There’s lots of sweeping statements being made here, I think it’s rare that anyone would clip and leave a horse literally physically shivering to shift weight, shivering happens before the cognitive functions are heavily effected, so it is one of a few things that can be used to judge how the individual is coping with the cold.
I clipped Dan last winter and left him out without a rug throughout, terrible me by the sweeping statements! The finer points are I clipped him in late September so he’d grown some back before it got really cold, and I only clipped under his belly and neck -areas a rug wouldn’t have helped anyway, and he had access to food (though he was muzzled) and shelter. So not so terrible after all and I can assure everyone he didn’t once shiver or feel cold to touch.
I can completely see being told to prevent restricting circulation to feet by keeping warm, but it’s no reason to over rug either, stable/turnout boots/bandages are probably a more effective way of managing the initial effects now days. Laminitis also has a pretty big effect on foot circulation so there is still a balance to be found.
Couldn't have said it better myself.
P has EMS and has been high chaser clipped most years and turned out naked. He's not just survived but thrived. This year he's fully clipped & out in 0g turn out currently.
I'm not pro or anti rugging but just pro doing the right thing for the horse in front of you in a specific set of cicircumstances.
I'm in the SE with a native pony in full work and not so much had a mild frost yet (plenty of flooding though!) so what I'm doing I expect would be different to someone living 'oop North - or even someone else in the SE with a retired pony or a finer breed.
If P starts to struggle with his feet specifically I'd put leg wraps on before a thicker rug. But of course he'd get a thicker rug if he was just generally chilly.
All most people can do is their best.