Temperature regulation

carthorse

Super Moderator
Jan 6, 2006
13,798
8,546
113
This article on the BBC site got me thinking about how common it is for people to clip and under rug horses and yet tests on people are showing far reaching medical implications of exposure to temperatures that aren't even particularly cold. Yes I'm well aware horses aren't people! They are mammals though, and while the range of temperatures they tolerate are different we also interfere heavily in terms of management. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-63602501
 
Horses and humans may be both mammals, but the way we heat our bodies is drastically different from the way a horse heats theirs. Horses have internal furnaces and heat themselves from the inside out by creating heat through digesting forage - they are designed to live outside in winter whilst humans are not.

I think that the majority of people vastly over rug their horses rather than under rug them. I often feel sorry for horses wearing such a ridiculous amount of rugs which in my opinion are just not needed.
 
Copy of text, in case the article is moved
By James Gallagher
Inside Health presenter, BBC Radio 4

Mention deadly cold and I think of polar explorers with icicles dangling from their beards and mountaineers tackling the heights of Everest; of fingers turning black with frostbite and the chilling clutch of hypothermia.
So I was sceptical when I was asked to take part in a cold experiment that took place at just 10 degrees Celsius. Yes, 10C.
To me that's mild, nowhere near freezing and certainly no Arctic blast. Surely we'd have to go much colder before putting a strain on the body? I was wrong.
"It sounds mild, but it is a real physiological challenge," Prof Damian Bailey, from the University of South Wales, tells me.
He's invited me to his laboratory to explore the impact of cold homes on our bodies and why such seemingly mild temperatures can become deadly.
"Ten degrees is the average temperature that people will be living in, if they can't afford to heat their homes," said Prof Bailey.
And as I was about to find out, 10C has a profound impact on the heart, lungs and brain.


I'm led into the environmental chamber in the corner of the laboratory - it's all shiny metal walls and thick, heavy doors. In this air-tight room, scientists can precisely set the temperature, humidity and oxygen levels.
I'm hit with a blast of warm 21C air. The plan is to start at 21C, drop the temperature down to 10C and chart how my body responds to the chill.
First, I am wired up to countless state-of-the-art gizmos for the most in-depth analysis my body has ever faced.
My chest, arms and legs are dotted with monitors to track my body temperature, heart rate and blood pressure.
"You will look like something out of Star Wars," says Prof Bailey as another sensor and trailing cable is attached to my body.
A headset is fitted to monitor the blood flow in my brain just as the first beads of sweat breakout on my brow; an ultrasound inspects the carotid arteries in my neck (hearing the rhythmic whoosh of blood going to my brain is oddly reassuring) and I breathe into a huge tube that analyses the air I exhale.

The measurements are done. The scientists know how my body performs in a pleasant 21C. So the fans kick in and a cool breeze gradually lowers the temperature in the chamber.
"Your brain is tasting your blood as we speak and it's tasting the temperature and the brain is now sending signals to the rest of your body," Prof Bailey tells me.
The goal is to keep my core - that's my major organs including my heart and liver - at around 37C.
I was still unaware of the profound changes happening inside my body, but there were already clues on the outside.
By the time the room has dropped to 18C I was no longer sweating and the hairs on my arms were starting to stand up to help insulate my body.
"Science tells us that 18 degrees is the tipping point... the body is now working to defend that core temperature," Prof Bailey shouts over the droning fans.
Next my fingers turn white and they feel cold. The blood vessels in my hands are being closed off - known as vasoconstriction - in order to keep my warm blood for my critical organs.
This would happen even more quickly if I were a different gender.
"Women do tend to feel the cold more, because of hormones (oestrogen) their blood vessels in their hands and feet are more likely to constrict... and that makes us feel cold," says Dr Clare Eglin from the University of Portsmouth.
My first shiver kicks in at 11.5C as my muscles begin to shake to generate heat.
At 10C the fans shut down. I'm feeling uncomfortable, but not freezing as we repeated all the bodily measurements again at the lower temperature and it soon became clear I was wrong to doubt that 10C would affect me.
"The body is working jolly hard at 10 degrees," says Prof Bailey.

What shocks me is the change in blood flow to the brain and how much longer it takes me to complete a shape-sorting game.
I wouldn't want to be trying to do school homework in a cold room or to have this compound something like dementia.
"You're delivering less blood to the brain, so there's less oxygen and less glucose [sugar] getting into the brain and the downside of that is it's having a negative impact on your mental gymnastics," Prof Bailey says.
But my body is achieving its main goal of keeping my core body temperature stable - it's just having to do more work.
I'm pumping warm blood around my body more intensely with my heart beating faster and blood pressure also shooting up.
"That increasing blood pressure is a risk factor for a stroke, it's a risk factor for a heart attack," Prof Bailey tells me.
The blood itself is also changing "so it becomes a bit like treacle", says Prof Bailey, and this thicker gloopier blood also adds to the risk of a dangerous blockage.
It's why heart attacks and strokes are more common in the winter.

Fortunately, I started off with "fabulous vasculature", Prof Bailey tells me, but these internal changes are a risk to those who already have poor heart health and the elderly.
"The evidence clearly suggests that cold is more deadly than the heat, there are a higher number of deaths caused through cold snaps than there are through the heat snaps," says Prof Bailey.
"So I really do think that more recognition needs to be paid for the dangers associated with cold."

Cold favours viruses too​

The cold also lends a helping hand to many infections that thrive in the winter months such as flu. Pneumonia, when there is inflammation in the lungs because of an infection, is more common after cold weather.
It is easier for viruses to spread because we're more likely to meet up indoors with the windows shut and no fresh air to blow viruses away.
Cold also makes it easier for viruses to survive outside the body and cold air contains less virus-trapping moisture.
Dry air allows viruses to travel further distances, says Prof Akiko Iwasaki, an immunobiologist from Yale University. She has also performed experiments showing breathing in cold air affects how the immune system works in the nose.
Prof Iwasaki tells me: "At these cooler temperatures, your immune response becomes less active and this can allow virus to grow better within your nose."

What can you actually do about it?​

In an ideal world we'd all heat the room we're in to at least 18C. When that is not possible, Prof Bailey says "it's like preparing for a mountaineering expedition".
His tips are:
  • focus on clothes that provide good insulation such as those made of wool
  • gloves and warm socks are more important than a hat (but a woolly hat will help too)
  • switch foods to a higher carbohydrate diet
  • generate more body heat by moving around and not just sitting in a chair and watching TV.
 
It's an interesting article, however it's been done under a non realistic setting. If they really think a home without heating is ten degrees, then use one to back up the science.

We've not got any heating on and the room is 16 degrees. I think we do what horses do and adapt to our surroundings.
No we are not designed to be out in the wind and rain, horses are. But we can add layers, eat something that warms us from the inside out as it does a horse.
We can use a warmer room in the house as a horse would choose the least exposed area of the field, turn its bum to the wind.
The biggest issue I can see is for the young, sick and old having even more issues because they cannot keep warm or fed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kite_Rider
The owners I feel should consider how this applies to horses are the ones who in an attempt to get them to lose weight clip them out then turn out with no rug or a rainsheet, restricted food and little or no shelter - and yes it does happen. I appreciate losing weight is necessary for many but I feel this is not a kind way to do it, and since a horse's body will act in a similar way to ours if put under similar stresses then it would seem this method carries more risks than people realise. We change the rules, this isn't the same as a wild horse dealing with winter by growing a coat and roaming freely to find food and shelter.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers
That sounds like a miserable existence, I'm thankful I don't know anyone who turns their clipped horses out without any food or shelter. I do know people who clip their fatties and leave them out with food and shelter and they are fine, they do rug though on less inclement days and it's usually not a full clip. Depends on how fat they are I guess, that guy doing the experiment for the BBC was slim. I'd also argue that all mammals bodies do not function the same, for example whales are perfectly content in very cold oceans. I'd be really interested to see a similar study with a much larger sample size than 1 being carried out on horses though.
 
I suspect the range a which they are good varies due to physical adaptations, but the response to being outside those ranges would be similar so much higher burning up of calories, the body adapting circulation to protect key areas, mental function reduced etc. Yes you can't assume a complete crossover, but it's food for thought. Years ago I was told by a vet to keep Little Un well rugged in cold weather because as an EMS pony he couldn't afford anything to compromise the circulation to his feet, I then had plenty of well meaning people say that as he tended to be a good doer the most he should wear was a rain sheet and ideally not even that as then he'd shiver some weight off.
 
Horses left out in winter grow a thick winter coat. But on almost every yard I have been on, the horses that work through the winter get clipped. I think this is to stop them getting too sweaty when exercised. And then they have to be rugged.
 
Suze and Fleur are both on diets so they are unrugged but they have big coats, a thick hedge to shelter and also are given lots of straw for fibre and also a balancer for minerals. I weight tape them weekly and Fleur is a nice weight and Suze is still a hippo. IF it is really horrendous they come onto the yard for a bit of relief. Buddy and Ginger Giraffe are rugged but unclipped. She has a 100gm rug on and Buddy a 50gm one, have just bought her a 50gm one, and if it is mild they have a rainsheet only.
 
There’s lots of sweeping statements being made here, I think it’s rare that anyone would clip and leave a horse literally physically shivering to shift weight, shivering happens before the cognitive functions are heavily effected, so it is one of a few things that can be used to judge how the individual is coping with the cold.

I clipped Dan last winter and left him out without a rug throughout, terrible me by the sweeping statements! The finer points are I clipped him in late September so he’d grown some back before it got really cold, and I only clipped under his belly and neck -areas a rug wouldn’t have helped anyway, and he had access to food (though he was muzzled) and shelter. So not so terrible after all and I can assure everyone he didn’t once shiver or feel cold to touch.

I can completely see being told to prevent restricting circulation to feet by keeping warm, but it’s no reason to over rug either, stable/turnout boots/bandages are probably a more effective way of managing the initial effects now days. Laminitis also has a pretty big effect on foot circulation so there is still a balance to be found.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PePo
I clipped Ben for several years and turned him out throughout winter with no rug apart from when it was raining, and then he had a lightweight. He was in a field with plenty of grass and hay, and I never saw him shiver during the winter. The one and only time I found him shivering was after a rainstorm in summer when he wasn’t even clipped. He needed to drop weight every winter and this method didn’t make him ‘shiver it off’, it made his metabolism increase so he burnt more calories keeping warm. He could also move to keep warm.

I wanted him to move and eat to keep him warm rather than keep him stabled overnight on limited diet. It is very difficult to keep weight off a good doer and in my opinion it is far crueler to let a horse gain weight and suffer laminitis. So many people want to wrap their horses up when they feel the cold, but horses are not humans and shouldn’t be treated as such.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Skib
Sid has a blanket clip, with his thick, soft thatch of fur left on his back and hairy legs. He is turned out with shelter, plenty to eat - fresh grass every 3 days - and he and Bella are also eating about 1/3 bale of hay per day between them: if it's going to rain hard I put the hay rollers in the shelter, so they get a break from the rain. I have had a rain sheet with half neck on him, really because it's convenient when I want to ride him. The other night it was heading for a frost at 7 pm and I was worried about him and zipped over to see if he needed a warmer rug - he has one which is a rainsheet with a fleecy lining. He was grazing happily, not shivering, and his ears and legs were warm as toast. So I left him in his rainsheet.

Our field is very windy. The sheet provides good wind protection - perhaps that makes the most difference to him? He certainly doesn't seek the shelter very often, unless he wants some hay.
 
I think the sensible thing is to go by the individual horse. If it feels cold (ears, armpits etc) then I suppose the choices are to rug up or feed more to 'heat from within'. Personally I'd prefer to rug. Similarly with 'over rugging' - if the horse has a few rugs on but is comfortably warm and happy and not sweating, then what's the problem? And I think both horses and humans were designed to live outdoors originally, but we have adapted and we've domesticated our animals away from their original physiology. Many horses can happily live out unclipped and having to work to find their food, but some can't. And a lot of wild animals die in winter because they get too cold.

I think the study is really interesting too - especially the explanation about why there are more heart attacks and strokes in winter. What I take from it is that if the extremities are cold the heart is working harder to keep the core body temperature stable, which makes it quite easy to gauge on an individual basis whether more heat/insulation is needed.

Also interesting that it mentions viruses spread more easily when it's cold - I remember this being a thing in my childhood, then it was discounted as a old wives' tale and now it's back!
 
I don’t like the sweeping “people over rug” and “people under rug” statements that are made. You need to look at the horse in front of you. For example robin is blanket clipped and in a 360grm combo. My friends pony has a similar clip and is fine in a rain sheet. Same yard same management. Robin will also have an under rug when it gets below freezing.

I don’t agree with clipping and keeping the horse cold to use up calories and loose weight. I am miserable slightly cold tho so projecting on to horses.

I havnt read the whole thing so hope I have not just repeated what everyone has said 😂
 
I wasn't trying to start an over/under rugging or clipping v not clipping thread, and certainly not to make people defensive of their management. There do seem to be plenty of people nowadays who use, or at least talk about using, the cold and wet to get weight off fat horses though and this article simply made me wonder if when they take that approach they are potentially taking risks that they aren't expecting. It's all well and good saying it's natural but we don't keep them as nature intended, many horses are no longer as nature intended, and nature has little care for the individual anyway.
 
I wasn't trying to start an over/under rugging or clipping v not clipping thread, and certainly not to make people defensive of their management. There do seem to be plenty of people nowadays who use, or at least talk about using, the cold and wet to get weight off fat horses though and this article simply made me wonder if when they take that approach they are potentially taking risks that they aren't expecting. It's all well and good saying it's natural but we don't keep them as nature intended, many horses are no longer as nature intended, and nature has little care for the individual anyway.
That is so true about us not keeping as nature intended. I remember a discussion on here many years ago - when I had just come to horse ownership. It was about a similar topic I recall. However, as one person pointed out, there are lots and lots of things we do with them that are not natural. Where do we draw the line? (I think the topic was actually natural horsemanship). Someone actually said, putting a saddle and bridle on are not natural - which I agree they aren't. So I think it works both ways. Some owners will believe as nature intends means no rug, no shelter and sparse pickings. Others will be the opposite.
I think it's a balance really - and looking at the individual. Today we've had a mix of hailstones (which hurt) and wind and bright sunshine. Just glad I can pick and choose about where I let them roam, they are free range mainly. It must be so difficult when you have to leave them and go to work for the day.
 
You definitely have to look at the horse in front of you. Chunky has been full clipped for a couple of weeks. He was fine and we have had some horrible rain. His coat is now starting to grow back, but this morning when i took his rug off to lunge his hairs were standing on end. That suggests hes feeling the cold. Hes just been in a no fill rain sheet since clipping. Im now going to have to look out a light filled one. Being hes old he doesnt run round anymore, and generally covers less ground movement wise than he use to years ago, therefore to help his arthritic joints he needs rugging more.
Billy is still out unrugged. He hasnt got a particularly thick coat as its a bit of a tb type coat. I am going to put a rug

A number of years ago i did full clip chunky and leave him out unrugged as was suggested to loose weight. He was obese. He was fine until one day it poured. I got to the yard and he was shivering head to toe. He got stabled that night, 3 rugs on, turned back out the next morning. I will never ever, ever, do that again. Whilst he had no knock on effects from it, it could so easily have caused pneumonia and lord knows what else.
 
  • Like
Reactions: carthorse
Every horse is an individual the same as every human.
Each field has its own temperature and will supply its own forage and shelter.
What I do with mine will be totally unsuited to someone else's else horse.
I had a tb that had been stabled overnight move in, refuse to eat the grass, dropped weight, stressed and moved out in seven days.
Mine actually doesn't like being too warm, I have to clip the summer coat. Some may have a horse that doesn't cope well with cold, as I said individual, like us.

Locally we have a horse welfare reporting person, I have spoken to them twice now. The only thing that was registering in their non horsey brain was whether or not mine had access to the shelter.
She will use the weather to reduce her weight as nature intended not by shivering it off, but because the grass is less nutritious and temperature is lower. In theory the temperature is lower, it's taken a while to drop down here.
 
You definitely have to look at the horse in front of you. Chunky has been full clipped for a couple of weeks. He was fine and we have had some horrible rain. His coat is now starting to grow back, but this morning when i took his rug off to lunge his hairs were standing on end. That suggests hes feeling the cold. Hes just been in a no fill rain sheet since clipping. Im now going to have to look out a light filled one. Being hes old he doesnt run round anymore, and generally covers less ground movement wise than he use to years ago, therefore to help his arthritic joints he needs rugging more.
Billy is still out unrugged. He hasnt got a particularly thick coat as its a bit of a tb type coat. I am going to put a rug

A number of years ago i did full clip chunky and leave him out unrugged as was suggested to loose weight. He was obese. He was fine until one day it poured. I got to the yard and he was shivering head to toe. He got stabled that night, 3 rugs on, turned back out the next morning. I will never ever, ever, do that again. Whilst he had no knock on effects from it, it could so easily have caused pneumonia and lord knows what else.
Yes I have seen the shivering - not that often thankfully. When we first got Zi it was May which can be pretty rough up here still. The first few days the sun was out and it was nice. However at the weekend it poured down and was cold and nasty. I hadn't seen a horse shiver before. Poor lad, I shan't forget that. We brought him in and dried him off as best we could and after that he had rugs when he needed them. He wasn't clipped or anything. But I hadn't realised that though he was a chunky warmblood he wasn't as hardy as a cob and a connie. So as you say, totally individual isn't it.
 
newrider.com