Positive and Negative Reinforcement

KP nut

I'd rather be riding.
Dec 22, 2008
6,539
5,379
113
I thought it was time to move this debate onto a new thread.

Assuming anyone involved in this is still posting on NR, (and sorry Alyth - but yes yet more discussion on this simple concept:D), I have a question.

We all know the definitions of +ve and -ve Sr. Both INCREASE the behaviour that immediately precedes the reinforcer. +ve is the addition of something, eg a click/treat/pat. -ve the removal of something, eg pressure on the horses side/mouth.

But actually surely you are always using BOTH.

Take children. Ignoring is a form of -ve Sr. Smiling at your child is +ve Sr. But when you ADD smiling you automatically, at exactly the same time REMOVE ignoring.

So for horses - the release or treat are both too.

The treat: ADDS something tasty, REMOVES uncertainty about what was wanted (pressure).

The RELEASE: ADDS freedom/praise/clarity about expectations and REMOVES pressure.

Or not?
 
I've pondered this before - in some situations it's not always clear what's going on, but they are often situations where there's a mixture of negative reinforcement and punishment going on for example, rather than negative and positive reinforcement. An example might be a horse that won't stand to be mounted, so you put it to work (positive punishment), but then stop and allow it to stand and take all pressure away (negative reinforcement). Which best describes what's happening? I personally think it depends on the primary intent and what action is having the greatest influence.

But sometimes it's also important not to over analyse :D
 
But sometimes it's also important not to over analyse :D

Yes. perhaps it's time to stop thinking and just get on with it......:p

Levi had me wondering if the claims for clicker are misleading and all that is really going on is communication and pressure/release. Then Frances Burton's post helped me understand some of your points about the usefulness of something actively positive to help overcome a fear response.

Anyway - nuff said perhaps.....
 
Don't worry, my comment was more directed at myself than your post :D I do think it's important to consider these things, it does help to understand what's going on when we ask for something.

I get exactly where you were coming from now and I'd agree that there is far more to it than just the release of pressure, you're using a completely different source of motivation :)
 
I wrote this yesterday, and then strange things seemed to happen and I couldn't get logged in correctly,

Here's a delayed ponder, and I hope it will stimulate some discussion and thought.



Reward, as per usual, I find myself with some questions that I find myself considering,

Does your horse reward you?

How?

How do you reward your horse?

What can I offer him, that he will understand “clearly”, and that he can always count on me to provide?

Where will I find it?


The horse will teach you if “your willing”


As usual, questions, :)


Keep on, keepin on

Jack
 
Daddy always told me that "only fools are sure",

I'm here for the time being, but it kills me to pay for the privilage of being abused. :rolleyes:



Jack

Hope that doesn't refer to my post! I value your contributions to threads enormously. I just like to think things through myself too.... and I'm certainly not 'sure'. (see my signature!)

Glad to see you posting. I'll give your questions some thought before replying.
 
Daddy always told me that "only fools are sure",

I'm here for the time being, but it kills me to pay for the privilage of being abused. :rolleyes:

Anyway, if maybe perhaps anybody wants to carry on, :)


Keep on, keepin on


Jack

So nobody misunderstands, I meant that with humor, and hope that a bunch of the "New Dedicated Riders" will respond with their thoughts and ideas.

If that happens I'll suffer the abuse, :)


Keep on, keepin on

Jack
 
Does your horse reward you?

Yes... Undeniabley. But only when she is happy - she is strong willed about getting her own way, but even if she hasnt had her own way, she can still be happy - its when I don't listen she becomes unhappy.

How?

It sounds pathetic on an open forum, but its the way it is. I crave attention and affection - from partner, family, friends etc. I am quite insecure and lack confidence, so am easily swayed by nice comments and signs of people accepting me.

When Silver is unhappy she shuts the world out. She gets aggressive - kicking and biting - this week really nastily :( However, when she is happy, she cuddles me and nuzzles me.

Those times that she offers the affection to me make everything I put into her worth while, they really are priceless. Having had, and still having, a fairly rough ride together, which peaks and troughs, I really treasure the moments that she offers her affection.


How do you reward your horse?

It depends on what we are doing. I haven't got into this debate, because to be honest, I prefer to reward "in the moment" as cliche as that might sound. Generally I chose to reward, as I find it simpler and a more "obvious" method - it is clear when she gets a treat that she has done well.

However I don't always have treats, so sometimes thats not possible. In which case, if she has done something well, I will either leave her if she is grouchy and not wanting me in her space, or I will rub her favourite spots.

I just think it is much clearer for her, when she is so frequently "naughty" she often ends up with pressure - eg. dragging me off when leading her - am I supposed to release pressure when she stops... yet we aren't going the right way etc etc. When she does something nice or well, she is rewarded with praise treats and cuddles, although as I said if she doesn't want cuddles she is rewarded by being left alone :)


What can I offer him, that he will understand “clearly”, and that he can always count on me to provide?
Unconditional love is the only thing I can think to answer this tbh. Which is important for her. Don't get me wrong, it has its downsides, wherby she knows she can be naughty and I will still come back or continue to persist to do what I was doing.

I will never abandon her, despite her biting, kicking, napping and often complex behaviour (although really its me over analysing I think!). She understands that I will always come back for her, and as such has let me in. I am the only person she nuzzles properly, and she will nurse me if I hurt myself (and its not her that has done it!! :rolleyes:) - otherwise she stands at the back of her stable, quiet and sad looking. She comes to the door when I come in, and sometimes comes to call. She knows when it is me calling and responds.

However, she doesn't underrstand that I doing everything I do to be the best choice for her. And as such, we get some of the difficult behaviour explained.


Where will I find it?

Not really relevant to what I was talking about above.... I dont think. But in terms of progressing even further, then I need to listen more to her, and we need to find a ground to compromise on sometimes. I also find it really useful to watch others videos and such to learn more ways to play with her.


The horse will teach you if “your willing”


I have learnt so much from her, and I am not going to stop learning from her. I just need to become better at listening to her. We also need to build the element in our relationship where she trusts that what I am doing is for the best intentions, however on the other hand - I dont want her to stop being expressive about her wishes... just wish sometimes she was a bit politer :p. As previously said, I want to develop a ground where by we can compromise.
 
Ok here are my 'ponderings':

Here's a delayed ponder, and I hope it will stimulate some discussion and thought.

Reward, as per usual, I find myself with some questions that I find myself considering,

Does your horse reward you?

I don't think my horse consciously rewards me - as in - selectively targets particular behaviours of mine to let me know he's pleased or I've done the right thing. But I do perceive my horse as rewarding me in many ways. When he nickers when I approach him in the field. When he responds to a cue smoothly and calmly. When he drops his head and cocks an ear back to tell me he's listening.

How?

The reward is in the feeling of communication between us. There are times when we feel in tune. When I can think slow/fast/canter etc and he will respond. When I can change direction just by looking the way I want to go. When he feels like an extension of me. This 'tells me' I'm getting it right and he understands me. This is rewarding. Most times we don't have the connection and I then need to rely on rules for direction or gait change - the aids. He is less responsive, transitions are rushed or bracey. This is unrewarding. he's telling me I'm doing it wrong and it feels chaotic not controlled

How do you reward your horse?

I use food treats, heads rubs, verbal praise. I release pressure.
On a more subtle level, 'reward' is bi-directional. He rewards me by being responsive and soft, I reward him by doing whatever it was that I was doing that led to him being responsive and soft. Hard to define what that is but riding in balance seems important, as does having soft hands that follow his movement. I rarely achieve either
.


What can I offer him, that he will understand “clearly”, and that he can always count on me to provide?

Clarity and consistency

Where will I find it?

In timing and feel (which I don't have much of yet). In making the effort to consider his perspective.

The horse will teach you if “your willing”

He tries his best! He's very patient with me. :D
 
Those are both great replies. When people speak "from the heart" rather than the "text book", from "experience rather than theory", new ideas are shared.

Here's my answers. I definately don't believe that a "true reward" can be found in a candy wrapper. :o




Does your horse reward you?

Very definately, constantly,

How?

Offers me TRUST

How do you reward your horse?

I offer him TRUST

What can I offer him, that he will understand “clearly”, and that he can always count on me to provide?

TRUST

Where will I find it?

Good timing and feel will build trust in the partnership. It's within me.

The horse will teach you if “your willing”

Yes he will, and he will make it clear anytime "trust" is lacking.
I think it's the greatest reward I can offer any horse and the greatest gift they offer me. :)


Keep on, keepin on

Jack
 
It is true that from the heart/experience speaks volumes - dont get me wrong, recently I have become a frequenter to you tube and the sky chanell for MR or parelli programmes to gain "new" ideas on building our relationship.

My problem is needing reassurance. I can post the longest, probably most boring threads to most people, but am seeking reassurance/advice/criticism to know how to improve what I am doing etc. I find I over analyse and over worry. This directly confuses me about whether or not I am doing the right thing - aprticularily when Silver is acting against the decisions I am worrying about. I often forget that she is in actual fact a very straight forward, honest and direct pony, I just havent got the hang of understanding all the cues that cause her problematic behaviour - I have many of them, but I often don't understand why she responds in an agressive way somedays and not others, and equally to the most basic day to day activity.

Out of interest Jack/Levi1739, do you follow any particular school of thought NH wise?
 
Does your horse reward you?

All the time, the pair of them :)


By showing willingness to please me and trying to do what I ask them, by trusting me in difficult situations and by being affectionate and companionable.

How do you reward your horse?

With praise, rubs, rest, titbits and allowing them to do what they want.

What can I offer him, that he will understand “clearly”, and that he can always count on me to provide?

I hope, leadership, reliability and consistency.

Where will I find it?

It's something you've got to understand and try and find inside yourself.
 
Yann I'm glad you replied. I have questions of course,

Is the reward that you offer a horse when you give it a treat, greater than the reward you offer when giving it your trust?

Which is the "true reward"? How does a horse recognize "trust"? Which will the horse clearly recognize and remember as "my gift"?


Levi had me wondering if the claims for clicker are misleading and all that is really going on is communication and pressure/release. Then Frances Burton's post helped me understand some of your points about the usefulness of something actively positive to help overcome a fear response.

Is it possible that the "trust" that a horse learns to expect from a confident, consistent handler is the "better way". Without "release" a horse will never learn to "trust" his handler.

Popularfurball, I'm a comglomeration of NH ideas, but when I seek answers myself, it is usually to Bill Dorrance's book that I turn. I believe Clinton Anderson is an excellent teacher of "release and timing" and recommend him to all inexperienced horsemen. Dennis Reis, Chris Cox, Buck Brannaman, are horsemen I watch closely, and many others.


Keep on, keepin on

Jack
 
Last edited:
Is the reward that you offer a horse when you give it a treat, greater than the reward you offer when giving it your trust?

Absolutely not, although I regularly give small food rewards for various things or even for nothing at all (!) they're merely a useful tool and / or something pleasant in our relationship rather than fundamental to it. Because they respect my space and know the ground rules it doesn't cause a problem with mugging. I have some useful and relaxed fun with this, an example is teaching them to stop before we get to the field gate, wait while I open it, then walk through and then wait for me on the other side so I can take their headcollars off. They soon cotton on to what will get them the extra morsel of carrot :)

Is it possible that the "trust" that a horse learns to expect from a confident, consistent handler is the "better way". Without "release" a horse will never learn to "trust" his handler.

I don't think anyone would dispute that, even a die hard clicker person (which I am certainly not) would still need to operate this way to some degree working with a traumatised horse. The difference is always going to be in the 'how', how direct the approach is, how much pressure the horse is placed under in the short term to get the result and how quickly the work progresses.
 
Yes, they do actually. Find something to give them that they really really want more of and it's suprising how hard they'll work to try and get it.

Yann, This was in the “Parelli” thread. In my reply (there) to FB, I stated that I thought some folks were “basing their beliefs on a false premise”. It seem’s to me that you are confirming this, but reluctantly. Notice the path of your thoughts here, in reply to this question,

“Is the reward that you offer a horse when you give it a treat, greater than the reward you offer when giving it your trust? “


Absolutely not, although I regularly give small food rewards for various things or even for nothing at all (!) they're merely a useful tool and / or something pleasant in our relationship rather than fundamental to it. Because they respect my space and know the ground rules it doesn't cause a problem with mugging. I have some useful and relaxed fun with this, an example is teaching them to stop before we get to the field gate, wait while I open it, then walk through and then wait for me on the other side so I can take their headcollars off. They soon cotton on to what will get them the extra morsel of carrot

It seem’s to you recognize that the greatest reward possible is “trust” (or love/respect etc) and not a material object, but yet you immediately start speaking of the wonders of treats etc. Your fun withstanding, isn’t it “actual fact” that the greatest reward you can give any animal is not a “physical object” and is “recognized” long before any “clicker can mark” its existence?

All my horses receive “treats” but they are never confused with “rewards”. I think the "treat" actually interupts the reward. A reward is identified by a much more immediate response than any treat can be. This is what I believe to be the flaw in clicker training.

(Actually I wouldn't hesitate to use a clicker for sensitizing but that's another subject and not how it's being used in the examples I've watched) I am also still looking for examples where "children' have been taught using only "positive re-enforcement or clicker training" type of concepts. Do they exist?

:)


Keep on, keepin on

Jack
 
2 observations: wonder how they fit into this discussion:

On Charlie's first day at our yard he got attacked and bitten on the chest by the yard owner's pig. The pig was then penned, and Charlie had to walk past the pen on his way from his field to the yard. Not surprisingly he was not very keen. How could I expect him to 'trust me' enough to walk past? Frankly I want a horse who takes care of his own self preservation at least to a certain extent! What if I hadn't seen a pig and he had, and I was asking him to walk straight into danger.

So I felt that systematic desensitisation was the only way forward. Till I thought of clicker. I taught him targeting in about 3 minutes and then targeted him past the pig with very little hassle. His motivation to earn the click/treat seemed enough to help him put up with a greater degree of anxiety than would otherwise have been the case. I still did the systematic desensitisation and in the end the crucial part of what has changed for him is that he has learned that nothing bad happens to him. But he was more willing to try something a bit scary because of clicker.

Example 2: I have taught him to follow my actions. Ie to walk back/forward as I do. He does back up, and follow. But his energy and commitment to matching my every move is noticeable higher when I am carrying treats...

So if my offering 'Trust' is more important than my offering 'apples slices' how do I tangibly offer 'trust'? As far as I'm concerned I try and offer 'trust' all the time. I try to be fair and clear all the time. On top of that he also sometimes gets food rewards and these appear to enhance his motivation.

Not arguing for or against any position here, just sharing my observations. :)
 
what a great discussion

one thing I think would add to our depth here would be to add in a consideraton of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation

for example, if as a child I behave myself purely because I know I will get a treat (eg stay up late) then my motvation for behaving myself comes from an EXTERNAL source -- this is extrinsic motivation

if I behave myself because I will feel good in myself, and no one else might even notice but I still choose to do it -- then the motivation to behave comes from the inside -- and is INTRINSIC motivation

there is a lot of research a lot of it n the parenting area, on how often to get a desired behavour it is necessary to use external motivators to encourage the behaviour, but then the real skill as a parent, or coach -- is to cause the person to start developing their intrinsic motivation so that eventully the behaviour occurs without the presence or need for external motivators or rewards.

my aim with my relationships with my animals is to reach the stage where they want to work with me, and are looking for opportunities to be " good" ie perform desired behaviours to the desired standard...whether this is my horse leading, doing dressage moves, my dog doing agility or walking nicely on his lead...

now, when I begin a relationship with a horse or a dog, they might not be in a state where intrinsic motivation is there -- so this is where I will use rewards, treats, rubs, praise -- to encourage the behaviours I want

I will use extinction (ignoring behaviour) to remove unwanted behaviours, and punishment if the behaviour is dangerous (if a young dog uses teeth in play, he will get an time out and be ignored for a while -- this is extinction; if the habit continues beyond this then " no!" and sending to a place away from the pack is punishment and will take place...this is along with praise and reward when playing " nicely"

however, my aim is lways to develop the relationship so the animal soon doesn't even look for a reward or treat -- my horse, when I say " good girl" when she offers a nice lateral movement, whickers back to me and tries even harder the next time....

is that a reward? or am I on the path to a more intrinsic motivation here?

this aspect of extrinsic and intrinsic is why understanding the basic psychology of the animals we are living with makes such a difference to our ability to build relationships with them....

anyhow, something to add to the mix!

Cathy
 
Yes that makes perfect sense..

My shetlands come cantering over to me whenever I go to their field. This started last winter because my arrival heralded some more hay... But I haven't fed them for months and they still come cantering over. I guess now they just want to! I have 2 5 year olds and a 7 year old (kids that is, not horses). The 5 year olds are still quite 'reward' oriented, but the 7 year old does the 'right thing' because he just wants to.....

Does your horse really whicker when you say 'good girl'. That's so lovely. Mine whickers when I approach him in the field but I assume he's just saying 'hello have you got a polo?':D
 
newrider.com