passed vettings if the intended use was lower level.

If lameness occurance is increasing in horses for sale then I think something should be done to try and establish why. Before they get to the for sale point. Welfare audits, even just owner based ones could be useful. This would have been a great dissertation topic!

There are so many reasons for seeing so many lame horses for sale. In no particular order
- so many horses around with bad conformation, or conformation aimed towards a specific job but isn't conducive to long term sandwich
- horse prices are so high that some people will try to sell anything, and if lameness is bilateral it can often be covered up enough that uneducated eyes will miss it
- horses being used like bikes, ie picked up and ridden when it suits the owner, so they aren't fit enough for the work and are more likely to be injured
- there's no law against selling a lame horse, and I don't think there should be either since many a lame horse can still have a good life

If an owner can't see a horse is lame than an owner audit (and what do you mean by that?) is pointless as they still won't see it. And if the owner can see but chooses to sell then do you really think they'll change their mind after doing a welfare audit? No, they won't. And this is why any sensible buyer gets an independent vetting. Also a horse can be sound at 9am and lame at 10!

I really don't see that this is a matter for any sort of regulation or that there's a need for changes to the current situation. The emphasis has always been on the buyer to make suitable checks and employ suitable professionals to help them do that. Moving any emphasis onto the seller is going to add to the expense for absolutely no benefit since no sane buyer would rely on a vetting or any other check that was performed on behalf of someone else. I genuinely cannot understand why anyone thinks the system should change.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Lollykay
I think we are seeing more lame horses for sale because horse prices have gone up and older, broken horses still have a value. People who can’t or won’t pay for a more expensive sound horse can buy a cheaper lame one. Some owners can’t see lameness and some don’t care and will ride a lame horse anyway. Horse welfare isn’t top priority among everyone, money is more important.

The only real answer I see is that it be made legal for a vet to assess a horse for sale and approve the home it is going to. But in reality that wouldn’t happen.!
 
@Mary Poppins and why should it be made legal? There's no legal requirement to have a puppy, kitten or as far as I know any other animal checked before buying. No leal need to have a car checked, which is potential more dangerous to a number of people if it isn't roadworthy and you take it on a busy road. All it would do is add layers of bureaucracy, increase the expense of vettings because of the extra paperwork, slow down the procedure and no doubt cause problems if someone wanted to buy when there was a question mark on the vetting. What would happen to horses that were being sold because they didn't stand uo to one job but would be fine for another? And as for the vet approving the home, well do you extend that to any time someone wants to change livery yard, or move house if they keep them at home? Do you say there must be regular checks on how all horses are kept because people may say one thing and do another? Madness!
 
There are so many reasons for seeing so many lame horses for sale. In no particular order
- so many horses around with bad conformation, or conformation aimed towards a specific job but isn't conducive to long term sandwich
- horse prices are so high that some people will try to sell anything, and if lameness is bilateral it can often be covered up enough that uneducated eyes will miss it
- horses being used like bikes, ie picked up and ridden when it suits the owner, so they aren't fit enough for the work and are more likely to be injured
- there's no law against selling a lame horse, and I don't think there should be either since many a lame horse can still have a good life
I think this might be one side of it, but I also think that there is the side of it that some horses are not very well kept for their needs. Bad foot practices, horses with low level lami all the time, bad management, unsuitable pasture, obesity, incorrect feed etc. The list goes on really. So this side of it could potentially be improved by owner based welfare audits, just making the owners step back and actually take a good look at the horse. Of course it won't do anything about owners who know their horses are lame and unrideable and yet advertise them as ridden horses. Perhaps this could just be tackled by failed vettings being recorded in the passport. I think it's great if we can discuss ideas and have a debate about it.
 
I have had a few vettings done. Molly 5 stage age 6, potential moon blindness, said it wasn't, she went blind 4 years later and was written off age 9 and lived till 26. Bay tb, didn't even get as far as vetting it or taking bloods as was so lame when pulled out of stable no point, beat a hasty retreat. This horse was re-advertised and someone else who was looking at same time as me and asked why it was back up for sale. Was told due to previous timewaster and she said oh the lady who had it vetted and it was so lame when the bute wore off that the vet didn't even bother looking at it! I did actually ask the vet if i could try him, but she said it would be like buying a car with three wheels.....ok if a wheel falls off many years later but not to start out like that. Bay mare, failed vetting, vet said she should be retired as not fit to work. She was the one i looked at before Buddy. Looked at 60 horses before buying Molly as the best of a bad lot. Rode only 5 of them as some were so misdescribed....remember being taken througha hedge by a cob who didn't want to go out as it was dinner time and was 'perfect for a child'. Bought Sasa sight unseen ditto Suze. Neither of them had health issues until Sasa was killed by veterinary negligence. Didn't bother vetting Buddy, reckoned if he was still jumping 3'6 at 19 and looking magnificent, he would do me fine as a happy hacker. He would never pass a vetting now, but he is still sound to hack out, keep to straight lines and take care of him, of course he is on danilon with his arthritis and lower ringbone but he is coping very well. If I feel that Suze doesn't work out for riding, I will try to get an ex army horse as at least it will be good in traffic.
 
  • Like
Reactions: carthorse and Huggy
To my embarrassment I didn't have either of mine vetted. Bought Ramsey at 4, and only problem I ever had was cushings from about age 16. Hogan was 12, and so cheap that vetting would have more than doubled the price. 4 years on he's shown no health issues (touching wood like mad) . Saying that, I would never encourage anyone to do what I did - I was just very, very lucky.
 
@Mary Poppins I don't think your comment is that fair to be honest, you rode a horse that may have been lame.
You might not have seen it or felt it because you don't know how that horse moves, you didn't do all the tests that would show up an issue or the horse was sound that day.
I am sure in our lifetime we've all ridden a horse that's lame, knowingly or otherwise.

The word lame needs to be dropped imo.
Lame to me is I can see it, feel it.
Unlevel, means you might not.
A horse that is 1/10 or 2/10 lame can be missed unless you know that horse well. Mine would go 1/10 lame in season but the rest of her was so obvious that you couldn't ride anyway.
It didn't write her off as a ridden horse.
 
I have mixed feelings about failed vettings being recorded on the passport. On one level it could be useful, on the other any horse can have a day when it's a bit off sometimes from something as simple as stepping on a flint on hard ground so why should that be held against it? And again we're back to what level of vetting? Luka passed his with flying colours but he would have failed as a potential three day eventer simply because anyone with half a brain cell would see his size and confirmation were not suitable for that job - BUT there are plenty of people out there who don't seem to have half a brain cell and so may ask to have him vetted for that job (maybe thinking they'd get a "better" vetting done?). Should that be marked as a fail on a passport and maybe cause problems getting insurance or selling on for the rest of his life?
 
I came across an advert for a "perfect gentlemen" aged 19 with some hock stiffness.
At that age I would expect some arthritic changes. He was priced fairly.
Reading the advert it's a lovely horse suited to a first time owner, returning owner, confidence giver.
He will be 1/10 to 2/10 lame because of that stiffness. But it doesn't mean he's in pain, or that's he's useless.
 
  • Like
Reactions: carthorse and Huggy
Looking at it from another angle, I get stiff and have a limp a lot of the time. It doesn't stop me doing things - ok I'd never run a marathon or be a gymnast - and it doesn't mean I hurt. There are a lot of horses out there that are like this and they have a lot to give people who want to do things within their capabilities. They're the ones like @newforest mentions above.
 
I think this might be one side of it, but I also think that there is the side of it that some horses are not very well kept for their needs. Bad foot practices, horses with low level lami all the time, bad management, unsuitable pasture, obesity, incorrect feed etc. The list goes on really. So this side of it could potentially be improved by owner based welfare audits, just making the owners step back and actually take a good look at the horse. Of course it won't do anything about owners who know their horses are lame and unrideable and yet advertise them as ridden horses. Perhaps this could just be tackled by failed vettings being recorded in the passport. I think it's great if we can discuss ideas and have a debate about it.
And that's nothing to do with the vet.
And no failed a vetting should not be on the passport, why would it be.
Nothing to do with that department.

If you want to discuss welfare that probably needs a different thread.
I will say we all keep our horse to the best of our ability and knowledge, so you could argue about it being a mandatory requirement to take certain exams before owning a horse, I think that should be the case then for having children!

If we all kept our horses as per how welfare tells us to, you will shut down numerous livery yards.
It will create issues.
And how can we point the finger at other horse owners, if our own aren't being kept as per what's considered appropriately?
Mine is individual turnout, so I have no right whatsoever ever to critic on management.
 
  • Like
Reactions: carthorse
The thing with vettings is that it is a snap shot in time. On that day at that time the horse was sound. My old boss twice managed to buy a horse with issues. Both were 5 stage vetted and both passed as competition horses. Both times all the vet could/would say was “on x date at y time the horse I vetted was sound”. The first horse I could see why he would have been sound. As after we got him after a few days ridden he would be lame. The lameness would then wear off in a couple of days rest. There had been a gap of 6 days between viewing and vetting. So yes he probably was sound at that time. I actually felt sorry for the vet in the middle of that situation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lollykay
newrider.com