Talking of babies not feeling pain, have you seen the TV ad where a baby is held upside down by one leg? Something to do with lazy days .....
To me it's quite simple really - if you want your horse to lose weight, keep them away from the all-you-can-eat buffet!
is it a fair way to help lose weight.
It's not nonsense cortrasna, it's fact. It's a form of thermo-regulatory thermogenesis in mammals. It is controlled by the hypothalamus and triggered when a mammal drops below a critical temperature.
Yup. Till at least the mid 1980's. And even my new-born son had repeated bloods taken by an incompetent student who couldn;t find a vein. It took AGES of repeatedly sticking a needle in him. When I eventually protested I was told 'it's okay he won;t remember'....
From Wikipdedia: Do Babies Feel Pain
Late 19th Century[edit]
In the late nineteenth, and first half of the twentieth century, doctors were taught that babies did not experience pain, and were treating their young patients accordingly. From needle sticks to tonsillectomies to heart operations were done with no anaesthesia oranalgesia, other than muscle relaxation for the surgery.[citation needed] The belief was that in babies the expression of pain was reflexive and, owing to the immaturity of the infant brain, the pain could not really matter.[34]
Cope[32] considers it probable that the belief arose from misinterpretation of discoveries made in the new science of embryology. Dr Paul Flechsig equated the non-myelinisation of much of a baby’s nervous system with an inability to function.[citation needed]
It was generally believed that babies would not remember any pain that they happened to feel, and that lack of conscious memory meant lack of long-term harm. Scientific studies on animals with various brain lesions were interpreted as supporting the idea that the responses seen in babies were merely spinal reflexes. Furthermore, the whole effort of relieving pain was considered futile since it was thought to be impossible to measure the child's pain.[35]
This, coupled with a concern that use of opiates would lead to addiction, and the time and effort needed to provide adequate analgesia to the newborn, contributed to the medical profession's continued practice of not providing pain relief for babies.[36]
Mid 1980s[edit]
In the United States, a major change in practice was brought about by events surrounding one operation. Infant Jeffrey Lawson underwent open heart surgery in 1985. His mother, Jill R. Lawson, subsequently discovered that he had been operated on without any anaesthesia, other than a muscle relaxant. She started a vigorous awareness campaign[37] which created such a public, and medical, reaction that by 1987[38] medical opinion had come full circle.
A number of studies on the measurement of pain in young children, and on ways of reducing the injury response began,[which?] and publications on the hormonal and metabolic responses of babies to pain stimuli began to appear, confirming that the provision of adequate anaesthesia and analgesia was better medicine on both humanitarian and physiological grounds.[citation needed]
It is now accepted that the neonate responds more extensively to pain than the adult does, and that exposure to severe pain, without adequate treatment, can have long-term consequences. Despite the difficulty of assessing how much pain a baby is experiencing, and the practical problem of prescribing the correct dosage or technique for treatment, modern medicine is firmly committed to improving the quality of pain relief for the very young.[34]
I think any debate about 'natural versus non natural' is largely unhelpful. Pain is 'natural' while medical treatment is 'unnatural'. I imagine most of us would seek medical treatment for our injured horses?
Shivering is clearly a natural phenomenon that mammals use to generate heat. As this process uses energy it is possible to get a horse to lose weight by turning out clipped and unrugged to trigger shivering. People who recommend this generally say the horse does not mind - because it is natural and what the horse was designed to do. Which to me is totally illogical argument. Just because its natural doesn't mean it's not highly unpleasant for the horse.
No I wouldn't do it either as I think it's an unnecessary way of shifting weight. I have no problem seeing a horse shivering if it's in circumstances like a heavy downpour while they only have a summer coat for example,that then is in my eyes a natural response to the environment around them,but to see a horse purposefully kept cold in my eyes is neither fair nor productive. There are much better ways of helping get weight off.
Just to add over rugging is a major bug bear for me too,I'd rather a horse was under rugged than risk over heating but there is a line to how far you take that.