This saddle does'nt fit,right?

I am not a saddle fitting expert

I'm not either :D That measurement is one Kay Humphries uses, and does usually correspond with the last rib. On that basis I don't think the saddle is too long, especially as you point out that it possibly is positioned slightly too far back as well.

Agree you can't properly judge the fit without girthing or riding though :)
 
Sorry to be a philistine ( I think that is the word I want) but how can you tell anything about a saddle that has not even been girthed and is not sitting straight on the horses back. Oh and isn't it sitting on his loins?

I'm afraid I agree, much too long, the saddle should'nt finish further back than the rib cage and it is sitting on his loins, well looks to be anyway. You can't reallu check the fit of a saddle without it girthed up and central then of it looks to be fitting you also need to see ifti fits with the weight of the rider. A handy tip is to ride in it (if it looks to fit in a stand still) in all 3 paces without a saddlecloth/numnah and if a sweat patch is left and you can see the whole of the saddle shape from the pads underneith ie not just parts of it but the whole saddle shape then you know that thje pads are touching his back evenly and therefor distrabuting your weight evenly over his back. I am NOT saying that if this happens the saddle is 100% correct fit at all, there are many many other things that need checking ( I belive that a saddler checks for 9 different pointers) like shoulder clearance and gullet width etc and you should get a saddler out to 'finish' the job and make sure it definetly fits but this is a good guide.
 
I am not a saddle fitting expert but Yann I have never heard that measurement, surely one looks at the overall back length and rib structure to determine length. I personally think this one needs to be a little further forward but I am a hands on person who would need to feel the scapula and ribs to comment.

As far as 'fitting' without a girth I recently had a saddle so called fitted and restuffed without using a girth. Suffice it to say the expert I asked out to check my feeling that the fit was totally wrong when it came back confirmed the tree was far too narrow and would never be made to fit the horse by any amount of restuffing although just positioned on the horses back it had looked OK

ditto - you would need to know the position of the scapula and position of ribs to know if the lenngth was correct, having looked at the piccys again, it does look to be sat a bit far back but a bit more from one side than the other:rolleyes: . I think if the saddle is brought forward though it woud rise at the front and not sit level (but with a wider gullet it may sit level). However in a forward position and the saddle may come to far over the shoulder, (I tried a wintec and had this problem).

Totally agree EML on the flocking thing - I have always had to ride after having a saddle reflocked - I just meant the initial placing on of saddles, if you were perhaps looking for a new one. Out of 6 saddles maybe only 3 will actually be girthed on as the others are obviously not going to fit. It is quite a concern that your original saddler couldnt tell the saddle was too narrow and didnt bother to properly check.
 
No Chip not wanting to carry on old thread but that is a bit definative.

If I was Dina I would be repositioning the saddle further forward, putting an old bit of sheet underneath, doing up girth , rechecking length, sitting on top and getting friend to check clearance along spine, feeling shoulder clearance, supporting ribs and then if it seemed almost right either having a short ride and checking the impression on the sheet for evenness or calling a saddler depending on my experience.

Too few facts to jump to conclusions.
 
The head is too high off the horse indicating the tree is too narrow and making it sit up on it's points.Try a wider gullet plate, or alter the one you have to template.IE, template your horses withers with wither profile or piece of lead flashing make sure you mark nearside and offside as horse's are usually muscled up more one side , mostly nearside, transfer template to cardboard, transfer that to 3/4" width plywood (piece 1.5 foot by 1.5 foot) cut round wood with jigsaw, heat up existing gullet plate with blow lamp, do it slowly, it's mild steel so will bend easily under heat (paint will burn off and smoke so do it outside and don't breath the fumes in!) when sufficiently hot, bend it gently round template until it resembles the shape, tap gently with hammer if necessary, ignore the wood smoking,let it cool down, try it on your horse for correct fit remembering which is the nearside!
When you are happy it fits ok, re spray with car cellulose paint, re fit into saddle, (remembering the nearside!)now if you have done it right and the original saddle tree is correct for your horse (ie cut back head if you have high withers or 1/4 cut back or sloping head if you have horse with no withers) amd it is flocked correctly,then it should be 100% correct fit!
Hope this helps?
Oz :)
 
Quite honestly the saddle doesn't look to long on him. To narrow,yes,,,with the Gullet Flair the saddle has in it now...but not too long.
 
hey

after reading the whole two pages of this post, and then realising that this post is a few months old :o ops should of seen that at beginning, i just wanted to say that i have a wintec 500 and it wont sit centrally on my mares back most of the time, it is a real pain, only mentioned this as i noticed in the pics from the OP that the saddle isn't sitting centrally, so it may well be the make of saddle and not the way it has been positioned on the horses.

not got anything else really to add sorry.

lozzie an pinxx
 
hey

after reading the whole two pages of this post, and then realising that this post is a few months old :o ops should of seen that at beginning, i just wanted to say that i have a wintec 500 and it wont sit centrally on my mares back most of the time, it is a real pain, only mentioned this as i noticed in the pics from the OP that the saddle isn't sitting centrally, so it may well be the make of saddle and not the way it has been positioned on the horses.

not got anything else really to add sorry.

lozzie an pinxx

Have you had a saddle fitter out to alter it?
 
I reshaped the gulllet of my wintec saddle with a vice and a hammer, did a good job, at least then i had a gullet to fit my horse, and not just used the wintec ones, which were the wrong shape for her.

so glad i have my treeless saddles now, alot less stressing if saddle doesnt fit, i just adjust padding.
 
Have you had a saddle fitter out to alter it?

Not at the moment but i am trying to contact the person who fitted it to get them back out to have a look, i have only had it a month and i bought it brand new of the saddle fitter who fitted it for me.
have trouble contacting the saddle fitter though:rolleyes:

lozzie an pinxx
 
newrider.com