I thought it was time to move this debate onto a new thread.
Assuming anyone involved in this is still posting on NR, (and sorry Alyth - but yes yet more discussion on this simple concept
), I have a question.
We all know the definitions of +ve and -ve Sr. Both INCREASE the behaviour that immediately precedes the reinforcer. +ve is the addition of something, eg a click/treat/pat. -ve the removal of something, eg pressure on the horses side/mouth.
But actually surely you are always using BOTH.
Take children. Ignoring is a form of -ve Sr. Smiling at your child is +ve Sr. But when you ADD smiling you automatically, at exactly the same time REMOVE ignoring.
So for horses - the release or treat are both too.
The treat: ADDS something tasty, REMOVES uncertainty about what was wanted (pressure).
The RELEASE: ADDS freedom/praise/clarity about expectations and REMOVES pressure.
Or not?
Assuming anyone involved in this is still posting on NR, (and sorry Alyth - but yes yet more discussion on this simple concept
We all know the definitions of +ve and -ve Sr. Both INCREASE the behaviour that immediately precedes the reinforcer. +ve is the addition of something, eg a click/treat/pat. -ve the removal of something, eg pressure on the horses side/mouth.
But actually surely you are always using BOTH.
Take children. Ignoring is a form of -ve Sr. Smiling at your child is +ve Sr. But when you ADD smiling you automatically, at exactly the same time REMOVE ignoring.
So for horses - the release or treat are both too.
The treat: ADDS something tasty, REMOVES uncertainty about what was wanted (pressure).
The RELEASE: ADDS freedom/praise/clarity about expectations and REMOVES pressure.
Or not?