This saddle does'nt fit,right?

Dina

Active Member
Feb 21, 2004
5,078
0
36
Northland,New Zealand
www.freewebs.com
I tried Joe's saddle on Chunky today,its a Wintec 500.
It currently has the medium gullet in and I measured Chunky with the wintec gullet gauge which suggested he needed a medium-wide.
I have'nt ridden him in this saddle just tried it on,but to me it does'nt look like it fits,
photo052.jpg

photo053.jpg

photo054.jpg

photo055.jpg

photo056.jpg

photo057.jpg

photo058.jpg

photo059.jpg

I guess I'm going to have to convince my parents to get a saddle fitter out.
 
I looks OK to me too as far as you can tell from the photos, it appears balanced front to back, doesn't appear to be bridging and the panels sit nicely on his back (the saddle wasn't central). Would be worth getting a fitter to check anyway as what you get with the saddle plonked on the back isn't always the same as it girthed up or ridden in. There are other things like the state of the flocking that they ought to be able to advise on too.
 
I looks OK to me too as far as you can tell from the photos, it appears balanced front to back, doesn't appear to be bridging and the panels sit nicely on his back (the saddle wasn't central). Would be worth getting a fitter to check anyway as what you get with the saddle plonked on the back isn't always the same as it girthed up or ridden in. There are other things like the state of the flocking that they ought to be able to advise on too.

well said!!
 
I think we need to see a photo of it with someone sitting in/on it too - to see how much clearance there is then as well.....

Which leads to another question... do you sit "in" or "on" a saddle??? :confused: :)
 
Bexj-it just looked to me that the gullet was abit narrow.
Thanks Yann :),Domane I've have'nt sat in it just incase it was'nt a good fit on him,but I might just wait and find a new saddle,I'm too desperate to ride anyway.
And you sit "in" a saddle :confused:
 
ditto gypsygold, looks too narrow to me - it looks perched ontop of the horse with too much height above the withers. it may be different when girthed/with a rider on but thats what i see from the pictures.

also dont know if it was just me but it looks like the saddle from the rear shot is not sitting evenly and centrally on him back

dont know if he is muscaled a-symettrically or the saddle is a-symettrical or if it is just sitting wonky - hard to tell.

if your not sure then get a fitter to check x
 
Looks a little bit long to me; as for the rest of it, it would need to be girthed up and with a rider on board to say for sure.

Bear in mind that Wintecs often do sit a little high to start with and gradually settle with use, so when you first put a new Wintec on you do need to be aware of that.
 
Sorry to be a philistine ( I think that is the word I want) but how can you tell anything about a saddle that has not even been girthed and is not sitting straight on the horses back. Oh and isn't it sitting on his loins?

It is too long so perhaps the rest is irrelevant but the original question seemed to be asking about width so most people I guess commented on that. I said it looked too narrow because the angle of the gullet appears to be narrower than the angle of the horse. Therefore the gullet points would dig in. Although girthing the saddle on will make a difference its not going to make the gullet wider.

I have recently had the saddler out and she only girths on the saddles which she feels will fit after initially placing them on ungirthed.

Everyone has said how it 'looks' to them without neccesarily given an indepth critique. The OP asked how we thought it looked and we said what we thought.
 
Just curious about the too long comment? My understanding is you're looking for 5-6" clearance between the back of the panels to the whorls, which (photo permitting) appears to be the case here?

Just read the original post again (doh!), if it says he needs medium wide on the gullet gauge and it's only a medium in the saddle, then it is too narrow :)
 
I am not a saddle fitting expert but Yann I have never heard that measurement, surely one looks at the overall back length and rib structure to determine length. I personally think this one needs to be a little further forward but I am a hands on person who would need to feel the scapula and ribs to comment.

As far as 'fitting' without a girth I recently had a saddle so called fitted and restuffed without using a girth. Suffice it to say the expert I asked out to check my feeling that the fit was totally wrong when it came back confirmed the tree was far too narrow and would never be made to fit the horse by any amount of restuffing although just positioned on the horses back it had looked OK
 
I was going to try the medium-wide and see how that fitted,but now I'm not sure because theres no point if the saddle too long.
Its 17in,so would a 16.5in be better for him?
It did'nt look too long when I had it on him.
I did'nt think it would be good for me to get on him and ride in it when it looked like it might pinch his withers.
 
newrider.com