'Shivering' weight off

Talking of babies not feeling pain, have you seen the TV ad where a baby is held upside down by one leg? Something to do with lazy days .....:eek:
 
To me it's quite simple really - if you want your horse to lose weight, keep them away from the all-you-can-eat buffet!

Just a thought.....I personally find it highly aversive to be hungry, if that's the route your going down.

Shivering is a biological mechanism that heats us temporarily, I personally wouldn't want my horse doing it for a prolonged period (I know I get a sore back if I'm shivering all day because of tensing), but I don't think it's this horrendous thing that everybody thinks it is. I have found Kev shivering in the middle of summer after a short downpour, he was just heating himself up, he didn't need a rug.

Horses don't feel the cold like we do, otherwise I think their legs would fall off! There's no fat or muscle there to keep them warm. They are also not in and out of heated, indoor spaces, they acclimatise to the gradual changes of temp outside, just like we would if we spent our lives outside.

I spent 2 months in Australia last year, by the end of the two months I was shivering when it got to low 20's and pulling on jeans, jumpers and socks. After a few weeks back home in a freezing Scotland in the middle of winter and I was wearing the same clothes when it was around 5 degrees.
 
I think all this talk of shivering being a natural mechanism that the horse has evolved to deal with heat loss and weight control etc. is for the most part nonsense.

It probably did apply a good while back in their evolution, when they all lived a completely natural (to them) life style and were naturally culled by extreme conditions. I just don't think those arguments stand up much when you factor in the extremely unnatural way we keep our horses these days. And I include people like me who keep them out 24/7 as naturally as I am able, tis still light years away from how they evolved to be kept.
 
There is a huge difference in starving a horse and managing calorie intake for weight loss. I would never starve a horse. Malaika spent much of her time on a good doers diet,she wore a muzzle,came in off the grass during the day but she had a huge net of soaked hay,plenty fibre hardly any calories,she also had 2 bucket feeds of high fibre but hardly any calories. She thrived on this and work,but was never starved or kept cold to keep it off her. Grass unfortunately in most of the country is not suitable for horses waist lines,feet,digestion metabolic system and the like. For me it's taking out the chocolate so to speak and adding in the veg.
 
I can't see how it can be nonsense - shivering is a hard wired natural reaction outside the horse's or human's control, triggered off by thermosensors in the brain and spine. Regardless of how they are nowadays kept, they evolved in the steppes of Russia and we evolved in Africa, their comfort zone is way different to ours. What is certain is that their muscle mass is greater than ours and shivering is an effective way of generating heat.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Laura_107
It's not nonsense cortrasna, it's fact. It's a form of thermo-regulatory thermogenesis in mammals. It is controlled by the hypothalamus and triggered when a mammal drops below a critical temperature.

I studied it while doing my degree in animal biology. It is fact, though nothing to do with weight loss.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rubic and Ruskii
To me the question is though, is it normal when the reason they are or could be shivering is because of human interference with their natural coats? I've seen horses shivering. Normally thin skinned horses caught in awful rain when all they have is their summer coat. Neala shivered when I first got her,her coat was poor as was her general immune system,this year however she has a fantastic natural coat. Shivering is a form of warming up yes, but is it a fair way to help lose weight. While I agree the term is often used tongue in cheek and not ment to that extent,the problem is how do you know a horse isn't that cold all day and all night? It's too risky for me.
 
It's not nonsense cortrasna, it's fact. It's a form of thermo-regulatory thermogenesis in mammals. It is controlled by the hypothalamus and triggered when a mammal drops below a critical temperature.

Perhaps I didn't phrase what I meant to say clearly, I will try again. I don't have any degree or any formal education in the thermo-regulatory thermogenesis in mammals - I only know what I am told by people who have that eduction, my comment that it is all nonsense, is not saying that the knowledge you gained at university is false, far be it for me to argue the point of that with someone who has studied it in depth.;)

So, to explain what I meant by tis all nonsense -I cannot acccept that any argument on the horse's ability to shiver is quite alright as they have evolved to do this and it is a natural mechansim for them as it is in any mammal, so therefore that is OK and all is well for them, even if they are standing in a small field shivering, minus all their body hair, or even in some finer bred horses with all their body hair they will shiver in certain circumstances. My thoughts are that using that argument to suggest 'tis natural' for them to shiver so tis OK, is completely ignoring why horses evolved with this mechansim.

That mechanism will not help them one bit when they have -10 and lashing freezing rain coming down on their backs, holed up in small area of unatural grazing and terrain, that evolution most certainly didn't have in mind for them all those years ago.:)
 
  • Like
Reactions: mystiquemalaika
Yup. Till at least the mid 1980's. And even my new-born son had repeated bloods taken by an incompetent student who couldn;t find a vein. It took AGES of repeatedly sticking a needle in him. When I eventually protested I was told 'it's okay he won;t remember'....

From Wikipdedia: Do Babies Feel Pain
Late 19th Century[edit]

In the late nineteenth, and first half of the twentieth century, doctors were taught that babies did not experience pain, and were treating their young patients accordingly. From needle sticks to tonsillectomies to heart operations were done with no anaesthesia oranalgesia, other than muscle relaxation for the surgery.[citation needed] The belief was that in babies the expression of pain was reflexive and, owing to the immaturity of the infant brain, the pain could not really matter.[34]

Cope[32] considers it probable that the belief arose from misinterpretation of discoveries made in the new science of embryology. Dr Paul Flechsig equated the non-myelinisation of much of a baby’s nervous system with an inability to function.[citation needed]

It was generally believed that babies would not remember any pain that they happened to feel, and that lack of conscious memory meant lack of long-term harm. Scientific studies on animals with various brain lesions were interpreted as supporting the idea that the responses seen in babies were merely spinal reflexes. Furthermore, the whole effort of relieving pain was considered futile since it was thought to be impossible to measure the child's pain.[35]

This, coupled with a concern that use of opiates would lead to addiction, and the time and effort needed to provide adequate analgesia to the newborn, contributed to the medical profession's continued practice of not providing pain relief for babies.[36]

Mid 1980s[edit]
In the United States, a major change in practice was brought about by events surrounding one operation. Infant Jeffrey Lawson underwent open heart surgery in 1985. His mother, Jill R. Lawson, subsequently discovered that he had been operated on without any anaesthesia, other than a muscle relaxant. She started a vigorous awareness campaign[37] which created such a public, and medical, reaction that by 1987[38] medical opinion had come full circle.

A number of studies on the measurement of pain in young children, and on ways of reducing the injury response began,[which?] and publications on the hormonal and metabolic responses of babies to pain stimuli began to appear, confirming that the provision of adequate anaesthesia and analgesia was better medicine on both humanitarian and physiological grounds.[citation needed]

It is now accepted that the neonate responds more extensively to pain than the adult does, and that exposure to severe pain, without adequate treatment, can have long-term consequences. Despite the difficulty of assessing how much pain a baby is experiencing, and the practical problem of prescribing the correct dosage or technique for treatment, modern medicine is firmly committed to improving the quality of pain relief for the very young.[34]

Christ, reading that as a mother of a young child that has brought me out in goosebumps and near tears thinking of those poor babies.

:(
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gimp
I think any debate about 'natural versus non natural' is largely unhelpful. Pain is 'natural' while medical treatment is 'unnatural'. I imagine most of us would seek medical treatment for our injured horses?
Shivering is clearly a natural phenomenon that mammals use to generate heat. As this process uses energy it is possible to get a horse to lose weight by turning out clipped and unrugged to trigger shivering. People who recommend this generally say the horse does not mind - because it is natural and what the horse was designed to do. Which to me is totally illogical argument. Just because its natural doesn't mean it's not highly unpleasant for the horse.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers and Gimp
In those circumstances imo it's not natural though as a human has caused that possible reaction by removing hair.
Like cortrasna said earlier though,a trace or bib along the line of where the water naturally runs off very rarely causes shivering and leaves natural protection over the important areas of the back. It's actually a popular choice for horses who dont need rugged but need some hair off for exercise reasons and or because they are hot bods.
 
Yes I agree!
So it could be seen as unnatural (because you are removing a horse's natural protection) or natural because it is what the horse was designed to do. But either way it causes discomfort if the horse is cold enough to be actually shivering. So frankly I don't care whether it is natural or not, I still wouldn't do it because it makes no sense to imagine that the horse doesn't mind. Shivering MUST be highly aversive because it is so 'expensive' from an energy point of view and horses have evolved to conserve energy.
 
Perhaps this will help -

10353715_844958432190848_4125794012179407208_n.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrA
No I wouldn't do it either as I think it's an unnecessary way of shifting weight. I have no problem seeing a horse shivering if it's in circumstances like a heavy downpour while they only have a summer coat for example,that then is in my eyes a natural response to the environment around them,but to see a horse purposefully kept cold in my eyes is neither fair nor productive. There are much better ways of helping get weight off.
Just to add over rugging is a major bug bear for me too,I'd rather a horse was under rugged than risk over heating but there is a line to how far you take that.
 
I think any debate about 'natural versus non natural' is largely unhelpful. Pain is 'natural' while medical treatment is 'unnatural'. I imagine most of us would seek medical treatment for our injured horses?
Shivering is clearly a natural phenomenon that mammals use to generate heat. As this process uses energy it is possible to get a horse to lose weight by turning out clipped and unrugged to trigger shivering. People who recommend this generally say the horse does not mind - because it is natural and what the horse was designed to do. Which to me is totally illogical argument. Just because its natural doesn't mean it's not highly unpleasant for the horse.


I agree, just because it may be natural does not mean it is nice for the horse. Why should they be made to have an unpleasant and prolonged experience just because we humans choose to keep them in conditions less than perfect for what they evolved from and to be kept in. I need to lose a few pounds and no doubt running on less fuel would do the trick but I dislike feeling hungry very much and it can make me feel dizzy and miserable.
 
No I wouldn't do it either as I think it's an unnecessary way of shifting weight. I have no problem seeing a horse shivering if it's in circumstances like a heavy downpour while they only have a summer coat for example,that then is in my eyes a natural response to the environment around them,but to see a horse purposefully kept cold in my eyes is neither fair nor productive. There are much better ways of helping get weight off.
Just to add over rugging is a major bug bear for me too,I'd rather a horse was under rugged than risk over heating but there is a line to how far you take that.

My worry is that keeping a horse purposefully cold would lower their immune system as a result of their body using resources to keep warm. I am not sure if that is scientific fact or anything, but in the wild, an animal would also have the option of self-regulating their temperature by getting in from the cold and seeking cover and shelter - as my cats do the moment it starts raining - but field kept animals usually don't have this option either.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna and Gimp
I agree with you all, I wouldn't like to keep my horse in a state where he would shiver for any length of time.

But if you kept me hungry for a prolonged period of time and upped my exercise I imagine I would find it just as awful as or worse than being kept cold for a prolonged period of time.

I'm a cold person, I shiver a lot! I spend hours outside for work and I'm already shivering for hours on end. Doesn't do me any harm, but maybe that explains why I'm so skinny ;-)
 
I know its not the same but I shiver frequently in winter and do feel the cold a lot,my dad keeps our house cool and I'm outside a lot. I always loose weight in winter without trying! Nothing else really changes so I can only think its the being cold, its not very pleasant!
 
Mine needs to lose weight, my vet didn't suggest shivering the weight off.
Her first response was increase the work, if what's going in is more than being used it creates fat, so burn it off.
She also added a few other ideas as a "last resort" those didn't include shivering either!

As far as I know a horse grows a coat to protect it from the elements as the grazing will be poor/sparse over winter. It naturally drops weights, a horse that doesn't has a problem, medically or dietary.
I have never ever heard of clipping to lose weight, a clipped horse was described as needing stabling and rugging in winter. Perhaps you could reduce the weight of the rug, so they are a little nippy, never shivering.


IMO a shivering horse is too cold, it causes the muscles to tighten and become sore.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna
newrider.com