eml said:I think sadly no matter how much hats are tested we develop our own views based on experience. I would go along with your instructor that I don't trust Troxels
I don't think they offer enough variety of fit and I had an older customer have bad fall wearing one (fainted while horse was cantering) and had bad enough concussion for our local hosital to keep her in for two days. The same hospital that when I took a teenager after a serious fall and hitting the school wall head first said take her home but just make sure you can wake her every two hours!
I've got a trxel capriole (I believe, too lazy to run and check)- it looks massive on me, but no problems so far. However, I don't think I've hit my head in it yet- maybe once, but I don't recall if I was wearing a helment as it was on a lease situation a few summers ago. Anyway, a helmet is better than none in my books- though I will admit that I really prefer the look and feel of not wearing one (Don't worry, haven't been without for at least two years!)
The level of damage done varies VERY much between people. You can get someone knocking their head on a door frame and bursting vessels, or someone bursting into a wall and being able to go home no problem. Humans are very fickle things when injury is concerned. I fractures my arm in the two larger bones over my own knee, yet I've been tossed off of horses and have had only one very very minor concussion once.