Positive and Negative Reinforcement

Jack, I personally view the two things, trust and reward, as operating at different levels, which is perhaps why I don't see a conflict in the same way you seem to. Like I said -

they're merely a useful tool and / or something pleasant in our relationship rather than fundamental to it

So my payoff from them is finding myself in situations where they might demonstrate their trust in me in various ways. But I don't see that trust as automatically motivating them to do my every bidding, although they are willing enough. Although we have boundaries I think I cut them quite a lot of slack in our day to day interactions, and allow them to express opinions even if I might choose to overrule some of them. I suppose I'm trusting them to do their bit if you like, seems to work well enough for my purposes :)

this aspect of extrinsic and intrinsic is why understanding the basic psychology of the animals we are living with makes such a difference to our ability to build relationships with them....

Perhaps that's what I'm clumsily trying to describe here:rolleyes:
 
My point in this "debate" is that there is no method of training a horse that doesn't involve pressure of some type. Tom Dorrance originally said, "the horse has nothing to go on but feel and timing". In later years he added "balance" but said it took him a long time to recognize it's importance. Now I understand in Asian cultures the image of Ying and Yang is widely recognized. "Feel and Release", or better yet "Release and Feel", you must have balance.

Here's a good example of "clicker training" as it's being used to teach flexion. I believe everything before 3:05 is not helping the horse understand that he is being "asked" to bend his neck, only that he is "curious" about the target.

And then, at 3:05 some clarity is offered to the horse for the first time. Clarity that he is being "asked" to bend his neck by the human. It also happens to be the moment when she admits that maybe a bit of pressure would help. I really like it again at 4:38 when she proclaims, "he feels that" for the first time. That's how I see it anyway.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FUNxUAT2etY&feature=related

It is one of the best examples of "clicker" that I've seen, but it doesn't take that much time to teach a horse to "give" by flexing the neck without a clicker etc. It is much better than most of the examples I've seen.

Keep on, keepin on

Jack
 
Dinner rushed me last nite, and I didn't have time to read fth or yanns replies closely. I do hope folks watch that you tube though, and tell me where anything other than "pressure and release" is being used.

fth, this sentence really caught my attention

now, when I begin a relationship with a horse or a dog, they might not be in a state where intrinsic motivation is there -- so this is where I will use rewards, treats, rubs, praise -- to encourage the behaviours I want

Isn't "intrinsic motivation" always available to the horse? Is this not what horsemen mean when they say "bring the life up". One thing that is common in most of the clickier tubes I've watched is the absence of energy in the handler, leading to lack of energy in the horse. When I'm "asking a horse to perform a task" I always want his attention and energy to be at their peak.
That way I know they will be "intrinsically motivated".

I don't think horses need treats to be motivated, except maybe to motivate me to hurry up and upwrap the mint. :)

Yann, the two levels are what I"m trying to "nail down". Which level best teaches the horse? The level that is "clicker/treat based", or the level that is "trust/feel based". When I watch a performance horse and rider and know the methods used, and compare the rides to the horse and riders I see using clicker training, I confirm my own choices.

Remember, it was others claim that they understood "true reward" that prompted my defensivness. I believe that true reward is always present, if we are just sensitive enough to "feel" it.

Good things can come from diverse opinions. In that spirit, :)



Keep on, keepin on

Jack
 
Last edited:
Sort of conversley, I also using treating as a "human selfishness" if you like.

I know that when I have given her a treat, she is grateful and undesrtands that it is something nice. I can physically see the gratification there and then, rather than the reward of trust.

It may just be because of the way that Silver is, but it took me about 3-4months before she would show signs of listening to me when I call her in the field or even come to me, again that long for the first time that she put her head on my arms and breathed in my nose and nuzzled my face - she always used to stand at the back of her stable, spin around if anyone went in, never came to call, but stood robotically for you to catch (now she is a monkey - I partly hate and its a nuisance, but partly love that she in expressing herself. If she wants to come in, she will come to call, if she doesn't she stays out!)

So in terms of her trusting me, the first time I realised that she was really "letting me in" was when I had been on holiday for two weeks - I went to the field and called her... she came over from the other side of field (huge!) to see me. When we got to the stable she didnt want to know me, and ignored me but I tickled her favourite bits and she softened and wanted cuddles - this was the first indicator that she understood that I would be there and would be coming back - i'm sure she thought I had abandonned her and was excited to see me, then got it together and played it cool!

So I find it difficult to comprehend rewarding with trust as she is very independant and self sufficient. She knows what she wants and doesn't and would live just fine out in the wild without me. Hwoever I think for a needier attention wise horse it would work well, but Silver often doesnt want fuss and affection etc.

I also kind of think of it a bit like my OH asking me to fix his widescreen TV (his baby!!) (and not that I could!) I would be much more grateful for a take away, hugs and a thank you or box of choccies to say thanks, as it would take me longer to appreciate just how much he had trusted me to allow me to do that task and it is not as immediate as a "treat"
 
Jack -- you make an excellent point about how our ENERGY can be a key factor...

I had not gone into much detail to try to just bring up the issues of extrinsic and intrinsic motivation in a straightforward way - good to see you taking it deeper

when you say isn't intrinsic motivation always available to a horse -- well, in one sense intrinsic motivation is always available to EVERYTHING -- but, and here's the but -- there are BLOCKS to it

when motivating people and/or animals we are usually having to deal with removing OBSTACLES to motivation.

with my horse I have had since she was a yearling, I have never needed any external motivators. she wants to work with me and have fun and play -- and so since her needs of safety and comfort are met, and we can have fun together and I am entertainment for her and vice versa -- the relationship works almost totally from intrinsic motivation. her response when I invite her to do something new is "why not? now how can I do this....."

now another horse who came to me at 8 had NO USE for humans. avoided them if she could. if she could not avoid physically, she avoided mentally.

with her, using some target training and food rewards had the result of her looking forward to seeing a human come towards her vs running away.

once the habit of running away had been changed, then the block to intrinsic motivation was removed and the motivation based on relationship and energy was allowed to come out.

one thing it is important to add - -is that if external motivators are ALWAYS used, then that itself can and does block the development of intrinsic motivation!


blocks to intrinsic motivatoin can include:
micromanaging
fear
unconfidence
anxiety
uncertainty
lack of clarity in requests and releases
poor timing of release
inconsistency
unpredictability

any of these can cause a horse to respond to energy in a non-constructive way...and, of course there are many more....

which is why when we say "horses dont need treats to be motivated" well, it depends. with some horses, treats can help them be motivated....and with some humans, using treats can help us motivate a horse we do not otherwise know how to motivate....

interestingly my current horse likes treats, but they don't motivate her. whether I have treats with me or not I get the same effort -- what she responds to is that "good girl" and me making it clear in my energy and body langauge that I am happy and think she is the best horse in the world...

actually, I would like hanging out with someone who treated me like that...rather than someone who was saying "no, not that" every few minutes...

great discussion

Cathy


Cathy
 
Are whips and candy both external motivators? Do they motivate differently? I'm not clear on this.

I'm trying to keep this in the language of the horse so interpretation needs to be simple and clear. I'm just like my horse. :)

For me the "trust" that I speak of is a result of my being consistant with my "feel" and by "giving and taking" as the horse needs/chooses. It's a constant thing, not a static moment, though in the beginning I start with that one "exaggerated release" to begin the communication. In the process of picking up a horses foot, I might give and take a bunch of times, but it will be consistant with the "give" that the horse is offereing. That is my promise of honesty to the horse. This is where I build trust.

I often visualize a "water crossing" or "trailer loading" type situation to help myself "see" all that is needed between horse and rider when they encounter a new challange. As we consider +R,-R, intrinsic, extrinsic, introvert, extrovert, love, language and leadership, :p I don't believe any horse will face the unknown without first being confident that they can trust their partner. Those type of situations might offer some other thoughts.

Anytime spent pondering our horses can only make us better humans. :)


Keep on, keepin on

Jack
 
yes jack - both whips and candy can be seen as external motivators.

they can also be seen as indicators -- as tokens or symbols of something else. a whip can simply be an extension of the arm, candy can just be another nice thing that happens when near a human -- in which case they are not motivators....psychology of humans and other animals is a fascinating area of study

I guess I brought up the extrinsic vs intrinsic simply to high light that one leads to a transactoinal relationship, a calculated one where one party does things either because they have to or to get the specific reward -- this is inevitably a limited dynamic
wheras the other leads to something ineffably different

feel is the key, as you know and prove to yourself every day.


Cathy
 
Cathy, I ask these questions honestly. Trust me on that, :)

Can the "release of pressure" be an external motivator?

One of the things I came to realize as emphesized by "Bill Dorrance" is how we need to "start where the horse is". Sometimes we start in the soft spot, sometimes we have to apply some energy etc.

Starting with a release took me some time to discover. It's much easier to "feel" a brace, than a soft spot.

Are we talking about Natural Horsemanship now? Is there interest amongst us? :)


Keep on, keepin on

Jack
 
My point in this "debate" is that there is no method of training a horse that doesn't involve pressure of some type

Not many, it is possible to 'free shape' behaviour by reinforcing approximations towards the outcome, but it helps if you have somewhere to start rather than having to randomly wait for something to be offered. It's the dolphins in the pool training scenario.

But in most circumstances, I agree completely, we use pressure and release. The youtube vid is interesting, because I've done similar, but like you I used pressure from the word go and added a bit of extra motivation with the clicker. It would have worked fine without, and that wouldn't have been a problem to me either, but I like the effect adding treats to the situation has on my otherwise rather low energy and easily bored horse. As far as trust goes though I think we have a good degree of that between us, of the kind I understand you to be talking about.

Good point about energy too, one of my reservations about 'pure' clicker is how much the horse is 'learning' about the handler, and how much it's merely offering movements to get a treat. I remain to be truly convinced that you could build as solid a relationship with a horse purely on that basis.

I don't believe any horse will face the unknown without first being confident that they can trust their partner

Neither do I :)


Excellent posts here, especially fth at 6.15PM, this is really thought provoking :)

ETA - Jack, can you expand on 'starting with a release'?
 
I love your questions JAck!

here's the thing Jack -- ANYTHING can be an external motivator --

if the horse is motivated (ie willing to exert effort) to find an answer because they know this will lead to a release of pressure then yes, release of pressure can be an external motivator...

equally, if my horse is seeking to "guess" my requirements because we have a feel of partnership, then whether I release pressure or not might be irrelevant -- which is why when I get it right I can ride my horse on a constant contact with no apparent release and yet my horse is happy

I love the phrase "start with a release" -- a horse doesn't know what he doesn't know -- so how doe she KNOW I will release?

I was playing with a cob mare recently -- she was a worried horse....

so when I took her halter to ask her to back, the first thing I did was hold it -- not really asking anything, no pressure other than holding it -- then release -- when she hadn't even done anything.
well I tell a lie, she had done something - she had flicked an ear to ask the question "does this mean something?" I released to prove to her that I could and would release, and she could trust me to do so....

five minutes later I could touch the halter with an intent for her to go backwards and she would step backwards...

lovely horse

and the more I learn, the more lovely every horse turns out to be LOL

Cathy
 
You want a good horse, make it. You want a good forum, make it. :)


here's the thing Jack -- ANYTHING can be an external motivator --


Yes, yes, yes, I think that’s “actual fact” myself. May I ask a couple of more questions. :)


Would you agree that a horse is better at recognizing motivators than most humans?

(a side note, Could it be that autistic humans are better at recognizing motivators than most humans?)

Is fear a negative pressure, or a positive pressure, when used by a horse in escape?



Yann, I’ll offer up some thoughts but rest assured that now we are entering an area that becomes very hard for me to demonstrate with clarity. Beginning with the release, rather than the pressure isn’t where most of us start with our horses, but I hope it’s where everybody is headed. “There’s this place”, :):rolleyes:

Fth seem’s to find it here,

I was playing with a cob mare recently -- she was a worried horse....

so when I took her halter to ask her to back, the first thing I did was hold it -- not really asking anything, no pressure other than holding it -- then release -- when she hadn't even done anything.
well I tell a lie, she had done something - she had flicked an ear to ask the question "does this mean something?" I released to prove to her that I could and would release, and she could trust me to do so....

five minutes later I could touch the halter with an intent for her to go backwards and she would step backwards...

Somewhere along the line, I realized that what I always considered the horse “giving” to pressure was actually a “reactive” response by the horse and that really didn’t seem to be what I was searching for. I want to be an active leader, not somebody late to my horses thinking. Somewhere I saw some pictures of Bill Dorrance, a very old man at this time, sitting on a chair and “leading” a horse back and forth in a doubling pattern. He didn’t “pull” the horse, he simply “found that soft spot” (feel) and allowed the horse to “remain there”, even though it was moving it’s feet constantly. Hmmmm, he found the soft feel, and then he continued to mentally “lead” the horse to that spot”. He just simply “opened the door” and the horse moved there.

That has become my journey, and my reward from horses. I was very old before I ever realized that the “soft spot” was there all the time, (everywhere) waiting for me to find it and now that I’ve had a “feel” of it myself, I’m addicted to the search.

I’ve only touched on a subject that I “try” to live by everday. If I can start in the soft spot, the release etc, and then just stay there, me and my horse, all the time. Well, I think that might just feel pretty good for the both of us.

This feel and timing stuff is a lifetime commitment, and it’s where you will begin to find truth with your horse. Without feel, timing and balance, well the horse just doesn’t have anything to go on. I hope this stirs some more posters/ideas etc. about NH. These are the things that are common to natural horsemanship, the “real things”. I’ve offered the link to Leslie Desmonds articles time again and hope folks read them all. She has a couple of new books coming out. “You can bet your boots I’ll be buying them both”.

http://www.lesliedesmond.com/index.php?id=599


“Starting with the release, hmmmm, how can you know, what you don’ know? How can you see what you feel? “

Questions, always more questions :D



Keep on, keepin on

Jack
 
we have some great discussion on this forum, don't we? always learn something from every one....

" May I ask a couple of more questions. " of course!!! questions help me think differently especially when I have no answers.....yet


"Would you agree that a horse is better at recognizing motivators than most humans?

(a side note, Could it be that autistic humans are better at recognizing motivators than most humans?)"


hmmm -- I think a horse often responds to a motivator when we as humans aren't even aware one is there! as humans we can be very obtuse when it comes to motivators -- and often very self centred -- we tend to assume what motivates us motivates others, and sometimes find it REALLY hard to understand that some people are motivated by the OPPOSITE thing. for example, fear of success motivates some people to avoid working hard -- esepcialy in students....yet many people struggle with that concept...

whenever we get a behaviour that is a mystery to us, it is usually because the horse perceives a motivator that we have no idea exists :-) our challenge is to work out what has motivated the behaviour and change that rather than change the horse...


Is fear a negative pressure, or a positive pressure, when used by a horse in escape? "


ooh great question and you just know my answer is going to be "it probably depends" !!

generally a horse can be motivated to run AWAY from fear, or TOWARDS a state of non fear....
actually humans are similarly motivated....
with humans interviewing skilfully can identify when the "moving away from" motivator is in action and when the "moving towards" is in action

much harder with a horse, which is why so many good horsemen find approaches that would work WHICHEVER is happening - mostly by not putting the horse in that situtation in the first place...


xx

Cathy
 

Thanks Jack.
Ok tonight I went up to the field to practice 'feel' a la Leslie. Printed off a trees worth of articles from her website last night, read them till I fell asleep then today I stood in the field trying to ask Charlie to give to pressure and flex his neck on either side. Ended up closing my eyes to I could feel a 'try' more acutely. Anyway, it went ok I think. He was flexing either side at any rate. He did lots of sighing and snorting which Leslie says is A Good Thing, but I'm not entirely sure why. Seemed to me he was a wee bit bored.... Lower lip was all droopy too so at least he wasn't stressed by the process.

When I left the field a curious teenager said 'what were you doing with Charlie. Looked very weird'. Well someone standing in the field for 20 minutes with their eyes closed probably did look a bit odd!

Didn't really know how to reply. 'Umm teaching him to flex'.
'Oh right', came the puzzled reply and I hurried off as I had no idea how to answer any follow up questions :p

This leads me to a different question..... I want a 'how to' guide. A step by step process, starting with -say - lateral flexion, or control over the poll and leading (several years later!) to lightness and collection. Complete with DVDs of people doing it right, and the theoretical rationale of it all so you can flexibly apply the approach. And THEN I thought - well is that what Parelli does?

Which brings me to my real question - which I will post on another thread as I have taken this one OT:

And the question is:

Does Parelli teach 'Feel'?
 
Hello

I've come into this debate late, but felt that I'd like to add my thoughts. :) I clicker train, but I also work a great deal with feel and for me, both elements are as important as each other - meaning that I don't choose one over the other. When working with my mare I feel for her as she does me - we converse and the click and treat is an extention of this, a big yes! :D

Over the past year or so I've been playing around with microshaping, and this is all based on feel, timing and observation - seeing the slightest try, feeling the slighest try - releasing the moment the horse has the thought before the actual behaviour or movement.

I have been involved with Parelli type NH for many many years and have also clicker trained for around 10 years. I don't discount anything and have tried most things too :) But my relationship has transformed with my mare and her trust in me too since offering more reward and less correction.

I don't know if any of you are familiar with the work of Jesus Rosale-Ruiz and the research on the Poisoned Cue? But seeing the results of this study and the footage of the dog used, is extremely thought provoking. Its available in a DVD called the Poisoned Cue with Alexandra Kurland.

Talking of Alexandra Kurland - she is very big on feel and pressure and release of pressure. What I have learnt from her is that you don't need to escalate pressure to teach the horse to respond. This is one aspect of Parelli which I'm no longer keen on - phases - operating on a threat - a don't make me pick up the stick conversation. The horse learns the behaviour due to avoidance of the unpleasant consequence. I read an article recently that explained that behaviours taught using a threat or a strong aversive tended to stored in the primative part of the brain, whereas behaviours taught with a pleasant consequence like a treat of something the horse wanted are stored in the longer term memory.

I've also read about Jaak Panksepp's research (he's a neuroscientist) and his theory about the 'SEEKING circuit' which is part of the brain (hypothalamus) which initiates and maintains searching behaviour. His research has found that he can keep this part of the brain switched on via frequent and irregular positive reinforcement - treats etc. Now you are probably wondering why on earth I am writing all this :rolleyes: Well the reason is this, the seeking circuit is very closely linked to dopamine release - the feel good chemical.

When using +R we are causing the horse to feel good. Interestingly, when correction is used or punishment, we switch it off, the brain moves from its SEEKING mode to avoidance and fear.

Our own SEEKING circuits are switched on when we are looking for a new pair of shoes of a new book to read etc.

Sorry if I've digressed too much, but I just find all this stuff facinating :D

Thanks for reading ;)

Heather
 
I don't know if any of you are familiar with the work of Jesus Rosale-Ruiz and the research on the Poisoned Cue? But seeing the results of this study and the footage of the dog used, is extremely thought provoking. Its available in a DVD called the Poisoned Cue with Alexandra Kurland.

Can you summarise the study and results. I'm not familiar with it.
Thanks :)

Thanks for reading ;)

Heather

It was a pleasure!
 
Hi Krissie1

The best place to go to read about the poisoned cue is here: http://www.reachingtheanimalmind.com/chapter_09.html

Karen Pryor coined the phrase some time back, if you scroll to the bottom of the page you'll see her original article and also the thesis/study done at the University of North Texas. It is quite long to read, but the real impact is when you watch the video footage of the dog used for the trials which on the DVD. The DVD is well over 2 hours long with the first hour being quite hard going with lots of technical stuff, but very interesting nevertheless. The DVD can be purchased from Alexandra Kurland's site www.theclickercentre.com.

I fear I will not be able to do the study justice by describing it, but I will give it a go :)

They ONE dog and taught it 2 different come commands. The first being VEN (means come in Spanish) and the second being PUNIR (which means punish in French).

The dog was then rewarded with a c/t for coming when the handler said VEN and the dog came. When the person said PUNIR if the dog didn’t come the dog was corrected with a pull on the lead and then still given a click and treat.

What is immediately obvious is the difference in the dog’s emotional state and body language. The VEN dog is happy and engaged in the learning experience, tail wagging etc. The PUNIR dog is slower moving, looks worried, tail down. Now remember that this is the SAME dog, in the SAME location with the SAME person. Both behaviours VEN and PUNIR are consistently rewarded with a click and treat EVERYTIME. Only there is one big difference, the PUNIR behaviour is open to correction, the VEN behaviour is not. Basically the PUNIR behaviour has become poisoned due to ambiguity being thrown into the mix, the dog doesn’t know whether there is going to be a good consequence or an unpleasant one. This affects his learning in a very revealing way. This is shown when they move on to using each cue VEN and PUNIR as a conditioned reinforcer. With VEN the dog is easily able to expand the behaviour chain as VEN is always a reliable predictor of good things. But when PUNIR is used in chain, predictability is lost which leads to behaviour breakdown. The dog can no longer remember what to do, and you even see him freeze a few times. The PUNIR dog was unable to offer behaviour for fear of correction, whereas the VEN dog was happy to offer behaviour. Remember this was the same dog!

You really have to see the DVD to see the impact of this, to say this DVD blew my brain is an understatement! :eek:

Now, I’m not a positive reinforcement purist at all, I don’t think you can operate in only one quadrant of the operant condition grid, but this study has taught me the possible effects of over using pressure, especially when the horse, or dog is in a learning situation. And for that reason I don’t use phases, or escalate pressure. Though, if my horse went completely out of control, I would for safety reasons, but that would be the only time. In everyday learning situations, since not using escalating pressure, my mare is much more like the VEN dog, she thinks more for herself, offers me more behaviour and has much more TRUST in me than ever before.

I hope I’ve done the study justice, but to really appreciate its impact I highly recommend the DVD. :D

Heather
 
yes jack - both whips and candy can be seen as external motivators.

they can also be seen as indicators -- as tokens or symbols of something else.


Cathy



Might not get computer access for a couple of days, but wanted to follow up on this idea. Thanks to everyone for the honest replies. :)

"Indicators" indicate what?

How does the word "intent" or "signal" fit into the discussion?


Keep on, keepin on

Jack
 
Hi Levi1739

Would you agree that a horse is better at recognizing motivators than most humans?
I think that depends on the horse and human! I think it also depends on how the horse has been trained in the past too. Some horses are very suppressed due to always being corrected and punished, and this is the same for people too.

I think food is one of the strongest motivators for horses, it is certainly one that we are able to control easily and use to our advantage for training. But freedom is always a good motivator too.

My horse is prone to laminitis and has to wear a grazing muzzle at night, anyway, we had some big issues to overcome re putting it on, and clicker training helped us overcome this, but so did getting to go out in the pasture with all her chums, the muzzle has become a predictor of turnout time. She now knows as soon as I pick up the muzzle that its time to go out and stands waiting. She’s thrown some other behaviour into the loop as well, once the muzzle is on she starts to pose, arching her neck and looking very pretty – she knows this always gets a good response. :)


Is fear a negative pressure, or a positive pressure, when used by a horse in escape?
I think when a horse is fearful and needing to escape the pressure is negative as whatever the horse is fearful from would an aversive of some kind and therefore would be acting as a negative reinforcer – relief being felt when back in a place of safety. But I'm sure you could turn this on its head to be a positive pressure? Though I don't personally agree with what some people term as +R being the release of pressure.

Generally animals are only able to feel emotions one at a time, I say generally as there seems to be one exception and that is the emotions of fear and curiosity. Research shows that curiosity and fear come from different brain circuits but it is felt that horses are able to feel both emotions at the same time. Curiosity is a precursor to learning and often an antidote to fear. Using asking the horse to put his feet on a tarp as an example, of course he is likely to be suspicious, even a little fearful at first, he might be curious enough to put his feet on the tarp, and then oh no, he shoots back in fear! But if you can get him to be curious about the tarp without applying pressure, you know, a ‘what tarp’ type of mindset, that curiosity brain circuit will start firing again and with the help of some scattered treats, before you know it he’s walking across the tarp as if he’s done it all his life.

The scattered treats are acting as a motivator – driving his curiosity and helping him over any fear that he has about the tarp.

Heather
 
still a very thought provoking thread

re parelli and upping the pressure through phases -- you will be pleased to know that this is being presented very differently in the PNH programme nowadays as they too learn and grow..

indicators -- well, not to get too tied down in semantics, but I could use a whip to cause an irritating tapping that motivates my horse to want to move away from it (so the whip is an external motivator and, indeed an element of engative reinforcement) - I could use it to lightly touch the horse to indicate that I would like more effort from THAT spot there.... in which case it is an indicator and not a pressure point in itself...

I could point with the whip -- so it becomes an indicator of direction....

I could caress with the whip which becomes an indicator of a feeling....

so many things each thing can be...



I loved the reserach on the "seeking" aspect of the brain -- and indeed see this as what I am aiming for mto trigger that seeking and movement towards a desireable response rather than using aversive stimuli to lead a horse to focus on avoiding undesireable responses...

a horse worried about beign corrected will behave differently from a horse who is keen to find an answer and to whom correction is no big deal...

the key is how to achieve that as a highly compettiive predatorial human being LOL

Cathy
 
newrider.com