Riding hats

smudge

New Member
Jun 10, 2005
355
0
0
Shropshire
This is a follow on really from the Lidl riding hats thread.

My 10 year old needs a new riding hat, the one she has is just over a yr old but feels a bit tight over her forehead and she is complaining a bit.

So my question is which is the best riding hat or skull cap?

What are peoples views on both?

I have always used skull caps but recently bought my first riding hat with a fixed peak and I quite like it. She uses a riding hat with a fixed peak at the moment.

Thanks guys.

Liz
 
Casco are good if you don't intend doing any fancy shows. They alter with a dial at the back. They come in several sizes and even fit my big 'ed.
 
i don;t think it really matters. you can get multicoloured covers for skull caps - easy birthday pressies for relatives! as long as it is kitemarked and BSEN 1384 or PAS015, it's really an aesthetic issue. PAS is a higher standard - the 1384 is not accepted for eventing - but that's about it - the 1384 is accepted for all other disciplines.
 
If she does pony club then need to get one that is approved by them, find this out on their web site. Also if doing cross country in pony club will need to have a skull helmet, so perhaps best to get one of these and then just add different hat covers as appropriate for different disciplines she is doing.
But please make sure it is fitted by an expert fitter.
 
Thanks guys for the help, I just wanted to get some opinions.

I would always get it measured by an expert, I might have an opinion on asthetics but never on fit;)

I suppose I will end up getting what she likes, at this moment she is not good enough to be doing any cross country so if she chooses a riding hat then there will be no harm done.

Liz
 
A couple of years ago the Mark Davies Injury Fund did a study of most of the riding hats around and did a safety report - it makes really interesting reading. You might find it of use!
http://www.mdirf.co.uk/enchapresults/
 
When I was a kid I always had a skull, then I had a velvet peaked cap, then went back to a skull cap. For general riding there's no difference, just comfort.
I found that they tende to be different shapes, with velvet show cap style ones being longer and narrower, and skulls being more rounded, or that could be my head, and I'm sure it varies between makes.
Vicki xx
 
Hi.

I posted this on the lidl thread too so apologies if you've already read it....

If going for a velvet cap try to make sure the peak is as soft and flexible as possible. I've noticed a few brands that seem to be quite hard peaked, and from personal experience it isn't fun if this peak is forced down and onto your nose! (from a frontal impact for instance). It only took the minimum amount of pressure to shatter my nose from a peaked cap, whereas had I been wearing a skull cap with silk my nose would have survived the impact.

Just a consideration.

Cheers
 
smudge said:
So my question is which is the best riding hat or skull cap?

One that fits :)

I like both but tend to wear my skull with black silk for 'every day'.

I think that for kids the skulls are a good idea as you can put a variety of different silks on them to match their outfits :)

Of course there are the 'Troxel' type ones which are very popular too.
 
I'm 99% sure Casco hats have been discontinued, I think there were safety issues surrounding the harness or something.

I fit hats at work, and I have to say, it's rare that two hats fit the same child and fit them well!
 
my daughters hat has lots of padding in it that the shop said I could bring back to be thinned down when it gets tighter.

I'd go for fit rather than a set type, as both Erin and I were fitted with skull cap types and didn't get a good fit, they seemed half a size too big for us both, or too small of course! ;)
 
I don't like fixed peak hats. I had a nasty fall and the peak of my hat hit the floor pretty hard and I ended up with a very bad neck for a long time.
 
Well in my opinion, most peak helmets look way too ginormous (yes, a new word!), at least on my head. So my next one I buy next year or the year after will be a silhouette show hat, to try and minimise my very large skull.

But you need to replace them, at maximum, every 5 years to rule out a lack of safety due to temperatures and drops. So it should be mainly budget and taste- all certified helments do the same job.
 
Just.Jump said:
But you need to replace them, at maximum, every 5 years to rule out a lack of safety due to temperatures and drops. So it should be mainly budget and taste- all certified helments do the same job.

3 or at least it's 3 in the Uk anyway. ;)

Budget should be taken into account but fit should be priority, if you look on the Lidl thread, there's a link which shows that some hats do the same job better than others.

Unfortunately, health and safety means all hats must have (tongue in cheek bit coming up) 2" of padding all around, a seatbelt and a built in first aid kit. Seriously damages the appearance of the things :rolleyes:
 
I like the Charles Owen range, they all seem to meet all safety standards. I personally think where safety is concerned, get the most up to date British Standard, not just EN, as the UK, I believe test the hats to a higher standard. The Young Rider hats aren't too expensive and come in both skull and velvet. Like Bay Mare suggests, skulls are good as you can get different silks to match their outfits!
 
You UK riders must have better quality helmets =P

I believe that mine suggests being replaced after 4 years, but seeing as how it has never once been left in the sun (even when stored in my room, it's in a compartment of my desk) and has been dropped minimally, mostly in the soft sand arena.. so I'll take my chances for the extra year while saving up for a nice one that doesn't give me a bobble head effect!

I also need to save up for long boots and show wear, should I not suck terribly once I start english next month :rolleyes:
Time to get employed!
 
Mehitabel, thank you for explaining that BSEN 1384 is mnot accepted for eventing. I didnt know that.
But the website report puzzles me. It shows my Gatehouse High Spec (an eventing hat) lower in the list that other Gatehouse models.
And it gives it the same number of stars as the Troxel hat - which I so hankered after for summer - but which my saddler and one of our instructors told me was not such high standard.
In non-riding life I am a very clever woman. And after three years, I still fail to understand these standards.
 
I think sadly no matter how much hats are tested we develop our own views based on experience. I would go along with your instructor that I don't trust Troxels

I don't think they offer enough variety of fit and I had an older customer have bad fall wearing one (fainted while horse was cantering) and had bad enough concussion for our local hosital to keep her in for two days. The same hospital that when I took a teenager after a serious fall and hitting the school wall head first said take her home but just make sure you can wake her every two hours!
 
I have one of the Troxel ones. Just got back into riding and realised from reading threads on here that my skull cap with the cup chin strap was banned. So got a new one quick.

For me it seems a great fit and I'm happy that its scored highly in the tests. Yes there will always be people who will say that they saw someone have a fall and land on their head and hurt themselves, etc. But concussion is not so bad, maybe it might have been worse if she'd been wearing a lower scoring helmet? I would trust scientific tests more than one person's bad experience.

I used to have a skull cap that I had a bad fall with and fractured my skull. But I don't think, that I fractured my skull therefore helmet must have been bad. I think that the helmet probably saved my life.

The woman who owns the stables where I ride saw my pink Troxel and demanded to know if I was riding in a cycling helmet (she was serious). :D
 
newrider.com