"Scotland decides..."

As a general point, because I have seen this a lot in recent debates, mainly from English people: I am constantly disappointed to read/hear people say that Scotland sponges off England. Scotland actually contributes a great deal to the UK as a whole (and not just financially) and I hate that people genuinely cannot see that. I find it even more surprising and confusing when it comes from people who say they want Scotland to stay as part of the UK.
We can only go off what we see/hear. When you see what Salmond wants off England for the split, can you not see why us English people you're so disappointed in are saying such? If he doesn't want to be part of GB, why should he get to keep all the privileges of being a part of GB?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ruskii
No, I think so many of us have some kind of tie to Scotland (my husband's family in my case) that we definitely don't want failure any more than we want you to go!
Half of my mothers side of the family live in Scotland, and were successful and well standing members of the community, and those who are remaining have all been told to move their money to Ireland as the Scottish banks are far too unstable due to the potential risk of independence. It's a dangerous place to be financially...
 
We can only go off what we see/hear. When you see what Salmond wants off England for the split, can you not see why us English people you're so disappointed in are saying such? If he doesn't want to be part of GB, why should he get to keep all the privileges of being a part of GB?

I am not talking about when it comes to independence (I can see why rUK would be angry at an independent Scotland in that case) I'm actually talking about the current situation. (I do not like Salmond and I think that should we end up independent we should be truly independent with the national debt split according to percentage population, as that is what is fair (if you can call any of this fair), so there is no argument, as it were, there)

When people start talking about this referendum there is a constant stream of people saying/implying that Scotland *currently* sponges off the UK (and will "keep sponging/continue to sponge" if we end up independent). I feel that attitude has been really played on by some politicians/parties and some branches of the media and it's only making the divide worse and encouraging the anti-English attitude that is appearing now. Then England wonders why Scotland has such a problem and wants to break away and so the vicious cycle continues.

Would you not be disappointed if the country you lived in, worked hard in and were proud of and therefore the people in it, your community and work colleagues were being labelled as "spongers"? Would you not then start to wonder why they even want you in the union if they think you are a sponger...

This referendum is inciting a lot of hatred on both sides and it really saddens me. I'm not looking forward to Friday, it will be hellish for everyone whatever way it goes.

I have family and lovely friends in England, it's not somewhere I've been often (I've not been to many places!) but I have only good memories of being there. I don't hate England or English people but I love the place I've grown up, I love the people here, I love the history, the culture, the university education I was very lucky to get here.... The only thing I'd say I hate is the weather! That doesn't make me some Braveheart nut, I'd never use that as a reason to vote for independence. I can see that there could be potential in independence but there is also the potential for great loss and I can see that things aren't working the way things are either. I have been ignoring the lies that are being pumped out of both campaigns and reading some unbiased information that gives a clear idea of all the possibilities because I want to make an informed choice and be aware of what could happen either way.
 
Half of my mothers side of the family live in Scotland, and were successful and well standing members of the community, and those who are remaining have all been told to move their money to Ireland as the Scottish banks are far too unstable due to the potential risk of independence. It's a dangerous place to be financially...

Feck!!! don't anybody be tempted to move their money from a bank in Scotland to one in Ireland - our investments have been halved thanks to the Irish banks bringing Ireland to it knees! Just something you need to know if that is the sort of b****x that is being spouted over the water!
 
I know very little regarding the whole split business other than what i have read/heard in the media. As we all know the medias views are biased dependent on who supports who.

I personally would like to Scotland to stay as part of the UK because i believe that we stand together stronger. I do not believe that 2 years is long enough to " get a country " stood on its own 2 feet. If the vote is yes then the a huge chunk of the UK debt will be handed over to Scotland - the uk are struggling as it is. How on earth will Scotland cope with that kind of added financial pressure? I am sorry but the oil will not last forever - with more & more people looking at alternative energy sources. It is only a matter of time before renewable energy takes over because IMO IT WILL, and it will be sooner than people expect.

Do scotland have any other sources of income?:oops: ( I can only think of energy, and fishing industries)

@ Rubic I am shocked to hear you say that the English are calling you spongers - i have never heard anyone say this about Scotland AT ALL. EVER. Where did you hear/read this? I am embarrassed if you have heard people say this because as far as i am concerned its not true.

As for Salmond - the man is a grade A pillock. I suspect he sees himself as the modern day William Wallace and fancies going down in history as the savior of scotland. o_O . All he has succeeded at doing is causing an awful lot of dis-comfort and animosity between the Scots/English. I would also like to point out i have NO ISSUE what so ever with Scotland being ruler of their own land and spending money as they see fit.

This whole thing has been a farce from the start - all it is politicians arguing every 5 mins like children. Who are the ones that will ultimately suffer? The general population - if the banks & other businesses do up sticks , then how do the scottish gov have a contingency plan to cope with the massive influx of unemployment?

Like others on the thread - I also dont know anyone who will be voting Yes on thursday. All my scottish friends are against the idea, along with my english friends. I would dearly like to see a No vote. Either way we are all in for a big social change.
 
Ive read alot of tripe by racist keyboard warriors over these last few weeks, from both sides. Its very pathetic.
 
I think the 'sponging' thing may be a reference to the fact that Scotland has a higher number of benefit claimants per capita than some parts of the UK. Not surprisingly really as its geography has not historically lent itself to wealth! And being on some form of benefits is not the same as 'sponging' of course, unless you're a bit of a twat! The welfare bill is balanced by the oil revenues Scotland generates though. Or so I have read! Could all be BS!
 
I think the 'sponging' thing may be a reference to the fact that Scotland has a higher number of benefit claimants per capita than some parts of the UK. Not surprisingly really as its geography has not historically lent itself to wealth! And being on some form of benefits is not the same as 'sponging' of course, unless you're a bit of a twat! The welfare bill is balanced by the oil revenues Scotland generates though. Or so I have read! Could all be BS!

well what would people expect? Scotland has a smaller land to people to ratio? It makes sense that they may have a higher number of benefit claimants. Or is the niggle that it seems that Scotland are a bunch of lazy toads? The reality is more likely to be the fact there are more people than jobs - similar to the UK .
 
I have been ignoring the lies that are being pumped out of both campaigns and reading some unbiased information that gives a clear idea of all the possibilities because I want to make an informed choice and be aware of what could happen either way.

Where do you find this unbiased information, Rubic? I'd like to see some if you have a link.
 
  • Like
Reactions: squidsin
If I was voting I would be concerned that both sides arguments are simply emotive, not factual. I would want Heads of Terms on a split to have been negotiated in principle, so that I would have a little more understanding of the implications of what I would be voting on. But so far as I can tell, they have not been?

My gut feeling is that independence would be a bad thing. Again that is emotion as I don't know how it will all work.
 
If I was voting I would be concerned that both sides arguments are simply emotive, not factual. I would want Heads of Terms on a split to have been negotiated in principle, so that I would have a little more understanding of the implications of what I would be voting on. But so far as I can tell, they have not been?

My gut feeling is that independence would be a bad thing. Again that is emotion as I don't know how it will all work.
I agree. I would want to know what I was saying yes TO, but everything is still completely up in the air with one day to go!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gimp
If I was voting I would be concerned that both sides arguments are simply emotive, not factual. I would want Heads of Terms on a split to have been negotiated in principle, so that I would have a little more understanding of the implications of what I would be voting on. But so far as I can tell, they have not been?

My gut feeling is that independence would be a bad thing. Again that is emotion as I don't know how it will all work.

I have the impression that the Yes voters are more emotional; the Noes more concerned with facts. The trouble is, as Rubic's link makes very clear, there is a huge amount of stuff that just can't be known in advance, and that applies in some degree to the No arguments (because no-one knows what government will be elected in the (rest of the?) UK next year, so there's no way of knowing what the promised new devolution may turn out to be like. But there are more uncertainties with the Yes voters because there's so much more that's unknown. Still, Scotland seems to me to be doing pretty well at the moment, compared with England and Wales.
 
One of my old uni pals put it perfectly- under the current arrangements he's never been unemployed, never been homeless and has a wee girl who is getting a good education. Why throw all that away? I've read some frightening things from Yes voters that I can only liken to Animal Farm. They are hell bent on redistribution of wealth. I'm sorry but my money and I'll spend it how I please. Throwing money at those in poverty won't help. They need means to support themselves.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gimp
I
One of my old uni pals put it perfectly- under the current arrangements he's never been unemployed, never been homeless and has a wee girl who is getting a good education. Why throw all that away? I've read some frightening things from Yes voters that I can only liken to Animal Farm. They are hell bent on redistribution of wealth. I'm sorry but my money and I'll spend it how I please. Throwing money at those in poverty won't help. They need means to support themselves.

I have to say, I think the idea that Scotland is going to be a left-wing Utopia (or Distopia, if you prefer!) is highly unlikely. It's more likely to look politically pretty much as it does now, given that Salmond is a right-winger, and I've yet to see any darlings of the left come in and stake their claim over the political scene. The Scottish politicians of the future look rather like the politicians of, well, now. Economic dependency on oil and financial services, with tax breaks offered to big business to move to/stay in Scotland, does not smack of a left-wing government (not further left than Labour anyway and really they're centre-right, not even centre-left.)
 
I just don't understand where this pot of money is coming from. This oil money everyone is talking about? Bollocks. The oil industry operates on a financial knife edge, they will cut and run as soon as the price of oil drops and Scotland will have to provide huge tax incentives to keep them here. As an industry who generally doesn't do anything until it has to, they are already putting effort into thinking about decommissioning, oh, and the Government pays 75% of decommissioning costs (not insignificant!), the big companies are selling up the fields where it's harder to get the oil out (too much effort, not enough profit), never mind the fact that I think there is only one Scottish oil company, the rest are American/French/multinationals. We are not going to be Norway.

So effectively, our taxes are going to be through the roof! Can't wait...
 
SNP is a left wing Glasgow based extreme left driven party! Scotland is a very different country from the rest of the UK. Home ownership is lower and social housing particularly in cities is high and good. Strangely in this potential left wing utopia centered around cities some Scottish people are often the bravest and brightest entrepreneurs. In the highlands and Islands people have absolutely nothing in common with the 'Central belt' who are driving for independence
 
  • Like
Reactions: eventerbabe
newrider.com