"Scotland decides..."

Lol Linda we don't have lifts in Scotland. We scale the outside of buildings with Spider-Man esque athleticism.

Salmond is the Man Who Would Be King. God help Scotland if he gets his wish.

I have a feeling he'll retire ASAP, and then sit in glorious judgement of whoever has to captain the sinking ship, all the while saying 'that wouldn't have happened if I'd been at the helm.'

I have to say that, from the people I've spoken to, those who have lived in and experienced extreme poverty (and there are many of them here in Glasgow) are voting Yes. They want out of the Tory led government that hasn't done them any favours, they feel they'll have a better chance if Scotland goes independent to vote for a party that has Scotland's interests at heart - we will never get that without independence: with a population that's only 8.4% of the UK our votes count for nothing here. I wouldn't call them blind optimists. Optimists yes but those that I know have actually thought about it and have some very valid reasons.

Rubic, just my opinion and my sense of humour. Anything I write about politics is never serious. I unfortunately can't take it as such. I appreciate that folk have different opinions. Such is life. I'll continue to view it as a psychology project though and I'm a pessimist so I can never see the positives out of a situation, so anyone else around me who does, to me, is a blind optimist, cause pessimists (well this one anyway) are not fans of optimists and call them all blind.
 
I have a purely emotional response to this, I really don't want Scotland to go, I feel like Mummy and Daddy are divorcing. I know this is not rational, or sensible, and if the Scottish people decide to leave then that's entirely up to them. Bit I cant help feeling sad that they might want to.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers
But FM couldn't you look at it from the other way and say that those voting no are optimistic that things will improve if we stay as part of the union?

to keep sponging off England?

As a general point, because I have seen this a lot in recent debates, mainly from English people: I am constantly disappointed to read/hear people say that Scotland sponges off England. Scotland actually contributes a great deal to the UK as a whole (and not just financially) and I hate that people genuinely cannot see that. I find it even more surprising and confusing when it comes from people who say they want Scotland to stay as part of the UK.

I am usually proud to be Scottish (I am proud of the culture, diversity and attitude that we generally have) but I'm sickened by the behaviour of the campaigners right now and that is on both sides. Both sides are lying, both sides are arguing aggressively to the point of violence. People are fearful of riots this weekend when the results are announced (whatever way it goes). The whole thing has turned into a total farce. IMO we should have been offered the vote on Devo-max, it shouldn't have been a last minute panic thought from Westminster when the polls weren't going their way.
 
I am Scottish by breeding and birthplace but having 'emigrated' years ago to work in England get no say. Only one of my Scottish friends/family are inclined to the 'yes' vote but she has extreme left wing views and sees independent Scotland as a place where everyone will be equal and the state will totally support the weak. Telling her that won't work out is a bit like telling Salmond he cannot use the pound/stay in the EEC/NATO etc, just met with blank refusal to accept.

I cannot see Scotland being the same ever again whatever the vote and agree with Wally's last post.
 
I have very little knowledge of the political situation in Scotland, I only know what I read in the media and see on the internet, and we all know how reliable THAT information is! But I shuddder at the things I am seeing and hearing these last few days from both sides of the debate. I fear for Scotland's future and how it will ever repair and rebuild itself from all the aggression and racism, from both sides, however the vote goes.

Very sad times and a few lesson's could have been learned from looking just a short way across the water at the deep and everlasting damage that my small island of Ireland still suffers to this day after the terrible struggle for Independence many years ago, that split us in two..forever it would seem. :(
 
I have no clue on politics and rarely watch TV and don't read papers or the internet for news so can give no informed opinion, only to say as a Brit I would be sad to see Scotland go, sad to see our flag change, sad to loose a part of our union.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers
I am part English and part Irish......I am not much up on politics, but I would not like to see an independent Scotland ..I am really sad this might really happen... I haven't watched much coverage of the debates etc. But I feel breaking this union would be damaging for everybody.

I really hope Scotland's people vote No :( I have been to Scotland so many times what a beautiful country it is. I have no idea of finace etc but I would hate to see them struggle if it all went wrong :(
 
I have to say that, from the people I've spoken to, those who have lived in and experienced extreme poverty (and there are many of them here in Glasgow) are voting Yes. They want out of the Tory led government that hasn't done them any favours, they feel they'll have a better chance if Scotland goes independent to vote for a party that has Scotland's interests at heart - we will never get that without independence: with a population that's only 8.4% of the UK our votes count for nothing here. I wouldn't call them blind optimists. Optimists yes but those that I know have actually thought about it and have some very valid reasons.

It's very hard for people who are struggling with poverty, in the rest of the UK as well as in Scotland. It's easy to understand that they think that independence will get rid of the Tories for ever and make everything different - that's what they've been told. But it could be that Scotland isn't as rich as they thought, that independence costs more than they expected, and that once again it will be the poor who suffer.
 
It's very hard for people who are struggling with poverty, in the rest of the UK as well as in Scotland. It's easy to understand that they think that independence will get rid of the Tories for ever and make everything different - that's what they've been told. But it could be that Scotland isn't as rich as they thought, that independence costs more than they expected, and that once again it will be the poor who suffer.
I'm not necessarily saying these people are right or wrong and I understand poverty is a worldwide problem but if you ask someone who lives in poverty if they want to continue the way things are or if they want to try something that might improve things then many will pick the latter option and hold the opinion that "things can't get any worse" for them.

Voting is a very personal thing and if someone has a well thought out opinion (and not just because they hate the English or because they are worried they won't get to watch EastEnders) I'm not going to judge their decision either way. I'm going to respect their opinion the same way I would expect someone to respect mine.
 
Well I have family in Scotland, one aunty literally just over the border. They are all happy to stay part of the UK and I must admit I hope it does stay part of the UK. I like Scotland :-) I'm not at all up on politics so won't comment on that side but I will be sad if it's split.
 
I'm not necessarily saying these people are right or wrong and I understand poverty is a worldwide problem but if you ask someone who lives in poverty if they want to continue the way things are or if they want to try something that might improve things then many will pick the latter option and hold the opinion that "things can't get any worse" for them.

going Independant is a pretty big irreversible gamble though to just' try' something that 'might' improve their situation, as well as being something that effects everyone else including many that dont want it, and the rest of the nation thats going to be split.

I hate politicians and their speel of lies and manipulation they will try ( on both sides) in order to say things people want to hear.

me personally think its going to be a huge disaster if a Yes vote comes through
 
I respect people who vote yes Rubic, don't think anyone's saying to the contrary. We all have that right. I just don't understand how they can think it won't cost us more money we dont have and that's why I see it as blind optimism.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ruskii
Politicians NEVER got ANYONE out of poverty, if anything they are responsible for putting folk into it, The only person to get you out of poverty is yourself. Stop blaming others, if you are on the dole, sat there doing nothing then DO SOMETHING. Stop sitting there blaming others and pull yourself up by your bootstraps.
I have been in a place where I have not had two brass farthings to rub together, chances are there will be another episode of skintness in my life, but NEVER have I thought the answer to my lack of money could be improved by a politician, this blame the English, blame the labour party, the conservative party etc annoys me.
 
going Independant is a pretty big irreversible gamble though to just' try' something that 'might' improve their situation, as well as being something that effects everyone else including many that dont want it, and the rest of the nation thats going to be split.

I hate politicians and their speel of lies and manipulation they will try ( on both sides) in order to say things people want to hear.

me personally think its going to be a huge disaster if a Yes vote comes through

Well then they obviously believe that there is more chance of things improving for them with independence than if Scotland stays under Westminister rule and to them it is a risk worth taking. You are right politicians lie to get votes, I suppose it comes down to which side people think is lying least which is partly why good old Boris Johnson isn't doing the Better Together campaign any favours when they are claiming (at the last minute) they will give us more devolution with a no vote and Boris is apparently jumping about saying that the Torys don't want or plan to give us that. The same can be said of some promises from the yes campaign but then voters feel the stuff coming from the BT camp is somewhat reminiscent of what happened in the 70s so I suppose once bitten twice shy.

If it is a No vote you will also be going against nearly half of the population of Scotland - it swings both ways, the polls are far too close and there is no clear majority. Personally I think that is a huge sign that this referendum was poorly thought out on both sides and that it has come far too early and that is why there is also a huge group of people that are on the fence, can see the good and bad in both sides and genuinely don't know what to do.

I don't think they do believe that it won't cost us I think that is one of the few things that experts believe the yes camp have thought out and delivered a realistic idea about and there are a number of reasonable ways in which this cost will be recovered.
 
You are so right when you say the referendum was badly thought out. You are bang on the money there.

had the question been worded differently then I may vote yes, But as it's worded now, it's a pig in a poke. Had they asked, "in principle," given that thing currency, EU membership, pension, NHS, professional governing bodies , banks etc were all in place and negotiated, then in theory there is no reason why Scotland could not be independent, as it stands now Adolf Salmond is handing everyone in the country a poke that might have a pig in it or it might have an enormous smelly sticky turd in it.
 
couple of years ago I had to move due to extreme personal situation with literally 'nothing' but a suitcase I had no choice, I left behind a business to, howeverI found the benefits system from walking in like a rabbit in headlights generous and enabled me to move house to a better area, I got help with private rental deposits, help with furnishing my house, help with clothing for interviews, help with childcare costs for interviews, working tax credits is there in place and help with ongoing childcare costs when in employment. How much more do people exactly want? Ive now moved house since. From herr to nearest place of employment, work is approx a daily 70mile round trip, your either willing to do it push yourself for interviews etc or your not. I could of quite easily sat on my arse, not attempted to better myself and pleaded poverty and felt sorry for myself for the rest of my days blaming everyone under the sun! I did not expect housing or a new job to come to me. People expect far to much these days. Ive paid taxes all my life and when I suddenly found myself needing help through no fault of my own, I had somewhere to turn to. This country isnt perfect however I do not believe the grass is greener and I learnt alot about life from my rather unpleasant experience. Falling down hard from high up is a huge reality check.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: candyflosspot
I am in the 'no' camp - not that I get a say as I am British. I think it's absurd people this side of the border don't get a say on whether the union continues. Whatever happens, the result is going to be one that roughly 50% of Scots don't want. The whole thing has created disharmony in Scotland, let alone English/Scottish relations.

Also our last PM was a Scot. New Labour was dominated by Scots. Salmond's argument that UK politics marginalises Scotland is nonsense, unless he believes Scottish politicians suddenly lose interest in Scotland once elected. In which case, why would independence change that? A lot of his policies are basically Tory policies anyway, that's the irony. The 'new' Scotland isn't going to be some socialist utopia! But my friends voting yes say they are not voting for Salmond, and they don't think he'd win a General Election...
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna and Gimp
I'm also a no voter, the chance we may go independent genuinely terrifies me. It also saddens me that this is a really close run thing, 50% of Scotland is going to be unhappy no matter what happens. It has divided our country and no good will come of it no matter the outcome.

I'm sick to death of seeing political posts all over my Facebook & all the yes campaigners all over the city. I'm fed up of debating with yes voters who have no idea what they are taking about and just tell me how patriotic they are being and how much they hate Cameron.

I'm glad to hear that those South of the border still want to keep us, I was worried you would all be thinking 'stuff em, watch them fail'
No, I think so many of us have some kind of tie to Scotland (my husband's family in my case) that we definitely don't want failure any more than we want you to go!
 
newrider.com