Parelli!!! UPDATED

As for join up. I read the book and liked the idea but I did not have access to a round pen so never tried it. Then one day I had a bolshy disrespectful 3 yo on loan. I was putting out a salt lick in the field and he charged me. I used very assertive body language and swung the leadrope at him to drive him away. He circled me bucking and making threatening gestures and I kept him away from me. After a while I noticed he had dropped his head and was doing the classic submissive gestures. So I dropped my assertive stance and invited him in. He then did the classic following me about. So I just thought 'great I'm now his herd leader, join up is fab!' So I set up a round pen for Charlie and decided to join up with him too. But his reaction was totally different. He seemed fearful and bewildered. Why was I sending him away? What had he done wrong? I soon realised he had no desire to join up at all. He was very keen to get as far from me as possible! And who could blame him? It took me a while to repair the damage to his trust. So I decided join up may have a place in horsemanship but I was not experienced enough to know when to use it and when to leave well alone.
I think lots of horses have already "joined up" without us realising it happens, like NF said lunging is a similar action, and pushing them out of your space in the field, through a gateway etc, some don't need to do 50 laps before they choose to befriend a passive/assertive leader (their owner going about their business).

I think we all assume an alpha role, that doesn't mean we bully the horse to submission, there is a difference between a passive/assertive alpha and an aggressive alpha. If we were not alpha would our horse (those who have not already been taught this lesson by whatever means) not question everything we ask? (survival instinct) The differences between Bo and Jess were huge, Bo was like a lost puppy, just wanted to please (for the most part until he got over excited then often forgot boundries :rolleyes: ) Jess in her younger years questioned everything asked of her, I still have to watch her with new people and horses, she will think nothing of challenging them, she is a much more alpha personality. They got on fantastically because Bo was happy to follow Jess's lead, when Hank arrived he had a very steep learning curve, he had only been cut about 6 months and was just 4 still and had poor social skills and he had no idea it was not acceptable to get in her space and bother her, the result was some very hard lessons. Now days she just flicks an ear back and he knows he over stepped the line. Jess can be turned out with mares, but not other dominant mares, she has been fine with those happy to follow, yet took the metal 5 bar gate of the hinges twice at the last yard (neighbouring fields) to get into it with the YO's mare who is also an Alpha of her little herd. When I didn't assert my alpha-ness around Jess, we fell out big time, she battered me repeatedly. Aggression will be met with aggression with her, so calm assertiveness is essential for everyone's sanity and safety. When she was backed the one piece of advise my trainer (30 year pro) gave me was never, ever to pick a fight with her as she would win or die trying, so I haven't and she has become a very trustworthy companion who respects me as much as I respect her.
 
One thing I always wondered is why do the horses never get better??? I can get on Sonny after not riding for a while and hes fine.
They ride YESTERDAY and the next day its all the same stuff like the horse has not been ridden for years.
 
NF Mark Rashid called it Passive Leadership. He has since said it's a terrible name as no one understands it and also implies passivity which is not right. But basically his idea is that the alpha in a herd is not the same horse as the one the others all choose to follow. Horses fear and respect the alpha but do not really seek her out or chill with her. But there is usually a horse others will choose to follow. So the alpha leader is the horse who imposes his or her will on the herd and demands respect, while the passive leader does not seek leadership but is elected by the herd. Mark prefers to mimic the characteristics of that horse not the alpha.
 
Very true KP, and a very clear explanation. My mare is definitely alpha. I do think you can get both in one, but it is rarely the case.
 
Last edited:
NF Mark Rashid called it Passive Leadership. He has since said it's a terrible name as no one understands it and also implies passivity which is not right. But basically his idea is that the alpha in a herd is not the same horse as the one the others all choose to follow. Horses fear and respect the alpha but do not really seek her out or chill with her. But there is usually a horse others will choose to follow. So the alpha leader is the horse who imposes his or her will on the herd and demands respect, while the passive leader does not seek leadership but is elected by the herd. Mark prefers to mimic the characteristics of that horse not the alpha.
His horse Buck was one wasn't he ?
 
A
His horse Buck was one wasn't he ?

Actually thinking on it, I'm convinced my husbands horse was one, he'd never be a bully like one horse in the herd, he could hold his own for sure, but members of the herd would actively seek him out and relax near him, he was always the second in charge but never by force, (he'd pull faces to get to the hay but that was it) and we always used to think he somehow slotted in whichever herd he was in.

Mind you he could be a grumpy beggar at times too ! :D
 
His horse Buck was one wasn't he ?

Yes. He describes the idea in a book called something like the Art of Passive Leadership and he describes the sort of behaviours these horses show: assertive but not aggressive, calm, decisive, easy going, consistent etc. Whereas alphas waste a lot of energy fighting unnecessary battles and can be unpredictable and other horses tend to avoid them if possible.

Later he wrote Life Lessons From a Ranch Horse which was all about Buck. I don't think he uses the phrase Passive Leadership in that book but he is clearly describing the same kind of horse. And he is not saying 'pretend to be the elected herd leader' but 'act this way around horses because they like it and respond well to it'.

(He also seemed to think Buck was a Zen Master or Buddha Emanation so that particular book is a little 'Out There' but the basic horsemanship seems sound enough!!)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
My respect also goes to anyone who says what works for one may not for another because every single horse is different. You can pull little bits from every method.

KP Nut, I like your comments on join up. This is a classic what works for one....
The Bolshy horse needed to be taught those manners at that point. You had to assert yourself....
You're other horse clearly felt comfortable with you and how you worked together and I suspect this altered things from a working together as you had been partnership, to you suddenly to him, wanting to boss him about and that wasn't what he was used to or liked about your partnership.... Some horses are followers others are leaders. A leader is fine provided they're not Bolshy with it and this is where I suspect join up is of great help. With a natural follower I don't suspect join up would do much more than frighten them into doing what they already naturally want to do anyway and as such a different calmer approach is necessary.

Yep, I learnt the hard way not to just 'follow a method'. I sent the bolshy horse away because I genuinely needed to defend myself. And when I did, I noticed the submissive gestures and so followed the 'join-up' approach. And it was helpful in that context. With Charlie I was just doing it as a 'training thing to do'. After it was going wrong it dawned on me that I did not have a clear rationale in my mind about why I was 'sending him away' or what I was trying to teach or communicate! I decided after that, that whenever I worked with my horses I would try and have a clear plan and a clear understanding of what I am doing and why. Of course I still regularly get in a muddle, but at least now I have a chance of figuring out a solution rather than being lost when 'The Method' doesn't work. After all, horses haven;t read The Man Who Listens to Horses!! They don't know how that are 'meant' to respond and not all of them follow the script.
 
You are encouraged to have the horse follow behind you, I can't remember when you alter that into all areas and driving from behind -long reining. .
Yes but not by everyone - We had a thread on this when i had a Parelli style groundwork lesson with my old share and the RI said quite fiercely that I had to stand there and make sure the horse moved first. Whereas my habit from equally reputable people was that horse didnt move its feet till I moved, and it stopped when I stopped too. This bitter argument collapsed in my second lesson. If you want a laugh.
It was sheeting down with rain and the RI asked me to come with my share and get under the shelter of a tree. I couldnt get the old mare to budge and RI asked crossly what was I waiting for?
I need to do what you said and get the horse to move its feet first, I replied, ever the dutiful pupil.
O for goodness sake she said, I dont care how you lead the horse. Just get us into the dry. So I walked and (as always) the horse followed me.
As for the switch to long reining, I dont think it works like that does it? Long reining mimics riding without ones seat and legs. My RI always said that someone demanding obedience from the ground e.g. at the mounting block, helped with compliance when they were riding. The horse isnt stupid, so it must realise that the person standing beside it is the same person as the one riding it and has the same clothes, smell and voice.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KP nut
NF Mark Rashid called it Passive Leadership. Horses fear and respect the alpha but do not really seek her out or chill with her. But there is usually a horse others will choose to follow.
Thanks for this. I think my lass could be this as others follow. If I bring her in, everyone comes in, if hay goes out she is the first in, but eats outside away from the scuffles of whose pile is that. She grazes alone or can be with others, she attracts the boyfriend in season, they are buddies out of season.
I would rather be what my lass chooses to trust and follow not because she fears me. I was told when I called about her that if she didn't like me, I couldn't have her.
 
I've been on a livery yard where loads of middle-aged women chose to 'do' Parelli with their horses because they were far too scared to ride.

Oh, and why does Parelli sell a left-handed lead rope?? Have never figured that one out....

That's a bit of a sweeping statement. Are all people who enjoy-
Inhand showing
Lunging
Longreining
Driving
Groundwork
All scared to ride? I doubt it.

I think someone is pulling your forelock re left handed rope. Left handed halter yes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: horseandgoatmom
Whilst I have never done parelli as I don't like a lot of videos I've seen (mostly on TV so not the bad ones publicised). However, I do think that a structured approach definitely has a place- particularly with either new owners or p-taking bolshy horses. It provides structure, goals and exercises to do which help assert the human in the relationship. I've seen parelli transform very fragile/broken relationships - including ridden issues.

However it needs to be taken with a pinch of salt.

As has been said earlier - natural horsemanship is nothing more and nothing less than good horsemanship. How the relationship is established (ie the exercises or tasks done) is irrelevant as long as they communicate to the horse what is expected, they are humane and work for that horse in question.

Much like the barefoot / unshod debate. There is no difference, they are one and the same - whether it's. Farrier or trimmer or podiatrist, as long as the foot is trimmed well the finite details of how it's done is irrelevant.

I'm another who likes mark rashids writing though I also haven't seen him live as I am worried that i would be disappointed
 
Very true KP, and a very clear explanation. My mare is definitely alpha. I do think you can get both in one, but it is rarely the case.

My jasper is both in one. He's a fantastic lead horse and the alpha horse in the field. He rarely delivers a kick or a bite. He lets them do their own thing but they know if they've over stepped their marker. A couple of the smaller ones are even allowed to eat out of his bowl. He generally leads them up or down the fields. Where he goes they follow.

It's great to see and he's done wonders for helping me with training them myself. . The day he goes to the bridge will be a sad one for everyone human and equine. The whole dynamic will change then. I will have an alpha and one that they choose to follow then. It'll be alfie as the alpha and tegan they will choose to follow.

Jasper will play with them all and is great at teaching things like lady how to be a horse. He will let them all have their scraps but steps in if it gets too much. Alfie and lady had major arguments in the first couple of weeks of her being here and numerous times jasper would watch but then come trotting across to split them up if it got too heated. I trust all of my horses with him and they trust him to look after them too.

I owe a lot to that horse without him I wouldn't be able to get things done nearly as well :).
 
The Rashid book about passive leadership is Horses Never Lie. It also has the chapter "Finding the Try" which taught me how to teach any horse I rode to back up for me. Starting with Maisie all those years ago. I give a copy to most of the people I ride with, but I suspect they dont read it. To be honest I was quite bemused by the first Rashid book I read - I was urged by someone on NR to watch him and that made all the difference. Yet if you go and watch him this year, you wont be watching the same Rashid as ten years ago - nor even the one who wrote that book.
 
Hetty is our alpha mare, There is no doubt that she rules the roost, But she keeps order and respect with a glance, a squeal, a look a shake of her head and a swing of her bum in extreme cases. I have never seen her land a kick or a bite ever. Nobody guards resources, If I put out 6 hay piles they will all pile into one and share.

My new guy Tór has fitted into the herd and gets on with all the other horses, he charms them all.

You can be Alpha, herd leader call it what you will, but horses respond better to fair kind leadership than they do an aggressive dominating character. By making them fearful you are not herd leader, they will do as you ask through fear, but, it's been said many times, anything done by force can never be beautiful.
 
Oh, I've nothing against in-hand work at all NewForest, but seriously, this particular livery yard was a centre for middle-aged women who were scared to ride. I've never found another yard quite like it. Everyone was always sobbing somewhere because they couldn't bring themselves to get on board. Then Parelli swept through the yard like a virus and everyone was at it. I kid you not.
I've been on other yards since and never encountered a similar setup.
And I have great respect for a lot of non-ridden work that people do with their horses. Just not a great deal of time for 'by-the-book' Parelli.
 
I once met a 'parelli' trainer I respected but I suspect she was not a purist, she identified all the issues of nervous riders and addressed them, rein clutching is impossible if you only have one hand on a long rein, changing direction by stopping and looping rein over horse head is calming stopping by breathing out and relaxing is great education. She worked with nervous riders to great effect but I am not sure how Parelli purists would view her?
 
  • Like
Reactions: horseandgoatmom
eml, I think instructors who help nervous riders are like gold dust! I know that they're out there as I've had some amazing lessons myself.
On the yard in question though a huge part of the problem for said nervous middle-aged ladies was that they had bought completely unsuitable horses (mostly). There's a pattern (or there was on my old yard) of people who'd ridden when they were younger, given up through the 'children' years and then come back to it later in life. A few lessons at a riding school had triggered the 'I want a pony' gene, leading to women with plenty of money but a lack of solid knowledge buying young horses so they could 'learn together' and finding that life isn't always that easy. Sometimes admitting that you've bought the wrong horse can be too hard a step to take. And people like Parelli are there to mop up some of the middle-aged cash....possibly not what was originally intended by horsemanship, although LInda Parelli I think cottoned on pretty quick...:rolleyes:
 
I once met a 'parelli' trainer I respected but I suspect she was not a purist, she identified all the issues of nervous riders and addressed them, rein clutching is impossible if you only have one hand on a long rein, changing direction by stopping and looping rein over horse head is calming stopping by breathing out and relaxing is great education. She worked with nervous riders to great effect but I am not sure how Parelli purists would view her?
Purists I suspect wouldnt like her. I know a few trainers who left the program for having their own views. Even at Play days a member looking into other training methods would be viewed with contempt.
Sadly its my way or the highway and this is what puts off a lot of people. Everyone can learn something from someone but no one is god when its comes to knowledge.
From memory PNP doesnt do one rein riding, its one rein plus stick. Or no rein and two sticks. Least it was when I did my level 3.
 
  • Like
Reactions: horseandgoatmom
A family friend was one of the first UK instructors. Individuality and using different approaches was NOT tolerated and she left in the end. Pete's Mum said her instructors vary it a bit but even the phrase they use of "this isn't strictly Parelli, but...." implies going off programme is a bit suspect. Most instructors don't feel the need to justify using different approaches fof different horses.
 
newrider.com