"Scotland decides..."

eventerbabe

Well-Known Member
Dec 16, 2004
15,114
550
113
So Wednesday is D-day. I'm intrigued to know what those of you south of the border think about the independence vote? I know what I think.... I'm British. We don't live in the "brave heart" era. I'm sick to the back teeth of being told that England bully us and stifle us. Do they hell! We are one country and I hope and pray those brainwashed by El capitan Salmond come to their senses on Wednesday!!
 
I am so so glad to hear you say that. A friend and I were talking yesterday about how sick and miserable this has made us. Like many English people I have Scottish family, have spent lots of time in Scotland and love Scotland. I am terribly anxious about the whole thing, I so want the Union to be unbroken. But I remember Pinkheather saying that he would vote Yes because he is a romantic - nothing to do with megalomaniac Alex. I am scared, frankly.
 
I'm scared too. We are about to take on a huge mortgage and OH is vastly increasing his commute. On a personal level, a yes vote has the potential to royally screw us over. I've no time for the "romantics". This isn't like a general election, we can't wait 4 years then vote for change. This amounts to divorce- painful and permanent. The yes campaign are deluded. They haven't a clue. Their promises are based on fairy dust and rainbow-farting unicorns. I cannot believe anyone with half a brain cell gives them the time of day. I'll be saying no thanks on Wednesday and I know it's harsh but friends of mine who vote yes may find themselves being 'let go'. If the yes vote gets it, I can't and won't forgive them for ruining our country. Sorry, think I've gone into rant mode!! I've first hand experience of the mess which is now the Scottish education system. That's thanks to her Salmond. He's screwed our kids over, now he's out to get the rest of the country!
 
I think it is a shame as I do believe that if Scotland are going to be truly independent things may well get very tough for anyone north of the border, I mean is independent Scotland going to fund all there own benefits, hospitals, schools etc etc with no hand outs from the 'English'?
 
I will feel sad if Scotland decide to leave our unity. I like the fact we are united - it makes us great and stronger together. Seems so sad really and I worry about my family that live in Scotland as they are originally from England. What will happen to them? How will feelings be running?
 
Scotland CANNOT fund itself. Businesses will pull out in droves. Oil revenues go to Westminster despite our chubby little dictator Salmond running his mouth off about Scotland having them. The thought of the mess this will create is terrifying.

I'm actually ashamed to be of Scottish birth right now. There is a big Yes rally/flash mob going on in town today. So not only am I prevented from going shopping for wedding bits, I have to see the vile comments on FB from those for the split. Racist bigots springs to mind... My dad had a set to with three Yes campaigners yesterday. Everything is so unpleasant. They are destroying our country :(
 
Scotland CANNOT fund itself. Businesses will pull out in droves. Oil revenues go to Westminster despite our chubby little dictator Salmond running his mouth off about Scotland having them. The thought of the mess this will create is terrifying.

I'm actually ashamed to be of Scottish birth right now. There is a big Yes rally/flash mob going on in town today. So not only am I prevented from going shopping for wedding bits, I have to see the vile comments on FB from those for the split. Racist bigots springs to mind... My dad had a set to with three Yes campaigners yesterday. Everything is so unpleasant. They are destroying our country :(

It all sounds horrible for you eventerbabe :( I hope for you all that the majority see sense and vote NO.
 
I'm viewing it as a big psychology experiment. Blind optimists will vote yes, smart pessimists will vote no. I'm sick of the propaganda, and I think it's absolutely ridiculous to think we can go it alone without enduring a financial meltdown.
I've done next to no research into the subject and am going with my gut. I've come across some very persistent yes voters trying to convince me I'm wrong but I'm not of the opinion that our situation is broken, so why try and fix it?!
Some folk liken it to living with your parents and then choosing to live alone. Fine if you're the politicians of Scotland, feeling stifled by Westminster, but we're at the mercy of politicians no matter what happens, be them westminsterites or Scottish, I hate politicians and believe nothing they say. I'd rather stick with what I know already for that reason. Someone may come along and attempt to shoot me down for my uninformed opinion, but I consider it being unbiased - I have not listened to any of the hogwash either side has had to say for themselves and am going with how I feel. I'm proud to be Scottish, I take great pleasure in imitating the posh lift lady ("doors closing") whenever I'm down south, but I'm happily British. Rant over. I will fall off my seat if we get independence and won't be happy.
 
Well said, FM! I'm pleased to such solidarity; I just hope you and everyone who agrees with you gets out to vote. But I'm curious: do lifts really have different accents in Scotland?
 
Personally, I don't know any yes voters, Here there has been hardly a whisper about the whole campagn. So many tourists who have stayed have told the same tales of Mainland Scotland being riddled with Union flags and Saltires.

Yesterday a few Yes and No posters appeared in bus stops, that about it. I have a feeling the Northern Isles will be a majority No vote as they have no affinity with Scotland, Tartan, clans and Bagpipes. Edinbugger have no clue as to where we are anyway. London has more clue.
 
  • Like
Reactions: eventerbabe
I hope the vote goes no - I can't see how the economy will sustain if little support is provided from England...

Sadly, in times of hardship 'extremism' appears and people look for a different way - anyway. That's why UKIP and BNP have got such a hold as well. I wonder how a general election would pan out without Scotland's votes? I suspect UKIP etc will have an even bigger hold.

It would be sad to lose the allegiance.
 
I think, eventerbabe, that you will find the referendum is on Thursday, not Wednesday. I realise you are very keen to cast your vote, but that's a long time to wait for the polling station to open.
 
Whatever happens I think the relationship between England and Scotland will be damaged. I think Salmond lives on another planet, everything he's saying is a pro to independence is minute issues compared to things such as sustainability, british debt, North Sea oil, the EU, currency and the fact he's wanting a share of the Bank of England? That's not including the military forces - initially he wanted Glasgow naval base gone, although I have since heard he wants our military protection. Probably the comments about Scotland being at a higher risk of terrorist attacks. He also doesn't want border control etc...

Surely the idea of going independent isn't to keep sponging off England?

All of my Scottish friends say no to independence too, and that Salmond is an idiot. I'd agree with them, and you. It's a stupid fairy tale idea.
 
I'm viewing it as a big psychology experiment. Blind optimists will vote yes, smart pessimists will vote no.

I have to say that, from the people I've spoken to, those who have lived in and experienced extreme poverty (and there are many of them here in Glasgow) are voting Yes. They want out of the Tory led government that hasn't done them any favours, they feel they'll have a better chance if Scotland goes independent to vote for a party that has Scotland's interests at heart - we will never get that without independence: with a population that's only 8.4% of the UK our votes count for nothing here. I wouldn't call them blind optimists. Optimists yes but those that I know have actually thought about it and have some very valid reasons.
 
I think, eventerbabe, that you will find the referendum is on Thursday, not Wednesday. I realise you are very keen to cast your vote, but that's a long time to wait for the polling station to open.

So it is! I blame Salmond for that. If teachers weren't running around like blue a**ed flies trying to fathom out his god awful new curriculum then we might know what day of the week it is ;)

I'm sorry but I am NOT paying a grand PLUS additional tax because the yes camp think the Tories don't have their best interests at heart. They don't have MY best interests at heart but I'm not going to do something stupid like vote for independence. When my dad asked THREE yes campaigners yesterday what independence would do to his pension not one of them had an answer. The best they could come up with was "it will work itself out". Will it hell!! My family are lucky, we do ok financially but we've worked bloody hard to get here. I'm not paying for a decision I don't agree with.
 
I'm also a no voter, the chance we may go independent genuinely terrifies me. It also saddens me that this is a really close run thing, 50% of Scotland is going to be unhappy no matter what happens. It has divided our country and no good will come of it no matter the outcome.

I'm sick to death of seeing political posts all over my Facebook & all the yes campaigners all over the city. I'm fed up of debating with yes voters who have no idea what they are taking about and just tell me how patriotic they are being and how much they hate Cameron.

I'm glad to hear that those South of the border still want to keep us, I was worried you would all be thinking 'stuff em, watch them fail'
 
I think it would be best for Scotland to remain part of the UK, but as someone from the South East of England, I've paid it little attention to be honest.

It does frustrate me that things like prescriptions & university education is free for Scotland but not for myself (I've a nice student debt!) but as a UK tax payer that substitutes that, it won't upset me unduly if they do become independant. But, that might be a whole other debate ...!

I'm probably not the best clued up about the whole thing though.

It sounds worrying times for you though - I hope you don't lose out.
 
I'm also a no voter, the chance we may go independent genuinely terrifies me. It also saddens me that this is a really close run thing, 50% of Scotland is going to be unhappy no matter what happen
I'm glad to hear that those South of the border still want to keep us, I was worried you would all be thinking 'stuff em, watch them fail'

There's a difference between wanting to watch Salmond fail and wanting to watch all the innocent 'no voters' fail in trying to maintain a normal life because some idiot decided his fairy tale should come true.
 
newrider.com