Vetting

chunky monkey

Well-Known Member
May 2, 2007
9,424
7,029
113
Just pondering. With all these lame horses being advertised for sale. What are peoples thoughts on making the seller have the horse vetted at the time of adverising.
Should they be made to have a 2 stage vet minimum. Which would cover young stock. Not in work.
Could such a system even work.
 
Hmmm I’m not sure, as we all know a horse can be totally sound one day and lame the next. Plus I’m a cynical old bugger, I’d want my own vetting done by my own vet.
 
I'd never trust a vetting done on that basis, and I doubt that legally you could rely on it, plus the buyer would still end up paying for it as it would just be reflected in a higher price - and I'd still want my own vetting done by a vet of my choice.

Vettings are fit for purpose, even two stage, so what purpose would the seller be expected to vet for? There's a world of difference between a light hack and a top level competition horse, would would be a pass for one may be a total failure for the other.

The vet has a contract with the person who pays for the vetting, and if there are later questions about the reliability of the vetting or bloods taken need checking then it needs to be the buyer that the vet is responsible to and acting on behalf of. Getting the vet to do a vetting for the seller gives the buyer no protection and there's a potential conflict of interests for the vet.

I expect to attend a vetting so if anything arises I can ask questions and discuss things with the vet. That obviously wouldn't be possible.

Vettings are, in many respects, for the time of the vetting - an hour later a horse could do major damage to itself. In that scenario an unscrupulous seller could still say the horse had a clean vetting even if it had done permanent damage.

I also feel that a prospective buyer should know enough to see if a horse is obviously lame, and if they don't maybe they shouldn't be buying. More subtle things are why we get vets involved and are the very things that a vet may say are fine for a light hack (with disclosure) but unacceptable for a competition horse and questionable for a riding club one.
 
Absolutely not, is my gut feeling.

I'm not necessarily convinced there really more lame horses than there were. Are we just better at diagnosing them these days and vets are wary of the comeback unless a horse presents 110% sound?

Most leisure horses (and a lot of competition horses) are not 100% biomechanically sound in my experience - that doesn't make them perfectly capable of doing a job like RC all rounder.

P is quite happy playing at low level endurance, dressage and general all rounder but he wouldn't necessarily pass a vetting based on what the imaginary buyer wanted.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Lollykay
@PePo I have to say when I was looking last year I was shocked at how many unsound horses were up for sale, and the fact that sellers were posting video which suggested they either couldn't see this or didn't care. My vet commented on how many unsound horses they were failing at vettings, and not at the bargain basement end of the market either. Is this a new problem? I can't say, but I do think I see more unsound horses around now than I did years ago, my suspicion is that part of the problem is we now often seem to breed for bloodlines, looks and short term performance rather than long term soundness.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lollykay
I was (am still am) absolutely gutted that baby pony failed his vetting on lameness. I would always get my trusted vet to vet any future horses for me and wouldn't trust a certificate that the seller produced.
 
Some interesting comments i hadnt thought of.

I was thinking that maybe it would help prevent some of these dodgy dealers being able to sell under weight or poorly horses.
 
Some interesting comments i hadnt thought of.

I was thinking that maybe it would help prevent some of these dodgy dealers being able to sell under weight or poorly horses.

I think dodgy dealers are the very people who would misuse a system like that. Everything would be vetted as a companion, they probably would have enough horses being vetted that a dodgy vet would "miss" things because it's a good source of regular income for what would be minimal work, and I wouldn't even trust that the vetting certificate even belonged to that horse - one bay tb tends to look very like another, as do many other types. The best - only - defence against these sort of dealers is doing research before you go, keeping your eyes wide open, and if you do want to buy getting a thorough vetting done by a vet that doesn't have anything to do with them.
 
Some interesting comments i hadnt thought of.

I was thinking that maybe it would help prevent some of these dodgy dealers being able to sell under weight or poorly horses.
The dodgy dealers would find the dodgy vets. In my search I haven’t seen many underweight horses, but many, many lame ones. After my journey with Ben (significant lameness for many years) perhaps I am more able to spot it, or look out for it. What I have seen is a rise in older horses (18 plus) for sale and I worry that people on a budget will go for an older horse due to the price reduction but then not be able to afford or be willing to pay for the inevitable health issues that arise with old age.
 
There were definitely more horses being sold on lame when I was looking, in the past people could see it and would deal with it before selling, I don’t think they even see it now, or they put it down to stiffness as if that makes it ok. One mare I looked at to loan from a friend, I had to break it to her the mare was lame, that was an awkward conversation!

Some kind of pre sales vetting sounds appealing, but for all the reasons mentioned I can’t see it working.
 
Personally I think some kind of pre owning exam might not be a bad idea, not saying anyone who owns a horse needs to have an equine degree, but a basic care and welfare competency test.
 
Personally I think some kind of pre owning exam might not be a bad idea, not saying anyone who owns a horse needs to have an equine degree, but a basic care and welfare competency test.

But care and competency for what? A stabled tb is very different than an outdoor cob is very different to a small native. Keeping on a decent livery yard, even as a diy gives more access to support than keeping at home. And no amount of theoretical knowledge, or even hands on experience, will make a difference to people who only visit when it's convenient to them. I know too many people who would easily pass a competency test but should never have bought a horse, others who would have failed one but put in the effort to learn what they needed to fast and made good owners.
 
The lady who owns Harry wouldn't pass a competency test, but she loves him and pays for him to be on full livery at a yard where he gets the best of care. I know lots of people who pay livery yards to look after their horse and all they do is come and ride. It's the care of the horse that is important at the end of the day, not necessarily the knowledge of the person who pays the bills.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Skib and carthorse
Ive seen alot of 18 plus horses for sale, part of me cant help but wonder if these are owners who just dont want to deal with end of life care. Sold as heartbreaking decision. Maybe if theyve got niggles instead of being sold on to dealers etc, who might become cruelty cases in th wrong hands a vetting would stop them being passed on and the owners being made to keep or pts.

Vettings should not be done on what the horse is being sold as ie companion, it should be done on the soundness of the horse.

Im being told by my vets they are clamping down because of the rules. This is why many are just doing small animal and not large animals. There in theory shouldnt be any dodgy vets now, if there were they would loose there license to practice.

I just think that for potential buyers who spend hundreds and thousands getting horses vetted and then failing there needs to be some system in place to help them.
 
But care and competency for what? A stabled tb is very different than an outdoor cob is very different to a small native. Keeping on a decent livery yard, even as a diy gives more access to support than keeping at home. And no amount of theoretical knowledge, or even hands on experience, will make a difference to people who only visit when it's convenient to them. I know too many people who would easily pass a competency test but should never have bought a horse, others who would have failed one but put in the effort to learn what they needed to fast and made good owners.
Didn’t say I had all the answers, it was just a random thought.
 
They could add a section in the passport for soundness. If the horse is ever diagnosed with any significant lameness it gets recorded in the passport. This would write ale off from ever being sold as a ridden horse.
 
Last edited:
Surely vettings have to be done based on what the use of the horse is? A horse can be unsound for high level eventing but be perfectly capable of low dressage or as a hack? My friend's endurance horse was a failed show jumper due to soundness issues but a lifestyle of no jumping and working on straight lines is no issue for him even at fast speeds over long distances.

Provided any pain is managed, a companion horse doesn't need to be 100% sound if it isn't going to leave the field. Leaving a clearly suffering horse is a whole different issue.

Why should the SJ-er have had the horse PTS or be forced to keep him just because he could no longer jump? Or a companion horse not enjoy a retired life for a few years nanny-ing another?

I'm not 100% sound but I still cycle and go to the gym. I wouldn't make a Team GB athlete but I do fine at club level 😂
 
  • Like
Reactions: carthorse
1. Lots of common sense reasons as to why a vetting by a Seller’s vet should NOT be accepted:)

2. I agree 200% with @carthorse ’s thought in seeing mantpy health issues in modern horses due to people breeding for ”short term performance rather than long term soundness”.

I have a horse like that but thankfully in Rusty’s case it never affected his performance as a trail horse. He was lucky that his inherited club hoof is only Less-than-grade-one. Others from his bloodline weren’t and aren’t so lucky. I was also fortunate to have good farrier’s thru the years who kept him trimmed as the hoof dictated, as opposed to trying to make him look good Or correct something that was not correctable.

When I retired to Tennessee, the first farrier who trimmed him in this state asked me if he was Generator-bred. I said yes. He said “thought so. The Old Man, (as they call Pride‘s Generator in my area) was well, noted for passing along the club hoof. That stallion should have never been allowed to keep producing BUT he consistently produced winners in the show ring and that’s all they cared about.

3. To @PePo ’s comment - I have one of those too, lollol; my new companion horse Duncan. 60+ years with horses has taught me Duncan is a well bred horse. His leg issues are career related, which is mostly why he ended up having to retire in his early 20’s. He made it a lot of years before needing to find a safe pasture to live out the rest of his life.

Fortunately for him, I have plenty of “leg” experience and have everything needed to care for his issues on the spot. He will never be 100% sound again but I can give him quality of life for more years than the average retiree in a 24/7 pasture would get. His Dutch Warmblood self is a sweet gentle natured, well bred horse, very much in the image of my Tennessee Walker, Joker, who was bred by an ethical pleasure horse breeder. Joker had serious tendon issues but his were human induced by the AFA certified farrier who thought he knew more than the lameness vet - something I will never get over or forgive😡

I came up smelling like roses when I accepted Duncan from 2,100 miles away on nothing more than his latest owner’s word and a couple of videos. I went on 60+ years of gut instinct and hoped I wasn’t making a huge mistake. Those words “do not try this at home” applies here - buying or accepting a free pig-in-a-poke is not something the inexperienced should do, lol
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: carthorse
Ive seen alot of 18 plus horses for sale, part of me cant help but wonder if these are owners who just dont want to deal with end of life care. Sold as heartbreaking decision. Maybe if theyve got niggles instead of being sold on to dealers etc, who might become cruelty cases in th wrong hands a vetting would stop them being passed on and the owners being made to keep or pts.

Vettings should not be done on what the horse is being sold as ie companion, it should be done on the soundness of the horse.

Im being told by my vets they are clamping down because of the rules. This is why many are just doing small animal and not large animals. There in theory shouldnt be any dodgy vets now, if there were they would loose there license to practice.

I just think that for potential buyers who spend hundreds and thousands getting horses vetted and then failing there needs to be some system in place to help them.

Any horse that's sold on can end up in the wrong hands an come to a bad end. The only way to avoid that is not to sell, and I'm sure no-one would want to extend the logic to that point which probably wouldn't be in the best interest of many horses either.

The proposed use of a horse is very relevant to the vetting though, a horse may be sound and happy in one job but not stand up to another be that due to age, a physical weakness or old injury. Most of us don't want GP dressage horses, 5 star eventers, etc so why would we want a horse vetted to that level? The horse that would suit us may well fail that vetting yet give us years of pleasure and be infinitely more suitable than the horse that passed. Likewise if I wanted a horse to compete at a high level I need to know it's likely to stand the work, a vetting that says it's ok to work at novice or maybe pop round a 3' course just doesn't cut it.

I'm afraid you can still find vets prepared to turn a blind eye or not look to deeply, and that's all that's required to get a vetting certificate where maybe one shouldn't be issued. My vet commented on a conformation weakness that meant a horse I had vetted was unlikely to stand up to much work in the future, however on the day it would have passed as sound. If she'd been vetting on behalf of the seller it would have been a clean certificate, That's not even dodgy vetting but highlights relevance.

Normal people aren't spending thousands getting horses vetted, maybe if you're looking for that top class horse and so go for x-rays and scans too but that's a different world to the one most of us are in and compared to the cost of the horse the vetting is still a very small part. And make no mistake if sellers had to have the horse vetted that cost would be added to the price, and any sane buyer would still want a vetting done for themselves so effectively paying twice for the same horse to be vetted. It could also make it more difficult to get horses vetted if sellers were of the view the horse had already passed a vet,
 
I thought vettings were just standard regardless of what discipline you want to do with the horse. They only pass if they are sound don't they? So even if you get a horse vetted as a companion and it's lame, it'll fail the vetting but then the vet will suggest that they will be okay as a companion but future implications of the lameness could include X, y and z. Is this not the case as it's how I always thought it worked 🤔

Edited to add that surely this is how vettings work, someone put me out my misery and explain please 😂A vetting is a relatively short and uninvasive viewing of a horses movement. You couldn't diagnose sacroiliac issues very well at a vetting so the horse may look very slightly lame, horse passes vetting and vet recommends the horse suitable for low level work. But then the horse actually can't cope with the low level work. That would make the vet liable surely for incorrectly diagnosing a lameness issue at a vetting.
 
Last edited:
newrider.com